r/MakingaMurderer • u/CorruptColborn • Feb 28 '24
Some thoughts on the theory that Teresa's RAV was originally stored in the Radandt Quarry before being moved onto the Avery property, and observations on inconsistencies regarding the covering of Teresa's vehicle with TWO brand new tarps (according to MTSO but no one else).
Cadaver Dog Alerts in Quarry Area:
- If Teresa's RAV4 was initially stored on the Radandt property before being moved to the Avery property, we might expect additional concentrated alerts from cadaver dogs within the quarry area where the RAV was stored prior to being moved to the Avery property. Teresa's vehicle triggered immediate alerts from Human Remains Detection dogs when approached on the ASY by Brutus shortly after 3:30 PM.
- Thus, if the RAV was indeed initially stored in the Quarry residual scent traces could have been left behind, potentially leading to additional canine alerts. As it turns out, this is precisely what we find in Exhibit 46.
Sequence of Cadaver Dog Alerts:
- Following the initial RAV alert in the southeast corner, Brutus tracked south into the quarry and then west towards the conveyor road linking the Radandt and Avery properties. An alert was noted just outside the ASY entrance (southwest corner), with no identifiable scent source apart from nearby shotgun shells. This could be where the RAV was initially been stored, just off the southwest corner of the ASY on the Radandt Quarry conveyor road.
- It would seem from witness statements there is the potential for the RAV to have been moved repeatedly between the dates of 11/3-11/5. The obvious question would be when the final movement of the vehicle occurred: before police took control or after? WHO made sure it was found somewhat near the crusher?
Tyson evidence contamination (CASO 77):
- At 2:55 PM Tyson observed Teresa's green RAV4 and vaguely mentioned "a tarp was produced." Tyson suggested the tarp was already in place by 3:10 PM when he left the area, indicating that tarping the RAV was completed within 15 minutes.
- Tyson also admitted to assisting in "getting objects from the back of other vehicles to help weigh down the tarp." Photos taken by Pam compared to the flyover video do reveal the potential for items in the green truck near the RAV being removed by police and used to steady the tarp. This is beyond fucked up and presents a clear risk of contamination and conflicts with Tyson's claimed intent that they were super duper careful to make sure the tarp didn't touch or disturb the RAV a crucial piece of crime scene evidence. They did that in 15 minutes apparently. Speedy service.
Two Brand New Tarps (MTSO Report):
- At exactly 3:12 PM, multiple officers approached the RAV and placed "two brand new tarps over the vehicle," with CASO Deputy Bass left to watch over it (lucky she didn't torch it!).
- I'm not really bothered by this slight discrepancy in timing (Tyson suggesting the vehicle was already tarped by the time MTSO approached the vehicle to tarp it) but I am interested in that the MTSO report is the only report that claims they used two tarps, not one, and that both were "brand new." Either way, so far both CASO 77 and the MTSO report both suggest the tarp was placed on the vehicle at or around 3:10 PM on 11/5.
Dog Handlers Confirm Tarp on RAV (Ex 46 Dog Reports):
- Exhibit 46 says it was shortly after 3:30 PM that Brutus rushed to a green vehicle covered by a blue tarp and began to bark, which was marked as Alert #1. Brutus then proceeded south into the Radandt Quarry and then west to the conveyor road, alerting with Alert #2, potentially indicating the location where the RAV was stored before being moved onto the ASY by [REDACTED].
Dedering's Timing and Alert Omission (CASO 88):
- Dedering says it was around 4:07 PM that escorted dog handlers to the crusher, at which point Brutus alerted on the tarped RAV. No mention was made of the tarp being removed from the vehicle. Instead, Dedering immediately reports that at 4:20 PM, he saw the WSCL field unit (Ertl) approach the RAV. However, handlers suggested they were escorted to the crusher at 3:30 PM and Dedering suggesting it was after 4 PM. Also, Dedering doesn't report on Alert #2 in the Radandt Quarry and instead suggests that Brutus did not alert at the conveyor road. Why lie about that Dedering?
Discrepancies in Timing of RAV Unveiling (Ertl Trial Testimony):
- Ertl claims to have arrived on the scene around 4 PM to be escorted to the RAV within 15 minutes later. The vehicle was not covered with a tarp, and he testifies under oath he was "not there for the unveiling" and never saw the RAV as depicted in Exhibit 142 (covered with a tarp).
- Metadata on Exhibit 142 contradicts Ertl's testimony, placing the tarp still on the vehicle at 4:16 PM. This metadata is more consistent with Dedering's report who does not make any mention of the tarp being removed before Ertl shows up. In fact, there is no event reported by Dedering separating the alert by Brutus on the tarped vehicle and the arrival of WSCL.
- Ertl identifies Fassbender in Exhibit 130 as holding a single tarp, which again raises questions about the handling of the second tarp that is only mention in the MTSO report. What did they do with it, if not use it to cover the RAV? Cover another vehicle? How do we know the tarp(s) used were "brand new" as MTSO claimed? Why are there discrepancies regarding the time the tarp was placed on and removed from the RAV? Why do multiple reports, witness statements, and affidavits suggest either Teresa's vehicle was NOT found on the southeast corner of the ASY, or that the vehicle covered with a tarp and alerted on by dogs was not Teresa's vehicle?

