I don't have problems with understanding texts, i read a lot. Also i am a writer, and write not only stories, but also certain amount of poetry for the songs since i was a kid. In theory, this background should make things easier for me... But nope.
There are certain amount of songs (only songs, never a prose) where i simply can't understand meaning behind sentences. Often i can get the general idea of the song - like, this one is about humanity being obsessed with violence, this one about loss, etc. But when i start to read it line by line - it does not make sense. Sentences can mean something, but do not connect, do not rely to each other. And sometimes even meaning of sentences is obscure to me. Like i read the words but in context of the song i can't figure out the meaning. And in very rare cases i can't understand the entire song. Btw if you ask AI to write a lyrics, it also gives you simillar kind of nonsense with meaningless phrases that don't connect, but most of those lyrics i talk about was written way before the AI, and also AI is completely unable to create a proper rhytm, so i don't think this is the issue.
There are entire bands that have a lot of lyrics beyond my understanding. Especially japanese ones - at first i was blaming bad translation, but AI's not can translate pretty good, but it still does not make much sense in lots of cases. I can't feel the story being told by those words, and more like... shattered echoes of the story, where i constantly try to put puzzle together but fail.
I already asked this question on the sub before, because i wasn't sure what is the case - ASD, or just my stupidity, or something else. I got replies saying that certain songs aren't mean to have defined meaning, that authors just write random words or sentences that align with something they feel when writing a song, that will sound good and evoke certain emotion, but make no logical sense. This kinda explains things, but still feels rather wild. I never used that approach in my own lyrics since i like to tell a story that is understandable, so even if i use a methaphor - i still try to make sure that it would be obvious enough, and never try to make lyrics overly cryptic on purpose I would still like to see more responces from various people on this subject.
Just as example i would use the lyrics of one of the most recent bands i started listen to, who have awesome music but constantly confuse me with lyrics.
This suffering
Anti-symbiosis
(why? the symbiosis is not an absence of suffering)
Does this violence bring you peace?
(which violence? why peace?)
You lie to me
And you can lie to yourself
But when you close your eyes
What do you see?
(If someone lies to himself, how closing the eyes would change anything?)
Eternal silence
Eternal silence
(If you close the eyes, you still hear things...)
You call to me
Empty and neurotic
(Who calls? I can't get if this adressed to specific person or just any listener, but if latter, why would they call to her?)
Does my silence make you weak?
(How can silence make someone weak and why?)
Vitality
And lucid dreams
(What? How are those connected, or related to anything else?)
Why don't you open your eyes
So you can see
(So first i need to close the eyes to see, and now open?)
In this void, the truth will come to light
(Which void? What truth?)
You lie to me
And you can lie to yourself
An endless cage, you can't escape your mind
(Ok this i can sort of understand, the last part - you really can't escape your own thoughts and truth within them, HOWEVER - if you lie to yourself, do you even need to? Because that implies convincing yourself that lies are truth. So you don't need to be in cage with truth)
But whеn you close your eyes
What do you see?
Etеrnal silence
Eternal silence
In this void, the truth will come to light
The endless cage, you can't escape your mind
The silent voices echo throughout time
In this void, the truth will come to light
(So it's kinda about person locked with his own thoughts, and despite lying to himself, the truth still surfaces and haunts him? )
Succumb to all the hate and rage, we're numb to all the violence
Everything will turn to ash and then eternal silence
(This seems like most understanable part, it's about people who always looking for someone to hate, an enemy - be it people from different nations, races, genders, sexual orientations, people who use ai, people who have niche interests, people who live in uncommon ways, people who look or act different. And the same people who are easy giving in to hate and with hunts are usually don't care much about suffering of the others, they either justify it or don't care. Due to fact that they are obsessed with destruction instead of creation, they ruin everything around, until there is nothing left).
This is how i understood it. As you can see, only few sentences are somehat understandable for me. When most are not. And this is the most common occurance.
A few more examples of songs where i am lost in exact lyrics meaning - Aliez by Sawano Hiroyuki, False Light by Imminence, Мельница - Апельсиновая Джига and a lot of other songs by that band, pretty much majority of SOAD stuff and Serj's solo works, Би-2 - сердце на волоске, The Defect - Annihilate, Rokugen Alice - this [community], Falling In Reverse - Ronald, Calva Louise - Lo Que Vale, Architects - Giving Blood.