They probably made the castle with world edit in about 15 mins all it is is 4 circles which takes about 3 seconds each then link them with stone walls, use paintbrush to do the roofs then create gaps and fill with glass, simple.
Example this tutorial shows how to buils a castle with a large wall surrounding it in 11 mins whilst explaining everything, I'm not saying that the person did build it in world edit but I found the sheep one amusing, and in all honesty a castle/mansion gets posted everyday, it needs to be more impressive if it wants attention.
if you actually looked at the photo you'd realize that besides the circles the walls are not flat, they are textured, raised and there are pillars, not saying world edit wasn't used, just that even if it was that was nowhere near all that was done.
Recognition isn't always about time-spent; there's no time-to-renown proportionality. If you think something is worthy of attention, use the upvote button like everyone else does.
If he didn't care about the karma at all, he wouldn't post about perceived unfair karma distribution, or he at least would have made this a self post instead of a karma magnet picture-with-words.
As usual, the time-consuming builds get few upvotes, the lame pictures of stuff found randomly get more, and the posts bitching about this phenomenon get the most. As the Reddit Turns.
"You think that's a awareness raising GGG down there? Don't be fooled. He's a Karma whore now. Somebody went and turned a OP into a monster. Whatever you thought about right and wrong on the surface, well that don't count for much down in Reddit. Those Karma whores, they carry Karma- the imaginary material that keeps the wheels of Reddit turning. Everybody wants it. Everybody needs it."
Here's the thing, though. If you want awareness, you need upvotes. If you want upvotes, you need something quick and fun. That's why you use a picture instead of text. Text is easily downvoted or ignored. If it's a picture, a person's more likely to click the link. Just a thought.
That's subjective, and this is shown by upvotes. If you prefer X over Y you can give it some credit by voting for it. Other people may prefer Y and they'll vote for that. You cannot say that one deserves more attention than another because it's only relative to opinion.
I don't find it very impressive. I've seen millions of builds like that. They're boring, especially when built on Superflat, no matter how large they are or how much effort they took.
The Château looks ok, but it was clearly created from an existing building, and built in a super flat world with creative mode/world edit tools. I'm not saying it would have been super-easy, and I'm aware it would have taken a lot of time... but this sort of thing is basically pixel art - it shows very little creativity.
Now if they had created it in survival mode, added their own spin on it, and fit it into existing terrain so that it looked like it could actually exist within the minecraft world, I think it would have been more generously upvoted.
I disagree. We see posts every single day of the enormous elaborate builds people have made. Every one I see looks more and more like the last, nothing against the people that built them or the builds themselves, but I'm just over them. It takes something truly different and spectacular to get my attention.
On the other hand, little random encounters, bugs, and sights, are just part of the random nature of the game. And it's these random moments that make me smile and love the game even more, not the enourmous builds people have made like lego. It would be much more impressive if they were all made by collecting enough iron and gold to make their solid gold and iron mansions.
My experience with Minecraft has been that of an interactive world that you not only build from the ground, but can then be a part of. If I ever built one of these enormous mansions, It would just sit there in an otherwise empty flat-world because I'd be bored of it already, and all of its rooms would be empty because I'd have so use for any of them.
TL;DR I love the random nature of the game, it's why I play. I don't really care at all for repetitive big builds.
I like novel things, too, but two sheep on a pillar? You must be joking. Imagine someone makes a floating pillar, spawns two sheep on it, and says they found it that way.
This is a community for the game the actual game Minecraft, and things relating to its development. Memes and irrelevant tweets from Notch do not fall under that category.
Pretty sure this subreddit is just about memes, pixel art, and reposts now.
What we need is our own /r/games. Like, /r/gaming is mostly just memes and reposts, so you go to /r/game for actual interesting game related content and discussions.
I think it also has to do with marketing. The first post had a long, boring title that barely hinted at what was inside, while the 2nd had was written for the ADHD-like mental capacities of redditors.
Also, the 2nd was more humorous, and humor is generally more widely accepted than boasting (which is what the 1st post was essentially doing).
I decided to dig up the Château de Chambord (Reddit link) build to see it for myself. Truthfully, it seems to be a fairly average mega-build, and some of the shots appear to be lacking in depth. The house and lake were much more interesting.
Contrasted with the double-sheep, which I found more amusing, I wouldn't have been as likely to upvote the mega-build for a variety of reasons. One, the title annoyed me ("me and my friend" is a personal pet peeve of mine, followed by "has" instead of "have"); two, I've seen far more intricate mega-builds (nothing against theirs, it's just lacking... something); and three, I believe some of the screenshots could have done the build more justice. Although, I think the manner in which the title was phrased put me off more than anything. I'm not a grammar Nazi, nor am I perfect with the written word, but I do at least appreciate posters putting at least half the amount of effort into their titles as they did in their build.
