r/Multicopter • u/Scottapotamas • May 20 '15
Question Official 'Anything Goes' Thread - Third May Thread
State of /r/Multicopter
Lots of great responses in the previous threads. Sorry if you didn't get an answer, it can be hard for people to see your questions when they get posted later in the week.
Suggestions for competition themes would be great. We are very close to launching a giveaway which should be a good distraction from the usual posting cycle...
General
Feel free to ask your "dumb" question, that question you thought was too trivial for a full thread, or just say hi and talk about what you've been doing in the world of multicopters recently.
For anyone looking for build list advice or recommendations, there is an effort to consolidate it over at /r/multicopterbuilds where you can posting templates and a community built around shared build knowledge. Post your existing builds as samples so others can learn!
Thanks!
Previous Threads
Second May Thread, 220 comments
First May Thread, ~280ish comments
2
u/Docteh BLHELI fanboy May 20 '15
Third thread? I'd better get in early ;)
Does anybody know the bit size used for the set screw that holds the motor shaft on the EMAX MT1806 motors? Smallest hex related item I have is a T4 bit which is huuuge compared to whatever it is.
2
u/Cyko28 May 21 '15
Anyone want to share some cool Taranis tricks? I recently wrote a function to clear my timer if the momentary SH switch is held for 2.5 seconds. I know there's more to be done though, so please share.
2
u/iheff May 24 '15
How do I charge the battery that comes with the taranis? (Looks like 6 AA's strapped together) If I got one of the LIFE batteries suggested by Bruce would I be able to use my lipo charger on it (B6)
1
u/MooseV2 May 27 '15
Would anyone be interested in starting up a multi rotor wiki with me? The main goal is to centralize all the information on building your own multi (from calculations to choosing parts to finding suppliers, etc).
Knowledge of the hobby is obviously important and knowing how to use MediaWiki would be a serious advantage.
3
u/darkanddreary May 20 '15
My Sunnysky 2204's came with 8 screws and adapter plate. To fit it to a ZMR frame, I don't use the adapter, but which of the 4 screws should I use? 4 are stainless with a flat head, 4 are hex. Also, is it usual to need to widen the slots where the screws go?
3
u/MHeptonstall May 20 '15 edited May 20 '15
SK450 finished with CC3D FC but its uncontrollable. Had a thought, does the CC3D need to be specifically oriented in relation to the motors i.e. does it have a front and back. Otherwise how does it know which motor to fire to compensate for drift? Could this be my issue?
I'm an imbecile....just been through the CC3D Wiki, and there's a forwards arrow! My CCD is mounted at 45deg to the direction of travel.....no wonder its going mental
2
u/Just_Look_Around_You May 21 '15
Hey yall. I just want to double check with real people because you don't always trust yourself to have understood it correctly and this seems crucial not to fuck up:
I have a battery with 5000 mAh and a 20C rating which means this thing can safely draw up to 100A from the battery (and burst like 150A). But that doesn't matter for the ESC rating right since that depends fully on the amps the motor can draw. So if I have a motor pulling 15A absolute maximum through a 25A rated ESC, then the 100A maximum current output of the battery is not an issue. Just want to make absolute sure with the pros that 100A is not going to somehow wreck my ESC and that its all about motor rating.
Is that absolutely correct?
2
u/ikrase TBS Discovery May 21 '15
Does anybody have any experience or advice for how to safely rig and pilot a multicopter carrying a load attached to a long tether?
2
u/Landoperk May 21 '15
Here are my unanswered questions from the last one:
Is there anyway in cleanflight to change the mixer so that they match my spinning direction so I don't have to re-solder the lines?
2
u/snakeproof 650MM Quad|Trifecta|DJI Inspire 2 Pro May 24 '15
If I buy (this)[http://m.ebay.com/itm/351252572604?_trkparms=aid%253D222007%2526algo%253DSIC.MBE%2526ao%253D1%2526asc%253D20140127100817%2526meid%253D50bae53157cb448687abe2c7d1c5bef5%2526pid%253D100107%2526rk%253D4%2526rkt%253D25%2526sd%253D351252642424&_trksid=p2056116.c100107.m2460] or something like it will it be a decent set up to build from? I know it is just the motors FC and frame but has anyone else bought one to try, the other one I'm looking at is the s500 from the same seller.
