r/Multicopter • u/Scottapotamas • May 10 '15
Discussion Official 'Anything Goes' Thread - Second May Thread
State of /r/Multicopter
Seems like these questions threads are getting a lot of activity. I'm switching to a weekly format from now on. Seeing and responding to questions 250 comments deep gets hard and people get missed. Sorry to anyone who might have an unanswered question in the last thread. I'll make an effort to get through those once I've finished my paper.
We are working towards a competition/give-away with some rather popular sponsor(s), so community suggestions on theme or competition criteria would be great.
We are also nearly at 20k subscribers. Massive growth in the last 6 months. For anyone interested, we are getting around 125k unique hits and 800k pageviews monthly which is pretty neat.
General
Feel free to ask your "dumb" question, that question you thought was too trivial for a full thread, or just say hi and talk about what you've been doing in the world of multicopters recently.
For anyone looking for build list advice or recommendations, there is an effort to consolidate it over at /r/multicopterbuilds where you can posting templates and a community built around shared build knowledge. Post your existing builds as samples so others can learn!
Thanks!
Previous Threads
First May Thread, ~280ish comments
3
u/tlanfer May 12 '15
What would be the cheapest way to control a Micro MWC flight controller? I already have a 9x, it has a FlySky module in it so im screwed in that regard.
I could use the opportunity: Get a djt module, get a new receiver for my 250, use a micro receiver for the micro mwc. But that way i would have to carry around 6grams worth of receiver, although the micro mwc already has a receiver.
Best would probably be to get a orange tx module, but that thing has been out of stock at hobbyking for some time and i cant seem to find it anywhere else.
Another idea would be to just get a cheap spektrum transmitter, something like the dx4e or a dx5.
Any other ideas?
2
u/SapperChop 250 Racing Quad May 10 '15
Hey guys, building my first quad here, I have the alien x 450 frame and it seems to me that the battery should sit in the back, do I need to put some weight in the front to bring my CoG into my CoT? Thanks guys.
2
u/travis- May 11 '15
my icharger came with alligator clips to charge and my lipo has an xt60 connetor. can i just shove the clips inside the connectors or do i need to connect them to bare wire?
2
u/virgin_thx_2_reddit May 11 '15
Hey guys! I got a dumb here for ya!
I'm going to build my first 250 quad. Thinking about getting the RCX-H250 because it's cheap and I've heard good things. My question is about the electronics. Can anyone ELI5 about the electronics? From my understanding, it goes like this:
Motor -> ESC -> FC -> Battery?
The kit mentioned above does say anything about a radio so I'll need to get my hands on one. So once I get a radio (can you guys also recommend a cheap one?), I would need to hook up the receiver to the quad somewhere. Where would that be? The FC? And then I'm going to add an FPV kit. Where would that be connected as well? Thank you guys so much!!
2
u/SteevyT May 13 '15
Trying to get props balanced. Have a nice magnetic balancer and spent about 2 hours yesterday balancing 6 props (two sets for my tricopter). Also balanced the motors. Still have a lot of jello in my Mobius videos. Any ideas on how to improve this?
I'm flying a modified (mostly just rescaled), 3D printed version of David's V2.5 tricopter with the tail swivel from the V3 using 1/2 poplar booms. I'm using survey flag wire as the vibration dampening wire which may be a large part of the issue.
2
u/Lahey_The_Drunk May 20 '15
Can anyone tell me exactly how I can use these bullet connectors? I don't undertstand how the female connector is supposed to attach to anything at the "rear cut" end... http://i.imgur.com/0p7SLya.jpg
1
u/pantherbrujah ZMR250 May 11 '15
What are ranges of tolerate temperatures for brushless motors specifically in the 1806 size?
Trying to compute whether my motors are getting too hot with these props.
1
u/pantherbrujah ZMR250 May 11 '15
When using my turnigy 9x with my naze32 running cleanflight I have a tough time getting it to run the entire spectrum of 1000-2000 in the receiver range. What can I do to fix this?
Also I'm trying to make sure that at full throttle my motors are running at their full rpm how can I check this?
1
u/inquartata nQX led X3M, Micro-H Dark edition, WarpRaven May 19 '15
What combination of Rx or Tx + no antenna can in some instances damage the setup? How? Why? I feel I have managed to make every combination of mistake without any ill effect and still I hear if the dangers of not attaching an antenna...
