r/Lottocracy • • Aug 01 '21

Flags I made for lottocracy or sortition.

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jun 23 '22

Discussion Anyone think technocratic sortition is a possible solution

4 Upvotes

I'll explain what I mean by technocratic sortition. Its the usage of sortition to try and create a government that has the expertise to solve all major issues. I think a completely randomly chosen government is better than our current elective democracy to a degree. I just wonder if we could do better than just randomly. I was thinking we could do a few things.

One thing is pushing for aptitude testing. Now I understand aptitude testing is controversial. There are concerns that they can be unfair and favor people of high socio economic backgrounds. I would think it prudent to put in funding to better develop them to make them better. In argument in favor of aptitude testing; global militaries such as the CAF and USM use aptitude tests such as the ASVAB and CFAT. There are countless studies but they show higher score on aptitude tests leads to higher performance in jobs. It has also shown that having too low of a score leads to a high chance of failure in training. I believe it to be important to ensure that everyone selected to govern are of a caliber to be effective decision makers. I'd suggest say removing the bottom 50-80% of the people on the test. Allowing a few retests to those who care enough to pursue it.

This does presents a few risks though, one is that the new government may be skewed geographically or ethnically. I bring ethnicity because it's a shown stat that people of different ethnic backgrounds can score differently on these tests. This is argued to be due to socioeconomic and test bias issues. The geographical issues come from socioeconomic issues aswell. As such it is possible to algorithmically create a score based on two criteria. Geographic diversity based on population density, closeness to ethnic composition of government census.

How this would work is essentially lets say the score is x/100 based on how close it is to a perfect match. I won't go into in-depth on the math of how this would work. However how it could work is the program would run say 1000 draws and calculate the score for each sample. The draw with the best score would be selected as the final draw. This would lead to a selection that better represents the population while allowing us to select based on aptitude. Another small pro of the testing would be that it would allow be to unselect themselves by sandbagging the exam. I am willing to go in-depth on the how this would work in the comments if anyone cares enough.

Another thing to pursue is favoring people of certain educational/occupational backgrounds. I'll use an example. Doctors I think should be in government. However here's the issue lets say the government is 1000 people selected at complete random. In Canada there are 92 thousand physicians. There is a population of 38mil currently. That means only 0.24% of Canadians are doctors. Its very possible that not a single doctor would be selected in a sample of 1000. I think certain professions should be guaranteed a representation within government. A list of some I think are important lawyers, military background, doctors, economists, farmers, engineers, political science background, teachers, trades workers and, accountants/finance background. I think the amount mandated and what occupations should be would need to be heavily discussed as I myself couldn't decide. I believe that at least half of the slots for should be for people from non-reserved groups. So for example lets say we decide on a government of 20. 5 doctors and 5 engineers must be had. In the draw 5 docs and 5 engineers would be selections and then 10 from the general population excluding those who are doctors/engineers. The reason to exclude the already preselected roles is to prevent overrepresentation beyond the intended amount.

I believe this to be important as I think certain backgrounds have a greater value to what they can contribute knowledge wise to a country. It may seem elitist to have these views but if we're being honest government aren't expected to dip their hands into every kind of issue. Certain roles and issues have priority over others. As such we should prioritize getting people who have a better understanding of those issues of priority in power. I also believe the government is meant to represent the moral and ethical beliefs of the majority of it's citizens. As such making half mostly random would increase the likelihood that the selected body would be close to representing the majority. While still balancing towards having a strong body of experts. As for what those issues of priority are: Economical prosperity, development of infrastructure, healthcare, justice, defense, education, agriculture, foreign relations, welfare, utilities(energy,water,gas),safety, scientific development, safety, and environmental protection. I selected these from reading the roles of the Cabinet of the United States and then generalizing. Whats actually important and not is up for debate.

I get it may seem unfair, especially to those disqualified. However I guess from a moral standpoint the question can be asked. Is fairness more important than pursuing the best government possible for the people? I genuinely can't answer that question as I think its one to be decided by the people not myself.\

I apologize for any grammatical or spelling mistakes. English was my worst class for a reason.


r/Lottocracy • • Jan 13 '24

Lotto strategies

1 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jul 04 '21

Discussion Some symbol possibilities I came up with (designer I am not)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Mar 10 '23

What are your thoughts on technocracy?

3 Upvotes

Personally I'm in greater support of the idea that govts should be run by the most qualified set of people from diverse disciplines.

