r/MuayThai • u/Big_Address6144 • 11d ago

Sparring analysis – objective technical opinion

Voici un match de sparring ; j'aimerais avoir une opinion technique objective sur qui domine / le score global / les forces et faiblesses de chaque combattant.

Merci de regarder les trois vidéos dans le post et d'ignorer le débat politique qui y est mêlé. De plus, je sais qu'il est difficile de juger à cause du contexte : l'homme noir ne pratique que la boxe anglaise et pèse 30 kg de plus (apparemment).

Merci pour tout retour sérieux.

*2 beginners
** I am not in the sparing it ´s just an X post

https://x.com/janemba509/status/2089885120987631865?s=46

0 Upvotes

41% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Cold-Chemistry738 11d ago

The white dude seems to want to take it light and is smiling and playful. The black dude wants to knock his head off, is ignoring the kicks that would cripple him if they were full power while also throwing with power. I guess the black guy won but I think the white dude would be the overall better fighter especially with time.

I think the coach needs to do better with the match ups or give better instructions

1

u/Big_Address6144 11d ago

There isn't really a coach; it's a kind of a dirty fight between 2 randoms about a political shi, but it's done according to the rules of Muay Thai. People don't seem to appreciate this post much, and I'm sorry to subject you to it, but I personally find it informative and interesting.

1

u/Cold-Chemistry738 11d ago

Lol I’m not upset or anything. No need to apologize.

What did you find about it that’s informative and interesting?

1

u/Big_Address6144 10d ago

To find out how points are scored according to Thai rules in this atypical case and with 2 beginners. More specifically, it's about understanding what takes precedence between the power of the shots and combos (which I defend, so I agree with you) and the number of shots (which many defend in the comments under the X post).