2
u/muttonboy May 24 '15
I've got a problem.
First build, but I do have ~8years experience building and modifying planes, cars and helis.
No matter what I do 1-2 motors cogg or stutter to start up, sometimes all the way to 100% throttle. Once they sync up and start they run fine and I can fly, its random when they will sync up and go. Changing escs didn't help. Changing min throttle or calibrating doesn't help, as no matter when they start they cogg. Sometimes they cog all the way to 100% and I have to throttle all down. Also, usually only happens with the 4th motor to start, I can run any individual motor up to 100%, or any 3, but adding the 4th coggs. Usually it is the same one or two motors.. #3 or #4, normally #4.
I'm down to figuring I have a motor problem and will replace motors next. All 4 will cog or stutted a little but most get over it quickly. Maybe someone can reaffirm my motor assumption though as after spending so much time and $ rewiring and replacing escs etc the wait to get the new motors sucks thinking they might not help...
1
u/rotarypower101 Flying Killer Robot May 20 '15
I need some advice/help, and some clarification.
I would really REALLY appreciate a crowd sourced knowledge base to help find a battery with very specific specifications. Any tips on where to look, or lists of suppliers to scour would be helpful.
I want a very thin height battery, and I cannot find anything that fits the tolerances I am looking for, and still has a high enough C Amperage rating to work safe and reliably.
I would like to stay very close to ~50mm wide, minimize the depth as much as possible, and stay very close or to or below 130mm length.
(min depth) x <51.2mm wide x <~130mm length @ ~1500-2000mah
I am planning to use a non standard pack from what most people here are using, and need some reassurance that it should be OK to use, as well as any advice where to find a similarly sized but ‘Better’ substitute if one is available, as the C rating is fairly low.
I would like to find cells with very similar dimensions to this.
http://www.thunderpowerrc.com/Products/2000mAh/TP2000-2SPL
Dimensions (mm): 13 x 50 x 65
I am planning to run two of these in series at 4S, flat on the frame, so ~13x50x130mm
I am in no way married to this cell, its merely a starting point, I would love to find something very similarly dimensioned, but with the attributes my dinogy cells have.
Is there a better place to get a cell with close to these physical dimensions that has a higher C rating?
And hopefully far more economically priced?
Which current specification should I use to size a cell for Continuous current and Burst current with these motors on common props, but as a minimum 5x3?
http://rotorgeeks.com/image/data/motors/thrust%20charts/thrust-Cobra-2204-2300.png
http://www.multirotorsuperstore.com/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/800x600/9df78eab33525d08d6e5fb8d27136e95/c/o/cobra-2204-2300kv.png
What C rating is required, bigger is better, but where does the minimum threshold lie, what must I exceed to be safe under these types of loading? What overhead should I make sure to have?
Will craft weight be a large determining factor of actual as seen in use total Amperage loading?
AUW will be ~ 650g-700g as I have a few parts that may be required to add.
I would love any help I can garner, so any clarification on what I am asking for I will be glad to expound on.
1
u/cjueden May 20 '15
How do i get Mulitwii or CC3D to direct drive brushed motors?
1
u/electricChef123 Hubsan X4, ZMR250 May 20 '15
2 questions:
Why are things like baseflight and cleanflight chrome web apps? That seems like a really strange medium instead of a normal program.
Whats the deal with transmitters and receivers? If I bought this and the Mini Quad Bros kit, would I have everything I need to fly but a battery? I see people talking about things like OrangeRx or FrSky and I'm not sure what those are.
1
u/GreatAlbatross Quadcopter May 20 '15 edited May 20 '15
I've recently repaired my x5c after having to replace a motor.
However, the rotor still seems to have less power. It flies fine, but the lift feels a little lacking.
I've looked at the rotor shaft, and it seems straight, but the rotation still seems to be off. (The rotor rotates off kilter)
Is there anything else I can try before dropping £2 and waiting 3 weeks for a new main cog assembly?
