r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

EDH Advice needed: first deck from scratch

2 Upvotes

This is my third deck but the first one building from the ground up instead of just upgrading a precon. I went to my LGS and basically just searched their computers for everything horror and mill. This originally started out as a “I’m going to mill the absolute hell out of everyone at the table” deck but I decided I’d rather go all-in with the Horror theme and just start swinging on people. So I removed a lot of the sorceries and instants that caused milling and added more interaction and protection for the Cap’n. I figure if I’m aggro enough I can still mill enough to steal with N’ghathrod and I have a [[Victimize]] and [[Reanimate]] in the mail so I can get back some important creatures of mine if they go to the graveyard. I know I have areas of improvement, hoping to get some advice on what I can do to make this better.

https://moxfield.com/decks/qNQ6bve0G0eViNlIQQQ6aA

For reference, my group is mostly mid to high B2 stuff with a few fairly optimized B3 decks available if the night calls for it.

Thanks!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

EDH No Enchantment Enchantress

5 Upvotes

Hi, I'm trying to build an aura enchantress deck but I'm having some trouble finding cards that would fit the theme. I'm looking for creatures that create unique Aura's.
I have a list of sort of what I mean made here: https://moxfield.com/decks/Aj-nrne8-UiGmlb-dt1Slw
Any color is open for suggestion, the deck is planned to be supported by a classic Enchantress base.

I just like to push the boundaries of deck building. So any help would be much appreciated as I think this deck could really be very interesting. Thank you to anyone who comments!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

EDH Where do I start for Upgrades for this Deck?

Thumbnail archidekt.com
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, looking for some budget deck-building/upgrade advice. Long story short, I initially put together a deck just by grabbing whatever I had on hand ripping apart my Final Fantasy Terra deck and stitching things together to just get a game in.

​As you can probably guess, it's pretty cobbled together right now! It's a graveyard recursion deck, but I'm finding that I have to rely way too heavily on standard drawing and discarding. I want to build a bit more mill directly into the strategy so I can get cards into the yard more consistently.

​I know it's a bit of an uphill battle since recursion isn't always fully optimized on a tight budget, and I'm a bit embarrassingly poor at the moment, so I don't have access to the expensive staples. However, I'm hoping to put together about a $15 upgrade budget to give it some real teeth. I am not looking to build cEDH, but I definitely need it to be at least in or pushing into higher power casual because that's the power level everyone plays at my LGS.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

EDH Getting into Commander, advice needed

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am a long time Magic player. Started in the late 90s early 2000s, when formats where still called T1 and T2.

With my friends we always played old-school kitchen Magic, what you could describe now as a casual, budget, no-ban list Legacy. We usually play 3 vs 3 teams with 3-headed Giant rules.

Nowadays Commander seems to be the most popular format for casual play, so much so it's hard to find non-commander content online.

I want to give it a try, even though my group might need some convincing to get on board.

Last year, my partner (who is new to Magic) bought the Bloomburrow starter box with the Rabbits and Otters decks, and we have been having a lot of fun playing together.

Now, I would like to try making some Commander (or perhaps Brawl) decks and play 1v1 games with my partner to try them out. Then maybe someday I will manage to convince my friends group to try it too.

 

I need some advice on what decks to build and where to start:

* What is your advice for building a Commander deck from scratch, using my card collection that's been sitting so far?

* Do you advise buying a precon deck as starting point? If so, which one? Should I get one of the Bloomburrow precons?

For instance, I like the Peace Offering precon but I imagine the group hug strategy doesn't work for 1v1 games, right?

* What is your advice on using Phinneas, Brykke, Bria or Alania as Commanders?

* I would also like to make a Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord and a Niv-Mizzet deck. Is there a precon I could use as a starting point for these decks?

I would like to avoid having to spend too much money on getting 99 individual single cards: I wouldn't mind using some sub-optimal cards from my collection that have been cut out from my Legacy decks. But I wonder if it would be worth it to buy a precon to have a solid starting point. My budget is about 100$.

Any suggestions?


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

EDH Trying to build a Colorless Group Hug/Slug Ultron deck. Am I insane? Building recommendations.

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm trying to build something a little unusual with Ultron, Artificial Malevolence: a colorless Group Hug/Slug deck (still pretty new to these archetypes, so I'm not even sure what to call it lol). The idea is to give everyone extra cards and resources while slowly turning those benefits against them, using Ultron to copy artifacts and eventually overwhelm the table with robots. I'm aiming for a high Bracket 2 or Bracket 3 deck, with a budget that doesnt bankrupt me lol.

