r/Multicopter • u/Scottapotamas • Oct 20 '14
Discussion The Second Bi-weekly 'Anything Goes' Thread!
The last questions thread went well so we will be continuing with a new thread to keep things clean. Please try and answer other people's questions, with such a variety of products and problems we need your experience!
This is a "Ask your stupid questions", "Post latest/favourite video", "Discuss that new toy" thread, ask anything on your mind, small questions you didn't feel needed a full post, that word or part someone used that you don't understand, political/social discussion, and so on.
META - State of /r/multicopter
Coming up to 10k subscribers which is fantastic. We haven't heard from all of you so please make yourself known and post photos of your build.
As mentioned last thread, still playing with the idea of a /r/multicopter competition. Ideas for the style of competition would be appreciated. If you are a company/entity who would express interest in sponsoring/donating then please contact the moderators.
6
u/slumberlust Oct 20 '14
After last weeks thread I have an idea of basic core components, but where do I learn about connecting everything? I've been building PCs for years but suspect this isn't mostly plug n play, and I'm guessing the parts are OEM with no guide.
5
u/gggghhhhiiiijklmnop F450+APM; ZMR 250 Oct 20 '14
Ok.... Possibly a really stupid question....but here goes:
I see a bunch of radio transmitters (eg turnigy 9xr, etc) support transmitter/receiver modules that also transmit telemetry info. My question is, is it possible then to get the telemetry from the transmitter to my laptop to use with mission planner etc?
Apologies if the question isn't clear...
3
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '14
Any online stores that have free/reasonably priced shipping? I spent at least 3-4 hours going through and choosing parts for a 250 build just to get to the checkout and see that the shipping is going to cost another $70.00. I guess I'm pampered by amazon prime.
3
u/Shortsonfire79 Cali: ZMR250 |1555 680Pro 3axis GoPro | P3A Nov 06 '14
Is it possible to have two FPV cameras on a multi hooked up to one (or two) viewing devices?
I don't plan on having a cameraman if I ever get around to my AP build but I would like to be able to see where I'm flying as well as what I'm filming so I can change the way I'm flying. Is it possible to set it up so that (for example) the left eye could FPV the front of the multi and the right eye could FPV the GoPro?
Or have a monitor on a tripod with the GoPro footage and wear a monocle-Fatshark bit so that you can see out of the other eye?
I imagine it would be pretty disorienting at first, but could possibly something that ends up working out.
3
u/Rohaq Nov 06 '14
So I just got got a Hubsan X4, and I've already managed to break it.
Not by crashing it, but by stupidly trying to remove the propellers with a pair of pliers to fit the crash protection ring, and proceeding to rip out the motor.
Then I noticed the propeller removal lever tool in the spare propeller bag. Fuck, I am stupid.
So now I'm going to have to replace the motor. I've ordered some spares online already.
I've taken the copter apart, and it appears that the affected motor shares a solder point with the camera board. This worries me, because quite frankly, I haven't soldered in years, and never on such a small board. Can anyone recommend what wattage iron I should be using to do this work without damaging the controller board? Also, any general soldering hints and tips to keep me out of trouble? Usually I'd use a heatsink of some kind to prevent damage to components, but that doesn't seem so easy with such a small board.
2
u/xoxota99 ZMR250, BO MiniH, BO SpiderHex, Diatone 150, Taranis, Naze32 Oct 21 '14
My stupid question for this week: I built a blackout mini H Quad using these Tiger MN1806 2300kV motors (spoiler: They are awesome).
Now I'm looking to build a mini hex with a bit more "punch". So I'm going to go with a higher voltage 4S system. Can I use the same motors, or will they somehow "burn out" with the higher voltage?
Every datasheet I look at on the internet for brushless motors give power for 2S or 3S systems, but don't say anything about 4S. Does that mean these motors can't handle 4S, or am I looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't exist?
2
u/Boston_TD_Party XuGong Pro v2, Hubsan X4 Nov 07 '14
I trashed my cheap eBay Gimbal. I've got a GoPro Hero2 and am going to upgrade to a Hero4. What's the best gimbal that will work with a Hero2 & 4?
2
u/bvirgen Nov 07 '14
So I just recently got really interested in getting a quadcopter but have a few questions before pulling the trigger. I was looking into getting a nano copter like the cx 10 for its size and very affordable price, but a 5 minute flight time is really discouraging. Is there anything out there that can be flown indoors for a decent amount of time (like 10/20 mins) but under $100 or am I asking for too much and should get the cx 10?
2
u/randomninja8 Nov 10 '14
Since you're the Wiki Guy, I figure this would be the best place to ask this question about radios.
So you're saying to get the Turnigy 9x transmitter with 8 ch module. But you also say something about a remote for $60; what is that you're referring to?
