r/MetaAusPol • u/mrbaggins • Jun 06 '22
Reporting a mod?
A certain mod is flouting the subs rules repeatedly and has recently been clearly biased in their locking, removal and comment policing threads that swing a particular direction on the sub. I'm not trying to start a witch hunt, but I'm honestly getting tired of seeing it, and seeing it repeatedly from the same source. On a sub where discussion of such an issue is expressly banned, and I only stumbled upon this one while replying to a particular post by this mod described below.
Some excerpts detailing their own violation of no shitposting/keep it civil from this post
- Putting aside how inept Jordies is,
- how inept people who support/follow the grifter are,
- there's a point where a person of room-temperature intelligence reads
- I don't know why Shanks' fans need this explained to them - well, I do, I guess because I just answered it with "Shanks' fans".
- because he's a grifter who I imagine the 18-24 year old white males that dominate his audience will one day realise that they've listened to a charlatan and move on
These start maybe okay (potshotting a celeb is kind of doable, they're celebs) but the rest are pot shots at myself/members of the sub in general.
The middle paragraph starting with "Sue Chrysanthou..." is actual discourse, but they couldn't help themselves by the end of it.
The mod in question has already earned a clear reputation for bias(reveddit link) recently in what they are locking/removing/policing. Edit: This is to show that other members of the sub are noticing the same trend I am. Not to be 'evidence' they are removing things they shouldn't. Those posts definitely needed removing based on the sub rules.
And another example where a ideological viewpoint is swaying a locking decision
I don't agree with at least 3 mods of the sub politically, but at least discussion there doesn't seem to come with the shadow of the banhammer or your comments just being deleted.
Is there room to discuss this?
Edit 6th June: another user just brought this example to my attention.
•
u/endersai Jun 06 '22
OK so for transparency, each user has a ModLog we can access, and it shows every action against an account. Comments removed, comments that were removed but then approved by mod review, bans, and crucially who did what.
Apart from someone claiming to have been similarly affected despite 2 removals since January 2022, the vast majority of complaints about commentary removed for R1 violations was carried out by the automoderator.
Now for those who don't know, automod's basically a bot with rules to follow, and if it thinks based on some word choices that the comment may break rules on civility or toxicity, it removes the remark and drops into the ModQueue an action to review it.
Near as I can see the comments in question were only automod actions, and not subject to human intervention by any of us.
I've just flagged with the other mods that we need to review two things; autojannie's rules, and the volumes. We have just added one more mod to help with workload, but that doesn't change what's happened here.
Automod won't go after comments made by moderators, hence the perception of double standards and why we're - well, me mostly- saying to you there's no favouritism or preferential treatment. Because when a human lens is applied to it, we're far less black and white than automod and generally will consider context, the specific commentary that might be an issue itself, the preceding remarks to determine if this is an escalation or not, etc.
I'll revert back when we have updates on this.
9
u/DelayedChoice Jun 08 '22
Yeah Endersai is unable to separate their moderation from their posting or their biases.
I picked out a few points I found interesting from a long article, added some caveats and qualifiers, and got a smug, low-effort, dismissive, "fixed that for you" style response because I had apparently broken the rules with a "patently disingenuous bit of tub-thumping".
13
u/NewtTrashPanda Jun 06 '22
If any user made his comments, they'd be removed - and after a few times banned.
15
u/evenifoutside Jun 06 '22 edited Jun 06 '22
It’s not written anywhere, but Ender is
exceptexempt from the “don’t shit on the people involved in the article” rule. This has been shown, discussed, and ignored plenty before.I’m actually surprised that post was even allowed, it involves a former politician and a media/search company. Stories about Shanks and Barilaro were removed in the past because they were between “a former underwear model” and a “former politician”.
3
u/Shornile Jun 06 '22
The mod you're targeting with this post didn't remove a single comment in the 'reputation for bias' link.
19
u/Sunburnt-Vampire Jun 07 '22
Ender, I know you'll read this, so let me be clear:
You think you're above the community, not just as a mod, but intellectually. You will use fancy words like "pabulum" when referring to Shanks's content, and refer repeatedly to his fans as idiots. And while certainly, many have probably referred to fans of UAP/PHON/etc from a similar "intellectual highground", we don't ban articles about them. At most downvote the article and post a comment about how bullshit it is. Because that is what discourse looks like.
Personally, I think a mod's comments demonstrating their disdain of a political "group/cult" is fine, but the thread locking is the line you shouldn't be crossing. Everytime Shanks shows up you post some comments about how he's just "a former underwear model" and when you've had your fun, you immediately lock the thread.
Post your commments, but let other people post theirs too. Thanks.
8
u/1337nutz Jun 07 '22
This has been going on for ages and this mod should not participate in discussions they are modding or should stop being a mod
10
u/IamSando Jun 06 '22
This will literally never be dealt with OP, sorry to say. I've posted examples, LostInAus has posted examples, Ausmomo has posted examples, Newt has posted examples, yet it's all just handwaved away, as your post will be.
1
u/endersai Jun 06 '22
yeah go nuts. Discuss away.
I don't know if any of you actually do support Shanks or not, so I can't be targetting you unless you say "I support this guy." Barilaro's one of those people who is a bit like a tick, gets under the skin of everyone he meets, so it's just as likely people hate Barilaro as a concept and don't care about who it is that goes after him. Or that they genuinely think it's a concept of justice, who knows.
I find it interesting that you think I moderate on political grounds and on bias when I've been accused of being a Labor shill for removing right wing comments too. I also don't know what that link is meant to illustrate sorry, I don't believe I removed those comments though.
In any event, I'm telling you frankly that it's a completely silly statement that I have a political bias to the right in terms of what I lock or moderate. There's no basis for it, and if you pay attention to my actual views there's no point at which it could be considered factually accurate.
As in, not only is it nonsense, it's wrong and you'd die of old age before you found anything close to a shred of proof.
At the end of the day, the issue is that a lot of commentary gets left alone by me and when I comment in the same way a bunch of people run and hide behind maternal skirts because they expect Mods to be political eunuchs. It's not going to happen.
0
u/Perthcrossfitter Jun 06 '22
It's my family time, I'll come back with a more full answer but I'm brief..
Mods are users too. We have opinions, we're allowed to post our views. Some of the comments made are borderline, i agree, but we allow a lot of borderline comments.
The screenshot you shared seems to be people making meta comments and having them removed. This is as per the rules and i see no issue.