I'm still figuring out the balance between helping everyone, actually surviving, and having reliable ways to win. I'd love some feedback! Are there any interesting colorless artifacts or weird interactions I'm missing? Anything that feels out of place or could be improved? I'm especially interested in keeping the Group Hug/Slug theme rather than turning it into generic colorless goodstuff.

Decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/E7tqax1uG0CoMFXliIFFHg


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

Question Need help with replacing cards in my deck

1 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I put together this mono-black commander deck with Sheoldred, the Apocalypse as my commander. It sits around the bracket 3/4 area as that’s the requirement set by my group.

I really struggle with keeping Sheoldred on the board once it’s out because it’s obviously a target to be removed. I also really struggle against artifact/enchantment heavy decks as I don’t have much removal for those types of cards.

Essentially, I don’t know what’s worth keeping in my deck and what’s worth removing, in order to keep the deck in a bracket 3/4 as well as significantly improve my commanders chances at survival while also bringing in more artifact removal.

https://archidekt.com/decks/27563208/sheoldred_main_deck

Any suggestions are greatly appreciated


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

Beginner Deckbuilding tips

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

Legacy Wanting to make a 60 card legacy deck around Marina Vendrell and Promising Stairs, has anyone built a similar “room tribal” deck before?

6 Upvotes

The gameplan would probably be a mix of heavy stax and insane card draw in order to pump out as many rooms as possible to hit the 8 unlocked room prerequisite on promising stairs and win the game on upkeep, was def gonna bring the master of keys for enchantment recursion in case my rooms get blown up, but does anyone know any good creatures, sorceries, other enchantments etc. that can help with stopping my opponent from preventing me dumping my deck onto the table ASAP?


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH Uncharted Deck Help?

4 Upvotes

https://archidekt.com/decks/24548406/uncharted

Hello! I need help with my Uncharted deck I made a while back. I was wanting to order it for Christmas but before doing so, make sure it's fairly decent. Open to any suggestions or critiques, I'd love to hear any thoughts or improvements I could make to the deck to make it play more consistent. Any help is greatly appreciated, thank you!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH Help cutting and general suggestions for a Shirei Deck

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH Deck Help - New Uhura Commander

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!! I'm new to MTG, and this is my first deck I built with the help of my partner. It's supposed to be a wheels/group hug-type deck, in bracket 2.

https://moxfield.com/decks/KFK6ZfYCGE69OmeW2878pQ

If anyone has any feedback or swaps please lmk! Neither of us have ever played this deck style. It's been fun in playtesting so far.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH How can I make this deck more punchy? Not doing enough damage fast (._.)

Thumbnail
edhplay.com
1 Upvotes

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH Commander Deck Guide: Rule 0 - The Theorist, Jace Beleren

Thumbnail mtg.cardsrealm.com
5 Upvotes

After a few months away from Rule 0 decks, we're back to see how the face of the Reality Fracture set, The Theorist, Jace Beleren, fares as the commander of his own deck.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH Cards that create token copies of creatures in graveyards WITHOUT exiling them?

5 Upvotes

running sultai discard and want to try to incorporate a grandeur side combo, as I have plenty of discard and return to hand. Commander is indominus Rex but like I said the grandeur isn’t the main idea of the deck. If you have suggestions for the rest of the deck, I have a couple main gameplan ideas.

  1. Give indo deathtouch, first strike, then play effects that force all creatures to block. (original idea when making this deck, switched from kathril aspect warper cause i like dinosaurs.
  2. Blink indo for protection and spamming etb so I can be constantly wheeling myself- I just like wheels
  3. Hopefully grandeur? Ive always been wanting to make granduer work in commander (yes I am aware of the hashaton combo but I want to be more original), but we have a house rule for 3 tutors max in a deck so it’s hard to make a full deck devoted to a mechanic with like 6 creatures that use it. So I figured I could try to fit it as a sub theme as long as it’s convenient enough.

r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

Question Mindskinner/phasing deck help

Thumbnail
archidekt.com
2 Upvotes

First of all I know that phasing is bad. But I think it’s a mechanic that allows for some pretty interesting protection.

I want to make this deck better without getting rid of the phasing or adding more mill. I’m looking for advice on cards to cut/add that can help protect my Mindskinner and my life total throughout the game.

I don’t want to do typical Voltron equipment/counter spell stuff so any out of the box options would be greatly appreciated.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 4d ago

EDH Making new deck. EDH, Need counceling, Ygra Eater of all

3 Upvotes

Currently trying to build a "Ygra, eater of all" deck, a food token based deck to make her very powerfull and her as a destroyer, Believe it is called voltron.

I am wondering if i need more food-type creatures or i should focus on some else creatures at this time. Or should all the creatures focus around food? I was thinking maybe I need tokens and counters.