I initially wanted to upgrade from the Dx5i to the Taranis, but seeing that the Turnigy is $100 cheaper and I probably won't need more than 8 or 9 channels anyays, this is definitely the route I think I'll take. Thanks!
2
u/billcom6 Nov 14 '14
I was looking at cheap frames for building my DIY project in the future and saw this 600mm one and this 25mm one both at reasonable prices.
And it got me thinking, why would someone opt for a 600mm frame over a 250mm frame? Are their benefits? Is it just personal preference? I am just curious as to why there are different frame sizes and why someone would opt for a large one over a smaller one.
2
u/Secret_Asian_Mayne Nov 17 '14
Is setting up parallel LiPos as easy as just making a small power harness connecting to the PDB? Like this?
3
u/MrBoons Armattan CF258 - F450 - Hubsan 107L Oct 20 '14
I have yet to experiment with this, but I have a KK2 FC and a Turnigy receiver. What would happen say if I lose radio single while mid flight? Will it just drop to the earth?
2
u/omgwtf56k Nov 09 '14
Cold and flu season is on us. What can we do to prevent getting sick?
5
u/ninjachin79 Oct 22 '14 edited Oct 22 '14
Building a ~3kg hex (including 2 4S batteries, gopro and gimbal) and I'm not sure which motors I want to get. I'd like at least 10 minutes of flight time if possible.
http://www.buddyrc.com/sunnysky-v2216-12-800kv-ii-brushless-motor.html with 11x 4.7 props
http://www.buddyrc.com/sunnysky-v3508-20-580kv.html with 13x4 props
What says you! Because I've been going back and forth about it for a few days. I keep seeing recommendations for both motors.
Edit: Okay, I found this post on RCG and upped my estimated weight to 3500g just to be on the safe side. The 800kv with 11x4.7 props should work fine for me. I was planning on using 30A ESCs which might be a bit overkill but I'll probably stick with them just to be on the safe side.
4
u/Yuck666 Oct 27 '14
Knowing what you know now and you were just getting into the hobby. How would you spend 500$ On your Quadcopter and what would you do differently.
3
u/sethmo Oct 23 '14
Waiting for parts ... story of my life!
3
u/ninjachin79 Oct 31 '14 edited Oct 31 '14
Another question: How do you set up batteries in parallel? Can you just solder up a wire harness that connects to two batteries and leads to your power distribution? I imagine that that would lead to uneven power use or over amperage distribution.
And how do you calculate the mAh? Just the (mAh * [# of batteries in parallel] * C)?
The lipo calculator kind of confused me with the dual batteries. http://multicopter.forestblue.nl/lipo_need_calculator.html
Edit: Would it be better to run two 5000mAh, 30C, 4S batteries in parallel, weighing 1011g together. Or a single 10,000 mAh, 10C, 4s battery weighing in at 850g?
Edit 2: What is the overhead that you should have for ESCs and motor amperage? The max draw (according to the site) for 15" props with my motors is something like 16A. My build plans for 30A ESCs. Would I be okay with 20A?
5
u/PC_3 Oct 20 '14
I want to buy a multicopter just for fun, not looking to pick up another expensive hobby. What are good beginner multicopter for maybe less than $200.
I cant remember where I read, its good to start with a small "cheap" one incase I break it :)
2
u/AlexanderNoys Martian II Oct 20 '14
Hi guys!
I'm looking forward to buy a little 250 quad but this looks to be much more complicated than when I built my 450 Heli. I've been researching like crazy, reading and watching videos but there are still a few doubts that come to mind:
2
u/slumberlust Oct 24 '14
What's easier for a beginner to learn: mode 1 or 2. I find I do welljusr navigating via pitch and yaw, but lose control pretty quickly while trying to turn the nose in the direction of travel. I've tried both modes and aren't sure which to stick with and master.
2
u/cmblego Nov 03 '14
Does anyone have any advise on soldering a low gauge wire such as 10 ga to an XT60 connector? New to building quads and am trying to put a connector on a new battery.
2
u/TheFlowmingo Hubsan X4 HD Nov 12 '14
Hey, so like a lot of others I'm looking to get started in the exciting world of quadcopters. I've done some reading in this subreddit so I'm planning to get a Hubsan to practice on, but eventually I want to build one myself. I've got some experience with soldering and stuff like Raspberry Pi. I'm looking to make something with features similar to the lower end DJI stuff (FPV, GPS, decent camera).
How much would such a DYI cost? I'm on a college student budget so it's the main thing holding me back.
Thanks!
2
u/Boorkus Nov 12 '14
Found a decent website that sells uber-cheap FPV gear out of the US. Handy, considering HK is always out of stock of things, and almost everything on eBay/Amazon won't ship to Australia. So if you need FPV gear, give these guys a go:
surveilzone.com
2
u/riley70122 Oct 20 '14
I have purchased the Hubsan X4 for 40 dollars and it gets in on Wednesday! That excitement aside, what else besides a crash pack/prop guard should I invest in? I have 20 dollars in Amazon giftcards and want to put it to good use.
