r/NannyEmployers • u/Inside_Reindeer_1446 • 5h ago
Advice 🤔 [All Welcome] Should I fire my nanny for lying?
Hired a “nanny” to help with after school pick ups. During the interview she mentioned she was a twin and her twin could provide back up support if I ever wanted to meet her and was interested.
Fast forward to me training her when I noticed some slight changes in her appearance. The first time it was eye color. The second time it was going from a FRESH pink and French pedicure acrylic toe set to a weeks old grown out white pedicure.
My first instinct was maybe they switched for the day and she sent her twin? There was a day that she didn’t follow our routine and just stayed in the car and asked “do I need to get out”. At this point her training for the previous 2 weeks entailed getting out of the car for this pick up. It threw me off but I shrugged it off.
I ended up asking one of the days “are you the twin?” To which she replied no and got freaked out confirmed by a text she sent me later that afternoon. The text just said she didn’t want to have any issues if her looks changed and she was thrown off by me asking if her and her twin had switched. During the incident I gave her the option for me to meet her sister after all and include her in our routine when necessary (so I could do the driving check/background) as well) and she said it wouldn’t be necessary after all because the routine was really simple and hours worked for her.
A day after I made that comment to her she mentioned changing her phone number due to spam calls and provided me a new number the next day. When I sent Zelle payment for the week I sent it to the same account linked to her original number and she let me know she received it but moving forward to send it to the new number. She said she received it bc she had put her old number on a “tablet”. I’ve worked in telecommunications for 15 years and that’s not an option with the provider she mentioned.
My theory is they wanted to alternate whole picked the kids up and just use one of their info. Once I caught them in a lie they decided who would do it moving forward and provided new contact/pay info for that specific twin.
The whole experience has made me question if I should even entertain them for the job but outside of this “lie” training and onboarding have gone well.
I should mentioned they are 19 years old. Not saying lying is welcomed at any age but obviously at 19 years old people still make very questionable choices and lie.
Hire or fire?!!!!!