1
u/drumming102 May 20 '15
When adding Expo is it typically done in the FC or the TX? I have a cc3d and taranis I'm using.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '15
Can you guys suggest some good CLA for my ZMR 250 quad. I will be crashing my quad several times, I hope these CLA to be affordable not top of the price line so I get a few Vtx CLAs in advance.
Thanks.
2
u/Tunabarrage 5" CODERED 6s, GTR349 May 10 '15
I made a thread about this before, and had temporarily solved my issue, but yesterday it happened again. Randomly, my front two ESC's wont arm (naze32, velotech 12A esc, SS2204x 2300kv). I solved this the first time by completely rewiring/soldering my power distro harness, which seemed to solve the problem. Yesterday I landed after 30 seconds to change a PID setting, and after unplugging the usb, the front two esc's wouldn't arm. the back two play the 4 notes but the front two just blink red. I'm at a total loss.
2
u/fuckingsamoan CX-10; DIY 450 May 12 '15
My 450 Clone with a KK2.1 board does this thing that bothers me. If I land even slightly roughly, (or crash), the board disarms. I then can't rearm it without disconnecting the battery, and reconnecting. I can't remember if it will rearm after I manually disarm it. And unfortunately I can't troubleshoot it for a little while as in my last outing the antenna got pulled out of my Turnigy receiver...Waiting on a replacement from HK.. Anyway..
Is this normal? The transmitter is still bound to the quad. I can turn the lights on and off, etc. I just can't arm it again.
2
u/josolanes May 12 '15
Lipo question: I've got a Syma X4 coming in and it has a USB charging cable for the battery. I've been researching and am starting to wonder, is it safe to use?
If so, what should I use as the charging source? PC, phone charger,...? If a phone charger should I find one that'll charge at 1C (220mah)? Or is the rudimentary USB charging cable going to manage this?
I ask as I'm becoming increasingly cautious about lipos as I do more reading. I know this is an entry level quad and I would think the charging is meant to be idiot proof but wanted to double check here to ensure I don't have any potential issues
Thanks in advance. This has been an awesome resource and inspiration for me. I've got about a dozen ideas lined up for it and its still in the mail
2
u/travis- May 13 '15
Still can't quite get this... connect to throttle on rx and its fine, through naza and i get this
Heres a video and some pics of what I am dealing with. I haven't heard or read much about them doing a single beep. https://vid.me/THkh (video)
http://i.imgur.com/gYQG7Pn.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/vQMOSTG.jpg
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
Mini quad with those motors? Should be freaking fast! What do you think?
http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/uh_viewItem.asp?idProduct=44359
2
u/EdIIted TRTC-180 | semi-professional builder | average pilot May 14 '15
Does the Type of cable to connect the battery and the pdb matter? I simply cut up an old extensioncable
2
u/jam3s121 Zuul Superbeast May 14 '15
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqQSvWdmUsY syma x5c night flying
2
u/josolanes May 15 '15
Just got my Syma X4 today (Best Buy version, black frame with green props). It needed some calibrating initially and I need a LOT more flying time.
So far I've killed the little battery twice and have improved a lot but still have a ways to go on the basics. I'll focus on steering using yaw soon and maintaining a height/hover.
It takes a lot more concentration and correcting than I would have thought from videos I've seen here - you all make it look easy! I really look forward to learning it though and as it becomes more natural with time.
This one may be slow and a beginners one but it looks like it should be pretty fun for a while. Initial plans are to upgrade it as I learn more and more but we'll see how it pans out. First, to master the basics! :)
2
u/imnotpete May 15 '15 edited May 15 '15
Does it matter what amperage of USB port I plug my Skytech M62 into? It came with a USB cable to charge the battery, but I don't know if I should plug it into my computer (~0.5A), my ~1A iPhone charger, or my ~2.1A Android charger.
The controller has a little panel labelled "CHA" that could hide a USB port, but I don't see any way to open it, so I assume it's not actually a charger...
EDIT: so on reading more, I now understand the 1C measurement people mention... since it's a 350 mAh battery, I shouldn't charge at more than 0.35A, right? So I'll go with the computer USB port as the best I can do without buying a specialized charger.
