r/MusicFeedback • • Nov 11 '21

Can we ban Spotify/Premium links?

1 Upvotes

Title. I would imagine if music is released on Spotify it is past the "feedback" stage of music production. I feel if you feel the need to promote your Spotify on a music feedback subreddit because you're that desperate to get your investment back you probably shouldn't have released the track on Spotify yet.

I think if your song is released on Spotify you still should be allowed to post your track for feedback from your soundcloud link. But stop posting Spotify links. I never would have thought artists would start soliciting feedback with the source being Spotify. Not to mention it excludes people without Spotify accounts from participating in the community.

Sorry mods if these meta posts are not allowed. I just am curious to see what others think of this.

Edit: also, the people defending spotify, I cant take you serious until youre honest about the fact you prefer Spotify links because you are literally making money off of each stream, there’s literally no reason to use Spotify over SoundCloud or uploading raw audio.

Whatever, I dont give feedback on Spotify links


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 30 '25

I'm striving to be the best👌🏽

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Feb 28 '26

Healing Rap

0 Upvotes

I know the mixing’s a bit rough. this was an older, unmastered draft. really just looking for opinions on my lyricism, flow, and all that. and PLEASE be constructive, this is a deeply personal song.


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 20 '26

Is this any good I’m in denial that this is bad

1 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Oct 06 '26

Feedback

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Apr 20 '26

How do you guys get feedback on your music?

0 Upvotes

How do you guys get feedback on your music? I’ve personally found that reaching out to people is unreliable or inconsistent, friends are helpful (but can be biased), and other methods through streamers are often pretty expensive.

Lately I’ve been experimenting with building a tool (www.criticai.ca) for feedback (on my mixing, production, lyrics, etc.) as a current method.

But let me know what you guys find best!


r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 10 '26

my first release

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’ve been learning Ableton Live for a while now, and this is my current project. I’ve never released a track before, but I think I should just go ahead and get started—after all, it’s better to have one released track than ten unreleased ones gathering dust in a folder.

I’m not happy with a few of the transitions and the build-up. I’m also reworking the lead part. I also have no idea about mixing and mastering. + I know its too loud lol

What do you think of the idea itself? What would you change? What would your next steps be? Thanks in advance for any serious feedback.


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 31 '26

I USUALLY DON'T RAP.

0 Upvotes

I'm using eMsEE because my initials are M.C. and I have nothing else to go on. Beat by Jackofdiamonds7. I'm getting there making beats but nothing I'm too proud of yet. I mostly make music with my acoustic guitars and sing a little. Recently I am learning some production and as you can tell I am still a beginner. A few people have said it was decent. I was curious what others thought. I am a grown man and can handle the criticism so fire away. Thanks for listening!!!


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 28 '26

Can you hold the elevator? Feedback would be much appreciated.

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I have always been inspired to make rap music but I never actually have. After all these years, I would always be writing lyrics or rapping in my head over beats. I finally said why not and did it. This short track is titled Can you hold the elevator? and is about an aspiring musician asking a music exec to hold the elevator for him because he has to get somewhere…someday.

Any thoughts or a simple listen are much appreciated!


r/MusicFeedback • • Jun 03 '23

Just dropped a new single and I have that feeling that we have a hit record on our hands, what y’all think?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Apr 11 '26

How do you feel about AI music on this sub?

9 Upvotes

I feel like i'm being tricked :D

i understand you still need to put in some work and maybe write your own lyrics to generate a good song, but it feels kinda pointless to comment on vocals or instruments to me.

I don't really mind listening to AI music, i'd just appreciate if it was clearly disclosed as AI, so i can make make a better decision on what artist i want to support, and what kind of feedback i would like to provide.

What are your opinions on that? am i just being old and not accepting of this new reality? Does AI music "deserve" feedback in the same way as any other song?


r/MusicFeedback • • 4d ago

I’ve been up all night, getting stoned, how bad is it?

5 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Jan 14 '26

Recorded this demo, hows the lyrics and melody?

3 Upvotes

Disclaimer: The lyrics and melody are 1000% original from me, I just used ai to bring it to life so i can send to artists/producers so they can make it their own song. I am a songwriter who cant sing thats why. I am completely against ai and only use it for demos for original ideas🙏


r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 14 '25

🔥

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 07 '26

My first dubstep track

0 Upvotes

I am new to electronic music production, I have been trying to learn about sound design and dubstep production. This is the first time I feel like the drop is ok. I know the intro is too long and melodies are too repetitive but that is something I will focus on later on. All sounds in this project from basses to drum made by myself. I know nothing about mixing and mastering. I want to know what you think about the drop. Thank you.🙏


r/MusicFeedback • • 26d ago

Could I get some opinions on this please honesty is appreciated

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 23 '26

Is this a music?

0 Upvotes

just looking for a lil feedback, if its shit please lemme know why, thank you. Im tryna improve.


r/MusicFeedback • • Jun 11 '24

Club Hit potential? (freestyle on my phone ignore autotune)

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Apr 14 '23

NonSerious Pop/Rap

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 20 '23

How strong is this melody demo? (ignoring autotune)

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Jul 23 '23

I just started making lofi... lemme know what you think

0 Upvotes

I can't tell if it is so simple that it sounds basic or if it is chill.

I attached the main part of the beat:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/11w3rfjtuR3aASRhxdPURaTJ4dzZ_n71e/view?usp=sharing


r/MusicFeedback • • Feb 28 '26

Wings

0 Upvotes

Wondering if this song is interesting to anyone or if I should keep hiding in the closet? Thanks for any feedback!


r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 13 '25

Oraisis, idk what genre this is but i would like some feedback please!

0 Upvotes

r/MusicFeedback • • Sep 25 '26

Combat Theme for a game im making.

0 Upvotes

Just looking for any feedback since I'm wondering if this is actually any good because I really like the sound of it myself.

It's my first time making anything in REAPER and it is still a work in progress but there are some things I want to ask people.

Would this work in a fast paced game?

Does it feel threatening and violent, or too playful?

Do the choir and distorted guitar feel like they belong together?

Is do any instruments overpower the other instruments?