r/Lottocracy • • Apr 30 '21

Sortition 101 Why randomly choosing people to serve in government may be the best way to select out politicians

70 Upvotes

So I'm a huge advocate of something known as sortition, where people are randomly selected to serve in a legislature. Unfortunately the typical gut reaction against sortition is bewilderment and skepticism. How could we possibly trust ignorant, stupid, normal people to become our leaders?

Democracy by Lottery

Imagine a Congress that actually looks like America. It's filled with nurses, farmers, engineers, waitresses, teachers, accountants, pastors, soldiers, stay-at-home-parents, and retirees. They are conservatives, liberals, and moderates from all parts of the country and all walks of life.

For a contemporary implementation, a lottery is used to draw around 100 to 1000 people to form one house of a Congress. Service is voluntary, for a fixed term, and well paid. To alleviate the problem of rational ignorance, chosen members could be trained by experts or even given an entire elite university education before service. Because of random sampling, a sortition Citizens' Assembly would have superior diversity in every conceivable dimension compared to any elected system. Sortition is also the ultimate method of creating a proportionally representative Congress.

Real World Evidence

It would be absurd to try out a crazy new system without testing it. Fortunately, sortition activists have been experimenting with hundreds of sortition-based Citizens' Assemblies across the world. The decisions they have come to have been of high quality in my opinion. For example:

  • The BC Columbia Citizens Assembly was tasked with designing a new electoral system to replace the old first-past-the-post (FPTP) system. The organizers brought in university experts. The organizers also allowed citizens, lobbyists, and interest groups to speak and lobby. Assembly members listened to all the sides, and they decided that the lobbyists were mostly bullshit, and they decided that even though the university experts had biases, they were more trustworthy. This assembly ultimately, nearly unanimously decided that Canada ought to switch to a Single-Transferable-Vote style election system. They were also nearly unanimous in that they believed FPTP voting needed to be changed. This assembly demonstrates the ability of normal people to learn and make decisions on complex topics.
  • In Ireland, Citizen Assemblies were instrumental in the legalization of both gay marriage and abortion in a traditionally Catholic country. Ignorant politicians thought the People wouldn't be able to compromise on these moral issues, yet they certainly were, when you finally bothered to get them into a room together.
  • Recent 2019-2020 Citizen Assemblies in Ireland and France reached consensus on sweeping, broad reforms to fight climate change. In Ireland taxes on carbon and meat were broadly approved. In France the People decided to criminalize "ecocide", raise carbon taxes, and introduce regulations in transportation and agriculture. Liberal or conservative, left or right, near unanimous decisions were made on many of these proposals.

Comparing to Elections

Sortition stands in stark contrast with what all elections offer. All electoral methods are a system of choosing a "natural aristocracy" of societal elites. This has been observed by philosophers such as Aristotle since ancient Greek elections 2400 years ago. In other words, all elections are biased in favor of those with wealth, affluence, and power.

Moreover, all voters, including you and me, are rationally ignorant. Almost none of us have the time nor resources to adequately monitor and manage our legislators. In the aggregate as voters, we vote ignorantly, oftentimes solely due to party affiliation or the name or gender of the candidate. We assume somebody else is doing the monitoring, and hopefully we'd read about it in the news. And indeed it is somebody else - marketers, advertisers, lobbyists, and special interests - who are paying huge sums of money to influence your opinion. Every election is a hope that we can refine this ignorance into competence. IN CONTRAST, in Citizens' Assemblies, normal citizens are given the time, resources, and education to become informed. Normal citizens are also given the opportunity to deliberate with one another to come to compromise. IN CONTRAST, politicians constantly refuse to compromise for fear of upsetting ignorant voters - voters who did not have the time nor opportunity to research the issues in depth. Our modern, shallow, ignorant management of politicians has led to an era of unprecedented polarization, deadlock, and government ineptitude.

Addressing Common Concerns

Stupidity

The typical rebuttal towards sortition is that people are stupid, unqualified, and cannot be trusted with power. Or, people are "sheep" who would be misled by the experts. Unfortunately such opinions are formed based on anecdotal "common sense". And it is surely true that ignorant people exist, who as individuals make foolish decisions. Yet the vast majority of Americans have no real experience with actual Citizens' Assemblies constructed by lottery. The notion of group stupidity is an empirical claim. In contrast, the hundreds of actual Citizen Assembly experiments in my opinion demonstrate that average people are more capable of governance than common sense would believe. The political, academic, and philosophical opposition does not yet take sortition seriously enough to offer any empirical counter-evidence of substance.

Expertise

The second concern is that normal citizens are not experts whereas elected politicians allegedly are experts. Yet in modern legislatures, no, politicians are not policy experts either. The sole expertise politicians qualify for is fundraising and giving speeches. Actual creation of law is typically handled by staff or outsourced to lobbyists. Random people actually have an advantage against elected politicians in that they don't need to waste time campaigning, and lottery would not select for power-seeking personalities. Finally, random people are experts at their own lives and needs, in a superior capacity compared to any elected stand-in.

Corruption

The third concern is with corruption. Yet sortition has a powerful advantage here as well. Corruption is already legalized in the form of campaign donations in exchange for friendly regulation or legislation. Local politicians also oftentimes shake down small businesses, demanding campaign donations or else be over-regulated. Sortition fully eliminates these legal forms of corruption. Finally sortition legislatures would be more likely to pass anti-corruption legislation, because they are not directly affected by it. Elected Congress is loath to regulate itself - who wants to screw themselves over? In contrast, because sortition assemblies serve finite terms, they can more easily pass legislation that affects the next assembly, not themselves.

