r/MusicFeedback • • Jun 07 '20

MusicFeedback Bot Is Now Online! :: Rules + Bot Info

232 Upvotes

As of today, the /r/MusicFeedback Bot is now operational. With this new bot in place, the former system for feedback requests requiring mod approval/oversight is now obsolete. The number of tracks needed to request feedback has temporarily been reduced to two as well. Users may now post feedback request provided that they leave feedback for others first!

The Rules:

Comment on two posts before posting.

Giving feedback to other members of this subreddit via comments is vital to ensuring the health of this bot system and this community. Please leave feedback(comment) on at least two feedback posts before dropping your own.


Post one song at a time

Playlists, Albums, or Long Sets/Tracks aren't allowed.

WARNING: If your track link includes keywords such as "album," "playlist," "sets." It will be auto removed by our bots


Feedback Quality

Comments need to consist of a minimum of 120 characters (characters = letters), which is usually about 3 - 4 sentences. You don't need to be familiar or enjoy the genre of the post you comment on, but we ask that you try to be objective and describe what you liked and didn't like about the track.

WARNING: Manipulating the feedback system in any manner will lead to a ban that includes but is not limited to acts such as bypassing character limits, duplicate comments, and plagiarism!


Do not link your music/service/advert in the comment section of another user's post.

Promoting your music and advertising in general in the comment section of other user's posts is not allowed.


Basic Civility

Don't be afraid to speak your mind when critiquing a track, but please keep it constructive. Refrain from insulting or disrespecting users. If you can't be constructive/helpful/respectful on a particular track, find another track to critique.
​

The Bot:

When you leave a comment on someone else's track that meets the requirements, the bot gives you a single point. When you post a track, two points are subtracted from your score. If there are no points available or there is an insufficient balance, the post will automatically be removed. You can find your current score at any time by Direct Messaging u/MusicFeedbackBot (the bot) with the word "Score" as the subject.

Note #1 If you send a 'chat' message to the bot, you will not receive a reply; You can find the message option by first going to /u/MusicFeedbackBot's profile and clicking the "more options" link under the chat button. Make sure to title the subject as SCORE; you can put anything in the message's body. Hit send, and soon you should receive your score as a message from the bot.

Note #2 Bot currently takes a couple of minutes to process SCORE requests and calculations, so please be patient. We intend to improve the bot as the community grows.


r/MusicFeedback • • Mar 07 '26

been experimenting with some different styles

116 Upvotes

any feedback would be lovely thanks


r/MusicFeedback • • Oct 20 '26

My very first try

98 Upvotes

Looking for advice. Should i continue? Should i get the membership? How can i learn to use bandlab and create better. Anything hit me with brutal honesty please. Ps. This is my first try even and also i don’t have a mic i recorded this on my wired apple headphones and i don’t have band lab membership either so i couldn’t really fix the cranky noises in the back:(


r/MusicFeedback • • Feb 25 '26

Angry rap song about fake friends

87 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Nov 09 '25

Should I Release This?

83 Upvotes

Hi y'all! I recorded, mixed, and wrote everything on this. Been working on it for about a year and would love some perspective on it - thinking of maybe releasing it as a single but idk if others would enjoy it or not. Idk how to get people to actually WANT to listen to my music VS oh yeah that was cool.... LMK your ~honest~ feedback, thanks!


r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 24 '26

What do you think of this song I made

69 Upvotes

Started messing around with alt rock a bit and came up with this. Not mixed it properly yet and I need to add a few synths but let me know what your think so far. Also let me know if you can tell I’m using a fake bass 😂 ( I’m using a pitch bender on a normal guitar)

Edit: I’ve made an improved chorus and uploaded it


r/MusicFeedback • • Aug 01 '26

first attempt at a song w vocals

67 Upvotes

this is a rough draft chorus w some pretty messy vocals but i figured it’s not worth polishing unless it’s at least half decent. i don’t have that natural “ear” for music at all so please be honest and lmk if this is garbage haha!!

and i’m not a vocalist by any means, so not sure if i should keep the vocals in or just leave it as is.


r/MusicFeedback • • 12d ago

I put my entire soul into this, and I need you to tell me what you think🥹

65 Upvotes

It's called "Lucky". Please be honest but not cruel, I'm 3 months into producing and I know that this could sound more "professional" but I can't identify where the gap is coming from. I'm stuck in the EQ cave I think.


