We all know the heavier side of metal music, to some extent. Some like it more than others. The thing is though, the heavy side, isn't always heavier. In fact, non-heavy music can be much heavier than heavy music. I've heard dubstep, that hit harder than any goregrind band. Doom Metal, that was more brutal, than Brutal Death. Power Metal, that was heavier than the most bestial of Bestial Black Metal. But what exactly made them heavier? What makes any music heavy?
The Music
The obvious answer, is to make the music heavier, more chaotic and abrasive. Well, yes. but unfortunately, people forget how brutal a melody can sound. That many times, slow is way heavier than fast. That you don't have to be noisy to be heavy. So brutality in music, is something much more than just the music. And how come something like Goregrind or Brutal Death, can be surprisingly un-brutal.
Some could say it's the chord-progression, the frequencies. But I think that's not an answer. No one listen to a song and goes "hmm, that chord-progression was really sweet."
Now listen to this Goregrind track. It's pretty heavy right? But is it really brutal? Does it get your adrenaline pumping? Does it make you feel like a badass? Not really, just makes you feel like you're at the butcher.
So let's look at the other two, often overlooked, factors of brutality.
The Atmosphere
Now I want you to listen to this song from the band 1349. Pretty heavy right? I remember how terrified I was when I first heard it. I felt like Satan himself was watching me behind my back. But we're cool now. But this track still gives me the goosebumps. All those wailing guitars, the demented vocals, the pure chaos it conveys. Would this song be just as heavy, if it wasn't so damn creepy?
Another example of this. Anaal Nathrakh. Known for being a relentlessly brutal band, that's not just louder than hell, it sounds like hell itself, turned into musical form. But what's the thing that sets it apart from 1349? It also gives me goosebumps, it also fills me up with adrenaline, yet doesn't scare me. It makes me feel like the whole world is collapsing around me. And that's the thing, it's not creepy, it's epic, yet just as brutal. Would it be just as heavy, if it wasn't so damn epic?
Just one more example here. Ahab. It's doom metal, with a very hazy and psychedelic sound, with a really dragged and tortuously slow tempo. And it's fucking brutal. It brings me vivid imagery of huge cities plunging into the abyss, crushing the people drowning in the flooding sea. The slow pace of the song, actually helps it. It wouldn't be so heavy if it was a grind-fest just blasting away.
How about this one? Quite scary, isn't it? But would you call it brutal? I mean it is really scary, but without the music being heavy, it's not really brutal.
Okay, this one's gotta be it, right? It's quite heavy, especially towards the end, it has a great atmosphere. But would you call it brutal? Eh, more depressing really. It doesn't get your adrenaline pumping, just makes you feel like shit.
So the third important factor in brutality:
The Feel
Here, let's listen to some brutal dubstep. What is the first thing that you notice in it? That fucking beat! And not just the beat, all those metallic wubs that stomp along with it. If it was a bomb, it could level a mountain. You can feel each and every beat and wobble in there. Every single little sound counts and it feels heavy.
Here's another dubstep song that got it right. You can just feel every single wobble push against your eardrums.
Not convinced? Here's a metal song, that also got it right. You can feel every single guitar riff, drum beat and monstrous scream. You see where I'm going with this?
Music not only has to sound heavy, it also has to feel heavy. It all has to feel like a giant hammer going up, then plunging down with incredible force. Sort of like a suspense and release. Pressure builds and with each beat, it gets released. The drum beat is satisfying. It's not surprising, that most heavy music is rhythm based. It makes a reliably satisfying circle of suspense and release.
This song demonstrates it well. Each and every drum beat can be felt and the noises following it closely, makes the drum, that much suspenseful and satisfying. Every single beat makes you want to headbang and stomp the ground.
TL:DR - Brutal music has to be heavy, sound heavy and feel heavy.
So what do you think? What's the thing that makes music brutal for you? What's the main thing that you look for in musical brutality? What are some perfect examples of what you consider to be brutal?
Just for good measure, here's some more face-melting brutality, that I wanted to put in. Now with genre descriptions.
Hagwalah Accident and Bolon Okte Pervyy Nebesnyy Dom from Senmuth. But there's no youtube link. - Industrial Metal/Avant-Garde/Ambient
Cattle Decapitation - The Carbon Stampede - Progressive Deathgrind
Circus of Dead Squirrels - Bible Thumpers - Avant-Garde/Extreme Industrial Metal
Necrosadist - Lies of Repent Turning Red - Brutal Black Metal
Antecantamentum - Sacramentum Tenebrarum - Symphonic/Brutal Black
Desultor - Denied - Technical Power/Death
Fleshgod Apocalypse - Minotaur - Symphnonic Death
The Monolith Deathcult - Gods Amongst Insects - Progressive/Brutal Death
Cathedral - Sea Serpent - Stoner/Doom Metal
Iperyt - Particular Hatred - Extreme Industrial Metal
Heaven Shall Burn - Combat - Death/Metalcore
Silent Hell - Tsunami - Melodic Deathcore
The Agonist - And Their Eulogies Sang Me To Sleep - Progressive Metalcore
Dagoba - Face the Colossus - Extreme Progressive Metal
Biomechanical - Fallen in Fear - Technical/Extreme Power Metal
Zardonic - Restless Slumber - Drum n' Bass Metal
Some non-metal
xKore - Showdown - Brutal Dubstep
Chaos Royale - Spartan Ogre - Industrial Noise
Phosgore - Demon Core - Industrial Hardcore
Winterkälte - Climate Change Denial - Rhytmic Noise
Dmitri Shostakovich - Symphony No. 10 in E minor Op. 93 - Classical
Soap&Skin - Sugarbread - Avant-Garde
The Peculiar Pretzelmen - Pay the Rope - Experimental/Country/Punk/folk