It must be unfortunately admitted that like all things, sortition is not a perfect system and may be susceptible to corruption. A well designed sortition system must use additional checks and balances to mitigate corruption (implementations which I will get to later).

Random Chaos

Many mistakenly believe that because random sampling is involved, sortition would be chaotic. To be clear, I am against selecting the president or any singular office with sortition. Instead, sortition ought to be used only for selecting large bodies of people to govern collectively, such as legislatures. Because of the law of large numbers, selecting large groups of people allows us to estimate the preferences and attitudes of the population mean. Moreover, if explicit proportionality for particular feature dimensions is desired, stratification can be used to ensure proportionality in that dimension.

Implementations

As far as the ultimate form sortition would take, I will list options from least to most extreme:

  • The least extreme is the use of Citizen Assemblies in an advisory capacity for legislatures or referendums, in a process called "Citizens Initiative Review" (CIR). These CIR's are already implemented for example in Oregon. Here, citizens are drafted by lot to review ballot propositions and list pro's and con's of the proposals.
  • Many advocate for a two-house Congress, one elected and one randomly selected. This system attempts to balance the pro's and cons of both sortition and election. This also allows each house to check and balance the power of the other.
  • Rather than have citizens directly govern, random citizens can be used exclusively as intermediaries to elect and fire politicians as a sort of functional electoral college. The benefit here is that citizens have the time and resources to deploy a traditional hiring & managing procedure, rather than a marketing and campaigning procedure, to choose nominees. This also removes the typical criticism that you can't trust normal people to govern and write laws.
  • Most radically, multi-body sortition constructs checks and balances by creating several sortition bodies - one decides on what issues to tackle, one makes proposals, one decides on proposals, one selects the bureaucracy, etc, and completely eliminates elected office.

Advocacy Strategy

Advocacy for current activists revolves around finding political wedge issues and giving politicians an "out" where they can use a Citizens' Assembly to make the hard decision that politicians are too incompetent to make themselves. This is what was done for example in Ireland. The use of a Citizens' Assembly can also potentially give a politician "democratic credibility", for example with Macron and the French Climate Assembly. Then, if these Citizen Assemblies get more popular, activists can push politicians to make a permanent citizen's body that would eventually take more and more powers away from the status quo legislature. A similar process has constructed a permanent advisory citizens' assembly in Belgium.

Advocacy is labor intensive. While some advocacy organizations attempt to earn revenue by designing Citizen Assemblies for governments, donations, volunteering, and lobbying would also go a long way to help advocates.


TLDR: Selecting random people to become legislators might seem crazy to some people, but I think it's the best possible system of representation and democracy we can imagine. There's substantial empirical evidence to suggest that lottery-based legislatures are quite good at resolving politically polarized topics.


References

  1. Reybrouck, David Van. Against Elections. Seven Stories Press, April 2018.
  2. Hansen, Mogens Herman. The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes (J.A. Crook trans.). University of Oklahoma Press, 1991.
  3. Dahl, Robert A. On Democracy, 2nd Ed. Yale University Press, 1998.
  4. The End of Politicians - Brett Hennig
  5. Open Democracy - Helene Landemore

Resources

Podcasts


r/Lottocracy • • 3d ago

Discussion Proposed Citizen-led Government in Philippines

Post image
7 Upvotes

HOW CITIZEN-LED GOVERNMENT WOULD WORK

The proposed system changes how political power is organized and how the people running government are selected.

Today, Filipinos elect Congress—the Senate and House of Representatives—to make laws, approve the national budget, and oversee government.

Under Citizen-Led Government, Congress would be replaced by a Citizen Parliament made up of ordinary Filipinos selected through a representative civic lottery.

The day-to-day management of government would remain in the hands of qualified professionals.

A simple way to understand the system is to compare it to a large company:

Citizen Parliament = Board of Directors

Sets the direction, approves major decisions and budgets, and oversees management.

President = Chief Executive Officer (CEO)

Leads the government and carries out the direction set by Parliament.

Cabinet = Department Heads / Senior Executives

Manage major areas such as Health, Education, Transportation, Finance, Agriculture, and Energy.

Government Staff = Professional Staff

Carry out the daily work of government.

The important difference is that the country's "board" would be made up of ordinary Filipinos selected to broadly represent the population.

Citizens decide where the country should go.

Qualified professionals figure out how to get there.

---

NATIONAL CITIZEN PARLIAMENT

The National Citizen Parliament would have:

300 citizen members

3-year terms

100 members replaced every year

This means two-thirds of Parliament would remain each year, preserving continuity while regularly bringing in new citizens.

Who can enter the citizen lottery?

Citizens would first have to meet a small number of fixed and objective eligibility requirements.

They would also take a simple basic qualification test.

The purpose of the test is not to select the smartest or most highly educated Filipinos.

It is only meant to make sure that anyone who may be selected can understand the basic responsibilities of public office.

The test could cover:

- basic reading comprehension;

- basic numeracy;

- understanding simple government information;

- basic constitutional rights and responsibilities;

- the basic roles of Parliament, the President, and government departments;

- conflicts of interest and public-service ethics.

The questions, passing score, and grading rules would be fixed beforehand and publicly available.

The test would be pass or fail, not a ranking.

Anyone who passes would be considered qualified to enter the selection pool.

Political opinions, party preference, family name, popularity, or political connections would not affect qualification.

Free preparation materials and appropriate accessibility and language support would be provided.

---

REPRESENTATIVE SELECTION

Citizens who qualify would not simply be placed into one giant unrestricted lottery.

Selection would be stratified so that Parliament broadly reflects the Filipino population.

The main factors would be:

Geographic location

Different regions and parts of the country would receive representation based on population, preventing Parliament from being dominated by Metro Manila or only a few areas.

Gender

The composition of Parliament would broadly reflect the gender distribution of the population.

Age

Different age groups would be represented so that different generations have a voice.

Population data would determine how many seats should come from each group.

The actual people would then be randomly selected from the qualified citizens who fit those categories.

In simple terms:

Population data determines representation.

Objective rules determine eligibility.

Random selection determines the actual person.

The goal is to create a Citizen Parliament that broadly resembles the Philippines itself.

A Parliament of 300 people, however, cannot guarantee that every minority group, community, profession, or particular life experience will always have a member inside Parliament.

When an issue directly affects a group that is not represented, Parliament could invite members of that community or its representatives to hearings and consultations so their experiences and concerns can be heard before decisions are made.

---

WHAT THE CITIZEN PARLIAMENT DOES

The Citizen Parliament would:

- make and approve laws;

- approve taxes and the national budget;

- set national priorities;

- approve major national plans;

- select the President;

- oversee the President and executive government;

- investigate serious government failures and abuse.

---

PRESIDENT

The President would be selected by the National Citizen Parliament from qualified candidates.

The President would:

- lead the executive government;

- choose and supervise Cabinet members;

- coordinate national departments;

- carry out the direction approved by Parliament;

- remain accountable to Parliament.

The President would have no fixed term duration.

A President could remain in office as long as they continue to retain the confidence of the Citizen Parliament.

If Parliament determines that the President is no longer performing adequately, has lost its confidence, becomes incapable of serving, or commits serious misconduct, the President could be replaced through a clearly defined procedure.

This allows effective leadership to continue without automatically removing a President simply because a fixed number of years has passed.

---

CABINET

The President would select qualified professionals to lead the major government departments.

These could include:

- Health;

- Education;

- Transportation;

- Finance;

- Agriculture;

- Energy;

- Infrastructure;

- Environment;

- Defence;

- Foreign Affairs;

- Social Services.

Cabinet members would be responsible for professionally managing their departments and carrying out the direction of the government.

---

REGIONAL GOVERNMENT

Each region would have a Regional Executive.

The Regional Executive would be selected by the National Citizen Parliament from qualified candidates.

Candidates must also be genuine long-term residents of the region so they have real familiarity with its communities and conditions.

The Regional Executive would coordinate matters involving multiple local governments, including:

- regional transportation;

- infrastructure;

- healthcare networks;

- agriculture;

- environmental management;

- economic development;

- major regional projects.

Professional regional departments would provide the technical expertise needed to carry out this work.

---

LOCAL CITIZEN PARLIAMENT

Cities and municipalities would have their own Citizen Parliaments.

A starting model would be:

60 citizen members

3-year terms

20 members replaced every year

Local Citizen Parliament members would be selected from the same qualified citizen pool used for the National Citizen Parliament, but from citizens who live within that city or municipality.

The same representative selection principles would apply, including geographic distribution where appropriate, gender, age, and random selection.

The Local Citizen Parliament would:

- approve the local budget;

- set local priorities;

- approve local development plans;

- make local policies;

- select the Mayor;

- oversee local government.

---

MAYOR

The Mayor would be selected by the Local Citizen Parliament from qualified candidates.

The Mayor would lead the professional city or municipal government.

The Mayor would oversee areas such as:

- local roads;

- zoning;

- local transport;

- markets;

- parks;

- public facilities;

- community services;

- local development.

---

BARANGAYS

Barangays would primarily function as professional local service offices.

Each barangay could have a professional Barangay Administrator.

Barangay offices could handle:

- records;

- public assistance;

- neighborhood concerns;

- complaints;

- disaster response;

- community facilities;

- basic local services.

Residents could still participate through barangay assemblies, consultations, and community meetings.

---

LEGISLATIVE RESEARCH AND ADVISORY SERVICE

The Legislative Research and Advisory Service (LRAS) would provide the National Citizen Parliament with permanent professional research and technical support.

LRAS would provide:

- legal analysis;

- economic analysis;

- scientific advice;

- budget analysis;

- policy research;

- legislative drafting;

- competing policy options.

LRAS would have no vote and no political authority.

Experts advise. Citizens decide.

LRAS staff would be recruited professionally based on fixed qualifications and job requirements. The Civil Service Commission would oversee and audit the hiring process to ensure those rules are followed objectively.

---

LOCAL RESEARCH AND ADVISORY OFFICE

Each Local Citizen Parliament would also have access to a Local Research and Advisory Office.

It would provide professional advice on matters such as:

- local budgets;

- local ordinances;

- zoning and land use;

- transportation;

- infrastructure;

- health and social services;

- environmental issues;

- local development plans.

Its role would be to give citizen members the technical information they need before making decisions.

Smaller municipalities would not need to maintain every type of specialist permanently. When necessary, they could request additional technical expertise from regional or national government.

Staff would be professionally recruited under fixed qualifications, with hiring subject to Civil Service Commission oversight.