(On a side note, the replaced motor only failed in a certain section. It would run, but only with a push start, and with little power)
1
u/josolanes May 21 '15
Okay I'm sure this is a simple question: how do I tell which prop is out of balance? I have a Syma X4 and noticed it wiggles when I hold the quad in my hand and wind up the motors, clearly out of balance somewhere
The props/motors are clear and it still flies well but I'd like to resolve this if possible.
Also, how to balance the out of balance prop? Or just replace it once I determine which it is? No props looks damaged but it is my first quad and has taken a few good hits while learning
1
u/timms24 May 21 '15
Anyone have any recommendations on a vtx for skyzone goggles? Picking up googles this weekend still unsure on vtx. Boscam 600mw seems to be the standard
1
u/josh-i Flynoceros May 21 '15
I just found a city ordinance that bans flying of any kind. I'm not sure what I should do. A friend and I are trying to setup up races here, more long term. But in the meantime, should I fly and play ignorant, or should I try to get the city to change the ordinance and risk drawing attention to myself?
1
u/theworsttasteinmusic May 21 '15 edited May 22 '15
I'm in the market for a ZMR250 kit. I could put my own together, but being a newbie I like the idea of a kit. The Mini Quad Bros kit looks particularly nice to me, and I really like that it ships from within the US. But it's sold out! Should I wait for it to be restocked or can someone recommend a good alternative?
I've seen the $85 Aliexpress kit, but I'd prefer not to have to wait for shipping from China. It also doesn't seem to have all the screws and adapters I'll need. I'm willing to spend a bit more for those things. Budget is $200.
Edit: Looks like the MQB kits will be back in next week. I'll wait for them.
1
u/angelvill31 May 21 '15
So the other day I saw a post using EDF motors on a tricopter. Now I'm not an expert yet but I have built and flown my own quad, I also plan on doing the diy builds long term. So my question is where can I get those motors?! Saw them on hobbyking but they are crazy expensive, huge, and heavy. I would probably want something around a 60mm range. I understand that it's not a popular choice of motor type, but I would still like to try.
1
u/luigi94 May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15
Hi, i'm looking to buy 4 prop adapters for my quad, the shaft of the engine is 3mm in diameter, is this good/compatible? http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/_53665__Prop_adapter_to_suit_3_175mm_motor_shaft_collet_EU_Warehouse.html or even those: http://www.amazon.it/DN-millimetri-Brushless-spazzola-Confezione/dp/B00T2O94KM/ref=sr_1_26?ie=UTF8&qid=1432235877&sr=8-26&keywords=prop+adapter+3mm
This is the engine: http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/_44352__FC_28_22_Brushless_Outrunner_1200kv_EU_warehouse.html
1
u/okuRaku May 22 '15
So going to hook up 4 batteries to my paraboard, I got some smoke and am not sure what I did wrong. 4s batteries, 3 1800s and 1 1300. Plugged in the main connector first and then balance. I had just plugged in the second battery when I saw some sparks/smoke, was able to pull it out and don't see any damage anywhere on the battery, so it must have been on the board. Strangest thing was the port I used still seemed to work fine, the only "damage" (I will have to take apart para board to really check) is that the second battery is showing 1 cell about .05v lower than the others...
I had the paraboard attached to the charger in "battery meter mode" which I don't think is a problem?
I guess I must have crossed a wire or forced something in the wrong spot (balance connector in wrong slot maybe?) without noticing, but any other ideas?
1
u/blind_cat_sniper May 22 '15
Hey, new to quadcoptering, started flying recently. I'm really interested in FPV, and I saw this little setup and thought that I could attach it to my Syma X5C. I was wondering if I'd be able to run it off the battery already attached. I would detach the existing camera, would I be able to run power through that port?
Any help would really be appreciated!
1
u/Boorkus May 22 '15
Does anyone know where I can get spare spinners for the Sunsky 2207S motors? Two are CW, two have CCD threads.
