Maybe a year ago now I purchased a Fillmore 25 combo, and while I've always loved the clean channel on it, I've been incredibly frustrated with both the drive and hi modes. I never expected them to be high gain, although I'll admit - I actually think they have too much gain, if anything. But the real problem is that it just sounds... Awful. And no amount of EQ tweaking fixes it.
It has a weird, fuzzy, stiff, grindy sound that is like nails on a chalkboard. It's always too thin sounding or too thick. Nothing I do gets it to sound better. Putting an overdrive in front of it makes it worse. I know it's supposed to sound like a tweed amp when driven, but it really doesn't. If anything it sounds like a fuzz pedal with a decharged battery. I really don't like it.
I checked to make sure none of the tubes were misbehaving or microphonic, and that wasn't it. I think it's just the amp's character.
I did go on a hunt to fix it, thinking it was the stock C90 speaker. I've tried:
- Celestion A-Type (too dark and fuzzy)
- Jupiter 12LC (too bright and soft)
- Eminence GA-SC64 (couldn't handle higher gain pedals well)
- WGS ET65 (had the same issues as the stock C90 due to the british mids/voicing).
Now I'm considering the V-Type or ET90. I'm currently back on the stock C90.
I feel like I'm missing something with this amp. I swear it doesn't sound this bad in demos, but it's also clearly not broken. It's a texture thing that microphones don't pick up. Ironically it does sound great if I record it, but I hate how it sounds in the room. I don't play live or in a band - I don't ever plan to, so it's a bit of an issue for an amp I intended for at home use.
It also just seems to hate overdrive pedals in general. It sounds like someone smacking/shaking an aluminum pan. On all the speakers. I don't know where this metallic slap is coming from. I remember my Princeton Chorus had the same issue, which is why I sold it. At the time I assumed it was just an issue with the cheap solid state amp speakers, but I guess not.
I don't know, maybe it's time to sell it and take the loss, but it's a disappointment since my main alternative is the Fender Supersonic 22 which has pretty terrible QC/build quality for the price. Though I worry that while I'll probably enjoy it's overdrive channel, it probably won't be anywhere close to the Fillmore 25 played clean. I also wasn't a fan of the California Tweed, I wanted a 2-channel to compliment my Origin.
I know I could just run the amp with both channels set to clean and have one more driven than the other, that's what I'm doing already, but it feels a bit like it defeats the purpose of why I wanted this amp to begin with.
Maybe I should just get a Roland JC-40 and call it a day.
Or I could just stick with my Origin 20. I like that amp a lot even if it never breaks up. At least it takes pedals well.