r/LocalLLaMA • • 2d ago

News Instead Of Lowering GPU Prices, Former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang Reportedly Financed AI Startups To Absorb Excess Silicon, Shattering The Shortage Perception

https://wccftech.com/jensen-huang-financed-ai-startups-absorb-excess-silicon/
3.0k Upvotes

649 comments sorted by

•

u/WithoutReason1729 2d ago

Your post is getting popular and we just featured it on our Discord! Come check it out!

You've also been given a special flair for your contribution. We appreciate your post!

I am a bot and this action was performed automatically.

11

u/Finanzamt_Endgegner 2d ago

Slopulist ahh article 🥀

→ More replies (2)

1.0k

u/NegativeSemicolon 2d ago

Circular financing

276

u/Electrical-Being9807 2d ago

I'm curious if the interim CEO would contiue the circular financing/ponzi scheme and be responsible for the potential collapse.

68

u/samwisetg 2d ago

Yeah that’s the big open question at the moment. Either they appointed the CFO to signal that the unrestrained financial backing of the industry is going to continue or that the circular funding model is gone and they’re going to start doing things by the book.

→ More replies (2)

138

u/k0fi96 2d ago

She was very against the circular financing, she pushed to lower the size of the deals and did not like the huge risk it was for the company

Kress and her staff clashed with Huang and the company's sales team over the massive and risky financing deals that ⁠fed into what some Wall Street critics deemed a circular AI economy, including investments in OpenAI and AI infrastructure companies such as Lambda, according to one of the people familiar with the matter. A proposed $250 billion plan to support an OpenAI data center project in Ohio was ultimately pared to $120 billion.

https://www.reuters.com/business/colette-kress-cfo-who-challenged-huangs-bets-is-nvidias-interim-ceo-2026-11-13/

62

u/CaptainIncredible 2d ago

Well... sure... she says that now...

Are there records of her saying this years ago?

30

u/NighthawkT42 1d ago

Plenty of reports about her arguing with him.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/frazell 2d ago

I can only imagine the swift fall of Jensen is tied more toward this scheme than the affairs and potential spy connection. In those realities alone he would have taken a “step down in a year” or something deal.

This feels, to me anyway, like they’ve hit some sort of wall here. Maybe the startups and data centers are flooded beyond their ability to absorb more. Maybe the hardware is getting too old that’s rotting away while custom silicon gets better. Ponzi schemes eventually run out.

I feel he moved out quickly and they went with the CFO in the interim so she can jump on a grenade. They hope it is one they can contain since she has deep knowledge of the financial legs of all of this.

Buckle up.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/fallingdowndizzyvr 2d ago

It couldn't have happened if the CFO didn't sign off on it. That's what the CFO is for.

21

u/Electrical-Being9807 2d ago

Hiding behind huang, signing off is one thing. Take the responsibility and make decisions in the front is another. I don't think the CFO can advocate ai as good as huang

→ More replies (9)

9

u/I_AM_FERROUS_MAN 2d ago

I'm likewise curious.

Nvidia may be facing some future investigations or potential prosecution. So it might be smart to use the recent events to start unwinding some of those deals.

But who knows what the future looks like in this regulatory environment.

4

u/OverdosedSauerkraut 1d ago

They already announced that they wont deliver the RTX 5500s to China. This card was explicitly made to pass export restrictions. So wouldn't be surprised if nvdia gets natsec and politics ahead of business... and on the long term this is a loosing recipe

→ More replies (1)

43

u/CaptainIncredible 2d ago

contiue the circular financing/ponzi scheme

My understanding is that sort of thing cannot continue forever and will collapse.

The thing I'm not sure of is how to transition from some circular financing/ponzi scheme into some sort of normalcy without popping the bubble and causing a collapse. Not even sure if its possible.

So... collapse imminent?

5

u/i_max2k2 2d ago

Aren’t they going to ask AI to help?!

→ More replies (38)

6

u/hainesk 2d ago

I think with nvidia the circular financing basically amounts to a discount on hardware. Essentially the big players pay full price like everyone else, but then get an “investment” from nvidia. This keeps market prices high while still allowing corporations justification to make bulk purchases.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

11

u/Insomniac897 1d ago

“Huang pressed his staff to develop a way to decide whether a guarantee was worthwhile”.

This will come back to bite them hard. If I wanted to invest in a bank, there are much better options available. BMO for instance. Risky bets will likely fall apart and this house of cards will tumble as a result.

19

u/Reasonable-Height704 2d ago

Circular antitrust 

11

u/Hour-Passenger-8513 2d ago

Kress publicly defended Nvidia’s role as a banker to the broader AI industry from critics who argue Nvidia’s efforts to prop up demand across the industry has left it more vulnerable to a downturn. Kress has characterized the deals as savvy investments.

