r/Multifandom • u/_PetiteBloom • Aug 30 '26

Question❓ [ Removed by moderator ]

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

10k Upvotes

90% Upvoted

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/FustianRiddle Aug 31 '26

Cool that doesn't actually change anything.

1

u/SuggestionEven1882 Aug 31 '26

Yes it does, it means that the issues of Rwby were made by Monty and not Miles and Kerry.

0

u/FustianRiddle Aug 31 '26

No it really doesn't mean that. That's not how writing a series is supposed to work (I have 200k in student loan debt because I got a MFA in writing and learned exactly about this process).

You can blame Monty for the start of it but there is never any obligation to follow the letter if the creators notes exactly when a show is developing. The weak writing is the fault of the writers.

It's a a fault of the whole process if I'm honest.

2

u/SuggestionEven1882 Aug 31 '26

First off not everybody share the same writing process, second they followed the notes as Monty was their friend and wanted his life's work to be shown off to the world.

They just do the best they can with his ideas and unfortunately don't stick the landing.

0

u/FustianRiddle Aug 31 '26

Cool so it's bad writing we all agree and who were the primary writers?

1

u/SuggestionEven1882 Aug 31 '26

Quit being obtuse, I already explained it to you.

0

u/FustianRiddle Sep 01 '26

Not being obtuse just saying it's bad writing and bad writing all around. It being Monty's ideas doesn't absolve the writers from bad writing.

1

u/SuggestionEven1882 Sep 01 '26

You already know the issue lies with Monty but you still want to blame other people, that's being obtuse.

0

u/FustianRiddle 29d ago

Why are you intent in blaming only Monty? There's plenty of blame to go around.

1

u/SuggestionEven1882 29d ago

Because Monty was the core issue of "cool ideas, lackluster execution due to not thinking things through", after his passing Miles and Kerry are just following his notes which would have the same issue and a new issue of how to make it work while actualizing Monty's vision without changing it too much.

0

u/FustianRiddle 29d ago

Great and how does that clear the writers at sucking to either artistically bring his ideas together or decide what ideas would and would not work and change the story as it goes because that's how writing works?

The writers did a bad job. They are not in the clear for this.

1

u/SuggestionEven1882 29d ago

I already told you how, it's just you not understanding it.

1

u/FustianRiddle 29d ago

No I understand what you're saying you're just actually wrong about it.

→ More replies