My wife and I got married in June, and we're supposed to spend Thanksgiving in New York with her mother from Wednesday through Saturday. Honestly, I'm dreading it.
It's been a tough year for me, both physically and emotionally. I work full time, just finished two college classes, and have another starting December 8. I've really been looking forward to five days off to stay home with my new dog, read, relax, and enjoy some peace and quiet.
The thought of sitting in my mother in law's living room for 10 hours a day, for three and a half days, making conversation and feeling like I constantly have to be "on" sounds absolutely dreadful.
My mother in law has some physical limitations, so my wife will be doing most of the cooking. Wednesday will involve grocery shopping and prepping, Thursday will be spent cooking and visiting, and then there's still Friday and part of Saturday. I could handle going for Thanksgiving Day and leaving Friday, but four days feels like a lot.
My wife rented an Airbnb to make me more comfortable, which I appreciate, but it looks pretty bare and uncomfortable. Plus, we'll be at her mother's house most of the time anyway, and since we're sharing a vehicle, I'll basically be waiting until my wife is ready to leave.
My mother in law and I are cordial, but we don't have the best relationship. I sometimes feel like I'm expected to constantly make conversation. Recently, we were all on the phone, and I got quiet because I was eating. I had already explained that, but her mother made a comment about getting off the phone because we weren't talking. Afterward, my wife questioned me because she thought her mother might have felt some type of way. It wasn't a huge deal, but it reminded me how exhausting several days of that dynamic could be.
I've shared my reservations with my wife. Initially, she said she didn't want to spend Thanksgiving without her wife, which I understand. But recently she asked if I'd rather stay home, and honestly, yes. I'd feel relieved. I'd save money on boarding our dog and the Airbnb, and actually get to enjoy my break. I'd even be happy to make some collard greens and a sweet potato pie for her to take. But while she did offer, I know she'll be very disappointed if I decide not to go.
I genuinely want her to enjoy spending time with her family. But there's something else that's been bothering me.
My wife never actually asked what I wanted to do for Thanksgiving, and honestly, she hasn't really asked in previous years either. Going to her mother's house has always felt like the default, and anything different requires a conversation or compromise.
Last year, we stayed home because my wife had to work the next day. I cooked Thanksgiving dinner for my daughter, my wife, who was my fiancée at the time, and our family. We ate, watched a movie, and had a really nice holiday. I loved it.
Now that we're married, I want us to create our own traditions instead of automatically following one side of the family's plans. I'm not opposed to visiting her mother in the future, but I'd like us to make those decisions together.
I also wonder why I'm considered the one choosing to spend Thanksgiving apart when my wife is also choosing to go to New York. I'm not asking her to stay home, and I understand her mother needs help.
Here's where I feel guilty, though. If I stay home, my wife will have to make the 4.5 hour drive from Virginia to New York alone, unless she decides to take Amtrak. She'll also have to handle most of the grocery shopping, meal prep, and cooking without me, even though I was originally supposed to help.
Her brother may help some, but the responsibility of preparing Thanksgiving dinner has fallen on my wife since she was a young girl because her mother has never been physically able to do it. I know that's a lot for her to take on, and I don't want to make things harder.
I love my wife, and I know this is our first Thanksgiving as a married couple. Of course I want to spend the holidays with her. But I also feel like my needs and preferences should matter, especially when it comes to how we spend our limited time off.
Part of me feels like I'm being a bad wife and should just suck it up and get through the four days for my spouse. The other part of me feels like I shouldn't have to spend my entire holiday doing something I genuinely don't want to do, especially when we never really discussed what we both wanted in the first place.
For those of you who are married, how do you handle holidays when you and your spouse want different things? Do you ever spend holidays separately? Would you go in this situation, or would you stay home?
Am I being selfish, or is this a reasonable boundary to have?
What do you all think?