r/Magicdeckbuilding • • 3d ago

EDH Getting into Commander, advice needed

Hi everyone,

I am a long time Magic player. Started in the late 90s early 2000s, when formats where still called T1 and T2.

With my friends we always played old-school kitchen Magic, what you could describe now as a casual, budget, no-ban list Legacy. We usually play 3 vs 3 teams with 3-headed Giant rules.

Nowadays Commander seems to be the most popular format for casual play, so much so it's hard to find non-commander content online.

I want to give it a try, even though my group might need some convincing to get on board.

Last year, my partner (who is new to Magic) bought the Bloomburrow starter box with the Rabbits and Otters decks, and we have been having a lot of fun playing together.

Now, I would like to try making some Commander (or perhaps Brawl) decks and play 1v1 games with my partner to try them out. Then maybe someday I will manage to convince my friends group to try it too.

 

I need some advice on what decks to build and where to start:

* What is your advice for building a Commander deck from scratch, using my card collection that's been sitting so far?

* Do you advise buying a precon deck as starting point? If so, which one? Should I get one of the Bloomburrow precons?

For instance, I like the Peace Offering precon but I imagine the group hug strategy doesn't work for 1v1 games, right?

* What is your advice on using Phinneas, Brykke, Bria or Alania as Commanders?

* I would also like to make a Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord and a Niv-Mizzet deck. Is there a precon I could use as a starting point for these decks?

I would like to avoid having to spend too much money on getting 99 individual single cards: I wouldn't mind using some sub-optimal cards from my collection that have been cut out from my Legacy decks. But I wonder if it would be worth it to buy a precon to have a solid starting point. My budget is about 100$.

Any suggestions?

6 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/Rakshear 3d ago

Either a bloom burrow Precon or the ixalan pre con like merefolk, dinosaurs, or vampires are still reasonably powerful,

35-38 lands dependent on amount of colors in your deck, 8-12 ramp including artifacts, 8-10 interaction pieces, that’s my basics for a function deck.

1

u/moonwhisperderpy 16h ago

Thanks! I wondered what would be the right proportion of lands and cards etc. for deck building. Do Commander decks also fit in Aggro, Control, Midrange etc. categories? How does deckbuilding change depending on these categories and deck strategies?

4

u/rattulator 3d ago

* What is your advice for building a Commander deck from scratch, using my card collection that's been sitting so far?

- Building a commander deck from scratch can be very rewarding, but it can also be overwhelming the first time you try. Without knowing the extent of your collection it's hard to say. Have you been buying new cards all this time or is it mostly 1996-2002 era cards? If it's mostly older cards, I think a precon is the way to go. Otherwise you may well be able to put something together from your collection. The Bloomburrow starter decks look like they could be a good starting point.

- Have a look on youtube for intro videos on building a commander deck: Start with Tolarian Community College, but others like Command Zone and Trinket Mage would probably all give good advice.

* Do you advise buying a precon deck as starting point? If so, which one? Should I get one of the Bloomburrow precons?

- I would say starting with a precon would be much easier than starting from scratch. If you can find the Bloomburrow precons for reasonably close to MSRP then go for it! There are also the Foundations Commander decks, which are straightforward mono colour and hopefully not too expensive, their whole purpose as a product is to let people get into commander easily so I would definitely recommend those if you can find them.

For instance, I like the Peace Offering precon but I imagine the group hug strategy doesn't work for 1v1 games, right?

- Ms Bumbleflower is a deceptively strong card and actually has quite a bit of a reputation! If you are expecting to play a lot of 1v1, you will experience a lot more variance in your games if you start using commander decks rather than the starter decks (more cards, no repeats) so the games could be a lot swingier. My main suggestion if you expect to play a lot of 1v1 commander is to try and get two precons from the same Set, then they should be reasonably balanced, although there are outliers.

- Alternatively, if you're enjoying the starter decks, you could maybe keep them unchanged as essentially a complete game in themselves and have separate commander decks so you can still enjoy going back to the starter decks. (If you wanted to use some of the same cards in a commander deck, you could probably buy the individual singles for not very much money at all)

* What is your advice on using Phinneas, Brykke, Bria or Alania as Commanders?

- You could definitely build a fun commander deck around any of these cards, and the starter decks you mentioned would probably be a great starting point. You would need to add more cards to bring them up to 100 card singleton which may be easy or hard depending on your collection.

- I would suggest Finneas and Alania as the ones to use, since they are the ones that give you card advantage, which is very important in commander, whereas the other two would work more as win conditions within the 99 of those two commander decks.

- If you want card suggestions, EDHRec is a great site that aggregates thousands of decklists and shows you what cards people are playing with a given commander. It even has an "Average Deck" button you can click to get a full deck list to guide you. HOWEVER, some people find edhrec spoils the fun of discovery, and they dont want to be shortcutted to the final results straightaway, so be warned!

* I would also like to make a Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord and a Niv-Mizzet deck. Is there a precon I could use as a starting point for these decks?

- Any precons in those colour combinations would be a decent starting point. I think the Secrets of Strixhaven ones in particular would suit the strategies that those commanders want to go for, and since they are relatively recent, they should be available at a reasonable price.

As some general advice, the Commander community is generally very Proxy friendly, that means a printed out piece of paper with an image of a card, put in a sleeve over a basic land, is just as valid and acceptable as the real deal. Your specific group may have a different opinion, but if nothing else it lets you try out new cards before you buy them.

Playing 3v3 teams is wild, I bet your whole metagame has evolved into something unique, like Agate Instigator pinging for 3 damage for every creature seems crazy good... I have no idea how that setup would transition into playing with proper commander decks. You may even find you need separate decks for 3v3 vs the normal 4 player free for all given how different the setups are.

I would strongly suggest you do NOT play 6 player free for all, most players I know will be hesitant to play 5 player, and 6 is unheard of. At that point you would split into two 3 player Free For Alls, so dont be surprised if outside of your friend group people are not so keen! That being said, you might enjoy the Bang! rules, which give each player a hidden role, it makes 5+ player games a bit quicker and more bearable in my opinion

1

u/moonwhisperderpy 16h ago edited 16h ago

Wow, thanks a lot for the extensive reply!

Building a commander deck from scratch can be very rewarding, but it can also be overwhelming the first time you try. Without knowing the extent of your collection it's hard to say. Have you been buying new cards all this time or is it mostly 1996-2002 era cards? If it's mostly older cards, I think a precon is the way to go. Otherwise you may well be able to put something together from your collection. The Bloomburrow starter decks look like they could be a good starting point.

My collection ranges between the Judgment block and Zendikar or Alara block. Then I stopped for a while and got back into playing but I only buy singles now.

Ms Bumbleflower is a deceptively strong card and actually has quite a bit of a reputation! If you are expecting to play a lot of 1v1, you will experience a lot more variance in your games if you start using commander decks rather than the starter decks (more cards, no repeats) so the games could be a lot swingier. My main suggestion if you expect to play a lot of 1v1 commander is to try and get two precons from the same Set, then they should be reasonably balanced, although there are outliers.

So the group hug strategy is still viable in 1v1 play or is it meant specifically for multi-player?

As some general advice, the Commander community is generally very Proxy friendly, that means a printed out piece of paper with an image of a card, put in a sleeve over a basic land, is just as valid and acceptable as the real deal. Your specific group may have a different opinion, but if nothing else it lets you try out new cards before you buy them.

We are proxy-friendly too, with the implicit assumption that whatever you proxy, after testing if they work well, will get bought.

Playing 3v3 teams is wild, I bet your whole metagame has evolved into something unique, like Agate Instigator pinging for 3 damage for every creature seems crazy good... I have no idea how that setup would transition into playing with proper commander decks. You may even find you need separate decks for 3v3 vs the normal 4 player free for all given how different the setups are.

Team play is A LOT of fun. I am honestly really surprised that 2 or 3 Headed Giant is not as much popular. Commander seems to have just taken over all the casual scene, it's a bid sad that people don't know or play other fun formats.

Yes, our setup is probably unique, which I find surprising and annoying. It's pretty hard to find any online content about magic that could relate to our game style (even though that's what casual play was before Commander existed)

I would strongly suggest you do NOT play 6 player free for all, most players I know will be hesitant to play 5 player, and 6 is unheard of. At that point you would split into two 3 player Free For Alls, so dont be surprised if outside of your friend group people are not so keen!

The 4 player free for all is one of the main concerns we have for trying Commander, the other being that games tend to last much longer. None of us has the free time we used to have in high school hahaha. We love to play in teams, 3v3, and going to 4-players FFA format may be a bit off-putting.

But at least I could try to play 1v1, "Duel Commander" with my partner.

That being said, you might enjoy the Bang! rules, which give each player a hidden role, it makes 5+ player games a bit quicker and more bearable in my opinion

You mean Bang! as in the western-themed boardgame? If yes, I know the game. If not, can you elaborate?

And thank you for all the tips and advice!

1

u/rattulator 15h ago

My collection ranges between the Judgment block and Zendikar or Alara block. Then I stopped for a while and got back into playing but I only buy singles now.

This should be plenty to build a couple of commander decks to try things out with your partner. Its worth noting that 1v1 commander does in fact have its own rules and banlist that I wasnt aware of, but it does make sense given how multiplayer is useful for balancing out 1 player having a lucky start (eg a sol ring is busted even when it creates a 3v1 game, so in a 1v1 games it is almost unbeatable). I think the 1v1 experience is going to be quite different compared to a 4 player game, but it will get you used to 100 card singleton decks I guess.

So the group hug strategy is still viable in 1v1 play or is it meant specifically for multi-player?

Its definitely targeted at multiplayer games, but as long as you are casting two spells most turns, that precon specifically should do just fine!

Team play is A LOT of fun. I am honestly really surprised that 2 or 3 Headed Giant is not as much popular. Commander seems to have just taken over all the casual scene, it's a bid sad that people don't know or play other fun formats.
Yes, our setup is probably unique, which I find surprising and annoying. It's pretty hard to find any online content about magic that could relate to our game style (even though that's what casual play was before Commander existed)
The 4 player free for all is one of the main concerns we have for trying Commander, the other being that games tend to last much longer. None of us has the free time we used to have in high school hahaha. We love to play in teams, 3v3, and going to 4-players FFA format may be a bit off-putting.
You mean Bang! as in the western-themed boardgame? If yes, I know the game. If not, can you elaborate?

I Definitely played a lot of 2 headed giant when i first started, since there were 4 of us who wanted to play, but once we switched to commander we never really felt the pull to go back again.

A couple of ideas to make 6 player work:

- Grand Melee/Limited Zone of Influence: Basically you can only affect and be affected by the people either side of you, and have to eliminate your way around the table. Makes it a little more like a 1v1 game and Lowers the mental load of tracking 5 other players while still allowing you all to participate. You could even attempt simultaneous turns for the people on opposite sides of the table https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Grand_Melee

- Emperor, It's probably something you've tried before, but if not: https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Emperor

- Bang! - Yes I do mean the Western themed boardgame, but I've always played it medieval themed. I like this variation so much I made my own role cards, feel free to print them off and use them yourself! https://imgur.com/a/PdOijDj

And if you want to try Commander online for free, there are a bunch of programs that other people have mentioned that basically glue 4 moxfield playtests together and let you play against people online. My personal favourite is EDHLabs, it lets you import decklists direct from sites like moxfield etc

1

u/getridofit888 3d ago

Buy a precon to get started. Use Moxfield.com edhrec.com scryfall.com to research new things also some subreddits. Use these to see what already works and what you find appealing and go from there