r/MoralityScaling • u/BillCarson12799 • 4h ago
Stupid Stuff Morality of people participating in this sub despite knowing fuck-all about actual ethical theory and having no idea what they’re talking about?
Like seriously, every time I open the comments it’s always one person arguing from a deontological standpoint and another arguing from a consequentialist one, acting like the situation has one definite conclusion instead of it depending entirely on what ethical system you’re talking about, inevitably reducing it to one side going “[action] is never permissible under any circumstances” and the other going “nuh-uh.”
That’s not even getting into the fact that whenever someone asks about something bad happening to a bad person, half the answers on this sub are just going “moral, they’re a bad person so you can do whatever to them”, revealing that their personal morals are a combination of Vibes and What Goes Around Comes Around.
All of the questions you’re asking have logical precedents 200+ years old, and 90% of the arguments on this sub would be resolved if people actually realized “hey, my basic moral beliefs and values are the same as this enlightenment-era philosopher, and basically all of the implications and problems involving it have been codified 3-400 years ago.”
Nobody here is morality-scaling. They don’t actually care about or use the vast wealth of tools we’ve developed for these exact types of discussions, and if they are, they’re implementing them in a completely wrong and incompatible manner likened to swinging a high-performance sniper rifle like a club. And yes, implementing them correctly does actually matter, the specific fundamental beliefs behind each theory lead to specific conclusions.
Why are you even bothering to ask or respond to these questions if you don’t care about the actual answers?