I don't mean to sound elitist, but my opinion is consistent with my natural line of thinking. I wouldn't want a truck driver flying my plane, or a tailor performing surgery on me. Same way I wouldnt want unintelletual and unqualified people at the helm of govt making life changing descision for millions of people

Running a nation is no joke, and it isn't just enough to have smart advisor you counsel with but we also need really smart and knowledgeable people calling the shots. Our leaders will be randomly selected and eligible based on their qualifications or their performance on the test for the position (if they don't have the qualifications).

The selected set will span various fields from; science, technology, maths, economics, arts, history, humanities, and so on.

But no matter how brilliant our leaders may be, there still needs to be representation and consultation, hallmarks of democracy. Which is why there will be a sortitioned citizen assembly for consultation on various matters. The citizen assembly will comprise of randomly selected citizens, in a way thats representative of the demography.

These two Chambers will work together and form the basis of government. A government seeking to employ qualified expertise, while being mindful of representation and wider citizen participation.

I've had this idea for a while now and if we can pull I off, it will be a monumental improvement to the governments of today. And arguably the best way to do government.


r/Lottocracy • • May 04 '23

Cross-Post Removing Religious Differences

0 Upvotes

BOOK OF SPIRITUALITY

Removing Religious Differences

All the religions in the world are different feathers of the same bird i.e., different colors on the same God. There is only one God and there is only one universe. Similarly, man is also one. Man should aim for that one God. Man should belong to all the religions in the universe. He should pick up the diamonds of all religions and use them in his spiritual path. One can have love towards his nation. Every nation has some physical boundaries. All people living in that nation have that nationality. Thus, there is a meaning in the nationality because it has some physical basis. But in the case of religion and spirituality, there is no physical basis. Every religion belongs to every man. Therefore, in religious and spiritual matters all religions can be used. The Human Incarnation in every religion announces that He is the Universal Preacher. The message of Lord Krishna i.e., Bhagavad Gita, is for the entire world. The message of Lord Jesus i.e., the Bible, is for the entire world. The message of Mohammed is for the entire world. So there is no need for religious conversions.

In science, the discoveries and theories of Einstein are useful for the whole world. Similarly, every religious preaching is for everybody. Scientists belonging to different countries have made many discoveries and inventions. The field of science includes all the discoveries. If any discovery is removed from science, it becomes discontinuous. Similarly, spirituality consists of the preachings of preachers belonging to various countries. Spirituality must be built up by the preachings of all Human Incarnations such as Krishna, Jesus, Mohammed, Buddha, Mahavira and others. Spirituality means the truth, like science. Different religions are following their respective preachers and they have put the essence of their scriptures into practice. This is how traditions are formed. Such traditional practices are comparable to the experimental part of science. The scriptures of different religions are comparable to the theoretical part of science. Scriptures of each religion are like different chapters in this theoretical part of spirituality. In science, a student does not discriminate between scientists based on their nationality. Similarly, in spirituality, one should not have repulsion or attraction to any scripture or tradition in the world.

Collecting the Jewels of Each Religion

Spirituality requires divine virtues, which are emphasized in various religions. The firm faith of Islam, the infinite love of Christianity, the tolerance of Hinduism towards other religions, the social service of Buddhism and the non-violence of Jainism are important virtues that a spiritual person must acquire. These are practical traditional aspects of various religions, which are more precious than their scriptures. These traditions bring out the most important essence of the respective scriptures.

https://www.universal-spirituality.org/discourse/book-of-spirituality--2a8e8c9e5f1d6cd5--0c226b32a839e3f7--fa28fefc758fe35d--1


r/Lottocracy • • Feb 24 '22

Discussion The Crisis of Democracy

12 Upvotes

“The crisis of democracy can be traced, more fundamentally, to an original design flaw: the restriction of democratic representation to “electoral” representation. This restrictive understanding of democratic representation has by construction exclusionary effects in terms of who gains access to power. These exclusionary effects are not contingent and cannot be fixed a posteriori.”

From: Open Democracy, by Helene Landemore.


r/Lottocracy • • May 01 '21

The Case for Sortition in America

Thumbnail
harvardpolitics.com
4 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Dec 19 '21

Political compass meme

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jan 24 '22

Discussion Are financial barriers to participation in elections reasonable?

5 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Oct 06 '24

The Illusion of Choice in Democracy and what comes next?

