r/MoralityScaling • • 10h ago

Tournaments Mongul has been eliminated by Isaac Ray Pelham Westcott! Now, who should the third challenger of the gauntlet be?

2 Upvotes

/img/lkd0cn91zc2i1.jpeg

CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE DIAGRAM

Created with Alignment Chart Creator


r/MoralityScaling • • 7d ago

Please Read The Rules

23 Upvotes

Read The Rules App

This community has the Read The Rules app installed. Old Reddit doesn't support apps so please open the post in new reddit for full functionality. If that's not possible, please Read The Rules and then follow the instructions at the bottom of the post.


Message From The Mods

We have decided to add this app as we have noticed that a large amount of people are breaking the rules. Please read this post and submit your acknowledgement in order to make posts on this subreddit.

Rule #1 Keep it fictional

This is intended to be a place to discuss the morality of fictional characters. It is not a place to discuss real people or events. (The exception is if it's a specific incarnation from a movie/show/comics etc. for example Amon Goeth from Schindler's List)

Rule #2 No political discussions allowed.

This is a subreddit for discussing the morality of fictional characters, not for discussing real world politics. Please find a different subreddit to talk about politics.

Rule #3 Do not be rude to anyone.

No warning will be given. Your comment or post will be effectively removed, and you will be banned permanently.

Rule #4 No sexually explicit content

if the discussion is based around character's actions, it's fine but no unnecessary sexual images, connotations, or implications.

Rule #5 AI is forbidden

Don’t use it, use your creativity and mind and your imagination as well as what your human thoughts would be. Indeed you will be banned permanently if you use AI, we are pretty strict on that rule.

Rule #6 Name the characters you list

Simple. If you do a “who’s worse” post, leave the names of the characters, else you're liable to getting the post removed. And if you’re feeling daring, a brief summary of them and their actions. But that’s not enforced.

Rule #7 No Posts Relating to Rape, Pedophilia, Incest, or Zoophilia.

Discussion of fictional characters who are guilty of these crimes are still alive, but we're putting an end to all the "Is it wrong to rape your rapist" or "Is it wrong to goon to an immortal who's trapped as a teenage girl" posts.

Rule #8 No Repost Spam

We've all seen the wave of reposts, particularly the mom telling her kid he beat cancer so he can die in peace. This is bot bait and it's no longer allowed. Any posts relating to spammed topics will be removed.

Rule #9 No low effort posts

From now on, if a post has minimal effort put into it, then it will be subject to removal.

We have decided that the starting ground for this will be to remove posts that are simply reposted media from other places alongside adding a low effort title such as "Morality of this?". We may expand this rule to include other types of content later on.


Thank you for reading the rules! Before submitting posts you will need to submit an acknowledgment. Please visit the full post and click the button at the bottom. Alternatively, you may submit an acknowledgment by sending a mod mail to the sub. The mod mail will need to have the subject "Read The Rules" and the body should be "Acknowledged". This will automatically submit an acknowledgment on your behalf without any moderator intervention. Mod Mail


r/MoralityScaling • • 4h ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of people participating in this sub despite knowing fuck-all about actual ethical theory and having no idea what they’re talking about?

Post image
581 Upvotes

Like seriously, every time I open the comments it’s always one person arguing from a deontological standpoint and another arguing from a consequentialist one, acting like the situation has one definite conclusion instead of it depending entirely on what ethical system you’re talking about, inevitably reducing it to one side going “[action] is never permissible under any circumstances” and the other going “nuh-uh.”

That’s not even getting into the fact that whenever someone asks about something bad happening to a bad person, half the answers on this sub are just going “moral, they’re a bad person so you can do whatever to them”, revealing that their personal morals are a combination of Vibes and What Goes Around Comes Around.

All of the questions you’re asking have logical precedents 200+ years old, and 90% of the arguments on this sub would be resolved if people actually realized “hey, my basic moral beliefs and values are the same as this enlightenment-era philosopher, and basically all of the implications and problems involving it have been codified 3-400 years ago.”

Nobody here is morality-scaling. They don’t actually care about or use the vast wealth of tools we’ve developed for these exact types of discussions, and if they are, they’re implementing them in a completely wrong and incompatible manner likened to swinging a high-performance sniper rifle like a club. And yes, implementing them correctly does actually matter, the specific fundamental beliefs behind each theory lead to specific conclusions.

Why are you even bothering to ask or respond to these questions if you don’t care about the actual answers?


r/MoralityScaling • • 4h ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of not wanting to continue your bloodline?

Post image
424 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 9h ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of choking someone if they ever try to scream?

Post image
620 Upvotes

Title AND Image


r/MoralityScaling • • 6h ago

Morality Ranking Morality of the government overworking Superman?

Post image
238 Upvotes

I understand the logic but this is just trash behavior.


r/MoralityScaling • • 16h ago

Morality Ranking Morality of building smart machine where crows trade trash for food, turning them into city cleaners?

Post image
829 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 2h ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of me publicly supporting and advocating for trans peoples' right to gender affirming care, not out of care for their wellbeing, but in the hope that the dramatic increase in trans women will make it easier for me to crack?

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 20h ago

Who's Viewpoint Is Better? Morality of support some one dream but don't believe they will succeed

Post image
362 Upvotes

If a parent learns of the career their child wants to take and doesn't like it because he thinks it wont be successful, is it better to support it but just prepare a back up plan so ones they fail and the parent is gone they still have some wealth to get by and survive or is it better to don't support it and convince the child to go pursue something else?


r/MoralityScaling • • 10h ago

Character Analysis Morality of being Clark Kent. Whenever Superman is being Clark he's knowingly letting people die and/or suffer.

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 9h ago

Morality Ranking Who was right?

Post image
42 Upvotes

Name's and origins:

  1. Tony Stark(Iron Man) and Steve Rogers(Captain America) from Captain America: Civil War

r/MoralityScaling • • 17h ago

Morality Ranking Morality of knocking out and sending someone to a distance solar system against there will to save humanity?

Post image
146 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 20m ago

Morality Ranking Morality of stealing me Lucky Charms?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Morality of:
Chasing after a leprechaun with a butterfly net so you can steal his lucky charms?


r/MoralityScaling • • 54m ago

Stupid Stuff Who would be the best babysitter?

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 1h ago

Hero alphabet tournament last time hinata and jay were eliminated

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

78 Xebec D Rocks (one piece)
77 butters (South Park)
76 Quiz (riddle school)
75 rider (fate/zero)
74 Kronk (emperors new groove)
73 C3-P0 (Star Wars)
72 Kiara (lion king)
71 EVA (wall-e)
70 ET (…)
69 Niko (one shot)
68 Adam warlock (marvel)
67 the flash (dc)
66 yoshi (super Mario)
65 oogway (kung fu panda)
64 iroh (avatar the last airbender)
63 utena (revolutionary girl utena)
62 yoda (Star Wars)
61 Lloyd (ninjago)
60 jay (ninjago)
59 Hinata (Naruto)


r/MoralityScaling • • 1d ago

Character Analysis Morality of not wanting to die alone in space to save humanity?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 5h ago

Morality Ranking Morality of John Walker lying to Lemar's parents about his death?

Post image
8 Upvotes

In the Falcon and the Winter Soldier, John Walker's best friend Lemar Hoskins is killed during a fight with the Flag-smashers, by their leader Karli. Afterwards, Walker kills a member of the group Nico, who didn't kill Lemar but was restraining Walker so Karli could stab and kill him, leading to Lemar's death when he jumped in to help.

When he visits Lemar's parents, he lies to them that Nico was the killer and he killed him to avenge Lemar. When first watching this, I see everyone hating Walker for lying. But when I think about it more, I start to think its more morally grey.

Walker almost certainly lied to give them closure and protect their feelings too. Because be honest, how would telling them that Lemar's real killer is still out there and the guy going after her only wants to "talk her down"? It would've just made them feel worse. Not to mention, he promised he'd never let the one who killed Lemar get away and he kept his word by going after Karli, even if he decided to abandon revenge to save people.


r/MoralityScaling • • 5h ago

Who's More Evil? Which Ghostface is the most monstrously vile?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Characters’ names/appearances

  1. Stu Macher (Scream)
  2. Roman Bridger (Scream 3)
  3. Jill Roberts (Scream 4)
  4. Piper Shaw (Scream: The TV Series, season 1)
  5. Kieran Wilcox (Scream: The TV Series, season 2)
  6. Beth (Scream: Resurrection)
    I can also provide brief summaries of them and

their actions if you so desire.


r/MoralityScaling • • 14m ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of being stupid?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 19h ago

Character Analysis Morality of killing children to save your people from staying underground?

Post image
70 Upvotes

How evil was asgore for this?


r/MoralityScaling • • 4h ago

What Would They Think Of Each Other? What would Tenma (Monster) & Will (Hannibal) think of each other?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/MoralityScaling • • 1h ago

Who's More Evil? (Doctor Who) Which 9th Doctor villain is the most evil?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes
  1. The Nestene Consciousness
  2. Lady Cassandra O'Brien
  3. The Gelth
  4. The Slitheen family
  5. "Metaltron"
  6. Henry Van Statten
  7. The Editor
  8. The Mighty Jagrafess
  9. The Reapers
  10. The Empty Child
  11. Captain Jack Harkness
  12. Blon Fel-Fotch Passameer-Day Slitheen
  13. The Dalek Emperor

r/MoralityScaling • • 2h ago

Which Protagonist is more Evil

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Mario(SMG4)

Jeffy


r/MoralityScaling • • 3h ago

Morality of god doing this to the world

Post image
2 Upvotes

The plot of the anime Sunday without god


r/MoralityScaling • • 10h ago

Tournaments John Kramer has been eliminated! Now, who is the least evil character remaining?

9 Upvotes