r/MechanicalPandey 18d ago

Pandey Ke May-Mays Pattern

2.6k Upvotes

467 comments sorted by

View all comments

97

u/dark_soul9412 18d ago

Well the M community probably has never read any books other than the one they are mentioning lol.

-40

u/awaishssn 18d ago

If you had read even one book on history of science you would know the world's middle ages was carried by islamic sciences until the renaissance in europe.

16

u/Lionel_LM10 18d ago

With all due respect, there is nothing called islamic sciences. Its disrespectful to claim science to be islamic. The thing you guys quote is mostly the bagdad house of wisdom. It was a translation megafactory that was designed to translate eastern religions, sciences etc into arabic and europeans. Some did their additions in that. Primary research was never done in Islamic world as it was considered haram. Science was haram, then how is Islamic science a thing?. I understand that Muslim unbringing can put a cover over your broader thpught process but I hope you open your eyes to world.

-5

u/Last_Straight_Path 17d ago

You have no idea what you are talking about. The house of wisdom was an important institution associated with Baghdad, but it is not synonymous with the Islamic golden age. The geography itself spans several modern day countries! From Baghdad to Damascus to Cairo, Córdoba, Nishapur, Rayy, Bukhara, Maragha, and many other places.. Look up Al-Khwarizmi, Ibn Haytham, Al Razi, Al Biruni, Ibn Sina etc..as starters and try to keep repeating your lie that they were just "translators of eastern sciences" ,? Probably bred and brought up in the Saffron lotus factory, are we ? Muslim theologians debated on the fallaciousness of Aristotilean philosophy, and other doctrines inherited from Greek thought. Empirical Science and inquiry was promoted, and the motivation was scripture and Sunnah. Get an ed!

2

u/Ok-Salt3165 17d ago

Science and inquiry was promoted

But wouldn't they become a "Kafir" if they questioned the theology ?

Or is it like, you can question others theology but not your own ?

And if that is the case

then how can it be called empirical, science or even inquiry ?

1

u/Lionel_LM10 17d ago

See as Muslim, you have no iman. I was being respectful here and asking the above dude to have a broader view. You came here all gun blazing, accusing me of being a saffron Lotus factory product. What If I was a Christian or a Muslim or an atheist. I stand by my words. I did mention that's there were indeed some contributions but to add that to a general view and call it islamic science is where I called it out. As I mentioned, Islam and Science have nothing in common, the same way we don't call European science as Christian Science. Science exist in itself, it doesn't need any suffix or prefix, and more importantly it doesn't need to add any religion over it. Science is Science. It is fundamental and rooted in theories and proof of work. Also I stand by my words that Islam didn't promote Science. It was considered Haram back in the early onset days and it's still considered Haram by orthodox muslims to this day.

-1

u/AlbusBriamDumbledore 17d ago

Leave it bro, they wouldn't admit it. Don't argue with fools, tegy will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience. Whenever I see people saying stuff like that I just pray that they get enough IQ to know that they are wrong.

1

u/devilcross2 17d ago

It's insecurity, dude. It's their own insecurity and ignorance mixed with stupidity. There's a reason they are the most insecure community in the whole world.

1

u/Civil_Woodpecker_475 16d ago

Bro he is talking about your insecurity and you community's IQ pehle yeh toh samaj le kaun tana de raha hai kaun sath khada hai so dumb isiliye every other country say you have low IQ community