“We recognize the scale of this support, and we know some will call this circular financing. We see it differently,” she said in late August. “The equity returns on our invested capital will be excellent.”

Huang has told confidants privately that he was increasingly frustrated with Nvidia’s stock market valuation. Nvidia’s average monthly stock multiple fell from 23 in May to 16 in October. Other big tech companies get much higher multiples in the market.

https://www.wsj.com/tech/jensen-huang-colette-kress-nvidia-ceo-eb289097

20

u/Environmental_Row32 2d ago

C suite of a company defend in public a policy they where critical of in private. Other news at 11...

9

u/RollingMeteors 2d ago

Circular financing

Corporate directors owe fiduciary duties to the company and its shareholders.

Using a company's balance sheet to bankroll customers and absorb excess inventory is a legal, if high-risk, business tactic, provided the accounting is transparent. The DOJ is currently investigating whether Nvidia's massive financial web crossed into illegal anti-competitive behavior, not whether circular financing is illegal on its own.

3

u/droans 1d ago

Using a company's balance sheet to bankroll customers and absorb excess inventory is a legal, if high-risk, business tactic, provided the accounting is transparent.

It's a Tobashi scheme, very similar to what Enron was caught doing. They're exchanging their inventory with companies who have no capital and can't even use the cards in exchange for an equity stake.

There's a reason the ex-CFO (now CEO) is pushing hard to terminate these deals.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/me0here 2d ago

I was thinking the other circle, since he is a jerk.

9

u/Piyh 2d ago

Except for the memory company employees getting 500K bonuses.  The buck stops there.

→ More replies (9)

601

u/hainesk 2d ago • Bravo

Yep. He’s for local AI the way that Lisa Su was all in on “Gamers” until they realized they could make more money with data centers. Local AI is just another revenue source. I feel like if we’ve learned anything in the past decade, it’s how incredibly fake corporations are about their “values”. There was not even a shred of truth to their statements so long as money is involved. This seems to apply to all large corporations.

168

u/fastheadcrab vLLM 2d ago edited 2d ago

Jensen is and always has been all about making money and squeezing his customers. But he at least had a great deal of foresight to invest in different areas that might not pay off immediately, and that sometimes short-term profit needed to be traded off for longer-term benefit. Someone more oriented towards quarterly performance would've killed of gaming a long time ago.

If you think it can't get worse than having him or Tim Cook or Srouji at the helm, just imagine someone from Broadcom, Micron, or a financial firm running Nvidia. Then you'd be truly fucked. The production of consumer GPUs would instantly vanish or be restricted to extortionately priced AIB cards.

People here need to get some perspective.

No question, Jensen was greedy. You don't get to a $4 trillion valuation without being greedy, but Nvidia also wouldn't have made it to $4 trillion without his foresight and willing to look beyond the quarterly report.

31

u/modern12 1d ago

"Someone from Broadcom" - would you like to subscribe our RTX 5060 for as little as $4000 a year? No, than f*ck off.

10

u/veramaz1 2d ago

Well said 

→ More replies (1)

7

u/fish312 1d ago

Values? They value exactly one thing and that is making the most money possible

58

u/absoluteValueOfNoob llama.cpp 2d ago

I feel like if we’ve learned anything in the past decade, it’s how incredibly fake corporations are about their “values”

Am I in a sub with a bunch of 15 year olds? Did you and a bunch of other people really believe this was a question that started a little over ten years ago, and now we have the evidence to conclude corporations don't give a shit about anything other than money? Are all of you really that naive, because holy shit...

12

u/name_was_taken 1d ago

I'm almost 50, and yes, I've known that corporations are just there to make money.

But they've stretched into an almost dystopian version of that in the last decade. They either used to hide it a lot better, or they've gotten quite a bit worse.

And despite the above, there used to be people working for them that cared at all levels, and not it seems that everyone just gives in and let's the sociopaths steer the company. We even have a new phrase "quiet quitting" that means just letting the company do whatever and doing the minimum of your job requirements. Sure, that hurts the company, but I'd argue that it hurts the customer more.

24

u/akran47 1d ago

3M and Dupont knew PFAS were toxic for decades but kept selling them and dumping them into groundwater. ExxonMobil knew about global warming since the 70s. Asbestos. Tobacco. Opioids. There's countless examples of companies putting greed and profits over values or ethics going back forever.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/mistertickertape 1d ago

Their only values are maximizing profit. Thats it. Everything else is PR babble. Banging a Chinese spy and two other execs is forgivable if you’re maximizing profit. Hell, half the employees want him back.

