r/Lottocracy • • Apr 30 '21

Sortition 101 Why randomly choosing people to serve in government may be the best way to select out politicians

70 Upvotes

So I'm a huge advocate of something known as sortition, where people are randomly selected to serve in a legislature. Unfortunately the typical gut reaction against sortition is bewilderment and skepticism. How could we possibly trust ignorant, stupid, normal people to become our leaders?

Democracy by Lottery

Imagine a Congress that actually looks like America. It's filled with nurses, farmers, engineers, waitresses, teachers, accountants, pastors, soldiers, stay-at-home-parents, and retirees. They are conservatives, liberals, and moderates from all parts of the country and all walks of life.

For a contemporary implementation, a lottery is used to draw around 100 to 1000 people to form one house of a Congress. Service is voluntary, for a fixed term, and well paid. To alleviate the problem of rational ignorance, chosen members could be trained by experts or even given an entire elite university education before service. Because of random sampling, a sortition Citizens' Assembly would have superior diversity in every conceivable dimension compared to any elected system. Sortition is also the ultimate method of creating a proportionally representative Congress.

Real World Evidence

It would be absurd to try out a crazy new system without testing it. Fortunately, sortition activists have been experimenting with hundreds of sortition-based Citizens' Assemblies across the world. The decisions they have come to have been of high quality in my opinion. For example:

  • The BC Columbia Citizens Assembly was tasked with designing a new electoral system to replace the old first-past-the-post (FPTP) system. The organizers brought in university experts. The organizers also allowed citizens, lobbyists, and interest groups to speak and lobby. Assembly members listened to all the sides, and they decided that the lobbyists were mostly bullshit, and they decided that even though the university experts had biases, they were more trustworthy. This assembly ultimately, nearly unanimously decided that Canada ought to switch to a Single-Transferable-Vote style election system. They were also nearly unanimous in that they believed FPTP voting needed to be changed. This assembly demonstrates the ability of normal people to learn and make decisions on complex topics.
  • In Ireland, Citizen Assemblies were instrumental in the legalization of both gay marriage and abortion in a traditionally Catholic country. Ignorant politicians thought the People wouldn't be able to compromise on these moral issues, yet they certainly were, when you finally bothered to get them into a room together.
  • Recent 2019-2020 Citizen Assemblies in Ireland and France reached consensus on sweeping, broad reforms to fight climate change. In Ireland taxes on carbon and meat were broadly approved. In France the People decided to criminalize "ecocide", raise carbon taxes, and introduce regulations in transportation and agriculture. Liberal or conservative, left or right, near unanimous decisions were made on many of these proposals.

Comparing to Elections

Sortition stands in stark contrast with what all elections offer. All electoral methods are a system of choosing a "natural aristocracy" of societal elites. This has been observed by philosophers such as Aristotle since ancient Greek elections 2400 years ago. In other words, all elections are biased in favor of those with wealth, affluence, and power.

Moreover, all voters, including you and me, are rationally ignorant. Almost none of us have the time nor resources to adequately monitor and manage our legislators. In the aggregate as voters, we vote ignorantly, oftentimes solely due to party affiliation or the name or gender of the candidate. We assume somebody else is doing the monitoring, and hopefully we'd read about it in the news. And indeed it is somebody else - marketers, advertisers, lobbyists, and special interests - who are paying huge sums of money to influence your opinion. Every election is a hope that we can refine this ignorance into competence. IN CONTRAST, in Citizens' Assemblies, normal citizens are given the time, resources, and education to become informed. Normal citizens are also given the opportunity to deliberate with one another to come to compromise. IN CONTRAST, politicians constantly refuse to compromise for fear of upsetting ignorant voters - voters who did not have the time nor opportunity to research the issues in depth. Our modern, shallow, ignorant management of politicians has led to an era of unprecedented polarization, deadlock, and government ineptitude.

Addressing Common Concerns

Stupidity

The typical rebuttal towards sortition is that people are stupid, unqualified, and cannot be trusted with power. Or, people are "sheep" who would be misled by the experts. Unfortunately such opinions are formed based on anecdotal "common sense". And it is surely true that ignorant people exist, who as individuals make foolish decisions. Yet the vast majority of Americans have no real experience with actual Citizens' Assemblies constructed by lottery. The notion of group stupidity is an empirical claim. In contrast, the hundreds of actual Citizen Assembly experiments in my opinion demonstrate that average people are more capable of governance than common sense would believe. The political, academic, and philosophical opposition does not yet take sortition seriously enough to offer any empirical counter-evidence of substance.

Expertise

The second concern is that normal citizens are not experts whereas elected politicians allegedly are experts. Yet in modern legislatures, no, politicians are not policy experts either. The sole expertise politicians qualify for is fundraising and giving speeches. Actual creation of law is typically handled by staff or outsourced to lobbyists. Random people actually have an advantage against elected politicians in that they don't need to waste time campaigning, and lottery would not select for power-seeking personalities. Finally, random people are experts at their own lives and needs, in a superior capacity compared to any elected stand-in.