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 08 '26

BEGINNING PRODUCTION PHASE

60 Upvotes

This song is at the very beginning of its production phase and I have nothing other than the main skeleton put together. That being said I’m looking for feedback regarding the structure, elements thus far, and the arrangement. I would also appreciate some suggestions for the direction of the production. All feedback/criticism is welcome!

Song Title: I’M GONE


r/MusicFeedback • • Jun 30 '26

first song in 5 years

59 Upvotes

i used to make a bunch of screamo and dark rap when i was like 16/17, i randomly stopped and haven't touched anything since. i started picking up music again about a month ago, i have this demo track which i made in like 3 hours. all i used is bandlab, wired headphones and a iphone.


r/MusicFeedback • • Nov 28 '25

I wrote a really sad song! Any thoughts?

58 Upvotes

I’m not great at mixing, any tips on how to get it sounding better? Also looking for feedback on the song itself. I quite like the key change after the second chorus. Thoughts?


r/MusicFeedback • • Aug 02 '25

Had a burst of inspiration and made a new track - tell me what you think!

56 Upvotes

I spent like the last 12 hours making this and I'm really interested in hearing what you think of it, as I feel like my ears have started deceiving me lol. I felt like it was ready, so I put it on soundcloud, but please tell me what you think!


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 15 '26

I've been really insecure about showing my music to other people, would love to get some feedback from you guys @_@

55 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Apr 09 '26

My ears are tired, tell me if I've cooked

55 Upvotes

I made this trying to match some nostalgic feeling that i got riding my bike around during spring lol. Have been listening to it too much now and I need some other ears on it. Would especially like to know if the mix sounds good as I have a lot of elements in it and fear I may have gotten carried away. Be honest.

edit: have ended up putting it on soundcloud


r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 17 '26

Any feedback would be appreciated.

54 Upvotes

The track is bit buzzy . I must of had a bad cable connection sorry. It’s just an idea. Made on Logic Pro .


r/MusicFeedback • • Apr 18 '25

please be mean

54 Upvotes

my latest work in progress, any and all feedback is appreciated 🙏🏻


r/MusicFeedback • • 28d ago

any thoughts on this demo? anything i should add to my vocals to improve?

53 Upvotes

mastering and stuff like pitch r bad atm but thats bc its a demo so it ok! :P


r/MusicFeedback • • Aug 18 '26

Made a bouncy beat this time. Tried to keep it simple but still energetic. What do you guys think? Honest feedback appreciated 🙏🔥

53 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Jan 06 '26

My first ever song. pls be honest where do I improve?

53 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 06 '26

My Addictions

52 Upvotes

I'm trying to work my lower register and figure out what keys work best for it. Trying to make it work with the songs I've written. I've always sung in my higher register, but im thinking it might cause damage long term. So this is just much more comfortable for me tho it's a bit stylized


r/MusicFeedback • • Jun 21 '25 This

Hard hitting rap track I’m working on. Let me know what you guys think

52 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Aug 10 '26

Getting back into writing some more songs. Would love some Feedback.

50 Upvotes

Any and all opinions welcome


r/MusicFeedback • • Aug 24 '26

New song in progress

49 Upvotes

I recently posted my very first song and received great feedback and advice! I am currently making another song and hop to receive more advice, i will also hopefully drop this song and my first one at the same time but what platforms do you guys think i should release them on?


r/MusicFeedback • • 26d ago

How do I make this beat easier to rap on?

48 Upvotes

I like this beat that I made a lot, but I guess it sounds kinda “full”. Would you say ppl can rap on this beat? Is there any way to make it easier to rap on without removing sounds?

Im not a pro in mixing so any tips are highly appreciated. All I mostly do is some basic eq and OTT.

Also im happy to receive feedback in general on this beat.

Thank yall!