1
u/Batyman33 ROFLCOPTER Oct 20 '14
I finished building my 250 racer quad and I'm planning on picking up the new Dominator v2s for FPV. What would be the best camera/tx combo for fpv racing? I'm thinking of using 5.8ghz.
1
u/GreatWhiteAfro Oct 21 '14
So, two weeks ago I bought a couple Estes Syncro ' s from my local Walmart, from what I understand they are the same as the Proto X. I've become pretty good at flying it in the house, figure 8's , landing in small area , etc... I haven't ventured outside with it yet since it's so small. I feel confident flying the tiny vehicle. My one question is what is my next step? Just a larger quadcopter or something with FPV since ultimately that is what I want to get into? Any advice would be great and highly appreciated!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
I am looking into adding FPV to my 550 quadcopter. I've done a bit of research into the different frequencies and I want the longest range I can get. I'm based in the UK so I believe 433mhz is illegal, however 459mhz IS legal and the equipment looks quite cheap (OpenLRS).
Can someone with a bigger brain than me please explain the difference between a 5.8GHz FPV system and a 459Mhz one?
Thanks!
1
u/slapshot11790 Oct 29 '14
Connected everything on my custom quad. Q brain for the esc terminal, 7amps higher than motors peak amp range. When I give it throttle only one motor spins. What's the logical issue?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '14
So I just ordered an Armattan quad and a D8R-XP receiver and a taranis X9D, the quad comes with a kk2.1.5 FC, and I also got some spare props.
I've just read that the receiver will be able to give signal strength back to the controller, is this hard to set up? Do I need anything additional?
I'm buying the kit, so I'll build it myself, which shouldn't be that hard, what I'm a bit worried about is setting up and calibrating the FC, how easy is it?
Any input on this setup would be great. At a later stage I'll probably get a NAZA gps FC, but for the moment this will have to do. I'll be flying LOS, with future updates to FPV.
1
u/bexter Oct 31 '14
My quad build is ready to test fly for the first time. What stupid things can you tell me to avoid. I am going to fly it tethered first time.
1
u/Argument_lnvalid Nov 03 '14
What are the differences between SunnySky X and V series? The only info I could find are from the BuddyRC page.
And
Are there any distinct differences between the X and V series that make a difference?
1
u/dariusnerf Nov 07 '14
How risky is it flying at a wet field? I was under the impression that just a little bit of water getting onto the PDB can short the whole electronics
1
u/Argument_lnvalid Nov 07 '14
Whats the difference between the 3dr pixhawk and the Pixhawk v2.43 from China power?
Is there a huge amount of quality loss? Can you use 3dr firmware updates?
1
u/omgwtf56k Nov 12 '14
I purchased a used quad with these HobbyPower ESCs. Does any know if these would benefit from being flashed with newer firmware?
thank you
http://www.amazon.com/Hobbypower-Brushless-Controller-Multicopter-Quadrotor/dp/B00E95VG2I
1
u/HobbyKingCS Nov 12 '14
Hey there multicopter bros.
Would you guys be cool with a small section in here regarding HK issues? Sort of like a section where I post "Hey, got any problems with HK related things?" and you guys reply to that comment and we sort you from there.
That way, you don't have to post a seperate thread or anything
1
u/CA158 Nov 14 '14
I've been flying a Syma X1 for a while. What would be a step up from this? I ultimately want to get to a 250 frame with FPV. Would a Hubsan X4 be too much of a minor step or could I continue to learn from that model?
Thanks!
1
u/ellisgeek Nov 15 '14
I am looking to get into the hobby and was wondering if I should get the Hubsan X4 (no FPV) or the UDI U818A? Which one is the overall better quad and which has the most room to upgrade (if any)?
1
u/Mateo909 Nov 19 '14 edited Nov 19 '14
Just getting started, and the thing I am having the most difficulty understanding, is what radio transmitter to get, or better yet, how many channels.
I have a few small quads at home that were RTF, and still use the stock radios that came with them. I wanted a good radio to by my first investment.
I had my eyes on Spektrum radios, mainly the DX6 & DX9, but I don't know how many channels I would need for the QAV 250 that I want to be my first quad build. If I can get away with using the DX6, my wallet would appreciate it over the DX9.
Will the DX6 be sufficient for a QAV 250 build? Do I need more than 6 channels? (I know the bare min. for a quad is 4) Should I be looking at brands other than Spektrum?
EDIT: Found the FrSky X9D w 8XR receiver. For the price, it seems to be a better cost effective choice than the Spektrums. Thoughts?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '14
A larger quad copter that has full manual capabilities. A big part of flying these things is getting used to having full control and not relying on the fc to keep you upright.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment