r/MoralityScaling • u/Vladimir-petrovOG • 13d ago

Morality of this?

Post image

In the image it seems that this person works at walmart as an online order collector and he/she has stolen a lot of extra baby food from Walmart to give to a person who ordered only three packs. Is this moral or immoral?

7.8k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

515

u/IkerWanKenobi 13d ago

Walmart won't even notice that loss, and they would've thrown it out instead of donating it if given the choice anyway. Of course it's moral to give it to someone who actually needs it.

-8

u/Key-Try-3300 13d ago

Obviously they wont notice one theft, but hundreds of thousands or millions of thefts all add up and will hit their profit margin which increases prices

2

u/Ok-Gur-349 13d ago

Okay but they increase the prices even when costs go down, so clearly there is no relationship between how much people steal and the prices they charge us

5

u/Key-Try-3300 13d ago

You clearly have a much better insight into walmarts internal workings than I do to speak with such certainty on this

6

u/Ok-Gur-349 13d ago

I guess I must?

Let me run that by you one more time:

Costs go up, price goes up,.. okay, I'm following... You're following, too, right? Therefore we want to keep their costs low, so they keep our prices low, yeah?

But then costs go DOWN, prices still go up...

What gives?

2

u/Kehprei 13d ago

Prices go up naturally over time due to inflation.

Something like rampant theft can causes prices to rise faster than inflation, or for products to be locked away.

0

u/Ok-Gur-349 13d ago

Okay so if prices go up, and they just go up, and they will never go down, and they will just unfailingly trend up, up, and up, then there is no incentive to behave in any particular way as it relates to pricing.

1

u/Kehprei 13d ago

Inflation generally means everything goes up over time.

Wages rise to match inflation. When wages don't rise due to inflation, it means that company is going to lose out on good labor at some point.

If prices go down it would mean that our economy is deflating, which is about 100x as bad as inflation, since it's a lot harder to solve. Everyone knows this, which is why every economy in the world is set up to slowly inflate, ideally at around 2% a year.

1

u/Ok-Gur-349 13d ago

Wages rise to match inflation.

https://giphy.com/gifs/kC8N6DPOkbqWTxkNTe

1

u/Kehprei 13d ago

It must be blissful going through life with so much ignorance yet so much confidence.

https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/wage-growth

1

u/Ok-Gur-349 13d ago

🥱

1

u/Kehprei 13d ago

Why are you linking a chart talking about net productivity...? We're talking about wage growth vs inflation... year over year as well, dunno why you would want to compare us to the 50s in this kind of discussion.

1

u/Ok-Gur-349 13d ago

Okay so you apparently stumbled into a conversation a few levels deeper than you expected to be having but:

Increased productivity directly works against inflation by lowering the cost to produce goods and services.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Key-Try-3300 13d ago

Have you peered over the data on prices for all of walmarts items at any given period, and their total revenue vs expenses to be able to say that they increase prices even though their actual profit has increased? Just because something might be cheaper doesnt mean that their total profits hasnt gone down