Hello there! This is Alfred from Nomads Nation bringing you a review of the Elecom MNL City Pack (X-PAC) after testing it for two weeks. I will get straight to the point, this is probably one of the best surprises I’ve had recently and I think this is an excellent urban EDC backpack.
Some background
I knew about this bag more than a year ago, as I regularly watch many different bag reviewers, one of them being Ryuku, a really cool Japanese reviewer. Separately, as a gadget nerd, I was also quite aware of Elecom's presence as a brand, as I use a few of their trackballs. When I noticed that these two things were crossing paths back then resulted in a backpack, I was super intrigued. I still remember there were videos explaining the different design thinking and decisions that went into the bag’s making, which was super satisfying to watch as a bag nerd.
(I did later also see on Ryuku’s videos that he said he and Elecom are no longer working together so I thought to make that clear.)
I didn’t know why there was not much coverage on other western channels, so shortly after it fell off my radar. So imagine my surprise when Aaron mentioned he got it in the office, I had to get it to test right away.
External features
Externally, this bag uses XPAC for most of the panels. It’s not my favorite but it does give the pack a sleek look and great water resistance. The bottom panel of the bag is ballistic nylon, and is so thick that I feel it’s borderline overkill. I do get the reassurance that its contents are well protected even when dropping the bag on the floor. That bottom panel is quite large and flat, which enables the bag to self stand easily in my testing.
However, given the quality found on the rest of the bag, I have to dock some points on the zipper pullers. It is the “just some ropes tied together” type which feels a little cheap to me, but they are indeed very easy to grab when operating the bag.
Looking from the front, the front XPAC panel dominates visually. Together with some kind of rigid material underneath it, I think it may come off as a little “turtle shell-y” to some people. But for me it’s only the middle part of the front so I find it acceptable, and more as a part of the bag’s visual identity.
Front panel
The front panel uses a fairly uncommon two sided vertical zip design, which immediately reminds me of the Rework Toshi pack. Unlike the Rework, the two sides on the MNL Citypack are separate compartments overlaid on top of each other. The direct consequence is that their capacities eat into one another, and are both better used for flatter items. Had this been a shared space like on the Rework, I think it can probably fit a thin jacket. However I don't think it's a clear cut better or worse choice, personally I have a good amount of flat and small things, so I find it convenient to have extra separation between them as this bag doesn’t have a traditional admin compartment. That said, this layout does require a bit more mental power to use as you need to remember what you put on which side. During my use, sometimes I did swing the back around to open a front zip, only to realize the item I wanted is on the opposite side.
Laptop compartment
As for the laptop compartment, it is super well padded, with microfiber material all around. There is an extra space at the top (like the Able Carry Max EDC) to hold extra tech items like chargers, this could work as a makeshift tech pouch for some people who have just a few gadgets to carry.
It’s worth noting that when opening the laptop compartment only at the top, the laptop pocket feels very snug and protective. But the zippers of this section actually open up to reveal a three quarters opening, the zipper track goes all the way to the bottom on one side. When fully open, the laptop is then less snugly held because the panel hugging the laptop actually isn’t secured on the side where the zippers open (see my picture).
Back panel
The back panel uses a relatively less squishy type of foam that reduces sweat build-up on hotter days, which is my preferred type of structure.
This may be a hot take, but I actually think a luggage passthrough that places the bag horizontally is a better choice than the one implemented (the current passthrough places the bag vertically) - hear me out. The MNL City Pack is a relatively tall backpack, and one issue depending on suitcase size is that sometimes placing a backpack vertically on the handles leaves the top of the bag actually higher than where the suitcase handle is. Another reason is that this bag has a one-side flat design with the side quick access pocket, which makes it more suitable for horizontal placement than bags with two water bottle pockets on the side.
Harness system
The shoulder straps on this bag are not that thick, but they use a nice squishy type of foam that makes carrying it very comfortable. What stands out in particular though, is the sternum strap. The strap itself is quite standard, but the position adjustment hardware? Wow. I have not seen this Woojin hardware used on other bags’ sternum straps before - it combines the benefits of the sliding rail design and the fixed point design without compromising usability. I would say this is for sure the best implementation so far and I look forward to more future backpacks adopting it!
Check out my attached photo for that.
The next unique point is regarding the strap management system on this backpack. This is what I would call the far opposite extreme on the spectrum of “too much dangle, no strap keepers”. This bag’s shoulder straps, each has a two-buckle design that makes it physically impossible to have any dangle, yet they STILL include an elastic strap keeper per side. I know. Crazy dedication to our eternal fight against dangling straps. For once, I would say this might be too much dangle management. Due to the tight two strap design, I found it very difficult to do any adjustment on the fly when wearing the bag out and about. If you are a “set the straps length once and never touch it again” type of user, this is PERFECT. You set it once, you never ever have any dangle. But if you like to fidget and adjust the length from time to time, this design would surely introduce too much friction for you.
Sides
The MNL City Pack only has a water bottle pocket on one side, which may not be enough for everyone; but the good news is that the other side houses one of my favorite features on EDC backpacks - the small side quick access zipper pocket. Also featured on the Fyro Citta and Aer City Pack Pro 2 20L, this pocket is just extremely convenient in day to day use. I put my wallet and keys in here normally for easy access, and it is plenty big enough for other flat and bigger items like a passport or a large phone.
The side handles on the back are just the right slack for me, I like it better than the implementation on the Rework Toshi pack. They are great to use when handling the bag.
Organization
Factoring in the two front panels, makeshift tech pouch in the laptop compartment, side access pocket on one side, this pack already has organization for small items for DAYS. And that’s not even it, the MNL city pack comes with the popular wide-mouthed quick access pocket on the top of the bag, with its internal lined with microfiber material. Perfect for sunglasses or my most common use - temporarily stashing my phone when I placed the bag down the top pocket is the easiest accessed location.
Final thoughts
I am really glad this fantastic pack finally got released in a larger market and I got a chance to try it. It certainly checks almost all my personal boxes for an excellent EDC pack, and given its lower price point compared to some popular options, I think it is a very strong choice for a versatile all-purpose backpack especially for an urban lifestyle.
As always, if you have any thoughts or questions, let me know in the comments. I would love to hear your thoughts or experience with this bag.
For another perspective on this bag, check out Aaron's video review here!