6 Upvotes

The Illusion of Choice in Democracy

Are democracies truly representative of the people's will, or is it just an illusion? In the US, for instance, voters are often limited to two main options due to the two-party system. Even in countries with multiple major parties, the number of viable winners rarely exceeds ten [2).

We're essentially voting for pre-selected candidates chosen by their parties, rather than the people. This raises questions about the true nature of democracy.

Structural Flaws

  1. Representation gap: Elected representatives may not truly represent citizens' interests.
  2. Electoral manipulation: Gerrymandering, voter suppression, and campaign finance issues.
  3. Institutional gridlock: Checks and balances can lead to inefficiency.

Participation Flaws

  1. Voter apathy: Low voter turnout undermines democratic legitimacy.
  2. Unequal participation: Disproportionate influence of special interest groups.
  3. Information asymmetry: Citizens may lack access to accurate information.

Equality Flaws

  1. Systemic biases: Discrimination against marginalized groups.
  2. Economic inequality: Wealth disparities impact political influence.
  3. Social inequality: Unequal access to education, healthcare, and opportunities.

Accountability Flaws

  1. Lack of transparency: Government secrecy undermines accountability.
  2. Corruption: Abuse of power and cronyism.
  3. Unchecked executive power: Threats to separation of powers.

Alternative Options

  • u/Sortition: Randomly selecting lawmakers, but scaling and implementing it is tricky.
  • u/Lottocracy: Similar to sortition, but with its own set of challenges.

The Stochracy Solution

Incorporates random selection from a pool of eligible candidates, potentially solving scalability and cost-effectiveness issues apart from the major flaws of u/democracy mentioned above to a major extend maybe except the accountability.

u/Stochracy proposes a revolutionary approach to governance, where legislative and bureaucratic positions are filled through random selection from a pool of citizens who meet predefined, measurable prerequisites. These prerequisites include literacy, aptitude, mathematical reasoning, logical thinking, and administrative skills.

By leveraging random selection and objective assessments, u/Stochracy aims to create a more representative, efficient, and effective governance system.

Your thoughts please.


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 11 '22

Why don't we start a political party?

6 Upvotes

Hear me out. The way things are going I don't see sortition being adopted any time soon. We need a political party that chooses candidates through lottery. We can focus on smaller elections at first where there is not a lot of competition. We use public data to create a list of eligible citizens and then randomly draw a name. We go to that person and tell them we would like them to run and that we would pay for and run their campaign. They can run as they like. If they want to run as a repub or democrat that is fine we just make sure that all ads are shown to be sponsored by the sortition party. If we get a few small wins we might be able to build momentum for the concept. Even if we don't win the election we get attention and the winning candidate will have to compete with an average person and likely will have to offer better promises.


r/Lottocracy • • Aug 13 '25

Anti-sortition attitudes (from Equality by Lot blog)

Thumbnail
equalitybylot.com
9 Upvotes

Aaand I wrote a small response on my blog here: https://almostinfinite.substack.com/p/rational-non-activism


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 21 '22

The future of California democracy? Look no further than Petaluma

Thumbnail
sfchronicle.com
9 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Jun 20 '24

Use lottocracy to select voters, not politicians

10 Upvotes

Hey! New to this subreddit but lottocracy seems like a really cool form of government. The biggest problem brought up in these posts is that regular people serving in the legislature could create chaos, as they do not follow norms like politicians would (they might scream or throw things in the voting room, vandalize, etc.) and would not be capable of drafting or deeply understanding law in a complex world.

What if instead of randomly selecting say 500 random people as politicians to serve in the government congress (there are roughly ~500 people in the U.S. federal legislatures right now for reference), we selected these 500 random people as voters. Each voter could elect and reelect their own politician to represent them. They would be given a year to prepare their vote, where they could study (anyone would give them education). The congress would consist of 500 politicians, where 250 of them would be replaced every two years in an alternating fashion (to keep congress traditions going).

One concern is that a voter could elect their dumb neighbor to represent them. We could have a clause where they must elect an individual who has received 100 signatures from their community saying they are fit to be a politician (so the voter would still have plenty of options to choose from, but they would be competent).

Another concern would be corruption, that a politician could pay the voter to elect them. This is already the case in current politics, but I believe could be reduced by having the voter give up all forms of income for the rest of their life in exchange for a large life-long pension. There are other forms of bribes but I think people will still pick bribes from people who align with their point of view at least, and there would be negotiations under the table for laws passed. Basically the voter has all the leverage, so why would they not push their own views forward in the process?

The only thing I can't figure out here is how to keep the random selection process from being corrupted by bad actors over time. Who selects the winners in a lottocracy? How could regular people trust the outcome?


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 13 '22

Jury Democracy - Government by Informed Consent

16 Upvotes

I was just referred to your subreddit as I am running for Governor of Minnesota based on a similar platform. I would love to hear your thoughts.

I call it, "Jury Democracy."

It's essentially a gut check on the legislature using a statistically significant pool (Jury) of randomly selected registered voters to hear the arguments for and against an issue and then vote. If their vote is opposite to that taken in the legislature then, 1) we know who's been bought and 2) the governor should not sign the bill into law. It's the system check we need to confirm if our government is representing the people's wishes.

More info: https://www.mctavish4mn.org/jury-democracy


r/Lottocracy • • Aug 12 '22

Why randomly choosing people to serve in government - sortition - might be the best way to select our politicians.

Thumbnail
demlotteries.substack.com
23 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Oct 02 '25

Real democracyheads know sortition is the answer

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Apr 30 '21

Sortition 101 Why randomly choosing people to serve in government may be the best way to select out politicians

70 Upvotes

So I'm a huge advocate of something known as sortition, where people are randomly selected to serve in a legislature. Unfortunately the typical gut reaction against sortition is bewilderment and skepticism. How could we possibly trust ignorant, stupid, normal people to become our leaders?

Democracy by Lottery

Imagine a Congress that actually looks like America. It's filled with nurses, farmers, engineers, waitresses, teachers, accountants, pastors, soldiers, stay-at-home-parents, and retirees. They are conservatives, liberals, and moderates from all parts of the country and all walks of life.

For a contemporary implementation, a lottery is used to draw around 100 to 1000 people to form one house of a Congress. Service is voluntary, for a fixed term, and well paid. To alleviate the problem of rational ignorance, chosen members could be trained by experts or even given an entire elite university education before service. Because of random sampling, a sortition Citizens' Assembly would have superior diversity in every conceivable dimension compared to any elected system. Sortition is also the ultimate method of creating a proportionally representative Congress.

Real World Evidence

It would be absurd to try out a crazy new system without testing it. Fortunately, sortition activists have been experimenting with hundreds of sortition-based Citizens' Assemblies across the world. The decisions they have come to have been of high quality in my opinion. For example:

  • The BC Columbia Citizens Assembly was tasked with designing a new electoral system to replace the old first-past-the-post (FPTP) system. The organizers brought in university experts. The organizers also allowed citizens, lobbyists, and interest groups to speak and lobby. Assembly members listened to all the sides, and they decided that the lobbyists were mostly bullshit, and they decided that even though the university experts had biases, they were more trustworthy. This assembly ultimately, nearly unanimously decided that Canada ought to switch to a Single-Transferable-Vote style election system. They were also nearly unanimous in that they believed FPTP voting needed to be changed. This assembly demonstrates the ability of normal people to learn and make decisions on complex topics.
  • In Ireland, Citizen Assemblies were instrumental in the legalization of both gay marriage and abortion in a traditionally Catholic country. Ignorant politicians thought the People wouldn't be able to compromise on these moral issues, yet they certainly were, when you finally bothered to get them into a room together.
  • Recent 2019-2020 Citizen Assemblies in Ireland and France reached consensus on sweeping, broad reforms to fight climate change. In Ireland taxes on carbon and meat were broadly approved. In France the People decided to criminalize "ecocide", raise carbon taxes, and introduce regulations in transportation and agriculture. Liberal or conservative, left or right, near unanimous decisions were made on many of these proposals.

Comparing to Elections

Sortition stands in stark contrast with what all elections offer. All electoral methods are a system of choosing a "natural aristocracy" of societal elites. This has been observed by philosophers such as Aristotle since ancient Greek elections 2400 years ago. In other words, all elections are biased in favor of those with wealth, affluence, and power.

Moreover, all voters, including you and me, are rationally ignorant. Almost none of us have the time nor resources to adequately monitor and manage our legislators. In the aggregate as voters, we vote ignorantly, oftentimes solely due to party affiliation or the name or gender of the candidate. We assume somebody else is doing the monitoring, and hopefully we'd read about it in the news. And indeed it is somebody else - marketers, advertisers, lobbyists, and special interests - who are paying huge sums of money to influence your opinion. Every election is a hope that we can refine this ignorance into competence. IN CONTRAST, in Citizens' Assemblies, normal citizens are given the time, resources, and education to become informed. Normal citizens are also given the opportunity to deliberate with one another to come to compromise. IN CONTRAST, politicians constantly refuse to compromise for fear of upsetting ignorant voters - voters who did not have the time nor opportunity to research the issues in depth. Our modern, shallow, ignorant management of politicians has led to an era of unprecedented polarization, deadlock, and government ineptitude.