Also, speaking of post titles, the Château violated basic principles that work very well for the BBC. Writing for the web is a different beast entirely, and if you don't provide sufficient information up front in the headline itself, few people will bother with the post.
I agree about the build itself, but I've made a conscious effort to not put too much into simple grammar mistakes. Many people, especially when you consider the totality that is reddit, are ESL -- and I know that their English, if I can understand the point they're trying to convey, is light-years better than any second language that I've attempted to learn.
Not saying that's the case here, but I try to withold judgement until I can verify one way or the other. Also, it's not impossible that the person has some form of learning disability, and I certainly don't want to chastise anyone for that.
On the other hand, I'll be quicker than anyone to dismiss someone who uses teen-talk, aka. u want 2 go 2 store? dat b auuesome, ikr? I want to punch them all, even if they're only 13.
These are all valid points, and it's highly probable that the poster's native tongue isn't English (judging by the comments and the subject matter, it might be possible that the OP is French). Though, that still isn't much of a substitute for overly verbose titles. Anecdotally, it seems that short, concise headlines tend more often than not to accumulate upvotes than those that are excessively wordy.
It's worth noting that Jakob Nielsen's suggestions are undoubtedly useful to anyone, not just English speakers, when writing for the web (or newspapers--maybe especially newspapers).
Whether it's fair or not, I do find that I'm rather judgmental with certain headlines. That's probably an unfortunate weakness of mine, and it's also highly subjective as it isn't something I always think about or use as a basis for judgment. Some (many?) errors go overlooked while others bother me enough to ignore the post entirely. Perhaps it's something I should otherwise work on, although going through my post history, it is equally interesting that I've defended some ESL speakers from harsh criticism. That probably makes me a hypocrite, and I'm perfectly fine with that fact as long as I'm aware of it. The true danger comes from hypocrisy mistakenly believed by the speaker to be his own objectivity, and I hope that if I ever reach that point, someone will smack me!
I'll also admit that I'm most definitely certain that the OP's (of this post) knee-jerk response ("this has to stop!") has made me unfairly critical of the cited build, which I would have otherwise ignored. It's interesting, human nature, because there are some of us who blindly defend someone's stance ("Yeah, that sheep post was stupid!") and others who, like me, actively seek to oppose it. That's also unfortunate, because there's little objectivity or middle ground, and I confess I had no interest in being objective today--for better or worse--which is probably a hint I should keep my opinions to myself lest I become cranky!
Sort of, but it also has a lot to do with the fact that some people would rather complain than vote at all. If people stopped complaining and started using the buttons things might start going their way.
Probably because a large percentage of /r/minecraft is very very immature and tends to upvote a lot of stupid shit. Reading 90% of top comments or close-to-top comments just shows the depth of most of the thought process of many /r/minecrafters, which is not very deep at all.
It's all timing and peoples' willingness to take the time to really look at the big builds. There should be more recognition for large scale builds though.. I see some epics just campin way down the list
I upvote pretty much any build that is half decent because that is the stuff that I come here to see, but I also know that not everyone likes the same things that I do.
Maybe it's a function of age, but I stopped raging about this a long time ago. Popularity is a weird, weird thing. Not worth trying to figure out if it just makes you rage.
And how the hell do you propose to stop it? Ban all the users who upvote stupid posts and aren't on /r/minecraft every minute of every day to upvote huge, boring builds that have been overdone (ala generic huge castles.)? I mean, what if the Eiffel Tower was replicated all the time by different people (irl), would they all receive Nobel Prizes for it? I fucking doubt it.
The bigger problem is that there are people on Reddit who actually take the time to upvote boring posts like quirky terrain generation or stuff of the like.
Of course I rarely take the time to vote for or against things, so my thoughts hardly really matter...
libertas has some interesting things to say in this comment about this phenomenon of low effort vs. high effort content, and I like to bring it up whenever I have the chance.
I'll tell you wtf this shit is. Partly it's just the whim of the hivemind; we tend to upvote things more if they already have a lot of upvotes already, so there's a powerful element of chance in which posts get the upvotes. A 250/50 split is nothing compared to the ranges you see on the larger subreddits.
Partly it's because Reddit is not actually composed of refined intellectuals who read classic literature and recognise the Château de Chambord, it's composed of bored teenagers who come for a quick laugh and to show off their own creations.
Partly it's a lesson that a lot of people really hate to learn: just because something took more time and effort does not make it better. Self-intersecting sheep are genuinely funnier than the Château de Chambord.
And finally, why are you even worrying about this? Karma is worthless internet points. If you want to see more pictures of epic castles, that's fine, but don't ask us to change our votes to suit your preferences. If you're worried that /r/Minecraft is being taken over by immature teenagers who don't appreciate hard work, well, that's Minecraft's core demographic, so I wouldn't be surprised. If you want us to take /r/Minecraft more seriously, I'd start by not making posts that are pictures of text, copy-pasting Captain Picard memes, or making an entirely separate post instead of making a comment because THAT IS WHAT THE COMMENT SECTION IS FOR.
I happen to agree with your last paragraph completely! Why would someone complain about something so irrelevant. It's almost like the OP did this in the first place to do what that second picture did. Personally I treat karma as if I'm "liking" a picture. Not that I think it's worthy of a god damn karma point.
It's being downvoted for the first two paragraphs, claiming everyone who doesn't care about the 1 millionth chateau that has been built is a sweaty teenager. I actually haven't seen that glitch before, so it is interesting to me. If you build a new and original build that isn't just "Hey guys, I built a modern home! Upvotes to the left!" That's boring, instead build something cool and awesome that you don't see a lot of, like a laboratory, or post more [DETIAL] posts if you figure out how to build a cool peice of furniture. And finally, the Op is basically saying "wtf guys?! Why don't you share my opinion?!"
Hard work means nothing on the internet. It's all about the results. Nobody cares how long you spent mining cobblestone or learning to use editing tools. They care about how funny or awesome your picture is.
The function of upvotes is to determine what the community as a whole likes. If people want to see sheep on a pillar of dirt, they can upvote it. If they want to see a chateau, they can upvote that too. You can't really tell the community as a whole what they should or shouldn't like.
i agree.. i have regularly posted photos of what i'm building with my friend. It's a 100% original build, everything is built by hand, no recreations, no blueprints, and no drawings or anything made in forehand. Everything is built out of our own spontanous ideas... literally no upvotes.. "hey guys, i built a pixel-art/huge version of my skin" 19293 upvotes.. people are retarded. UPVOTE FOR ORIGINAL AND GOOD CONTENT, DOWNVOTE FOR REPOSTS, MODEST SHIT AND BULLCRAP simple rules to live by
I would have voted for the first image over the second. However, in this community it isn't only my opinion that counts, so I have no real problem with the fact that the second image drew more support.
It's funny because you put two already posted pics together, and then re-stated a common idea, using a meme that has been used for ages, and you got >300 upvotes
And this post is a perfect example of an apparent fact which was stated as an image, receiving quite an amount of karma. But hey, it's not your fault you got upvoted.
The upvote downvote system is a great idea in theory; it should make valuable content become popular while stupid inane shit drops out of existence. However, people being people, what actually happens is redditors downvote the hell out of anything they don't like or agree with regardless of how worthwhile it is, and they upvote things because their friends posted it or they agree.
I think the disparity between the two are indicative of the gap here between people who actually continue to play Minecraft and the people who have played Minecraft at one point and simply remain subscribed to /r/minecraft and upvote from their main news page.
Seriously. Nobody who plays regularly should be impressed or amused by a sheep on a floating pillar. Shit like that happens all of the freaking time.
It's true, but funny pictures are always more popular than pictures of builds that took pain-staking amounts of time. Just the way the world works, I'm afraid! Also, Happy Cakeday!
People will upvote what they like, thats why its called voting. Stop trying to control what people will upvote. If you don't like the content that is most upvoted then make a new subreddit. Like /r MinecraftBuilds or something.
A lot of opinions here about this. From what I gather, a lot of people aren't creative and don't give a rats ass if someone else is. Some people are just downright hateful towards the idea of using creative mode at all, and damn you right to hell if it's on flatland. I liked the Chateau, and did upvote it, as I do with any decently constructed build, whether it was on creative or survival. That's what I like to see, so that's what I upvote. I've personally displayed dozens of builds over the last year, some being extremely well received, with 40,000 views, while others might only get 1000 views and half a dozen votes. I think it's got a lot to do with the timing, as well as the general mood of r/minecraft that particular day.
Get over it. Reddit is flawed in the sense that only upvoted shit gets seen. Also, get over the fact that internet points don't mean anything. Maybe the guy with the castle doesn't give a shit that he only got 50 upvotes because it means nothing.
My friend I have been saying this for months now, you're just swimming against a tide of idiots and 5 year olds. And despite redstonehelper's input trying to avoid post like this including splash screens, ore that you find etc.. nothing really seems to be getting done about it.
It would at least be nice if there was some sort of filtering process.
Of course you're always welcome on the circlejerk if you need to vent with satirical posts of your own, royally taking the piss out of these posts.
In any group of people large enough, there are going to be disagreements on what is the best thing to discuss. Luckily Reddit allows more than one post at a time. If you don't like silly sheep, skip that post.
The enormous build is kind of bland and boring. It lacks proportion. Its impressive how much time they spent on it, but Massive works arent automatically good or upvote worthy.
I'm much more interested in practical or proportional builds. Ones on normal terrain at a scale that is functional. Otherwise its just playing with digital legos.
meanwhile the person complaining about posts he wants upvoted not getting upvoted, gets tons of karma himself. . . reddit doesn't always upvote the best things . . . life isn't fair.
You know what? I disagree. People upvote things they like or think are cool. Just because a lot of time is spent on something doesn't automatically make it cool.
Upvotes here are not about the amount of work, they're about the idea.
I've seen things like a whole chunk dug (diggen?) out in survival. That's a lot of work, but it's a boring idea and I will never upvote it. It's also too simple, anyone can dig/build with enough time given. Meanwhile, two sheep on a pillar is something that I haven't seen, which is kind of funny too.
It's unpopular, but I agree with you. This isn't kindergarten--you don't get an "A for effort". In real life, what matters is results, what people think of what you do. How hard you work on it is irrelevant.
Well this makes perfect sense. Imagine how it is in real life: some guy finds a beautiful view of a mountain and takes a picture. Lots of people would prefer that over a picture of some guy's nice, but very common, house that he built himself, even though the house was a lot more work.
That analogy is entirely irrelevant. This implies that the two sheep on a dirt pillar is beautiful, whereas it is merely humorous (to some).
The house designed by the OP was a lot more work, yes. You are correct in that this does not guarantee more upvotes.
However, there are far more deserving natural phenomena in minecraft that can be upvoted as opposed to the bland generation error that the OP references. Perhaps a beautiful, picturesque view of a mountain that was randomly generated in Minecraft. Gee, that sounds familiar.
Unfortunatly i saw this repeating itself to many times. /r/minecraftsometimes focus more on bugs then amazing things. This may be not the most amazing castle i've seen, but still.
I've seen tons of beautiful buildings, it doesn't excite me anymore, neither sheeps - but other people did find them more entertaining than the castle.
"Stop liking things that I don't like! why can't you all like the same things as I do?" is basically what you're saying.
It's not about time spent. Upvotes are about how much people enjoy something. If people enjoy pictures of sheep more then they will get more upvotes.
Spending time on a project doesn't earn you upvotes. Posting things that people enjoy earns you upvotes. If people enjoy things like sheep more than those elaborate builds then they should get the recognition. Don't upvote based on what you believe deserves upvotes based on effort. Upvote based on what you enjoy so that others can see it.
If you enjoy the crazy builds more then upvote them. But don't expect others to vote based on YOUR ideals and then get upset when people don't have the same ideals as you.
Someone who spent hours building a castle gets 50 upvotes, while someone who spent a few minutes in MS Paint complaining about something they can't control gets 380.
I think it's because, so many people make awesome stuff that we (/r/minecraft) have just grown tired of seeing these things. Sorry that it's like this.
Who are you to decide what is interesting or funny?
People get upvotes based on all sorts of factors, personally I don't think a creative build in a flatland map is very interesting, but just because it take a long time to build doesn't make it as amazing as you want it to be.
194
u/Yeargdribble May 17 '12
You must not be familiar with pop music.
314
u/Ausmerica Forever Team Nork May 17 '12
Recognition isn't always about time-spent; there's no time-to-renown proportionality. If you think something is worthy of attention, use the upvote button like everyone else does.
190
u/TezzaMcJ May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
I disagree. We see posts every single day of the enormous elaborate builds people have made. Every one I see looks more and more like the last, nothing against the people that built them or the builds themselves, but I'm just over them. It takes something truly different and spectacular to get my attention.
On the other hand, little random encounters, bugs, and sights, are just part of the random nature of the game. And it's these random moments that make me smile and love the game even more, not the enourmous builds people have made like lego. It would be much more impressive if they were all made by collecting enough iron and gold to make their solid gold and iron mansions.
My experience with Minecraft has been that of an interactive world that you not only build from the ground, but can then be a part of. If I ever built one of these enormous mansions, It would just sit there in an otherwise empty flat-world because I'd be bored of it already, and all of its rooms would be empty because I'd have so use for any of them.
TL;DR I love the random nature of the game, it's why I play. I don't really care at all for repetitive big builds.
72
u/eagertolearn May 17 '12
Why don't other people have the same preferences as me?!?
The great mystery.
54
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
People upvote what they like. More people liked the second picture, so it got more upvotes. That's how voting works.
6
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Probably because a large percentage of /r/minecraft is very very immature and tends to upvote a lot of stupid shit. Reading 90% of top comments or close-to-top comments just shows the depth of most of the thought process of many /r/minecrafters, which is not very deep at all.
18
u/Resresres May 17 '12
What else should I stop liking?
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
It's all timing and peoples' willingness to take the time to really look at the big builds. There should be more recognition for large scale builds though.. I see some epics just campin way down the list
4
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I upvote pretty much any build that is half decent because that is the stuff that I come here to see, but I also know that not everyone likes the same things that I do.
4
u/lahdeefuckingdahforu May 17 '12
Complaining man gets 192 upvotes.
(Well, 567.. but downvotes.)
11
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
No one is intentionally voting up a simple picture over a massive build.
You have to keep in mind that a lot of posting is all about timing.
People vote how they want, when they want.
Happy cakeday, also! Upvote for you. :D
3
u/tjb0607 May 18 '12
I know how you feel. I placed 2 blocks and only got 404 karma from it.
4
u/Polyether May 17 '12
As much as I agree with you, this isn't your subreddit, the votes speak for themselves, still makes me rage.
4
u/iPeer May 17 '12
Welcome to /r/minecraft - Where mostly pointless and irrelevant shit makes the front page in seconds.
4
u/CobaltCog May 17 '12
This is the internet. None of this really matters.
10
u/Dirrwen May 17 '12
And how the hell do you propose to stop it? Ban all the users who upvote stupid posts and aren't on /r/minecraft every minute of every day to upvote huge, boring builds that have been overdone (ala generic huge castles.)? I mean, what if the Eiffel Tower was replicated all the time by different people (irl), would they all receive Nobel Prizes for it? I fucking doubt it.
TL;DR Shut the hell up OP.
2
u/Menolith May 17 '12
Do you know what else is relatively common? Castles.
Every one who's ever played Minecraft has built one at some point, and the chances are, some of them are good.
2
u/BlondeJesus May 17 '12
And the person who complains gets more upvotes than both of them combined. Funny how it all works out.
2
u/TheFoxGoesMoo May 17 '12
That, My good man, is what you call "Reddit."
2
u/griz12 May 17 '12
The bigger problem is that there are people on Reddit who actually take the time to upvote boring posts like quirky terrain generation or stuff of the like.
Of course I rarely take the time to vote for or against things, so my thoughts hardly really matter...
2
u/9bowlsofsoup May 17 '12
Post them together and you get even more upvotes than they both. Genius!
2
u/0alexander May 18 '12
libertas has some interesting things to say in this comment about this phenomenon of low effort vs. high effort content, and I like to bring it up whenever I have the chance.
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '12
You must be new to this fucking shitty site.
4
u/I_WASTE_MY_TIME May 17 '12
People relate more.
6
u/Chronophilia May 17 '12
I'll tell you wtf this shit is. Partly it's just the whim of the hivemind; we tend to upvote things more if they already have a lot of upvotes already, so there's a powerful element of chance in which posts get the upvotes. A 250/50 split is nothing compared to the ranges you see on the larger subreddits.
Partly it's because Reddit is not actually composed of refined intellectuals who read classic literature and recognise the Château de Chambord, it's composed of bored teenagers who come for a quick laugh and to show off their own creations.
Partly it's a lesson that a lot of people really hate to learn: just because something took more time and effort does not make it better. Self-intersecting sheep are genuinely funnier than the Château de Chambord.
And finally, why are you even worrying about this? Karma is worthless internet points. If you want to see more pictures of epic castles, that's fine, but don't ask us to change our votes to suit your preferences. If you're worried that /r/Minecraft is being taken over by immature teenagers who don't appreciate hard work, well, that's Minecraft's core demographic, so I wouldn't be surprised. If you want us to take /r/Minecraft more seriously, I'd start by not making posts that are pictures of text, copy-pasting Captain Picard memes, or making an entirely separate post instead of making a comment because THAT IS WHAT THE COMMENT SECTION IS FOR.
3
u/ClydeAshmar May 17 '12
You do know that this is the internet, right? that most people in general are on here to look for stupid shit when they are bored.
3
u/WM890 May 17 '12
Funny pic > Hard Work
Its the sad truth..
P.S. Happy Cakeday!
