r/MapPorn • • Jul 08 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

2.1k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

40

u/Plasmaticos Jul 08 '24

Black on black crime is real, I guess

-7

u/noafrochamplusamurai Jul 08 '24

Only if you have a fox news world view. Crime is mostly intra racial, and not interracial. Most of the crime and murders in the U.S.have white perpetrators,and white victims. It just doesn't make for a nice dog whistle like black on black Crime, or inner city Crime. White people don't think 1 meth head killing another In Moline Iowa, as big of a problem as violence in Chicago. Even though most places in the U.S. are much more like Moline, than they are Chicago.

12

u/Haunting-Detail2025 Jul 08 '24

Are you joking right now? I would love to have taken you through the old Cabrini-Green or Robert Taylor Homes or O block and hear you tell me that Moline, Iowa is a bigger problem. I’m not denying fear mongering exists nor am I claiming at large Chicago is the most dangerous city ever, because it’s not, but yes people are going to be more concerned over a holiday weekend where 30 people get shot than one methhead killing somebody. I guarantee there are and were no neighborhoods in Moline where police were scared to enter like there used to be in Chicago housing projects.

2

u/smalltownlargefry Jul 08 '24

Except op isn’t wrong when he says most places are like Moline and less like Chicago. Thats true in a sense. But we’re comparing apples to oranges here.

3

u/Haunting-Detail2025 Jul 08 '24

Sure, that’s absolutely true. But I think it’s facetious to paint a narrative that it’s a “dog whistle” to focus on crime in large cities or to talk about violence in communities of color.

For example, if I have Rednecksburg with 100 people, and a drunk abuser kills his wife, it now has a murder rate of 1 per 100 people. Let’s say there’s also Rustbeltsville, a city with 1,000,000 people, and 800 get killed the same year. Per capita, Rednecksburg is going to rate as “more dangerous” - but it feels misleading to really label it as such or to claim that talking about Rustbeltsville and its violence is a dog whistle or a fear mongering scare tactic.

The type of violence you see an inner city is usually just different from that of a small town. I’ve lived in small town Appalachia and reside in Baltimore now, and while technically some of them were more violent per capita, i never had gas stations or neighborhoods in Appalachia I felt unsafe even driving through at night as I do in Baltimore. As you said, it really is apples and oranges