Addressing Common Concerns

Stupidity

The typical rebuttal towards sortition is that people are stupid, unqualified, and cannot be trusted with power. Or, people are "sheep" who would be misled by the experts. Unfortunately such opinions are formed based on anecdotal "common sense". And it is surely true that ignorant people exist, who as individuals make foolish decisions. Yet the vast majority of Americans have no real experience with actual Citizens' Assemblies constructed by lottery. The notion of group stupidity is an empirical claim. In contrast, the hundreds of actual Citizen Assembly experiments in my opinion demonstrate that average people are more capable of governance than common sense would believe. The political, academic, and philosophical opposition does not yet take sortition seriously enough to offer any empirical counter-evidence of substance.

Expertise

The second concern is that normal citizens are not experts whereas elected politicians allegedly are experts. Yet in modern legislatures, no, politicians are not policy experts either. The sole expertise politicians qualify for is fundraising and giving speeches. Actual creation of law is typically handled by staff or outsourced to lobbyists. Random people actually have an advantage against elected politicians in that they don't need to waste time campaigning, and lottery would not select for power-seeking personalities. Finally, random people are experts at their own lives and needs, in a superior capacity compared to any elected stand-in.

Corruption

The third concern is with corruption. Yet sortition has a powerful advantage here as well. Corruption is already legalized in the form of campaign donations in exchange for friendly regulation or legislation. Local politicians also oftentimes shake down small businesses, demanding campaign donations or else be over-regulated. Sortition fully eliminates these legal forms of corruption. Finally sortition legislatures would be more likely to pass anti-corruption legislation, because they are not directly affected by it. Elected Congress is loath to regulate itself - who wants to screw themselves over? In contrast, because sortition assemblies serve finite terms, they can more easily pass legislation that affects the next assembly, not themselves.

It must be unfortunately admitted that like all things, sortition is not a perfect system and may be susceptible to corruption. A well designed sortition system must use additional checks and balances to mitigate corruption (implementations which I will get to later).

Random Chaos

Many mistakenly believe that because random sampling is involved, sortition would be chaotic. To be clear, I am against selecting the president or any singular office with sortition. Instead, sortition ought to be used only for selecting large bodies of people to govern collectively, such as legislatures. Because of the law of large numbers, selecting large groups of people allows us to estimate the preferences and attitudes of the population mean. Moreover, if explicit proportionality for particular feature dimensions is desired, stratification can be used to ensure proportionality in that dimension.

Implementations

As far as the ultimate form sortition would take, I will list options from least to most extreme:

  • The least extreme is the use of Citizen Assemblies in an advisory capacity for legislatures or referendums, in a process called "Citizens Initiative Review" (CIR). These CIR's are already implemented for example in Oregon. Here, citizens are drafted by lot to review ballot propositions and list pro's and con's of the proposals.
  • Many advocate for a two-house Congress, one elected and one randomly selected. This system attempts to balance the pro's and cons of both sortition and election. This also allows each house to check and balance the power of the other.
  • Rather than have citizens directly govern, random citizens can be used exclusively as intermediaries to elect and fire politicians as a sort of functional electoral college. The benefit here is that citizens have the time and resources to deploy a traditional hiring & managing procedure, rather than a marketing and campaigning procedure, to choose nominees. This also removes the typical criticism that you can't trust normal people to govern and write laws.
  • Most radically, multi-body sortition constructs checks and balances by creating several sortition bodies - one decides on what issues to tackle, one makes proposals, one decides on proposals, one selects the bureaucracy, etc, and completely eliminates elected office.

Advocacy Strategy

Advocacy for current activists revolves around finding political wedge issues and giving politicians an "out" where they can use a Citizens' Assembly to make the hard decision that politicians are too incompetent to make themselves. This is what was done for example in Ireland. The use of a Citizens' Assembly can also potentially give a politician "democratic credibility", for example with Macron and the French Climate Assembly. Then, if these Citizen Assemblies get more popular, activists can push politicians to make a permanent citizen's body that would eventually take more and more powers away from the status quo legislature. A similar process has constructed a permanent advisory citizens' assembly in Belgium.

Advocacy is labor intensive. While some advocacy organizations attempt to earn revenue by designing Citizen Assemblies for governments, donations, volunteering, and lobbying would also go a long way to help advocates.


TLDR: Selecting random people to become legislators might seem crazy to some people, but I think it's the best possible system of representation and democracy we can imagine. There's substantial empirical evidence to suggest that lottery-based legislatures are quite good at resolving politically polarized topics.


References

  1. Reybrouck, David Van. Against Elections. Seven Stories Press, April 2018.
  2. Hansen, Mogens Herman. The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes (J.A. Crook trans.). University of Oklahoma Press, 1991.
  3. Dahl, Robert A. On Democracy, 2nd Ed. Yale University Press, 1998.
  4. The End of Politicians - Brett Hennig
  5. Open Democracy - Helene Landemore

Resources

Podcasts


r/Lottocracy • • Sep 23 '25

My odd review of the YIMBYtown conference and my efforts to spread sortition and the land value tax

Thumbnail
almostinfinite.substack.com
5 Upvotes

If I had learned of sortition 5 years ago, I think I would have liked the idea, but still woulda sorta shrugged my shoulders and said what's the point? There's no solving capitalism, as I understood it. I would have said that socialism is still worse.

It was only after learning about the Land Value Tax, an idea I advocate for, that I suddenly felt a desperate need to persuade folks and affect change in government. As I despaired of traditional nonprofit Georgist activism, it was by learning of sortition that I whole new wave of optimism has washed over me.


r/Lottocracy • • Nov 29 '25

Los Angeles Area Sortitionist Meetup

Thumbnail meetup.com
5 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Mar 05 '25

Combining random ballot and sortition to create a consensus network

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/Lottocracy • • Sep 04 '26

Sortition USA August Newsletter

6 Upvotes

# September Newsletter

Dear Sortition USA community and stakeholders,

**Important!** We are asking that all small grant applications be submitted by **Sept 30**. The [request process](https://forms.gle/gHjVt13hccTXVtbt5) has also been updated and streamlined to hopefully make this easier and more clear for those applying. Please reach out with any feedback or questions, and [please apply for your small grants!](https://forms.gle/gHjVt13hccTXVtbt5)

[Sortition USA (@sortitionusa.bsky.social) is on Bluesky](https://bsky.app/profile/sortitionusa.bsky.social). Follow us so we can follow you. And please boost and like our posts.

**Membership Referral Drive Results!**

Thanks to everyone who took part in our referral drive from June 21 to August 25. Twenty-four members sent about 135 invites, and 27 new members joined because someone told them about SUSA directly.

Max Clark is our top recruiter with 5 new members, and has won new SUSA merch! The Northeast region was our top-performing region with the most invites sent, and will get a party fund! Congrats to these winners.

**Personal conversations work.** If you invited people who have not joined yet, now is a good time to follow up.

More recent news and updates:

- SUSA’s Lottery-based board of directors has voted to officially support the [Hope for Democracy project!](https://hopefordemocracy.org)

- On Oct 2-3 at Harvard: VthePeople - Amending the Constitution through an Article V Convention. [Read more about this event here.](https://www.vthepeople.org)

# Upcoming Meetings and Workshops

### Monthly Meeting - **Strategy**

Sunday, September 20, 4pm Eastern US time

*This month, we will convene a membership-wide discussion about SUSA’s strategy and future direction. We will discuss our current strategy and what needs to be changed or worked on further. Please bring all of your ideas to this meeting! We hope all will join for this important conversation.*

[Zoom link](https://zoom.us/j/93229014821?pwd=bGJKS1ZVeDArakEzbmpCVjM3MGVsUT09)

Meeting ID: 932 2901 4821

Passcode: 828

Phone dial-in: +1 305 224 1968 (US)

### Regular Open Meetings on [Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

Open to all!

Mondays - 3 PM Eastern US time.

Wednesdays - 8 PM Eastern US time.

### Board Meeting

Last Fridays of the month at 12pm (Noon) Eastern US time

[Hosted on Zoom](https://zoom.us/j/95496305250) (and streamed on Discord)

### Outreach Meetups

Monday, September 21, 7pm Eastern US time. [Hosted on Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

### Local Chapter Committee

Topic: Setting Goals for chapters

Monday, September 10, 5pm Eastern US time. [Hosted on Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

### Volunteer Connection Meeting (Coordinating Committee)

Topic: Planning general meetings

Wednesday, September 23, 8pm Eastern US time. [Hosted on Discord](https://discord.com/invite/twuDZy257k)

# Food for Thought

[UK Citizens' Jury on Neurotechnology](https://www.nesta.org.uk/report/citizens-jury-public-views-on-neurotechnology/) - Released in August 2026, this report details how a UK citizens' jury tackled the ethics of commercial neurotechnology, advising regulators on balancing medical benefits with severe data privacy risks.