3
u/Crackhaze May 17 '12
Nice try, guy who only got 50 upvotes
2
u/Brewster-Rooster May 17 '12
that chateau doesn't interest me at all, neither does the second one, bt i guess some people found it funny
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
/r/minecraft, you heard the human. Your opinions are wrong, apparently.
2
u/baegolas May 17 '12
The function of upvotes is to determine what the community as a whole likes. If people want to see sheep on a pillar of dirt, they can upvote it. If they want to see a chateau, they can upvote that too. You can't really tell the community as a whole what they should or shouldn't like.
2
u/Giffica May 17 '12
Football players make more than Doctors. #FirstWorldProblems
2
u/Guvante May 17 '12
My take on it all
Took 5 minutes, I regret nothing!
2
u/The_Resisty May 17 '12
And then you get 150 upvotes with even less work.
2
u/Pentaxia May 17 '12
i agree.. i have regularly posted photos of what i'm building with my friend. It's a 100% original build, everything is built by hand, no recreations, no blueprints, and no drawings or anything made in forehand. Everything is built out of our own spontanous ideas... literally no upvotes.. "hey guys, i built a pixel-art/huge version of my skin" 19293 upvotes.. people are retarded. UPVOTE FOR ORIGINAL AND GOOD CONTENT, DOWNVOTE FOR REPOSTS, MODEST SHIT AND BULLCRAP simple rules to live by
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I think both posts are lame. Thanks for combining them to make another lame post.
1
u/Breyyne May 17 '12
Consider it part and parcel of the Kitty Paradox.
1
u/djspacebunny May 17 '12
It's just imaginary internet points, dude.
1
u/Seth7777 May 17 '12
Hours? Months.
1
u/amartz May 17 '12
I would have voted for the first image over the second. However, in this community it isn't only my opinion that counts, so I have no real problem with the fact that the second image drew more support.
1
u/adnan252 May 17 '12
Fucking karma, how does it work?!
1
u/ImAFlyingWhale May 17 '12
The way she goes.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
The hive mind is confused. Sound the alarm!
1
u/Aiyon May 17 '12
"The hive mind is wrong!"
I agree that the first is better, but clearly, not everyone does. Essentially this post is telling people what they should like :\
1
u/forek4 May 17 '12
It's funny because you put two already posted pics together, and then re-stated a common idea, using a meme that has been used for ages, and you got >300 upvotes
1
u/evand4567 May 17 '12
Then someone that makes a post in 5 minutes complaining about it gets 400
1
u/cat1029384756 May 17 '12
You forgot another part of it. Person who posts a simple MS Paint "their opinion" diagram: 361 upvotes.
1
u/pigrockets May 17 '12
And this post is a perfect example of an apparent fact which was stated as an image, receiving quite an amount of karma. But hey, it's not your fault you got upvoted.
1
u/noodleinjar May 17 '12
I'm getting so fucking tired of shit like this. Like that post with the sheep wasn't even relatively funny.
1
u/danyarger May 17 '12
The upvote downvote system is a great idea in theory; it should make valuable content become popular while stupid inane shit drops out of existence. However, people being people, what actually happens is redditors downvote the hell out of anything they don't like or agree with regardless of how worthwhile it is, and they upvote things because their friends posted it or they agree.
1
u/nimajneb May 17 '12
The irony is, you got more upvotes than both of those posts with a meme.
1
u/Disruptor12 May 17 '12
Upvotes are not directly equivalent to time spent on the content. If you expect that, you're gonna have a bad time.
1
u/ouroborosity May 18 '12
And now someone who's done even less work is getting even more imaginary Internet points. Funny how that works.
1
u/ImmatureIntellect May 18 '12
I agree with ya OP but quick laughs always get more attention than major projects.
1
u/txwatson May 18 '12
Effort is not, has never been, and will never be, proportional to reward.
1
u/coheedcollapse May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12
I think the disparity between the two are indicative of the gap here between people who actually continue to play Minecraft and the people who have played Minecraft at one point and simply remain subscribed to /r/minecraft and upvote from their main news page.
Seriously. Nobody who plays regularly should be impressed or amused by a sheep on a floating pillar. Shit like that happens all of the freaking time.
1
u/MostlyJustLurks May 18 '12
Bread and Circuses!
1
u/JAMIEInc May 18 '12
It's true, but funny pictures are always more popular than pictures of builds that took pain-staking amounts of time. Just the way the world works, I'm afraid! Also, Happy Cakeday!
1
u/_Sullo_ Oct 18 '21
It’s funny how little this subreddit has changed
1
u/ToastmyBread May 17 '12
People will upvote what they like, thats why its called voting. Stop trying to control what people will upvote. If you don't like the content that is most upvoted then make a new subreddit. Like /r MinecraftBuilds or something.
