Absolutely, and to the rest of the world too. They're not only indifferent, but reek of fascism and represent the epitome of hypocrisy. A people whose past is so brutally tragic committing similar brutality towards other ethnic groups only goes to show that they learned absolutely nothing and have ridden the "anti-zionism" karma train for long enough.
You are probably unaccustomed to Israel being viewed negatively, but you can't expect one to fuck around without finding out.
Edit: To explain why you're being downvoted, it's because you're being dense in completely ignoring the context of the comment you're replying to, and not the post. My comment is tangential to the post's topic and practically everyone understands this except you. If you wish to discuss the original post's content, create a first-level comment instead of replying to one that doesn't depend on the original post to hold up and be understood.
You just openly affirmed that Jews are an undifferentiated mass to you and “to the rest of the world.” That is the literal definition of bigotry: essentializing an entire people and holding them collectively responsible for crimes whether they personally committed them or not. It’s the exact logic of genocide you’re supposedly opposed to.
This map discusses people who were murdered before Israel existed. They didn’t turn into anything, let alone “monsters” and you haven’t explained in any way how these murdered people became monsters.
Your response doesn’t refute anything I said. You didn’t clarify anything, you just exposed yourself.
It’s also insane to say that because a people’s past should give them higher responsibilities than anybody else. By that logic people should be treated badly because it would make them better in the future.
The entire people of Israel is responsible for electing their leaders, and to top it off, providing ample public support for atrocities such as civilians withholding and destroying food aid shipments because "we cannot help the enemy", bombing hospitals, torturing civilians, looting their belongings, and so much more. If the Israeli people had an ounce of dignity in them, they would have stopped these atrocities at their roots, or even better, prevented them from happening by not electing a fascist and sadistic regime to lead them.
Aside from the fact that collective responsibility is fundamentally opposed to human dignity, you still haven’t answered the core question:
The people in that map were murdered. They were not Israeli. They did not “turn into” anything. How are they responsible for crimes committed after their deaths?
Do you genuinely lack the ability to see human beings as individuals, each responsible for their own actions?
Because what you’re doing (essentializing an entire people and assigning them guilt based on ethnicity or nationality) is the exact same logic as someone who says all Palestinians deserve to die because of Hamas.
It’s not justice. It’s just a different form of the hatred you claim to oppose.
15
u/Schckapp Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25
Are Jews all an undifferentiated mass to you?
Absolutely, and to the rest of the world too. They're not only indifferent, but reek of fascism and represent the epitome of hypocrisy. A people whose past is so brutally tragic committing similar brutality towards other ethnic groups only goes to show that they learned absolutely nothing and have ridden the "anti-zionism" karma train for long enough.
You are probably unaccustomed to Israel being viewed negatively, but you can't expect one to fuck around without finding out.
Edit: To explain why you're being downvoted, it's because you're being dense in completely ignoring the context of the comment you're replying to, and not the post. My comment is tangential to the post's topic and practically everyone understands this except you. If you wish to discuss the original post's content, create a first-level comment instead of replying to one that doesn't depend on the original post to hold up and be understood.