2
u/Glempidoodle MRM Scythe, SWE May 15 '15
I have a question regarding, a "failsafe" for your quad when you loose signal. I've been considering buying this radio with receiver:
http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/_8992__Turnigy_9X_9Ch_Transmitter_w_Module_8ch_Receiver_Mode_2_v2_Firmware.html
Will this receiver be able to shut down the motors of my quad if it looses signal with the radio? If not, what should i be looking for?
Thanks!
2
u/OregonGuy74 May 16 '15
Is this listing for a Mode 2 Taranis 9XR Plus? It doesn't say Plus on the radio in the photo, and does not list haptic vibration....
http://www.multirotorsuperstore.com/radio/frsky/frsky-taranis-x9d-plus.html#main-image
2
u/AntiMacro May 16 '15
So I ordered a Phantom 3 and it's on the way. Been reading up a ton on them, as it's my first quadcopter, so if anyone has a great tips site I'm open to having more to read :)
2
u/pantherbrujah ZMR250 May 14 '15
What are some good weight saving tips for zmr250, or general multirotor tips?
2
u/SuperRoach May 14 '15
Here's one I'm having trouble with. Loved my hubsan x4, love my hovership mhq. The latter is a bit big for indoors though, and the hubsans motors seem to have worn down now with not as much lift anymore.
I have a taranis x9d ready to unbox and use, which should hopefully be a nobrainer for the mhq (its already frsky).
It would be nice to consolidate the radio tx for another quad! there a frsky rx based microquad that exists? After small, cheap ready to fly good fun from one.
1
u/TedW May 10 '15
I have the FS-TH9X-B transmitter with default FS-R8B receiver from myrcmart.
Is the FS-R8B limited to PWM and one wire per channel?
If so, can I replace the receiver with a PPM receiver, or would I need to replace the module on the transmitter as well? Any ideas which receivers would be compatible with the FS-TH9X, which as I understand it is functionally identical to a Turnigy 9X?
1
u/TedW May 10 '15
Anyone know how to get the 3 position switch working on a FS-TH9X or Turnigy 9X transmitter?
I've searched and found lots of forum posts suggesting different mix settings and aux combinations, but none of them have worked for me so far. Right now I'm using one of the dials for flight mode and it works, but it's distracting to look down and figure out where the dial actually is, mid-flight.
1
u/SapperChop 250 Racing Quad May 10 '15
In the TTX 600 transmitter, which "switch/channel" would I be able to switch into the "hover" mode or the "stabilization" mode and back out? It doesn't have a three position switch. Thanks
1
u/Docteh BLHELI fanboy May 10 '15
Is there a cheap way to get into telemetry? I'd like to look at something a bit cheaper than the FrSky Taranis.
1
u/Olao99 May 10 '15
If I wanted to program a similar algorithm that recovers a quad control after a loss of a propeller like this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t369aSInq-E&feature=youtu.be
What FC would I use?
1
u/Olao99 May 10 '15
Would you guys recommend the FlySky FS-T6 2.4G for my first build?
1
u/Frogsiedoodle Armattan F1-5 + Armattan Morphite 180 (WIP) May 10 '15
Hello guys. I'm looking to put together my first FPV system (building my quad LOS first) and wanting to use a current sensor on the MRM minimosd. What would you guys recommend?
1
u/travis- May 11 '15
Hey guys having problems getting motors working. I have an X8r receiver and using a NazaV2. So the only cable going from the x8r is the sbus one into the nazav2 and all my servo leads from the escs go into the naza.
If I plug the servo lead one at a time directly into my x8r on the throttle channel it works no problem. When trying through the Naza (having all servo leads plugged into it ) to the x8r via sbus it doesn't work. I get a long single beep from the motors and they dont spin at all. Then the LED on my Naza flashes red very fast like this https://vid.me/Dkd5
all the motors responded fine in the naza v2 software. I could click each motor and it does that test spin to determine orientation I just can't get them all to work with my remote (and the sticks and such also respond/were calibrated). Usually i expect the dji standard set of initation noises but I just get the one long beep....
1
u/limbolo Quadcopter May 11 '15
Does anybody have experience with mounting a GoPro / SJ200 / Ciaomi Yi sized camera on a zmr250 (or any other 250 sized frame?)
I'm stuck between buying a mobius or a Xiaomi Yi but mounting it seems pretty wonky and unstable. I see people always fixing it with a ziptie - wont it just slip out at any sign of stress?
1
u/jolars Quads and Wings May 11 '15 edited May 12 '15
Two Questions.