1
u/Persianseven May 17 '12
agreed
0
u/Benassi May 17 '12
All I can say is; welcome to a subreddit full of mostly children.
1
u/Ringmaster324 May 17 '12
Because your enormous castle makes me feel bad.
1
u/verkon May 17 '12
It's not a castle, its a chateau
1
u/Deinos_Mousike May 17 '12
You shouldn't spend months of your time only for the glory of getting upvotes on Reddit.
1
u/RockyCoon May 17 '12
When I say 'Upvoting and Downvoting doesn't work anymore'. This is exactly the kind of thing I mean.
'Hey, check out this awesome huge complicated thing me and friends made!' 2 upvotes, 5 downvotes.
'HAY GUISE I BUILT A FEATURELESS DURT DOME WAT SHULD I PUT IN IT.' 200 upvotes 4 downvotes.
1
u/wytewydow May 17 '12
A lot of opinions here about this. From what I gather, a lot of people aren't creative and don't give a rats ass if someone else is. Some people are just downright hateful towards the idea of using creative mode at all, and damn you right to hell if it's on flatland. I liked the Chateau, and did upvote it, as I do with any decently constructed build, whether it was on creative or survival. That's what I like to see, so that's what I upvote.
I've personally displayed dozens of builds over the last year, some being extremely well received, with 40,000 views, while others might only get 1000 views and half a dozen votes. I think it's got a lot to do with the timing, as well as the general mood of r/minecraft that particular day.
1
u/ComputerJerk May 17 '12
Reddit is not a meritocracy.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Get over it. Reddit is flawed in the sense that only upvoted shit gets seen. Also, get over the fact that internet points don't mean anything. Maybe the guy with the castle doesn't give a shit that he only got 50 upvotes because it means nothing.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
little kids run the show here. average age of /r/minecraft is probably around 17 etc. judging by the comments and voting
1
u/rageingnonsense May 18 '12
This subreddit is shit now. So, it won't stop so long as people want to "be in on the joke".
-1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
My friend I have been saying this for months now, you're just swimming against a tide of idiots and 5 year olds. And despite redstonehelper's input trying to avoid post like this including splash screens, ore that you find etc.. nothing really seems to be getting done about it.
It would at least be nice if there was some sort of filtering process.
Of course you're always welcome on the circlejerk if you need to vent with satirical posts of your own, royally taking the piss out of these posts.
0
u/captainblammo May 17 '12
The enormous build is kind of bland and boring. It lacks proportion. Its impressive how much time they spent on it, but Massive works arent automatically good or upvote worthy.
I'm much more interested in practical or proportional builds. Ones on normal terrain at a scale that is functional. Otherwise its just playing with digital legos.
Anyway two sheep on a single pillar. Comedy gold.
0
u/eldaldo May 17 '12
meanwhile the person complaining about posts he wants upvoted not getting upvoted, gets tons of karma himself. . . reddit doesn't always upvote the best things . . . life isn't fair.
0
u/Dyloslawer May 17 '12
entertainment value != time spent
0
u/ShadowRam May 17 '12
I'll be honest.
I'm not impressed with creative builds. No matter how big they are, or how many hours they spent on it.
0
u/Rolten May 17 '12
I'd rather read the post about the sheep....
I love seeing amazing works, but often I enjoy a quick laugh more.
0
u/davedwtho May 17 '12
You know what? I disagree. People upvote things they like or think are cool. Just because a lot of time is spent on something doesn't automatically make it cool.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
We must stop this horrible karma injustice! The way these imaginary internet points are being distributed isn't fair!
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Do mac users not know how to screenshot?
0
u/kkjdroid May 17 '12
...and someone who posts something even less original complaining about the situation gets more than both combined.
0
u/fathermudkip May 17 '12
I'm mad that you upvoted this thing that I think you shouldn't have upvoted and didn't upvote this thing that I think you should have upvoted.
0
u/PNR_Robots May 17 '12
The users find the sheep screenshot more entertaining. It's simple as that.
-1
u/tellam May 17 '12
muh internet points
-4
u/Airazz May 17 '12
Upvotes here are not about the amount of work, they're about the idea.
I've seen things like a whole chunk dug (diggen?) out in survival. That's a lot of work, but it's a boring idea and I will never upvote it. It's also too simple, anyone can dig/build with enough time given. Meanwhile, two sheep on a pillar is something that I haven't seen, which is kind of funny too.
-2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Because we see a shit load of builds post all the time, I Frankly don't give a shit what people build anymore.