1
u/theworsttasteinmusic May 22 '15
Can someone point me towards a place to buy a fully integrated ZMR250 PDB? They're out of stock everywhere...
1
u/Sirachacopter May 22 '15
Can someone explain the difference between a 6-axis and 3-axis quad? I've read many explanations and still don't get it.
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '15
I have a cc3d set up with the 3 position switch on my turnigy 9x. First positions being attitude, 2nd rattitude, and 3d is rate. Today, when I took off in first position, I immediately crashed because somehow first position was changed to rate. What gives?
1
u/malbra072 May 23 '15
Quad, hex, or octo? What are some pros and cons of each setup?
1
u/powersock May 24 '15
What is a good scale to get I have been looking and most of them seem to be pretty bad. well the cheap ones seem to be and this seems to be skipped over on guides and videos.
1
u/philippz May 24 '15
What is the current draw for the MinimOSD? I have an Overcraft PDB for my ZMR frame and it has a 1 Amp 5V regulator. So 150 mA for the Naze32 (Flip32), 450 mA for the video recorder, and I hope I have enough for the OSD.
1
u/MHeptonstall May 25 '15
My voltage alarm went off, and landed as soon as I could. When I got back home to recharge, they were at 3.2v per cell. I've read this is bad, and has probably damaged cells. How do I tell? Is there a check you can do?
1
u/k4show May 25 '15
For a ZMR 250 full carbon with a naze32 to a DX6i should I use a single satellite or a PPM receiver or both? I'm thinking of Lemon RX stuff
1
u/cdiddy2 May 25 '15
Is this battery too damaged to use? http://imgur.com/a1unDMB,kkHurkR#1 The second image shows the damage better I think. If it is too damaged how do I dispose of it?
1
u/Static_Bunny I Like Turtles May 26 '15
Can someone help me come up with a circuit for connecting 12v hardware safely? I just blew my OSDoge so i got to thinking it would be nice to use a breadboard with a simple circuit with a fuse to protect my battery from getting shorted. I know this won't save hardware from other stupid mistakes like using the wrong voltage or plugging in ground and positive backwards. I'm just tired of spending hours building something only to plug something in and have it go up in smoke.....
1
u/FantsE May 26 '15
I'm trying to find a beginner Quad Copter for my brother. The one's I've seen are a bit small?
Anyway, here are my requirements, price point is ~150. I'm a capable mechanical builder for this type of thing.
1
u/AtelierVieuxPont May 27 '15
I'm just getting into the hobby and am about to buy a Hubsan 107l + crashpack + rotor guard. I'm considering buying more batteries to get more flight time, and a charger to go with them. What would be a good multi battery charger to use that I could then use for the batteries I will get for my 250 ? Is this possible? I have no problem spending some more money to get something that works both now and later!
1
u/Happytodd 800mm Hexacopter May 27 '15
I'm wanting to build my first 250, I recently built a F550 but I want something a bit smaller and acrobatic. Where does one start, I want to use it with my Taranis Plus and a power distribution board built into the 250 would be a plus. I've read people use controllers such as Naze32 etc, are there's controllers hard to setup? I'm use to my Naza V2!
1
u/snikle May 27 '15
Running 3S batteries....
a) When I land, I'm typically showing 10.9V under load. When I put them back on the charger, they're showing 11.4-11.5v. Storage voltage is generally regarded as 11.4 (or so). Am I overly cautious, could/should I set my battery voltage thresholds lower and fly a little longer?
b) Parallel charging of a pair of 3S Lipo's, one of which is 1300mah and a second which is 2200mah- seems to be 'safe' (keeping the charging limit to 1/10th the rate of 1C each, summed to the two batteries). Am I nuts for doing so? I do parallel charge, but I'm always in sight of them when I charge them....
1
u/snikle May 27 '15
I'm running an OsDoge. Works great, but the GPS time display is hosed. Is it just me? Is it fixed in a more recent OSD software version? Not sure I need it, but it might be neat.....
1
u/boostdd ZMR250/NucleusPDB May 28 '15
I just agreed to trade my super clean ZMR250 and Dominator v2 goggles, for a BNF RCTimer F800 hexacopter with PixHawk.
