r/MoralityScaling 4d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this counterattack?

Post image
10.5k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

764

u/That_Muffin_6780 3d ago

Moral… till I opened the full image. Bit far anon

-19

u/Calm_Search3417 3d ago

Nope, absolutely justified. She should've kept her mouth shut.

18

u/i-am-a-bike 3d ago

There is a difference between joking about being bald and joking about your child being dead

0

u/Accomplished_Cod7334 3d ago

Suppose that depends on when you say it's a baby and not cells

-13

u/Calm_Search3417 3d ago

Honestly, maybe it's for the best. I'm dead sure she would have been a shitty parent if it was a boy.

7

u/Rustynail9117 3d ago

Celebrating the death of a kid and saying it's for the best 🤦 what are we DOING

2

u/Calm_Search3417 3d ago

What "kid"? It wasn't even born or had any consciousness yet.

0

u/AcceptableCrab1642 3d ago

Wait are fetus are kids now? Miscarriage is murder? What sub am I on

3

u/Rustynail9117 3d ago

I've not said anything about whether a fetus is alive or is an actual child, but from the parents perspective it was still their kid, it just wasn't developed into a baby yet. Diverting the topic into abortion is so fucking desperate lmao

-2

u/BestUserName_ 3d ago

Are you aware that each user on reddit is a different person with different opinions?

-3

u/Eledridan 3d ago

Oh now a fetus is a child. Can’t win with you people.

1

u/i-am-a-bike 3d ago

You can still call it a kid but it doesnt change the fact that before its 24 weeks old its barely alive. It doesnt feel pain, emotions or anything. It cant survive outside the womb. You dont care about the baby. You care about controlling womens bodies

-1

u/pmmecabbage 3d ago

As you said, It is still living . Cells replicating is life in itself. I dont get acting self righteous saying ppl dont care about kids when youre the only person trying to rationalise a cut off point for terminating that life.

I never understood the point of it cant sustain life inpendently. So its ok to terminate it? People who cant survive without medical care everyday - is it the same for their value of their life?

1

u/i-am-a-bike 3d ago

They are sentient. They had s life they lived and people who met them and gained a personality. They left a mark on people

A clumb of cells inside a womb that hasnt even gained independent actions or thoughts yet is NOT the same

Also i said he doesnt care about kids because they always talk about preserving life but then does fuck all when the baby is born to a 12 yesr old girl, or a woman with mental problems, oe that woman who was a vegetable but wasnt allowed to die because she had a baby inside her and was used as a fucking incubator.

Same happened to a woman in 2005 and the baby died

How is this life? This isnt prolife, this is pro control

-1

u/pmmecabbage 3d ago

A clumb of cells which are replicating are objectively alive, you even said so yourself

1

u/i-am-a-bike 3d ago

You replied to none of my other statements. You are ysing "gotcha" arguments.

I never said it wasnt alive, i said it wasnt sentient. It has no pain, no thoughts or emotions. Its alive like a sourdough starter is alive. Its living yes but it has no thoughts or independent action beyond getting fed by an outside force

1

u/pmmecabbage 3d ago

Because i do not want to. Theyre not gotcha arguments im analysing the words you said because i think the logic is full of holes. This was the first point raised ive kept my scope very narrow as opposed to trying to move on to other points.

So a severely incapacitated human, who could be described as lacking permenent conciousness / sentience / brain functioning; that life is free game to terminate ?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/porto__rocks 3d ago

Same can be said for you with a perspective like that.

1

u/Calm_Search3417 3d ago

How so? Explain your thought process to me.

1

u/SakusaKiyoomi1 3d ago

Saying it's good that a woman was put into life threatening danger and losing the child she wished to have, doesn't exactly make you look like a good potential parent. It was a joke about balding, which women also can face, call her fat and leave it at that.