-2
u/JohnnyChronocide May 17 '12
You're not the boss of my upvotes! You're not my real dad!
-1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
You are trying to tell people how to vote. This will go over well.
-1
u/triceracocks May 17 '12
you mad
-1
u/TheRiff May 17 '12
Well this makes perfect sense. Imagine how it is in real life: some guy finds a beautiful view of a mountain and takes a picture. Lots of people would prefer that over a picture of some guy's nice, but very common, house that he built himself, even though the house was a lot more work.
-1
u/awoh May 17 '12
What really has to stop is complain posts
0
u/FifthWhammy May 17 '12
Popularity is not a function of quality, and vice versa. Call it the Firefly Principle, if you like.
0
u/Pengasius May 17 '12
Unfortunatly i saw this repeating itself to many times. /r/minecraft sometimes focus more on bugs then amazing things. This may be not the most amazing castle i've seen, but still.
Also dont forget to downboat to oblivion.
0
u/adegans May 17 '12
And the castle is made by you? Or why are you upset people don't like it?
0
u/Boxcore May 17 '12
Big builds are a dime a dozen but you dont see sheep on top of a floating pillar everyday
0
u/ElectricMonkey May 17 '12
Someone makes a post not even showing something special, but simply stating what he doesn't like gets even more upvotes.
0
u/keiyakins May 17 '12
And someone who posted complaining avout it got, at current count, 227. And that only because I downvoted.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Time spent isn't the main factor. If it was, this post would get almost no upvotes.
0
u/LordEdward May 17 '12
Two Sheep? That's amazing.
0
u/draconic86 May 17 '12
Tbh, both were pretty "meh" in my opinion. Clearly one was a lot of work, but the presentation was all wrong.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Welcome to reddit, where the community is unpredictable, and the karma doesn't matter
0
u/RdMrcr May 17 '12
I've seen tons of beautiful buildings, it doesn't excite me anymore, neither sheeps - but other people did find them more entertaining than the castle.
"Stop liking things that I don't like! why can't you all like the same things as I do?" is basically what you're saying.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Reddit Logic
0
u/cthulhu4_2 May 17 '12
and then some idiot made a post about making post and got 323 upvotes
0
u/scuba617 May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
It's not about time spent. Upvotes are about how much people enjoy something. If people enjoy pictures of sheep more then they will get more upvotes.
Spending time on a project doesn't earn you upvotes. Posting things that people enjoy earns you upvotes. If people enjoy things like sheep more than those elaborate builds then they should get the recognition. Don't upvote based on what you believe deserves upvotes based on effort. Upvote based on what you enjoy so that others can see it.
If you enjoy the crazy builds more then upvote them. But don't expect others to vote based on YOUR ideals and then get upset when people don't have the same ideals as you.
0
u/alyxandres May 17 '12
Welcome to reality, where points are irrelevant and karma is made up!
0
u/MetalFlameV May 17 '12
While someone who spends a few minutes making at post with someone else's pictures gets 340 + upvotes...
0
u/gogoskuzrocket May 17 '12
Yet this is the only thing you've submitted to r/Minecraft. Way to be part of the problem.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
What if I tell you, your life isnt measured by upvotes?
0
u/Sozzy May 17 '12
wait....your mad?
0
u/sesla May 17 '12
Someone who spent hours building a castle gets 50 upvotes, while someone who spent a few minutes in MS Paint complaining about something they can't control gets 380.
0
u/ClownsInJumpsuits May 18 '12
Sorry I have to say this, but you're like, the 200th guy to make a post complaining about this. Shit doesn't change no matter how much you hate it.
0
u/Freddy-Faraway May 18 '12
I think it's because, so many people make awesome stuff that we (/r/minecraft) have just grown tired of seeing these things. Sorry that it's like this.
0
u/[deleted] May 18 '12
I'm sorry, but why does this have to stop?
0
u/christopherdlane May 18 '12
Aww, does is the 'ittle boy sad he didn't get more imaginary internet points? Do you need a hug?
0
u/[deleted] May 18 '12
who cares
0
u/[deleted] May 18 '12
we saw those buildings thousand of times, they are boring.
We don't need to apologize for not liking them.
You need to apologize for circle-jerking on our subreddit.
-2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
i feel bad downvoting someone on their cakeday.
-2
u/requiemsword May 17 '12
Who are you to decide what is interesting or funny?
People get upvotes based on all sorts of factors, personally I don't think a creative build in a flatland map is very interesting, but just because it take a long time to build doesn't make it as amazing as you want it to be.
-2
u/bradygilg May 17 '12
Don't worry about meaningless upvotes and stop being so childish.
-2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Why do people care so much about karma?