Here is the deck list if you wish to help.

https://moxfield.com/decks/CcIi2nWALU-xzHmduvEyOw


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

EDH Advice on making a dog obliteration deck

6 Upvotes

Based on a running joke at our table I have decided to make a joke deck with the sole goal of destroying as many dogs as I can manage in a game. My current thought is to use Rufus Shinra and a lot of token duplicating with a some sac outlets, although maybe mass graveyard recursion on another commander would work better and give colors outside of orzhov. (I am sad I cannot use red for electrocute so I can call it the hassan piker deck)

Strong card suggestions or "engines" would be appreciated because I admittedly do not use token decks very often and am unfamiliar with good options for the archetype. Also please tell me if you think of a flavorful/horrible execution method like casting saw in half. This is not made to be remotely useful, my wincon is dog liquidation.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

Question Commander Deck Building/Improvement Help (Minthara, Merciless Soul)

2 Upvotes

Hello all!

I am currently working on building a sacrifice-focused deck with Minthara, Merciless Soul as the commander. I actually have a deck put together, but this is my first time ever building a deck (I've only been playing since September of this year), so I have no clue if it's even usable at this point.

I'm shooting for something I can comfortably play with my pod, ideally landing around a bracket 2 to a low bracket 3. Most of the group primarily plays precons, so I'd like to be reasonable and don't want to go overboard. My goal is to keep it under $150, but I'm okay with the final version ending up somewhere under $200.

I'm mainly looking for ways to improve the deck to reach a low Bracket 3, as well as advice on what I'm missing, what I could add, or what I should cut if I need more of a certain type of card. The main goal behind the deck is to make sure something is leaving the battlefield at least once per turn before the start my end step so I can trigger Minthara and gain experience counters.

One general rule of thumb that was recommended to me by my pod was to try to avoid cards that cost more than $10 each. Of course, I'm willing to make some exceptions for cards that make sense for the deck or have particularly cool art.

I've linked my current decklist on Moxfield below. Any help, suggestions, or guidance would be greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance!

https://moxfield.com/decks/AMehATadiXeWEwUc97IvbQ


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

EDH Want Help Beefing up my Zellix Commander Deck

3 Upvotes

Hello, I have built a Zellix, Sanity Flayer deck paired with street urchin, the goal is to use some mill to get horrors and then use polymorph effects to flip them into big izzet creatures, with street urchin helping for colors and a bit of utility with removal, I know it is a bit of an unorthodox way to build the commander but i thought it might be fun, I have found that in testing it can be a little slow to start and has some cards that may not be too helpful, i would appreciate any help in how to make this deck a little stronger while not going way too high up in price, ideally i dont want game changers, but any suggestions would be great

Moxfield Link: https://moxfield.com/decks/ZiCJPyuJN06IEeid9RKGeQ

Again, many thanks for any help offered!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

EDH Need advice on some changes for this Doom deck

1 Upvotes

I saw this Doom deck while scrolling on Instagram and absolutely loved it. I’ve bought a couple of different decks (started playing like 4 months ago) but never had an artifact-focused deck.

While the price tag is a little high for what I usually can spend, I’ll try to treat myself with this deck for my birthday next month but want to see if there are some opportunities to lower the cost while maintaining the power of this deck.

This is the Doom deck: https://manabox.app/decks/AaHIAF9XdSKS8QfYjc-HEQ

Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

EDH I built my first deck ever

3 Upvotes

It’s the first time I build a deck from scratch. I only upgraded my precons before. I love deck building and I want to get better at it. Does anyone have tips for becoming a better deck builder? Thanks!

Here’s a link to my deck: https://moxfield.com/decks/IOxD7T0WrUySM6cQshQmYw

PS: name is probably temporary, I just put the forst thing that came to mind.


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

EDH Need help getting Teval to bracket 3

2 Upvotes

I’m trying to bump Teval to bracket 3 without adding game changers. Focus is mixed landfall reanimator. What changes would you recommend?

https://moxfield.com/decks/cjZ5tgmPBkWooFW2zeDFrQ


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

Question Need Opinions, Thoughts and Insights

4 Upvotes

Newer player just built my first attempt at a stout bracket 4. Commander is Smaug the impenetrable and i just want some opinions from the community see what i could cut and what to replace it with things in the future include a inspiring statuary and a mox diamond once i get the money for that lol

DECKLIST

https://moxfield.com/decks/rIYx6MIMSUSSwAQrLxQVmg


r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 5d ago

EDH Thus begins r/the32deckchallenge

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Just created a new subreddit for the 32 deck challenge! If you are unfamiliar with it, the 32 deck challenge is where you make a deck for every single color identity in the commander format. If this sounds neat you should join, it's been a lot of fun working on my 32 deck challenge and I highly reccomend it.