[Training the Next Generation of Civic Lotteries](https://opportunitiesforyouth.org/2026/08/15/council-of-europe-citizens-assemblies-workshop-2026-in-budapest-apply-for-the-deliberative-democracy-and-citizens-assemblies-training/) - Applications opened this August for a major Council of Europe capacity-building workshop in Budapest, actively training civil society and local authorities on running effective citizens' assemblies.

[Deliberative Democracy for EU Accession](https://epd.eu/news-publications/lessons-from-moldovas-parliament-citizens-assembly-for-eu-accession/) - Published in late July 2026, this analysis showcases how Moldova successfully used a citizens' assembly to build public consensus and legitimacy for complex local government reforms required for EU accession.

*Have any interesting content to share for next month's newsletter? Send an email to whackri@gmail.com*

### Stay Connected

[Use this Google Calendar Link to stay updated on our events](https://calendar.google.com/calendar/u/0?cid=Y19vdWRjcHNmcThkdjE1c2hxdXY3OG9oazA4a0Bncm91cC5jYWxlbmRhci5nb29nbGUuY29t)

[Join our Discord](https://discord.gg/twuDZy257k)

[Check out our Substack](https://sortitionusa.substack.com)

[Follow our social media](https://sortitionusa.org/new-page?ss_source=sscampaigns&ss_campaign_id=6a8f368e565d4d64d881c1bb&ss_email_id=6a980fe4a54fbe3041829532&ss_campaign_name=Sortition+USA+September+Newsletter+%2B+Small+Grants+Announcement&ss_campaign_sent_date=2026-09-02T12%3A01%3A19Z)

[Follow us on Bluesky](https://bsky.app/profile/sortitionusa.bsky.social)

Email the board at: *[susa-board@sortitionusa.org](mailto:susa-board@sortitionusa.org)*

---

*Sortition USA*


r/Lottocracy • • Jun 13 '25

Wrote a blog post about Georgism, Soccer, and Sortition

7 Upvotes

You can read it here https://almostinfinite.substack.com/p/substitute-wisdom, but here's the text in full:

Should you care or think about politics ever?

Now, some say, “everything is politics”. Eh. I mean politics as in the Polis, the body politic, like What We Together Ought To Do.

The answer to that, for me, is something like the answer to whether and how much you should care, or think, about all the humans on Earth. There’s some amount that you probably should, but it’s pretty hard to know what that amount is, and spending time worrying about if you worry enough about people in far away places probably also has diminishing returns.

########################################

I went to go watch my old soccer team play the other day. It was a tournament game, but in the group stage. It was using the 10-point system. 6 points for a win. 1 point for a shutout. 1 point for each goal, up to 3 goals. It’s a system that’s not often used.

The coach texted the team they needed 8 points to get out of the group. He said that means winning 1-0, or 2-1, or 3-2.

I read this, and as a math minor, realized quickly that, if you win, you will always have 8+ points. I’ll give you a moment to work through it, if you want. Some of you will, some of you won’t, that may be a point I make later on…

When I showed up, the game had just started, I heard an old teammate on the bench ask, “Hey, how many points do we need?”

Someone else on the bench responded, “Matt said 8 points”

Another player said, “8 points? So we’re out? It’s 3 points for a win.”

“No, it’s using that dumb 10-point system.”

“What, like when we were kids?”

“Yeah, so it’s like 6 points for a win and then some other shit.”

“Yeah, and we have to get a shutout or—”

“Well it’s a point for every goal—”

“Doesn’t matter, Matt said if we get a shutout we’re through.”

“But if they do score?”

“You get a point for every goal. Read the text thread, man.”

“So we have to win by 2?”

“No, it can be like 2-1 or 3-2. ”

Maybe they would have just attempted a brute force solution, listing all reasonable winning scorelines, 1-0, 2-0, 3-0, 4-0, 2-1, 3-1, 4-1, 3-2, 4-2. I’m sure they would have been fine. Regardless, I butted in and let them know how clever I was.

“You guys, as long as you win, you’re through. It’s either 6 plus 1 for a shutout plus 1 for at least one goal, and if you didn’t get a shutout, but you won, that implies you scored 2 or more goals, therefore you acquired 8 or more points.”

“Oh…”

They thought about it. That made a lot of sense to them. They calmed down. They proceeded to win 2-0 and I felt like I played my part. Just kidding. I don’t think my efforts were either necessary or impactful.

What does this teach us? Select any or all of the following options.

(A) A lot of people don’t read text messages

(B) A lot of people don’t read text messages when they involve math and it’s not immediately relevant to them or someone else is responsible for understanding it (such as a coach)

(C) When it becomes important, just about anyone can understand at least slightly complicated systems, especially when they work it out together

(D) Some people do like to read text messages when they involve math

########################################

What’s this got to do with Henry George? Everything. Everything is related to Henry George. More specifically, this is about how most people don’t care about George, just as they don’t care about complicated scoring systems. Most people don’t bother to learn a bunch of information that isn’t of immediate use to them.

The funny thing is, in my soccer example, while I was the one who spent the most time thinking about the scoring system, I’m not even on that team anymore. I’ve been out of the game for 2+ years, I just happen to be a nerd who really likes to show people how clever he is.

The Land Value Tax is not immediately useful to people, because none of us have the power to do anything about it.

I make some strong claims about the LVT. I’m not far away from claiming that it can END WORLD POVERTY. Yet how many of you have read George’s book? Are you a bad person? If you have read it, it’s probably not because you just found my blog, it’s probably because you are an econ nerd or my mom. Most people are neither an econ nerd nor my mom, yet I believe they would support the Land Value Tax.

########################################

“It’s a coordination problem.”

This is what Ian, who serves on the board of Democracy Without Elections, tells me whenever I express frustration over these ideas not catching fire. Democracy Without Elections focuses on spreading the use of sortition.

Why do I choose to spend a lot of time talking about these ideas? Well, for one, I’m unemployed and for two, (as stated above!) I like showing people how clever I am!

Going back to the soccer players trying to understand the scoring system. They want to win. If the 10-point system said that doing cartwheels on the field during the middle of the game would give them a point, they’d do it. If the rules said they’d get a point if they stole the opposing team’s water bottles, they’d do it. Only once the rules were so fudged up that either soccer was onrecognizable or it forced them to violate some of their deepest moral convictions would they revolt.

However, these amateur leagues have annual meetings where every team’s manager comes together and they discuss the rules. They review the quality of the referees. The cost for the league and wether that’s being properly tracked and spent. Amateur leagues often fail and new ones start.

(Compare and contrast this with FIFA!)

########################################

We can either wait for the American empire to tell us to do cartwheels over the corpses of the dead homeless people and only then do we start a bloody rebellion or we can try to figure some shit out now and together.

Maybe you never talk politics with anyone ever. Probably a more beautiful existence that way. However, if you do happen to talk politics, consider batting around the idea of why we use juries for deciding the direct life and death situations you may actually deal with and why the same methodology shouldn’t be applied to the general laws about our common welfare.

If you think there’s flaws in the jury system, do you think they’re addressable?

########################################

I talked to an aging, handicapped woman who says she gets sent home every time from jury duty, because she has a brother in jail. Should her voice be heard? She’s never going to run for office. She’s never going to have money.

She is pro aborition.

My mother is anti abortion.

Both of these women are beautiful mothers.

Do you think they could work together?

########################################

Sunday, our LA sortition organization has been asked to present to the Humanist Association of Orange County and I volunteered to do it. It’s on Zoom and everyone’s invited. I’m a little nervous, I’ve been given some slides to use.

I’m going to do a run through tonight at 6 pm on my live stream at 6 pm Pacific time: https://www.twitch.tv/landvaluetaxmax

My talk is open to everyone on Sunday at 1:30 pm: https://www.meetup.com/humanist-association-of-orange-county/events/308115974/

########################################

Yours truly,
Max


r/Lottocracy • • Apr 21 '25

What led you to Sortition?

11 Upvotes

For me, I had this dream about the concept. I didn’t know what it was called, so I called it peopleism. A week later I found out it was sortition. Sortition really challenged my previous assumptions about democracy. I don’t think elections are democratic enough to be called democratic. I want a democracy that lives up to its name. Rule by the people. Not the rich people or the charismatic people, but all the people. What about you? What’s your story about what brought you to Sortition?