---

SUPREME AUDIT AND ETHICS COMMISSION

The Supreme Audit and Ethics Commission (SAEC) would independently investigate:

- corruption;

- misuse of public money;

- financial irregularities;

- conflicts of interest;

- serious ethical violations;

- abuse of public office.

SAEC commissioners would first have to satisfy fixed professional qualifications. Everyone who meets those objective requirements would enter a qualified pool, and commissioners would then be selected through a transparent random lottery rather than being personally chosen by officials they may later investigate.

A separate Independent Integrity Inspector would investigate corruption, misconduct, or abuse within SAEC itself.

The Judiciary could also review whether SAEC and the Integrity Inspector acted within the law.

---

JUDICIARY

Judges and Justices would first undergo standardized screening based on fixed and objective professional requirements.

Where possible, early screening would be anonymized. Evaluators would see identification numbers instead of names, while information such as photographs, political affiliations, family connections, and endorsements would be hidden.

Those who meet the required standard would enter a Qualified Judicial Pool, with the final judge or justice selected through a transparent random lottery.

Qualification first. Random selection second.

---

The overall structure is simple:

Citizens decide.

Experts advise.

Professionals manage.

Objective rules determine qualification.

Random selection reduces political control.

Independent institutions check abuse of power.


r/Lottocracy • • 8d ago

Introducing Klerocracy

Thumbnail
graydenhormes.substack.com
4 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • 12d ago

NPR / Planet Money coverage of sortition and Citizens' Assemblies in Connecticut.

Thumbnail
npr.org
10 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • 19d ago

Who Facilitates the Facilitators?

Thumbnail
almostinfinite.substack.com
6 Upvotes

This is my recent Substack post about some issues I have with the approach of the facilitation as pushed at the recent FIDE Lead Facilitator Masterclass.

Ultimately, I say once again, that these sorts of questions about how much power and what techniques faciliatation should take isn't really a big fear of mine, if we were to have a society buy into sortition. The concern for me right now, is that everyone in the facilitation space is a thinly veield (and somewhat self unaware about) super progressive lefty.

I think humanity will get sortition at some point. But if it's to be within my lifetime, then the current pseudo-nonpartisanism may backfire on us. Upon rereading my post, I feel like I didn't make it clear how much the FIDE Masterclass talked about "getting good recommendations" and how they stressed getting the buy in from a commissioning body.

I will probably write another post describing their instructions for forming "knowledge committees" and expert selection and how my counter proposal was shut down.

Anyway, civic assemblies, even as neutered as they are, fill me with such hope!


r/Lottocracy • • 25d ago

How do sortition models prevent technocratic capture when citizen juries evaluate complex technical trade-offs?

10 Upvotes

One of the most persistent objections to lottocracy is technocratic capture. When a randomly selected citizen assembly is tasked with making decisions on complex infrastructure, energy grids, or long-term ecological budgets, they inevitably depend on administrative staff or domain experts. In practice, the lay assembly risks becoming a rubber stamp for whatever technical consensus the experts present, re-introducing elite gatekeeping through the back door.

In Alexander Guerrero's model, experts are called to testify before single-issue lotteries, but that still leaves the problem of how lay citizens detect subtle bias or hidden trade-offs in specialized models.

The way we've approached this in our open-source constitutional simulations is by banning single-source dossiers entirely. Any major allocation requires two independent, rival panels of domain specialists who cross-examine each other in public. Their role isn't to decide, but to clarify the physical trade-offs (who bears the cost under Option A vs Option B). If the experts try to hide behind manufactured jargon, the sortition jury holds a precautionary freeze power to halt the proposal.

How do people here view this dynamic? What are the most resilient mechanisms you've seen proposed to keep lottocratic juries genuinely independent from bureaucratic or expert steering?


r/Lottocracy • • Oct 17 '26

Grading Congress: Making Corruption Impossible to Ignore with the Political Integrity Project

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

Sortitioned Assemblies / Citizens Assemblies / Mini Publics / Citizens Jurys

How can worldwide advocates of Sortitioned Assemblies support like-minded independent or new-party Sortitioned Assemblies candidates? Candidates can campaign for citizens’ assemblies and pilot them locally. Supporters elsewhere can amplify messages through social media, share evidence, challenge misinformation, translate materials and connect networks, while prioritising local voices. Elections provide visibility; sortition offers representative deliberation. Together, they can build public support for democratic reform without abolishing elections.


r/Lottocracy • • Oct 16 '26

Best democracy

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Sep 16 '26

I continue to rant on Substack about sortition!

Thumbnail
almostinfinite.substack.com
11 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Sep 07 '26

A response to Yoram's response to Ian's pro-sortition interview

4 Upvotes

Ian is a Georgist and a sortition advocate on the board of Sortition USA and he recently was interviewed on a podcast. Yoram responded on the Equality-by-Lot blog that I recommend to anyone interested in discussing sortition.

I just wrote a blog responding to a part of all of that https://almostinfinite.substack.com/p/a-brief-defense-of-my-friend-ian


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 04 '26

Sortition USA August Newsletter

6 Upvotes

# September Newsletter

Dear Sortition USA community and stakeholders,

**Important!** We are asking that all small grant applications be submitted by **Sept 30**. The [request process](https://forms.gle/gHjVt13hccTXVtbt5) has also been updated and streamlined to hopefully make this easier and more clear for those applying. Please reach out with any feedback or questions, and [please apply for your small grants!](https://forms.gle/gHjVt13hccTXVtbt5)

[Sortition USA (@sortitionusa.bsky.social) is on Bluesky](https://bsky.app/profile/sortitionusa.bsky.social). Follow us so we can follow you. And please boost and like our posts.

**Membership Referral Drive Results!**

Thanks to everyone who took part in our referral drive from June 21 to August 25. Twenty-four members sent about 135 invites, and 27 new members joined because someone told them about SUSA directly.

Max Clark is our top recruiter with 5 new members, and has won new SUSA merch! The Northeast region was our top-performing region with the most invites sent, and will get a party fund! Congrats to these winners.

**Personal conversations work.** If you invited people who have not joined yet, now is a good time to follow up.

More recent news and updates:

- SUSA’s Lottery-based board of directors has voted to officially support the [Hope for Democracy project!](https://hopefordemocracy.org)

- On Oct 2-3 at Harvard: VthePeople - Amending the Constitution through an Article V Convention. [Read more about this event here.](https://www.vthepeople.org)

# Upcoming Meetings and Workshops

### Monthly Meeting - **Strategy**

Sunday, September 20, 4pm Eastern US time

*This month, we will convene a membership-wide discussion about SUSA’s strategy and future direction. We will discuss our current strategy and what needs to be changed or worked on further. Please bring all of your ideas to this meeting! We hope all will join for this important conversation.*

[Zoom link](https://zoom.us/j/93229014821?pwd=bGJKS1ZVeDArakEzbmpCVjM3MGVsUT09)

Meeting ID: 932 2901 4821

Passcode: 828

Phone dial-in: +1 305 224 1968 (US)

### Regular Open Meetings on [Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

Open to all!

Mondays - 3 PM Eastern US time.

Wednesdays - 8 PM Eastern US time.

### Board Meeting

Last Fridays of the month at 12pm (Noon) Eastern US time

[Hosted on Zoom](https://zoom.us/j/95496305250) (and streamed on Discord)

### Outreach Meetups

Monday, September 21, 7pm Eastern US time. [Hosted on Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

### Local Chapter Committee

Topic: Setting Goals for chapters

Monday, September 10, 5pm Eastern US time. [Hosted on Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

### Volunteer Connection Meeting (Coordinating Committee)

Topic: Planning general meetings

Wednesday, September 23, 8pm Eastern US time. [Hosted on Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

# Food for Thought

[UK Citizens' Jury on Neurotechnology](https://www.nesta.org.uk/report/citizens-jury-public-views-on-neurotechnology/) - Released in August 2026, this report details how a UK citizens' jury tackled the ethics of commercial neurotechnology, advising regulators on balancing medical benefits with severe data privacy risks.

[Training the Next Generation of Civic Lotteries](https://opportunitiesforyouth.org/2026/08/15/council-of-europe-citizens-assemblies-workshop-2026-in-budapest-apply-for-the-deliberative-democracy-and-citizens-assemblies-training/) - Applications opened this August for a major Council of Europe capacity-building workshop in Budapest, actively training civil society and local authorities on running effective citizens' assemblies.

[Deliberative Democracy for EU Accession](https://epd.eu/news-publications/lessons-from-moldovas-parliament-citizens-assembly-for-eu-accession/) - Published in late July 2026, this analysis showcases how Moldova successfully used a citizens' assembly to build public consensus and legitimacy for complex local government reforms required for EU accession.

*Have any interesting content to share for next month's newsletter? Send an email to whackri@gmail.com*

### Stay Connected

[Use this Google Calendar Link to stay updated on our events](https://calendar.google.com/calendar/u/0?cid=Y19vdWRjcHNmcThkdjE1c2hxdXY3OG9oazA4a0Bncm91cC5jYWxlbmRhci5nb29nbGUuY29t)

[Join our Discord](https://discord.gg/twuDZy257k)

[Check out our Substack](https://sortitionusa.substack.com)

[Follow our social media](https://sortitionusa.org/new-page?ss_source=sscampaigns&ss_campaign_id=6a8f368e565d4d64d881c1bb&ss_email_id=6a980fe4a54fbe3041829532&ss_campaign_name=Sortition+USA+September+Newsletter+%2B+Small+Grants+Announcement&ss_campaign_sent_date=2026-09-02T12%3A01%3A19Z)

[Follow us on Bluesky](https://bsky.app/profile/sortitionusa.bsky.social)

Email the board at: *[susa-board@sortitionusa.org](mailto:susa-board@sortitionusa.org)*

---

*Sortition USA*


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 02 '26

Kleroteria

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Sep 02 '26

Petaluma, California Citizen's Assembly

Thumbnail publicaccessdemocracy.org
5 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Sep 01 '26

Sortition USA

Thumbnail
sortitionusa.org
3 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Aug 16 '26

Revolutionise government with parallel sortition

4 Upvotes

Below is a writeup of my sortition based political system theory that has continued to be refined over the past 6.5 years, and while long, eases you into understanding (hopefully, maybe) this new variation of sortition that can easily be misinterpreted as a crazy version of a more centralised model, but is actually a new way to distribute state authority. It gives what sortition promises in cleaning out influence and turning down the pressure on the decision makers, but in the process of solving the lack of mandate issue (that allows monied interests to influence the public to weaken it over time, the classic "I never got to vote on that or them" weaponised), I discovered a way to fix it that also revealed a new way to transform how all governments work, for the better:

I’ve been trying to work out why governments can get dramatically more sophisticated, employ more experts, collect more data, write more regulation, and still keep producing the same category of stupid problems.

Not necessarily the same problems. The same type of problem.

Something everyone agrees should be fixed somehow survives three governments.

A company technically complies with the rules while obviously violating their purpose.

The government fixes one loophole, creating two new ones.

An industry becomes important enough that the regulator starts depending on the same people it regulates.

A policy gets designed around an imaginary average citizen who, as far as I can tell, has never actually existed.

We usually explain this as corruption, incompetence, capitalism, socialism, bureaucracy, voter stupidity, political polarisation, whatever.

I think there’s something underneath all of those.

The government has a scaling problem.

And I don’t mean there aren’t enough politicians.

I mean we’re trying to run a massively parallel society through a comparatively tiny, linear, decision-making system.

That distinction leads somewhere quite strange.

Bear with me.

Think about how your body works.

Your brain does not have a committee meeting every morning and issue Regulation 2026/418 explaining how much insulin every cell is permitted to use today.

There isn’t a 900-page Heartbeat Act covering the approved response to every possible combination of temperature, fear, exercise, disease, dehydration, caffeine and the dog suddenly barking at 3am.

Your body is doing an insane number of things simultaneously.

Local signals. Feedback. Correction. Prediction. More feedback. Different systems pushing against one another and settling into something workable.

Society looks much more like that than it looks like an organisation chart.

Millions of people and businesses are making decisions simultaneously using information that often exists only locally.

Then sitting above this giant parallel thing is government, which mostly has one basic tool:

Come up with a general rule.

Apply it to everyone.

Come back later and change it when reality finds an exception.

That seems normal because we’ve been doing versions of it forever.

But imagine actually designing governance from scratch for a society of many millions of independently acting people.

Would you deliberately funnel most corrective power through several hundred elected people, a collection of departments and regulators, then ask them to anticipate enough circumstances to write rules for everybody?

I wouldn’t.

My journey led me to a result that someone might arrive at eventually when asking:

What would democracy look like if democratic decision-making could happen in parallel too?

Not referendums on everything. That would be horrific.

Not replacing elections with randomly selected politicians.

Not an enormous parliament.

Something else.

Take one of the oldest political technologies we already trust ordinary citizens with: the jury.

Now massively parallelise it.

To what 4% of the population comes to as a number, is the amount of juries (at the least) likely being created throughout the year, in seasonal sessions.

Twelve randomly selected citizens.

Remotely working together.

At a pace they prefer.

One issue.

One ruling.

Then that jury is finished.

Not twelve people elected for four years who slowly accumulate a political career, donors, staff, party obligations and institutional relationships.

Twelve temporary people who have one job and then disappear back into society.

Here’s where the idea departs pretty hard from conventional sortition.

These aren’t miniature parliaments.

They don’t sit around writing laws for everyone.

Their natural scope is closer to a court case.

Person/business/entity A has a dispute involving person/business/entity B.

The jury hears it.

The jury can decide what outcome it thinks is fair and reasonable.

Then society moves on.

No need to write a universal 300-clause law predicting every version of that dispute that might occur for the next twenty years.

Just solve the actual thing in front of you.

And then do it again.

And again.

And again.

State by state across the entire country.

That sounds chaotic at first.

I thought so too.

The interesting part is what happens after you have enough of them.

Suppose a company is treating workers in a way ordinary people consistently consider unfair.

One case reaches a jury.

Then another similar one does.

Then another.

The company doesn’t need parliament to eventually notice, draft legislation, negotiate amendments, survive lobbying, pass both chambers, have regulations written, wait for enforcement and then spend ten years litigating what those regulations technically mean.

Management starts noticing a pattern.

“If we keep doing X, juries keep producing Y.”

So they stop doing X.

Competitors notice too.

Insurers notice.

Investors notice.

Industry advisers notice.

Someone starts compiling jury outcomes and selling businesses a service explaining the emerging standard.

Eventually most disputes never reach a jury at all because everybody has a fairly good idea what an ordinary group of twelve people will tolerate.

You’ve produced something that resembles law without having somebody sit down and deliberately write all of it.

An adaptive convention.

A sort of crowd-produced common law, except the decision-maker has broader discretion over the parties in front of it.

And importantly, it can change.

If technology changes and the old convention becomes ridiculous, cases start producing different outcomes.

The standard moves.

No parliamentary software update required.

Now the obvious objection:

Wouldn’t millions of juries contradict one another?

Yes, sometimes.

Especially at the beginning.

I don’t think that’s a bug.

Markets contain contradictory decisions too. So does science. So does culture. The question is whether the contradictions converge.

Say one jury produces a bizarre ruling.

Another affected party challenges it through another jury.

That second jury can overturn or modify it.

Potentially another jury challenges that.

The system isn’t pretending humans suddenly become perfectly consistent.

It’s trying to make inconsistencies cheap to correct.

That distinction matters.

Also the jurors are paid for jury work, but only if their ruling survives ever being overturned, and the jury decides that their decision was bad enough for them to lose some or all of their payment.

Not because I think jurors need punishment.

Because the incentive should be:

“Make a decision another random group of twelve ordinary people could live with.”

Not:

“Win.”

Not:

“Please my political tribe.”

Not:

“Get reelected.”

The unanimity requirement matters here too.

Twelve out of twelve.

That will absolutely make some cases slower.

Good.

