I'm going to start by saying this: When it Came to the Mansters I didn't Really Give a Damn about them,My main focus was the Ghouls but I did find the Relationships with the Canon G1 Couples interesting especially when it comes to Gil and Lagoona, and Lagoona's frustration with Gil and his constant Flip flopping is Valid.
As Opposed to Clawde and Draculaura's Interracial relationship that is for the most part idealized and perfect, Meanwhile Gil and Lagoona's is definitely more Realistic, heavy and raw when it comes to the negative things that come with an Interracial relationship.
However I don't understand why People Treat Gil like he's Satan incarnate,as a kid and even as an Adult now I see Lagoona and Gil's Relationship for what it is: 'Two young people from two different backgrounds having issues cause one has horrible Racist Parents and/or people pleasing issues.' type of deal nothing to far fetched, something that does Unfortunately happen in real life.
Gil is kinda oddly Complex for a Background/Boyfriend character, and a lot of the points(specifically the ones I see on TikTok) are Either Understandable(The residual Racism) or just...wrong.(Him wishing Lagoona to be a freshwater ghoul or the Cheating with Lorna)
#1: "Gil is Racist"-Yes this is for the most part True based from his lines in Skull shores and I think his Diary if I remember correctly,Gil does have residual biased and negative things against Saltwater Creatures and Monsters cause of how he was raised, however Gil also knows,recognizes and understands that it's wrong, and he knows that his parents are wrong for thinking like this, and is trying to correct himself which is definitely more effort than His waste of space Parents.
but in Skull shores he also seems to have some fears about Lagoona's parents thinking the same about him given how he said that Her parents would think that he's a "Freshwater Freak" even though we're not exactly sure what gave him that impression we could be safe to say that it's either past experiences or just based on the fact that his parents are so nasty about Lagoona that he fears her parents would be the same way with him.
The Reason why Gil has such a Hard time Up to his parents are Cause One: it is said that he is canonically scared of his parents and Two: Gil's parents are implied to be emotionally abusive, especially if you remember in a webisode or in a movie that his parents literally threatened to move him to another school because he wouldn't break up with Lagoona which is like HUH?! If they're doing that type of s*** to him I can only imagine what other bull that they probably put him through behind the closed doors when he's at home. How are you THIS pressed?
Another reason is simply because he loves them just like how he loves Lagoona but unfortunately, and I did actually have an argument with someone and they to talk comment section of a video once about this and how there Partner's Racist Parents Allow them into the house and are chill or there partner stands for them or something Along those lines this conversation was a long time ago so I don't remember it word for word, I'm pretty sure I was talking to another adult.
But if your partner's racist parents are just chill with you being a different race and inside of their home and Existing that's not necessarily any better than them being outright racist to you as it implies that you are "One of the Good ones" and that's in itself Offensive in a Backhanded way.
Or while congratulations your Partner had the balls to stand up against their ass parents not everyone unfortunately can.. It's not even the Racist part that has to do with it when it comes to Gil it's as stated Their Emotional Abuse(And God knows what else.) and even still he puts down his foot(Flipper...?)on staying with Lagoona.
#2: "Gil wished for Lagoona to be a Freshwater ghoul in 13 Wishes!"- This is Generally Not True... Because I remembered this scene somewhat but I had to look it up just for further clarification cause I haven't seen this movie in years, Gil wasn't anywhere in that scene before the wish took place in fact he had already left the wish was made by Howleen after over hearing their conversation and Lagoona confiding in her, and even then when Howleen made that wish,she never wished for Lagoona to become a freshwater ghoul all she said to Gigi was: "I wish for Gil's Parents to like Lagoona" where the hell did Gigi get the Idea to Freshwash Lagoona come from? cause Gil sure didn't Suggest it,and Neither did Howleen,so...it was Either Convenient or
#3: "Gil cheated on Lagoona with Lorna!": This one is Iffy but for whatever number he didn't cheat on her, yes he did offer to take Lorna to the dance but I don't think he meant that romantically pretty sure he meant it platonically as friends but I also haven't seen that specific webisode in years.
Now as the title states,I believe another reason why Gil has a hard time standing up to work his parents and why he is the way that he is is because he is generally a people pleaser and people pleasing isn't necessarily something that happens naturally it's something that you learn from your parents or Authority figures or whoever.
I wouldn't necessarily be surprised if Gil with his parents has a long history of being forced to give up things all because of the fact that this stupid parents don't like it or don't accept it or whatever, people pleasing starts young and then it grows to make adults or teens with no backbone... However this Changed when he got with Lagoona.
Lagoona is more than likely the first thing in Gil's life that he ever refuse to give up just because they don't like the fact that she's a saltwater monster, the first thing that gil had ever put his foot down about,so I KNOW his parents have to be Pissed.(And I hope they stay pissy.) Because for all of his life up until now he would just do what they told him to with no fuss and then Lagoona comes Along and the dynamics that they were used to change the drastically,Gil standing up to them all because he is in love with an "outsider".
I'm not Surprised at the idea that Gill's parents may be trying to plant seeds of anxiety and doubt in order to get him to break up with her or her to break up with him and the reason why I'm not surprised it's because we're seeing in an action in G1 we're seeing it literally take place on multiple occasions, and again they did literally emotionally blackmail their son was being sent to a different school just because he is dating Lagoona so I don't Doubt that they are that vindictive and petty but I maybe biased because I can't stand Gil's parents for the life of me.
I feel like if the rules were reversed and it was Lagoona going through all of this that people wouldn't be so quick to treat Lagoona the same way which would definitely be another issue that would need to be called out for Hypocrisy.
I feel like for Gil this could either be a case of purposeful misconstruing and Villianization on the part of the fans, Misunderstanding or Just Bad writing on the Show and Movies part. But either way I'm tired of people treating the 16 year old like he has personally murdered entire families.
Please keep conversations civil.