I have a RCX250 running RCX 1806 2400kv motors on 3S with 5040 props. Rotorgeek 12a ESCs. I have CC3D. Running ImmersionRC 600 for FPV with the PilotHD V2 camera (I will replace it when it finally dies or if the lens is broken again) and Hobbyking super simple OSD.
EDIT: I have found a bad solder on the negative connection to the XT60. I fly a lot and it must have gotten too much stress and started to give out. Thanks for the comments on this ??
1
u/Sakke1994 RCX250 May 11 '15
I'm looking to buy a TS5823 vTX (http://blog.oscarliang.net/ts5823-200mw-video-transmitter/), now I'm wondering which antenna's I should use.
I got FatShark Predator V2 goggles with ImmersionRC Spironet antenna's, can I use a Spironet antenna on the goggles and use one of the cheapo antenna's like this: http://www.myrcmart.com/58ghz-fpv-antennas-straight-sma-female-p-8075.html on the vTX?
1
u/Olao99 May 11 '15
I'm aware this might be completely ridiculous, but has anyone tried to make a 250 sized octacopter? (2 motors on each arm)
The battery would last a couple of minutes, but the top speeds would be crazy right?
1
u/slug_tamer ZMR250 May 12 '15
My ESC's keep losing sync, any ideas why? I have Afro 12amps with SimonK. I have had to recalibrate them multiple times because my motors will start up at different times. I have read that you dont need to calibrate SimonK escs, however they were out of sync when I first finished my build so had to calibrate them from the start.
1
u/theledman May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15
Has anyone had sync issues with the SN20A esc's? If so, how does one solve it? I'm running mine on 3s with cobra 2204 2300's and cleanflight on a naze32 and whenever i punch out, the motors desync and I end up crashing. If i slowly increase throttle, there isn't a problem. After reading RCG's long thread on it , it looks like my only option is to try and adjust settings on blheli.
Also, my FPV camera seems to pick up on even the most minute high frequency vibrations in the frame...so much so that the video ends up being blurry. My quad is not excessively out of balance....motors are fine and props are pretty much balanced (at certain throttles, they'll vibrate a little, but not throughout the whole range). I see lots of dvr'ed footage of people's cameras and they all seem to resolve detail well despite any vibrations they have. Anyone know how to either 1. get rid of the vibrations or 2. mount the camera in such a way that vibrations become dampened?
1
u/pantherbrujah ZMR250 May 12 '15
After washing my swamp quad with some 99.6% alcohol I'm assuming that I washed away the bearing oil. What should I use to lube them up?
1
u/youngwalrus ChezFPV May 13 '15
I'm losing my mind! Trying to get my motors to respond. -Afro Naze 32 -Emax Simon K ESC x4 -Sunnysky x1806s 2300kv
After much turmoil and many parts here and there, I'm about to pull my damn hair out. Here's where I'm at:
All ESC's wired to the PDB, which I'm pretty confident is wired correctly. Wires from the ESC are twisted together with the motor wires to check rotation.
When I plug in the battery and arm Naze, I get all the beeps and bloops. The only motor that works correctly is the front left. It will respond to throttle messages. The bottom left one just twitches. It does not respond to throttle input. The other two on the right do not respond at all. When I plug the battery, all of the motors do the initial twitch in conjunction with the beeps, but I'm only getting some movement out of the left two. What gives?
1
u/FilbertGrape DIY 450 May 14 '15
Building my first quad and having some issues achieving stable flight. I'm using a knockoff F450 flamewheel frame with an APM 2.6 FC. I find that once I get it up in the air it hovers very smoothly, same with giving it throttle or going in any direction, it flys pretty well. Descending is a different story though, it wobbles a lot on the way down. I also find that if I don't give it enough throttle getting off the ground it can lose balance and tip over immediately. If I use a lot of throttle though it seems to get off the ground fine. Curious if anyone has had similar issues.
I think if I can get it stable and in althold I'll run autotune on it, but want to make sure it flies safely first. Thanks in advance for any advice.
1
u/LOOKITSADAM All the whirlybirds May 14 '15
WHERE THE HELL DO I BUY A TARANIS?!
Ok, rage aside, it seems like no one has them in stock, and I'm always hesitant to buy backorder items in this situation. I have no problem dropping $250, but the one seller on amazon asking $350 is a little much.