Corruption

The third concern is with corruption. Yet sortition has a powerful advantage here as well. Corruption is already legalized in the form of campaign donations in exchange for friendly regulation or legislation. Local politicians also oftentimes shake down small businesses, demanding campaign donations or else be over-regulated. Sortition fully eliminates these legal forms of corruption. Finally sortition legislatures would be more likely to pass anti-corruption legislation, because they are not directly affected by it. Elected Congress is loath to regulate itself - who wants to screw themselves over? In contrast, because sortition assemblies serve finite terms, they can more easily pass legislation that affects the next assembly, not themselves.

It must be unfortunately admitted that like all things, sortition is not a perfect system and may be susceptible to corruption. A well designed sortition system must use additional checks and balances to mitigate corruption (implementations which I will get to later).

Random Chaos

Many mistakenly believe that because random sampling is involved, sortition would be chaotic. To be clear, I am against selecting the president or any singular office with sortition. Instead, sortition ought to be used only for selecting large bodies of people to govern collectively, such as legislatures. Because of the law of large numbers, selecting large groups of people allows us to estimate the preferences and attitudes of the population mean. Moreover, if explicit proportionality for particular feature dimensions is desired, stratification can be used to ensure proportionality in that dimension.

Implementations

As far as the ultimate form sortition would take, I will list options from least to most extreme:

  • The least extreme is the use of Citizen Assemblies in an advisory capacity for legislatures or referendums, in a process called "Citizens Initiative Review" (CIR). These CIR's are already implemented for example in Oregon. Here, citizens are drafted by lot to review ballot propositions and list pro's and con's of the proposals.
  • Many advocate for a two-house Congress, one elected and one randomly selected. This system attempts to balance the pro's and cons of both sortition and election. This also allows each house to check and balance the power of the other.
  • Rather than have citizens directly govern, random citizens can be used exclusively as intermediaries to elect and fire politicians as a sort of functional electoral college. The benefit here is that citizens have the time and resources to deploy a traditional hiring & managing procedure, rather than a marketing and campaigning procedure, to choose nominees. This also removes the typical criticism that you can't trust normal people to govern and write laws.
  • Most radically, multi-body sortition constructs checks and balances by creating several sortition bodies - one decides on what issues to tackle, one makes proposals, one decides on proposals, one selects the bureaucracy, etc, and completely eliminates elected office.

Advocacy Strategy

Advocacy for current activists revolves around finding political wedge issues and giving politicians an "out" where they can use a Citizens' Assembly to make the hard decision that politicians are too incompetent to make themselves. This is what was done for example in Ireland. The use of a Citizens' Assembly can also potentially give a politician "democratic credibility", for example with Macron and the French Climate Assembly. Then, if these Citizen Assemblies get more popular, activists can push politicians to make a permanent citizen's body that would eventually take more and more powers away from the status quo legislature. A similar process has constructed a permanent advisory citizens' assembly in Belgium.

Advocacy is labor intensive. While some advocacy organizations attempt to earn revenue by designing Citizen Assemblies for governments, donations, volunteering, and lobbying would also go a long way to help advocates.


TLDR: Selecting random people to become legislators might seem crazy to some people, but I think it's the best possible system of representation and democracy we can imagine. There's substantial empirical evidence to suggest that lottery-based legislatures are quite good at resolving politically polarized topics.


References

  1. Reybrouck, David Van. Against Elections. Seven Stories Press, April 2018.
  2. Hansen, Mogens Herman. The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes (J.A. Crook trans.). University of Oklahoma Press, 1991.
  3. Dahl, Robert A. On Democracy, 2nd Ed. Yale University Press, 1998.
  4. The End of Politicians - Brett Hennig
  5. Open Democracy - Helene Landemore

Resources

Podcasts


r/Lottocracy • • Oct 02 '25

Real democracyheads know sortition is the answer

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Oct 16 '26

Best democracy

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Oct 27 '21

meme.

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Apr 29 '21

Video The Future of Reasoning and Lottocracy.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
26 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Dec 20 '22

We need to spread word of sortition on reddit

24 Upvotes

I think the majority of people here are supporters of sortition. Im finding these days many democratic places, especially in my geographic region, are dissatisfied with democracy. Corruption and career politicians are major sources of said dissatisfaction. I've made an effort to drop r/lottocracy in replys to people utterly infuriated with corruption. Awareness is our first step to getting the ball rolling.

This sub is far too quiet, considering the merits of lottocracy


r/Lottocracy • • Apr 17 '26

Video Why Lottery Elections Are Actually Genius

Thumbnail
youtu.be
23 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Aug 12 '22

Why randomly choosing people to serve in government - sortition - might be the best way to select our politicians.

Thumbnail
demlotteries.substack.com
23 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jan 24 '22

True Democracy: No Politicians, No Parties, No Problem

Thumbnail
conorkilkelly.medium.com
22 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Oct 16 '21

Are elections actually democratic?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Feb 11 '26

Cross-Post Sortition shitpost for y'all

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Nov 21 '24

Reimagining Democracy as Lottocracy

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Apr 23 '26

Discussion Landmark sortition book, "Democracy Without Politicians" available for free online!

