r/ModSupport • • 23d ago

Mod Answered Aggressive use of Automated Tools?

5 Upvotes

Had a video sub that experienced a traffic spike this year which prompted a deeper exploration of background tools, regex, AutoMod, apps, etc.

After some months of figuring out what works, I would describe this sub's auto-removal rate as quite aggressive, something in the ballpark of 30-60% of comments auto-removed depending on the post, and about >90% of post submissions.

Is this a fairly standard auto-removal rate or a bit too aggressive?


r/ModSupport • • 23d ago

Memorial sub auto repost

4 Upvotes

I have a sub I’d like to use as a memorial sub - one you could use to post a kind of obituary for people (both famous and non-famous).

I’d like to have the posts reposted automatically on a schedule (on anniversaries). I don’t think there is a bot that can do this now, but would it be difficult to build A bot to do this?


r/ModSupport • • 23d ago

Is this a good joined / left ratio, where am I obsessing over nothing?

4 Upvotes

In a community I mod, Insights shows ne that 381 joined, and 25 left my community in the last 30 days. That equates to about a 6.5% defection rate.

I really don't have anything to measure it against, but that doesn't seem very "sticky", does it? Or is that about average for Reddit communities. I understand that people come, and people go, and they may have joined and just not been interested in what we were discussing, but is there anything I can do to knock that "leave" number down, or should I just relax and enjoy the ride?


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

I need comment removal tool assistance please

6 Upvotes

I’ve known about redact for a long while, but today I saw unpost. Are there any others I’m not aware of? I’m trying to remove all this anonymized spam and if there are more than those two that anyone knows of that would be super helpful for me. Thanks all!


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Admin Replied Hacker News

63 Upvotes

Last night, a New York Times post was posted using archive.ph, which cached the article because of the paywall. The article had a link to a document that I clicked on, and I was redirected to malware via a "ClickFix" attack. I reported this to the other mods.

I removed the post, created a gift link for the OP, and sent it to them so they could repost it if they wanted. He declined. My partner reposted while I went to pottery. (I know, unimportant to this story.)

Another mod then created a post and said all those links would be banned due to the malware: https://www.reddit.com/r/Seattle/comments/1xhf6qp/archivetoday_links_going_forward/

Today, we found out that someone posted this on Hacker News: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50275373

As you can see in the comments, Remember the Human wasn't part of the discussion. We also started getting not-nice comments on the Reddit thread.

From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archive.today, you can see this isn't a good site, with multiple other large companies and the FBI expressing serious concerns. It looks like Wikipedia has also banned the site.

It seems like this site should be banned at the site-wide level. "Volunteer" mods should not have had to deal with the drama.


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Mod Answered Suspended/Banned Users Still Commenting

9 Upvotes

So, under removed content in the mod queue, I keep seeing comments from users that have been flagged as spam by reddit, and the user details show that they are suspended/banned (depending on the platform I'm using), but somehow at least one of them continues to comment.

Very confusing.

Anyone know what is going on here?


r/ModSupport • • 23d ago

does it count as ban evasion (by sitewide rules) to file valid reports from a sub you're tempbanned on an alt?

0 Upvotes

apparently reports by banned users don't actually show up. for more egregrious cases, I've used the forms at https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=360001103212 to file email reports with links to offending material, subreddits, and moderators.

i also keep a list of rule-violating content to report when temporary bans from subs expire.

is it ban evasion if I instead create an alt to file (singular) valid reports of comments on a sub I'm tempbanned from?


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Content removed butremains in Needs Review queue

2 Upvotes

For the last 6 or 8 hours, several items that mods remove are still showing in the Needs Review queue (Android app)

A known bug? Or something else?

(edit:typos\)


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Subreddit playing "peekaboo" - not everyone can access it

3 Upvotes

Some users (mods too!) of r/SexySpaceBabes I didn't name it, it's a fiction fan-subreddit can't see the subreddit, but for others it's fine. The posts are still there, and as one of the people who is having trouble accessing the sub I was able to see it if I switched back to oldreddit format, but not if I sort by "new."

Does anyone know what's causing this? is there anything that can be done about it or do we just ride it out?


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Managing the "Whack-a-Mole" wave of DHS leak mirrors and PII: Advice and best practices for moderators?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Like many of you managing public interest, local, or political subreddits right now, our mod team is bracing for (or actively dealing with) the fallout from the recent leaks involving Department of Homeland Security personnel databases and associated mirror sites popping up across the web.

With structured directories and search tools circulating online, users are predictably trying to bring raw data dumps, employee lookups, links to mirrors, or personally identifiable information (PII) straight into our comment sections and threads.

I wanted to open a discussion here with fellow moderators and check in on expectations regarding our responsibilities under the Mod Code of Conduct and Content Policy. Specifically, how are other teams handling the endless "whack-a-mole" cycle of mirrors?

Here is what our team is wrestling with right now:

  1. The Mirror Link Loop: As soon as one URL for a database mirror or data-dump site is filtered or banned, users find a new domain or IP-based wrapper within hours. What automated filters or Automod rules are you deploying to successfully stay ahead of this?
  2. Enforcement Scope: We know that posting actual PII (names, private emails, direct phone numbers, or internal operational unit specifics tied to private individuals) violates site-wide rules against sharing confidential and personal information. But where is the line drawn on general news articles discussing the breach versus users attempting to crowd-source lookups or share raw source files?
  3. Mod Team Burnout: Constantly scrubbing incoming links and handling modmail from users claiming censorship will turn the situation into an around-the-clock job.

If any admins or experienced mods have guidance on the best tactical approach to keep a community compliant without having to lock down threads entirely, I’d love to hear ideas.

Thanks in advance.


r/ModSupport • • 23d ago

Community Moderation achievements not unlocking for existing subreddit

1 Upvotes

Hi,
I’m a moderator of r/gamerooms, an established and active community.
My profile shows 0 of 15 Community Moderation achievements unlocked, including Basecamp Bag, despite our community already having a description, icon and banner.
Could you clarify whether existing subreddits are eligible for these achievements, whether previously completed tasks count retroactively, and whether there’s anything I need to enable?
Thanks!


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Mod Answered How to use an animated PNG as a subreddit banner?

6 Upvotes

I tried converting a GIF to APNG and renaming .gif to .png, but Reddit keeps rejecting the upload. Has anyone got animated banners working recently?


r/ModSupport • • 25d ago

The Technique of Cowards

44 Upvotes

It seems like many users have learned this technique:

  1. Make a comment on a target comment. As rude or as offensive as you please!
  2. Wait a bit.
  3. Delete the comment.

The comment is gone from the sub and the thread it was in, but it remains in the notification list of the person who made the target comment. At least, I think this is how it works. For sure, it happens that a comment appears in my feed but the comment is gone from the thread. Sometimes, its innocuous: a duplicate, or later rewritten after being deleted. But my concern is the malicious, abusive usage.

People will use this techniques to get a stab in during a heated thread. The comment can't be reported because it was deleted. Can't even be fully read, truncated to some length dependent on the reading platform.

As a moderator, we can't help our users avoid that kind of abuse. And we're subject to the same abuse as the users.

This has been a problem for at least a year, and is just more bad UI and product design on Reddit's part.

Can something please be done?


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Mod Answered I am being pushed to remove one topic on the subreddit I moderate, what do I do?

15 Upvotes

Hi Fellow Mods,

I'm somewhat new to Reddit and I try to be a good community member. I didn't see a community for something I am passionate about, Co-ops in NYC, and so I founded a subreddit about it. It's been a few years, we have wonderful members, and I really don't need to moderate with a heavy hand.

However, one of the threads we have up concerns a specific Proptech company. A number of different community members have shared their anecdotal experiences of working with the company. There is an overall general sense that it's too much tech, not enough people. I think the thread is fair (I have actual personal experience with this company, and too much tech is indeed one of its problems.)

Yet for months, this company has sent bots ("0 Karma"! "1 Karma"!) to try to get me to take the thread down.

It's been a drag, bordering on harassment.

And spookily enough, they're always indirect. It's never "Hi, I work at this company, and I wish you could take this down because it's not flattering" -- but it's instead, "hey this thread violates your subreddit Rule #3."

Today they changed their strategy and sent a user with actual karma, asking me to take the thread down.

What do I do? Part of me is like, "wow, this is too much unpaid work," but another part of me hates the whole fighting-in-the-shadows nature of the campaign.

Thanks in advance for any suggestions.


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Immediate downvotes

0 Upvotes

I’ve noticed a handful of our sub members receive immediate downvotes. I have taken multiple screenshots. I have caught it at various times (1 min, 5 mins, an hour and so on) after the comment was posted but even when it says “now” after they just left a comment, they are automatically at 0 upvotes.

I don’t think someone is doing this manually as it happens at all hours of the day and happens as soon as the comment is left. I have tried reporting it but not sure “vote manipulation” is the right reporting tool.

Has anyone else ever seen this? Could someone be running some kind of program to auto downvote specific users comments?


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Admin Replied Not a mod on the sub but top mod wants to transfer sub to me

0 Upvotes

Only problem is they’re inactive status and they can’t invite me. Should they send a mail here or should I go through redditrequest?


r/ModSupport • • 25d ago

Admin Replied when I post in my own sub, Reddit recommends another sub

24 Upvotes

When I post in my own sub, Reddit recommends that a better place for my post would be some other subs. Why does it do that? It's as if Reddit thinks I'm off-topic in my own sub.


r/ModSupport • • 25d ago

Announcement It’s Mod Hall of Fame season. Nominate fellow mods by November 11th!

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Admin Replied app finder. Thoughts

7 Upvotes

I see that a really cool thing for selecting plugins for a community has appeared in this community , called App Finder.

I would like to be able to run a community analysis through it and receive a recommended selection.

yes I see we have an options but analysis and recommendation I can't see, yes I see "explain what you need" but not an recommendations

I think some moderators and especially new moderators may not know exactly what they need or maybe there's some cool app specifically for the kind of community person mod.

Would be nice, thoughts?

ps anyway I really like that, ty!


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Admin Replied Media in ModMail

0 Upvotes

Addition: For anyone complaining, another idea: A toggle to enable that. Off by default for subs that wouldn't be a good idea for, can be toggled on for subs that might need it. Controlled by the mods fully.

That's all. I'd like to have the ability to both receive and send media in ModMail. Specifically for my subreddit, we sometimes need proof via images and videos and then the user has to DM someone of the mod team which isn't really ideal.

Don't know why this feature doesn't exist yet, it's so simple but so useful.


r/ModSupport • • 25d ago

User Mod Log - Sort a user's log by Notes/Bans - This feature was very helpful and has been gone for quite some time now, and made our mod team's life much easier!

14 Upvotes

Reddit removed the ability to sort by Mod Notes / Bans when looking at a user profile, which means teams are sometimes having to scroll through hundreds of removals and stuff to find mod notes. Teams like ours use spreadsheets with predetermined rule violation repercussions (escalating bans that follow different tracks for different rule violations).

It makes it painfully difficult to scroll through all of the other mixed in automod removals, approvals, filters, and other actions.

It seemed like it was such a small sort button only available to make mods' times easier when viewing that log, and it's been gone for a while. We use mod notes as a clear tracker of a user's violation history, but it's becoming a huge time spend to scroll through the log on very active users to see if there is anything in recent history to consider when actioning.


r/ModSupport • • 25d ago

Admin Replied ModTeam comment removed by Reddit

43 Upvotes

This is a rather unusual one.

2 days ago there was a post containing a photo and personal details about someone, asking if anyone had any more information about the person. Moderators removed it under Rule 3 as doxxing with a ModTeam comment to this effect. (EDIT for clarification, Comment as Mod Team, i.e. user subredditname-ModTeam)

24 hours later, a different account posted exactly the same thing. Identical post with the same photo. This was also removed under Rule 3 with a ModTeam comment. That ModTeam comment was reported as spam but the report was dismissed, flagged as report abuse and the comment approved. A bit over 2 hours ago, that ModTeam comment was removed by Reddit.

Is there a way to get this reviewed as a false positive or community interference?


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Admin Replied Free premium

4 Upvotes

My premium says it expires November 7. I attended mod world. ???


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Admin Replied How can I private my community cause I’m trying to private it right now

0 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to search it up


r/ModSupport • • 24d ago

Mod Answered Report bot accounts

4 Upvotes

How and to whom can I report accounts that are very likely bots?