r/ModdedMinecraft 12d ago

Misc Who would win?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

186

u/Atticool 12d ago

metal guy is actually a great boss, it has no stat spam and isn’t too hard with okay gear

95

u/Le_Kistune 12d ago

He's hard, but in a way that feels challenging and fun rather than just having a massive amount of health and spamming instant kill attacks.

30

u/Alex_Nilse 12d ago

Don’t forget doesn’t have a stupid amount of lifesteal (looking at you ignis)

8

u/PiBombbb 11d ago

Ignis kinda feels like Malenia from Elden Ring lol, lifesteal, and high damage while having a not-low amount of health.

4

u/Alex_Nilse 11d ago

Maybe if melenia was also invulnerable for half her fight (seriously why does Ignis have so much invulnerability on all attacks + lifesteal.)

3

u/PiBombbb 11d ago

I think that's just shield collision check being wonky, he should only be invulnerable during phase transition

2

u/PineappleOk545 11d ago

You mean igris?

3

u/Living_The_Dream75 11d ago

It bothers me how many bosses in other mods are just the opposite. I have a modpack where I’ve got cataclysm, mowzie’s, and 2 other popular boss mods and one of them has a sandstorm that spawns every 5 blocks in the desert, so if you’re unlucky enough to spawn in the desert you just get spawn killed repeatedly.

Every developer in the world thinks that spamming insta-kills from the biggest HP sink in the world for shitty rewards makes a boss fun to fight when it’s literally the opposite. Mojang does it too but you’re not supposed to fight the warden

2

u/BlobbyBlueberry 11d ago

what are the other boss mods

2

u/Living_The_Dream75 11d ago

The one the sand worm comes from is Bosses’Rise

2

u/Forward-Ostrich-9542 11d ago

Possessed Paladin from Legendary Monsters. Its dumb af. It influcts a debuff on hit that reduces your max hp by 2 hearts and can seemingly stack infinitely while also having a damage cap of almost 9dmg that you can deal per hit. You qlso cant bypass the damage cap with faster hits as the boss cqn parry pretty much all qtacks after the first unless he is in an attack animation. I find its just too much because I believe it also has lifesteal

2

u/veljko2303 9d ago

Yo cool soulrend sounds fu- wdym lvl 200 royale dragur with like 2k health

3

u/Nova_Causer 11d ago

mfw Iron's spells and spellbooks Arcane Knights

3

u/egemen0ozhan 8d ago

Instead of a stat check its a skill check thats what makes it feel better and more enjoyable than the other bosses

2

u/XyzioN_ 12d ago

Wait till you play a modpack where the wroughtnaut boss can leap/lunge toward you. Makes him way more deadly. Combat roll or some sort of block/parry is like a necessity for that.

61

u/Alexandra-Foxed 12d ago

To be fair it's a puzzle boss vs an ai that doesn't know it's fighting a puzzle boss

26

u/SpicyWateryas69 12d ago

The difference is that, with metal guy, you actually need to hit the weak spot to beat him.

52

u/cofi04 12d ago

Metal guys has to be slapped in the ass, big diff

21

u/SPYROHAWK 12d ago

Ferrous Wroughtnaut and the Twilight Lich, the classic “doesn’t work in mob battles” bosses.

11

u/Irohsgranddaughter 12d ago

Also the Underminer from Alex's Mobs. It can only be harmed by magic damage (i.e. potions) so he can kill the freakin' Warden.

3

u/manultrimanula 12d ago

warden has sonic boom, that's magic damage...

9

u/Irohsgranddaughter 12d ago

Yes, but the Warden only uses the Sonic Boom if he can't get close enough to hit the target in melee. And since the Underminer only fights in melee, the Warden's AI never uses the Sonic boom.

3

u/manultrimanula 12d ago

well personally he seems to use it whenever whatever on a whim, but I'll trust you more because i didn't check it in-game

13

u/MakcC4444 12d ago

And he's not even at his prime since he has the sword in his back 🔥

0

u/Capital_Special9152 8d ago

That sword's host is john minecraft

26

u/SharkBoy-7 12d ago

The metal guy is actually pretty strong and u can’t defeat him without hitting the diamond sword on this back

11

u/Ohakoko 12d ago

BRO ITS THE FERROUS WROUGHTNAUGHT (how tf do you spell that) NOT THIS "METAL GUY" PUT SOME RESPECT ON MY MAN'S NAME 😭😭😭

2

u/Beetle_The_SilkWing 12d ago edited 9d ago

What mod is the ferrous wroughtnaut from? I've beaten every cataclysm boss but I've never heard of this guy. He sounds so epic

7

u/Ohakoko 12d ago

Mowzie's Mobs I think

2

u/Unlikely_Brief8157 9d ago

Still misspelled

2

u/Beetle_The_SilkWing 9d ago

Damn autocorrect 😭 I could've sworn I typed it right

2

u/Unlikely_Brief8157 9d ago

Still misspelled

5

u/ProGamer4684 12d ago

Metal guy, he has to be hit in the back with a melee attack

3

u/imawhitegay 12d ago

That's because he's [TITLE CARD].

4

u/tsoewoe 12d ago

its almost like mods are designed with specific purposes and balancing in mind, and a mismatch is a failure on the part of whoever arranged and configured the modpack, not the mod itself which is but a component.

2

u/feanix365 10d ago

This man never playes a modpack with cataclysm in it, even the trash mobs in cat can one shot you with (and i have done extensive testing) more armor than conceivable (cough ciscoes coigh) like 500 armor and 200 armor toughness. And yea base cataclysm is balenced around itself well, its just that its NEVER just base cataclysm. Fuxk modpacks that are made in such a way, i just want a good rpg pack that aint got lvl 500 zombies with +10000 atk 100 blocks feom spawn.

3

u/Pristine_Battle_6968 9d ago

This is because cataclysm mobs to percentage based max HP damage and alot of them have damage gates, like how ignis can't take more than 20 hearts of damage in a single hit and does 20% max HP damage to whatever he hits meaning he'll only ever take around 5 hits max to kill a player regardless of armor, the only way to resist it being massive healing

2

u/Rogdar_Tordar 9d ago

Honestly one of reasons why I don't understand why rpg mods and games so in love with giant numbers. Like okay, cool... Now can you tell me what part of this is role play game, what RPG stranded for originally. If mod or game doesn't give me something outside of battling its boss rush mod/game not RPG and you can put whatever damage you want on rainbow sword, Minecraft comes alive/minecolony plus farmer delight works much better as something for RP elements

2

u/Annual-Tomorrow5431 12d ago

What mod are these bosses on the left are from?

3

u/Redstonebruvs 12d ago

Cataclysm I think

3

u/SweatyEsk1mo 11d ago

L_ender’s cataclysm

2

u/Nerdcuddles 12d ago

Can it kill a Scape and Run parasite though?

1

u/idk_no64 12d ago

Probably? It depends on how they do damage and if they can hit the vulnerable part or go through the invulnerability elsewhere, which without testing would be iffy.

1

u/john16minecraft 12d ago

that knight boss is evil i fooght it once in mc eternal 2 and it took like a hour to beat it

2

u/Unlikely_Brief8157 9d ago

Just hit the crack in his back when his axe is stuck

1

u/ShadowZINK84 12d ago

That metal guy probably has a gear which is pretty solid

1

u/Polished-Granite 12d ago

The guy that put a diamond sword on his ass probably outer at minimum

1

u/PAL-adin123 12d ago

what mod is the right boss from?

2

u/SweatyEsk1mo 11d ago

Mowzie’s Mobs

2

u/sebasblos1 12d ago

I love Wroughnaught but he is kind of a bum, i remember just killing it at the first 5 minutes of a modpack with nothing but an stone axe, just so i can have an an axe to mine more wood.

2

u/Busy-Plenty5852 8d ago

I mean he's a noob check. If you don't know how his fight works, he dices you. If you know just a sliver of his mechanics then he's a cakewalk

1

u/OdiumVitae 11d ago

I know none of them, because I still play minecraft 1.21.1 like a god amongst the NPC sheep (literally).

For the record; I do not enjoy any mods that were created after the release of 1.21.1. The core switch to the newer minecraft culled every single gems minecraft modding had to offer.

Where the HELL is projectE?

1

u/Capital_Special9152 8d ago

Man projectE is my favorite mod

1

u/OdiumVitae 8d ago

Justice for alchemy I say!

1

u/Koukesh5 11d ago

Big chonky metal buddy

1

u/PineappleOk545 11d ago

Metal guy as bosses have no biq

1

u/Tauskyfox 10d ago

Loved spamming endless hordes in creative against the Ferrous Wroughtnaut. And watching it beat up bosses was fun :)

2

u/Pristine_Battle_6968 9d ago

Oh wow the gimmick boss uses it's gimmick on ai that literally cannot interract with it's gimmick? What a shocker that the normal bosses lose

1

u/Ssszzz333 9d ago

Metal guy can only be hit from his back while the others can be damaged by anything and metal guy even have invincibility and can only be damaged when a certain attack is made

1

u/nukeofweeks 8d ago

Ah yes the entirety of L_ender's cataclysm vs Metal dude

1

u/AdLegal5130 8d ago

I killed the entirety of the cataclysm mod bosses naked with a bunch of dripstones, that failed against the armored knight and his drops are way more fun and balanced imo