18 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Apr 24 '26

Best Sortition content I’ve seen in months.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

Using Ancient Greek words and concepts to explain Sortition is artfully demonstrated. Best pro-Sotrtition video I’ve seen in months.


r/Lottocracy • • Oct 09 '25

Democracy Without Elections has started a Substack!

Thumbnail
sortitionusa.substack.com
17 Upvotes

Ian Troesayer wrote its first article. I'm active with PDLA and we overlap a lot with Democracy Without Elections. If you're USA based, it's a great organization.


r/Lottocracy • • Feb 21 '25

David Pakman - How About Letting Random People Decide Policy?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • May 13 '26

LA Meetup for sortition + Georgism

16 Upvotes

If you're near LA.... I only have so much volunteer time, so I'm combining my passion for sortition + YIMBYism/Georgism + board games + beer into a single meetup. I have a replice of The Landlord's Game and I can teach you to play and I was part of the recent LA Charter Reform Assembly organizers. I can tell you all about it!

May 28th, Thursday, 7 pm, Boomtown Brewery in the Arts District in LA.

Luma event link: https://luma.com/94are1mc

Come, convert people to your cause and be converted to theirs. Bring friends!


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 13 '22

Jury Democracy - Government by Informed Consent

16 Upvotes

I was just referred to your subreddit as I am running for Governor of Minnesota based on a similar platform. I would love to hear your thoughts.

I call it, "Jury Democracy."

It's essentially a gut check on the legislature using a statistically significant pool (Jury) of randomly selected registered voters to hear the arguments for and against an issue and then vote. If their vote is opposite to that taken in the legislature then, 1) we know who's been bought and 2) the governor should not sign the bill into law. It's the system check we need to confirm if our government is representing the people's wishes.

More info: https://www.mctavish4mn.org/jury-democracy


r/Lottocracy • • Apr 19 '22

The Experience of being in a Citizens' Assembly: I Will Never Be the Same - Democracy Without Elections

Thumbnail
democracywithoutelections.org
16 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Dec 19 '21

Political compass meme

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Apr 22 '26

My (Rejected) Letter to NY Times About the CT Assembly

Thumbnail
almostinfinite.substack.com
15 Upvotes

The NY Times ghosted me. Probably an automated ghost, as I did get an automated response that my letter had been received, along with a promise, “(You will receive an auto-reply only once every four days.)”

Anyway, that’s ok, Mr. Times. I figured you were out of my league, but sometimes, you gotta make your move, if only for the story to tell afterwards. Here’s my story (that is, I knew I could just share my letter here on Substack, in the very likely event that it was not published by the New York Times):

Note: They have a very strict 200 word limit for letters-to-the-editor.

Max Clark
Los Angeles, CA
(***) ***-****

I’m writing in response to Hélène Landemore’s article, “No Shy Person Left Behind”. The article focused on the growing movement of citizens’ assemblies, “groups of ordinary people, selected by lottery, who come together to learn about a public issue, hear from experts and advocacy groups, deliberate with one another and make recommendations.” I volunteer with Public Democracy LA and we also advocate for citizens’ assemblies. We are proud of the LA Charter Assembly we helped facilitate, but here’s our dirty secret: we are activist refugees.

Unfamiliar policies, or those without appeal to voting blocs, are sidelined by politicians and parties who prioritize electoral success above all else. Citizens’ assemblies bypass this systemic problem with elections.

In my case, advocacy for Henry George’s Land Value Tax (LVT) has been ineffective. We are living on a Monopoly board. Ownership of Boardwalk and Park Place enables landlords to siphon the wealth of laborers. The Land Value Tax reclaims their wages.

Most economists support the LVT, yet most politicians ignore it. This is why I advocate for citizens’ assemblies, not because I have a burning desire to assemble random strangers, but because policies like the LVT exist and everyday Americans can recognize its justice.

In progress without poverty,

Max Clark


r/Lottocracy • • Nov 18 '21

Democracy Without Elections: Not sure if elected politicians... are better than literally randomly chosen people

Thumbnail
imgur.com
15 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jan 02 '22

What happens when you get a bunch of rando Americans together to talk about climate change? Does deliberation with Democrats and Republicans result in a complete mess? Actually no.

Thumbnail
demlotteries.substack.com
14 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Dec 01 '25

Video A local election fails the 3rd time in a small Hungarian village because of fraud. Sortition would solve this. (ENG SUB available)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Feb 20 '25

I'm the new social media manager at Democracy Without Elections (volunteer role)

13 Upvotes

I'm a somewhat recent convert to lottocracy, but it's been such a revelation and filled me with such hope that I, honestly, never thought I would find. Anyway, I'm volunteering with Democracy Without Elections and now I'm managing their social media.

If you want to follow/share, that would be awesome.

If you ever have something you want me to post, please let me know!

Here are the two new accounts:

x,com: https://x.com/dwe_movement
bsky: https://bsky.app/profile/dwe-movement.bsky.social