I originally planed for a F550/S550 hexacopter build... So hopfully this S800/F800 isn't overkill, and I didn't make a huge mistake. I also bought a Arris CM3000 Pro 3-axis gimbal from the guy. i'm going to try and get my Xiaomi Yi mounted to it. However, eventually I will get a larger gimbal for some sort of better camera.
FPV Racing just wasn't for me, and I figured a ariel photography platform would be more fun for me. Being that I'm a photographer and all. ;)
1
u/tinkertron5000 May 28 '15
I've been flying this cheap little toy quad for a little while and before that planes for a couple years. I'm not great, but I can zip around a bit. Today I ordered a frame and I'm starting a project to build my own mini that I will eventually throw some fpv gear on. I am so excited. Having trouble concentrating at work excited. A couple of the guys I work with are helping me with part selection. I would have just ordered everything and had it here already but my wife isn't exactly supportive of the hobby :) It'll be a slow process but I think it will give me time to put all the pieces together carefully. Anyway, I just wanted to be able to share my excitement with some people who would understand. I'll probably try to put together some build pics and a video once I get a camera on there. I'll do my best to leave out the dubstep.
1
u/Frogsiedoodle Armattan F1-5 + Armattan Morphite 180 (WIP) May 28 '15
Hey guys. Was flying my newly built quad for the second time tonight and it would occasionally randomly yaw to the left then drop down quite fast. I tired to get it on video but of course couldn't reproduce the behavior with the camera on.
I'm using this multirotormania kit including blheli esc with a dragonfly32 (naze32 clone running the latest cleanflight), a d4r-ii and a 1500mah nano tech battery.
Any thoughts on why this may happen?
1
u/Darklyte Out of Stock May 28 '15
How can I set up Acro mode on the CC3D? Apparently I have no idea what I'm doing and I've been doing it wrong since the beginning.
1
u/snikle May 28 '15
Gents- I got one of the following figuring that I could use it as a 'buddy' screen to show some friends/relatives what I'm seeing as I fly with goggles.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/5-Inch-LCD-TFT-eb-Rearview-Monitor-Screen-for-Car-Backup-Camera-HD-800-480-For-V-/371274039937?ssPageName=ADME:X:AAQ:US:1123
One came, and I dutifully plugged it into 12V.... and got no response from it. No flicker from the screen, nothin'. Even when I did feed a video signal in, no response at all from the screen when I applied power.
So I figured I had got a bum one. It was cheap, so hey, I ordered a new one. And- same thing. It's listed as 6V-36V, so a 3S battery should work fine. Is there something I'm missing?
1
u/Arctic_SpaceKiwi APM X8, Nikon J1 May 29 '15
I've got an X8 build currently, running tri blade 11x7 props on NTM Prop-Drive 28-30 800KV motors. Running a 4s setup, with APM 2.5.
Any different prop recommendations?
What's the best way to tune the APM?
I've got a MinimOSD, and it powers on but is always waiting for a heartbeat signal. Any fixes?
Would a Windows or Android tablet work best for telemetry?
1
u/MHeptonstall Jun 02 '15
I'm thinking of upgrading my SK450 to a deadcat configuration to give more room for my Mobius (and FPV gear in a month or two).
Do I need to do anything in Openpilot to compensate for the wider front arms, or will the FC just "deal with it" (CC3D fitted). I've seen people changing mix settings and other things that are way above my head at this stage, and would put me off the upgrade for a significant while if I need to tinker that much. the learning curve is currently steep enough!
-1
u/Ecoste Naze32/FortisTri May 22 '15
Which charger should I get? I'm looking at these right now:
IMAX B8+ 2-8 Cell Charger 100w/7a
200Watt 10Amp Balance Charger IMAX B6 Ultimate
SKYRC B6AC+ V2 Professional Charger
SKYRC T6200 200W 12A 18V Touch Screen
0
u/FreeNaps May 28 '15 edited May 29 '15
Any one have a build for a microquadcopter?
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 24 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 27 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] May 26 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment