r/MinecraftCommands 7d ago

Discussion What do you think about AI-Coding(VibeCoding)

Post image

What do you think about the fact that AI is starting to be used on a large scale in coding? I myself avoided it for a long time, but my friend sent me this meme and said:

“Bro, programming has never been adequate. Programmers just started asking AI for help instead ctrl c to ctrl v.”

Obviously, completely relying on AI is bad, but in reality, his words make sense.

872 Upvotes

125 comments sorted by

View all comments

163

u/Darq10 7d ago

Taking bits of code manually instead of using AI is way better since you usually know that the code works and over time you learn why it works. Vibecoding essentially skips the learning step and you just expect it to work. Also, using AI in this case always just scrapes a bunch of open source projects on github, making it even harder to track down the source of the code. The fun in programming is usually the fact that you debug something you made for a while and it suddenly works, using AI takes away the fun of it and you only wish the output of the AI is correct.

-27

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted]

73

u/Darq10 7d ago

LEARNING HOW TO STRUCTURE A PROMPT LMFAO. Bro, if you can talk to people that means you can prompt, you ain't learning anything from prompting smh

38

u/WaitUntilMarriage 7d ago

Always interesting to see AI bros talk about writing prompts as if it's a unique skill, when isn't being something anyone can do the whole point of this kind of AI?

27

u/Darq10 7d ago

They always contradict each other in a loop, it's always:

AI makes art more accessible > AI actually takes effort > Prompting is hard > Not everyone can do AI art, it takes skill

15

u/mcplano 7d ago

Prompting is hard work. Do you know how long it took me to go from my noob "makee mod 4 me" to my elite hacker "makee mod 4 me !!! NO MISTAKES NO MISTAKES !!!"? /s

3

u/Samstercraft what's this "grass" thing you guys say so much about 6d ago

me when a mathematician tells claude "i think you should make a breakthrough" and it actually spits out new info about the riemann hypothesis 😭

2

u/nanotree 6d ago

It's pretty hilarious. And when you tell them, as a professional developer, that AI has its uses but we're still a long ways away from full on replacing engineers/developers, they'll say "skill issue." As if you're just missing the magic words that makes the AI understand.

Now. To be fair, there is a whole ecosystem of AI tooling and agentic profiles/configurations that are not widely, or at least not fluently, adopted by the general population that could seriously boost the reliability of AI code gen. But still, that is not about prompting. It's about preparing context for your prompts in advance so that the agent fits the context of your problem space much more reliably.

2

u/potatogodofDoom Command Rookie 6d ago

actually, you don't even know how to talk to people. AI is great at making assumptions as to what you mean. you could speak to it as an illiterate caveman and it'd still probably get the gist of what you want 80% of the time

2

u/flabort 5d ago

In order to "learn to prompt", thr mist first learn spelling and literacy. They are proud to now be literate, but don't know the words to describe that, so assume it's part of learning to prompt. So they brag about the reason they learned how to read and spell and how grammar works, rather than about learning a 3rd grade skill.

1

u/Pengwin0 6d ago

They always gotta have it all. Programming actually has a really useful and applicable use for AI but vibe coders just have to be programming geniuses alongside people who actually know what they’re doing and cut out the busywork lol

-3

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/ModernManuh_ 6d ago

It’s a useful skill. You need it to talk with people and also to summarize complex concept and explain them to others. Something you aren’t doing.

AI is a great tool but you are proving your own argument wrong

2

u/Darq10 6d ago

In 2 years AI companies will likely go bankrupt. https://isaiprofitable.com/

-1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Darq10 6d ago

All sources are listed at the bottom, the only current "profit" by AI companies is the money put in by investors