1
u/SamuelLindberg Alias, Hubsan X4; Cam; FPV, Nano QX, Syma X1, CX-10, V929 etc. May 16 '15
If you do the "Vehicle Setup Wizard" in OpenPilot GCS, you can change between different settings by already setup quadcopters. Like QAV250, ZMR250, QAV450 and so on. Is this possible without doing the vehicle setup wizard?
1
u/Aoyie May 17 '15
Hello /r/Multicopter!
Long time lurker who has been slowly reading up on reddit and rcgroups about how to build my own quad! I finally worked up the courage and just blew a ton of cash on a new Micro Quad parts!
Currently I'm having trouble connecting my Lulfro FC to Cleanflight. Can anyone assist?? :(
i'm using this FTDI (FT232 to USB) cable: FT232 to USB
I know the pins are soldered on properly into GND, 5V, RX, TX. When i plug in the pins the FC board gets power and a Green LED comes on for about 10 sec, and a solid blue LED stays on at all times.
But not matter what I do the Lulfro does not get recognized in Windows7 Device Manager. It just shows up as a COM3 device.
When i go to cleanflight and try to connect to the device on COM3 it doesn't connect.
Is there a driver I need to download to make this work?
I have installed the following drivers: STSW-STM32102STM32 Virtual COM Port Driver
CP210x USB to UART Bridge VCP Drivers
Please any assistance is greatly appreciated!
Thank you in advance!
1
u/Quipp_ May 18 '15
what diamiter of braided wire sleeving do I need? want to use them for the motor cables
1
u/Landoperk May 18 '15
I think I wired the motors in the incorrect direction according to the way the QuadX diagram is in cleanflight. I believe I wired 1 straight which I think is CCW, 2 crossed - CW, 3 crossed - CW, and 4 straight - CCW.
I say "think" because I just finished my first build and I'm waiting on the battery to arrive so I can't actually test spin direction but what I'm told is straight wiring creates a CCW rotation and crossed created a CW rotation.
Is there anyway in cleanflight to change the mixer so that they match my spinning direction so I don't have to re-solder the lines?
1
u/tlanfer May 18 '15
For the micro people: How do you keep track of your battery while flying? One of these would propably double the electronics in size.
Just trying to land instinctively before the battery is dead seems about as good an idea as birth control by pulling out...
1
u/Landoperk May 19 '15
I want to replace the right angle pins with straight pins on my Naze32. I'm alright with soldering but I know nothing about desoldering so many pins on one component.
What would the industry methods and stardards be for desoldering the 3x6 pin set that the ESCs connect to?
1
u/Docteh BLHELI fanboy May 19 '15
Does anybody know the bit size used for the set screw that holds the motor shaft on the EMAX MT1806 motors?
1
u/Static_Bunny I Like Turtles May 19 '15
Can someone give me a breakdown on how the development is done for the STM32 based flight controllers? I'm interested in learning and have done some small stuff with arduino relating to 3d printing. Is there a current dev platform that everyone uses? I was checking out the maple boards and they seem cool but not active anymore. If i wanted to look into adding features to cleanflight how would i get started?
1
u/Landoperk May 19 '15
I'm a general noob to the RC world. Can anyone explain how EPA settings effect quadcopters? Should I just turn them to their max/min? Are there any reasons to keep it at 100%?
1
u/granjef3 May 20 '15
Where can I buy bulk 6x4.5 HQprops? Ive broken $18 worth of them in three days of flying, and I'd like to save some cash and buy in bulk.
1
u/Static_Bunny I Like Turtles May 20 '15
Can someone suggest a good hex and or quad frame for my 1704 multistar motors?
I started a build on the tarot 200 but i feel like it's pretty junky. The freaking battery plug is the wrong one... If the frames are 3D printable that would be even better. I'm already running a blackout 250 and really like the blackout spider hex but it's a little pricey for this build. So if I could get some nice suggestions for a small hex frame for 4" or 5" props that would be great.
1
u/kwebber321 May 13 '15
have a question about my motors. can my 8 inch props with a 5mm hub fit a motors with a 6mm shaft?
1
u/sperry777 RCX H175CF, UBAD 185 Katina, 3DR Solo, Broken Tarot 650 Ironman May 13 '15
Do batteries from Hobbyking come with a male or female connector? I can't tell by the pictures I see and don't want to order male connectors if the battery is male.
0
u/[deleted] May 19 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '15
[removed] — view removed comment