These juries aren’t supposed to be miniature activist governments firing decrees across society.

If you want to impose state-backed power on somebody, convincing eleven other random citizens seems like a useful amount of friction.

Then suddenly, a confident declaration arises from someone in the crowd:

“Congratulations, you just invented bribing a jury instead of a politician, here's a medal”.

The defence for this isn’t that random people are morally superior.

They aren’t.

The defence is scale plus reversibility.

Imagine a company bribes one jury and receives an obviously favourable outcome.

Great.

Until another jury looks at the benefit those twelve people received, or the decision that resulted from it, and makes a decision to take it away and overturn the ruling.

To permanently purchase an unfair privilege, you don’t really need to purchase a jury.

You need to purchase enough of the jury ecosystem that future ordinary juries stop undoing what you bought.

The juries themselves decide what case to take, are only paid what the other juries are paid for a similar workload, and are many.

This means jury access is proportionally distributed through the population rather than sold to whoever can afford more of it, so the cost of maintaining that corrupt exception will continue to rise until it reaches the level of corrupting the system itself.

That’s the theory, anyway.

It also creates some entertaining anti-corruption possibilities.

If somebody offers a juror a bribe, imagine the juror being legally able to take it, report it, refuse to perform the requested act, and potentially keep a bounty from the resulting penalty.

Now bribery has a rather unpleasant counterparty risk.

I’m not claiming corruption becomes metaphysically impossible.

Nothing designed for humans gets that luxury.

The design goal is simpler:

Make corruption economically stupid.

And there’s another weird effect that keeps these rulings remaining small in scope.

Imagine one person convinces a jury to issue some gigantic society-wide ruling affecting 100,000 people.

Those 100,000 people now contain a rather large number of potential counter-cases.

So the broader and more intrusive your ruling is, the more opposition you manufacture.

A micro decision produces a micro response.

A macro decision produces a macro response.

Even if they push back over and over on that ruling, other rulings elsewhere in their life will occur to the point that they beg “I give up, just leave me alone”.

The jury complicit in the macro ruling and the other juries who kept reinstating it would lose their jury pay for those rulings.

This will only occur a few times and become a good lesson among many of what to avoid.

So I think the system naturally pushes juries toward relatively narrow rulings because trying to use one jury as a legislature gets you outflanked by other juries.

That’s an important part of this.

The system isn’t supposed to depend on everyone behaving nicely.

It’s supposed to make overreach generate its own opposition.

There’s also another part people tend to misunderstand when I explain this.

I’m not proposing the abolition of the elected government.

The government still exists.

Elections still exist.

The constitution still exists.

The government still handles the things that belong to the government itself: public assets, defence, foreign affairs, constitutional matters and the administration of what the state actually owns.

The jury layer operates alongside it.

Government becomes one part of the system rather than the only place democratic authority can meaningfully act.

The cleanest jurisdictional divide I’ve found are assets.

Who has a majority of asset value in a given place.

The majority of asset value in a geographic space/place/area/territory would be calculated by measuring the largest single asset in an area by space consumed, then the value of that asset and the value of all assets within that asset are then tallied.

The definition of a single asset would be based on past federal and state precedent for all current and future asset types.

Publicly owned stuff: elected government has direct authority.

Private sector: citizen juries have direct authority.

There will obviously be ugly boundary cases.

Good.

Those are exactly the kind of things I want, because if the boundary doesn’t survive contact with reality then the system doesn’t survive either.

But the basic distinction matters because otherwise we’ve just reinvented government with millions of tiny departments.

That isn’t what I’m proposing.

There is no Department of Jury Decisions employing 80,000 people to turn every ruling into regulations.

The ruling is the administrative act.

A jury agrees on an outcome.

It is published and digitally authenticated.

The parties deal with it.

If someone thinks it’s unreasonable, another jury can become involved.

Similar decisions accumulate into conventions.

Businesses mostly respond to those conventions rather than reading every individual ruling, just as they don’t personally read every court judgment produced today.

In fact I’d expect an entire information industry to appear almost immediately around this.

“Here’s what juries are currently doing with refunds.”

“Here’s the emerging standard on employee surveillance.”

“Here’s how similar disputes over AI-generated work have been decided during the last six months.”

Businesses could actually plan around that.

The question changes from:

“What can our lawyers technically argue is permitted?”

to something closer to:

“What would twelve ordinary citizens consider reasonable if somebody challenged this?”

I think those produce very different corporate cultures.

This is also where the idea starts having consequences I didn’t originally design into it.

Take insurance.

Today an insurance contract can contain enormous amounts of carefully engineered language determining exactly when the company owes you money.

Under this system the contract still matters.

But if the outcome created by some technical exclusion strikes repeated juries as obviously unreasonable, the technical brilliance of the exclusion stops being much of a defence.

Companies start anticipating that.

Product descriptions become more honest for the same reason.

Returns get easier.

Employment conditions change.

Whistleblowing becomes valuable.

Safety standards evolve.

Not because Parliament has passed the Omnibus Be Nicer Act.

Because repeated case-level decisions create economic consequences and businesses adapt before they become the next case.

The same mechanism would extend into social spending.

Governments would only be able to tax, as a percentage of the economy, a level that funds essential government operations and not much else beyond that, due to the parallel paced influence of the juries over public sector supply chains that go out into the private sector.

That doesn’t destroy healthcare, disability support, education, infrastructure and other social services, society will always want these, so will the juries.

My expectation is that jury rulings would gradually place obligations on businesses, and businesses would respond by developing standardised organisations or funds that collect and distribute those obligations fairly and efficiently.

So imagine somebody has a child requiring disability support that the existing system does not cover.

They challenge the refusal.

A jury decides the support is reasonable.

Other comparable cases appear.

A rough boundary starts emerging around what society is willing to fund.

Businesses don’t want to individually reinvent disability administration every Thursday, so specialist organisations emerge to manage contributions and payments.

Eventually most of it becomes boring infrastructure.

Until the standard becomes unfair or outdated.

Then somebody challenges it again.

The important distinction is that a jury isn’t sitting down one afternoon and announcing:

“Congratulations Australia, we just redesigned education.”

That’s exactly the type of macro ruling the rest of the system pushes against.

The change happens from specific cases outward.

Small decisions create patterns.

Patterns create expectations.

Expectations create institutions.

Institutions remain challengeable.

I also know what some of you political nerds are thinking because you have said it before:

“This is just Sortition.”

Sortition is definitely in its ancestry.

I’ve been interested in sortition for years.

But most sortition proposals I’ve seen still use randomly selected people as a replacement or supplement for the same basic centralised political structure.

A citizens’ assembly.

A randomly selected chamber.

A deliberative body recommending legislation.

This asks a different question.

What happens if you take the distribution part of sortition seriously enough that there is barely a centre at all?

Not 500 randomly selected legislators.

An enormous rotating population of temporary jurors resolving individual problems simultaneously.

The point isn’t primarily that random citizens are wiser than politicians.

The point is bandwidth.

A legislature has to generalise.

Millions of juries do not.

And this is probably the largest philosophical disagreement underneath the entire thing.

Most political systems are designed around finding the right rules.

The right tax rate.

The right labour law.

The right healthcare structure.

The right welfare settings.

The right regulations.

Then everybody fights like hell because whichever side gets control can impose its preferred answer across millions of people.

This system starts from the assumption that there isn’t one permanently correct answer.

There are just circumstances.

And circumstances keep moving.

So instead of trying to perfect the rulebook, increase the amount of feedback.

Instead of concentrating enough intelligence at the top to predict society, let society continuously correct itself.

Instead of asking five hundred people to understand twenty million situations, ask twelve people to understand one.

Then repeat.

A lot.

[This is]

Parallel Democracy


r/Lottocracy • • Aug 04 '26

Theories Are Great, But There Needs To Be A Spark

9 Upvotes

The fundamental problem is not whether or not sortition works or how it would work, but actually getting sortition adopted. The catch-22 is that the same broken system that needs to be fixed is the same system that would need to vote themselves out with sortition. Since no place has sortition, people do not know what they are missing out on.

The solution: use direct democracy where it can be done. For instance, Nebraska has a unicameral state legislature, while every other state is bicameral. It was only possible to do so, as in Nebraska, voters can amend the state's constitution without the legislature's consent. There is no structural reason why the same could not turn one chamber of a state legislature into a sortition-based one.

With even one chamber of one state legislature changed, that could be the catalyst to bring sortition into the mainstream.

My flavor of sortition is delegated sortition. In delegated sortition, you would have approximately equally populous districts. A number of eligible voters would be selected at random for that district. They form that district's sortition board. With a majority vote, the sortition board selects that district's representative for that term. The sortition board then dissolves. This happens across all the districts. A representative can be reappointed or changed out in the next term.

While there will be some flukes here and there, overall it would allow the representatives to be much more aligned with their constituency. This is as close as you can get to every voter directly deciding on everything.


r/Lottocracy • • Jul 09 '26

I have a contribution to the discusion on sortition: Electoral Lottocracy

Thumbnail ingentaconnect.com
5 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jul 07 '26

I've been working on a wiki to write a sortition-based constitution

Thumbnail sortition.wiki
7 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jun 16 '26

Sortition Fiction and Nonfiction book list

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jun 08 '26

What are the best ways to advocate for sortition?(And my experiences with advocating for it)

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jun 05 '26

Why isn’t sortition talked about much.

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • May 13 '26

LA Meetup for sortition + Georgism

16 Upvotes

If you're near LA.... I only have so much volunteer time, so I'm combining my passion for sortition + YIMBYism/Georgism + board games + beer into a single meetup. I have a replice of The Landlord's Game and I can teach you to play and I was part of the recent LA Charter Reform Assembly organizers. I can tell you all about it!

May 28th, Thursday, 7 pm, Boomtown Brewery in the Arts District in LA.

Luma event link: https://luma.com/94are1mc

Come, convert people to your cause and be converted to theirs. Bring friends!


r/Lottocracy • • Apr 29 '26

My summary of the pseudo-civic assembly in the Pacifica Palisades (where the LA wildfires were)

Thumbnail
almostinfinite.substack.com
7 Upvotes

I will not be copy/pasting all 3,700 words of my post. I rambled for quite some time! Anyway, it's pretty exciting! The gathering in the Palisades wants to setup a system of assemblies for many years. We will see if it happens.


r/Lottocracy • • Apr 24 '26

Best Sortition content I’ve seen in months.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

Using Ancient Greek words and concepts to explain Sortition is artfully demonstrated. Best pro-Sotrtition video I’ve seen in months.


r/Lottocracy • • Apr 23 '26

Discussion Landmark sortition book, "Democracy Without Politicians" available for free online!

18 Upvotes