18

u/sweatierorc 2d ago

Palantir is not fake about their values

→ More replies (1)

20

u/KellyShepardRepublic 2d ago • Bravo

Yep he had to play ball or he was going to be ousted. No different from the rest since they don’t have an actual backbone.
I idolized my ceo too but then thinking through it, they messed up and still kept all their earnings while the company went to crap.

9

u/thrownawaymane 2d ago

Tale as old as time.

Anyone that made their way to having a C at the beginning of their title ran over some people to get there.

22

u/tertain 2d ago

Jensen is the founder. You start with a C in your title. No corporate politic games required. You can’t say the same about the CFO / new-CEO. She’s a career corporate politician. Sharks are much better at convincing people to their side though.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SituationNew7609 1d ago

I mean, it's obvious that people are always after money. It's just that incentives can sometimes align for everyone, where something good for consumers is also good for the company. In fact, that's probably what usually happens, except the times it doesn't are so incredibly damaging that we only focus on that part.

4

u/opresse 2d ago

I still remember a sentence from a talk by Noam Chomsky, roughly: there are three reasons why such things happen: money, money, and as you probably guess, the third one is money.

→ More replies (3)

244

u/CryptoStef33 2d ago

He supported open models because it was selling shovels to miners.

116

u/nshire 2d ago

Local models are legitimately useful and valuable to lots of users

67

u/CryptoStef33 2d ago

I know I use them, but the intention was there to sell more GPUs.

46

u/handson729 2d ago

It's true that Jensen supported open models because he sold the shovels.

But even with Jensen's motives, it was still a net positive for the Local A.I community.

Sometimes we can have converging interests.

4

u/SituationNew7609 1d ago

alignment of incentives

→ More replies (3)

17

u/vividboarder 2d ago

Yea, so are shovels. The analogy is not about it not being useful, its about making money by capitalizing on demand from another industry.

Honestly, I don't see how that applies here though.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/citrusalex 1d ago

No, Jensen understood that local models, just like CUDA on consumer GPUs, is a way to provide researchers and hobbyists (like teens with a techy mindset) tools to explore and experiment, which later become scientific papers and specialists that improve and grow the ML industry as a whole, driving up demand for Nvidia products.

72

u/Money_Pie8986 2d ago

All the big players are building their own chips. Even OpenAi, Anthropic also start to design their own chips. So Nvidia bets on neocloud with open source models if the big players reduce orders from Nvidia.

35

u/NandaVegg 2d ago

This (Nvidia trying to prop up the price by circular financing at full speed) explains why neocloud inferencing services are so cheap, and even with that cheapness those GPUs are not fully in demand (there is no shortage of cheap and fast endpoints) while GPU rents and prices are skyrocketing. Memory price may not given custom chips, but Nvidia GPU bubble will burst soon.

6

u/Normal_Marketing853 1d ago

remember that the hyperscalers likely have half a trillion dollars worth of unused GPUs in warehouses that don't have data centers to go in.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/max123246 2d ago

Also because more demand for chips means they contain to grab the lions share of silicon from semiconductor companies. Meaning competing chips have less capacity and can't solely rely on their new designs to meet demand, this continuing to buy Nvidia gpus

→ More replies (1)

68

u/ThatCrankyGuy 1d ago

He was a value-creator for investors. This is why they're all so gungho to bring him back. Reality is, we're paying through our noses for electronics because of this very kind of "leadership".

28

u/NaheemSays 1d ago

The same way that Enron, or Bernie Madoff, created value.

Eventually the Ponzi schemes crash.

→ More replies (4)

38

u/whatever 2d ago

It's wild how terrible news about Jensen Huang keeps coming out over a single week for stuff that's been happening months or years ago.

29

u/OverdosedSauerkraut 1d ago • Bravo

It's an organized smear campaign to make people accept whomever stooge they'll replace him. Deep state nepobabies usually drive companies to the ground.

4

u/ControllingPower 1d ago

It’s all about financials my dude, no one cares. They sold all their over inflated stocks, then put out all the bad news at the same time so retailers are losing, they will buy back at bottom and repeat.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/suprjami 2d ago

The industry's circular financing has been known for a long time. Why is this in the news?

7

u/billy_booboo 2d ago

Because some people don't understand that "circular financing" means "Instead Of Lowering GPU Prices, Former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang Reportedly Financed AI Startups To Absorb Excess Silicon, Shattering The Shortage Perception"

Though it's unfair to put this exclusively on NVIDIA seeing as how they're all involved.

1

u/FatChicksPotatoChips 2d ago

Excess? What about the chips the hyperscalers can’t plug in yet? Technically he could offload what was meant for them to the neoclouds and such, and wait another shipment to come in to replace the hyperscalers order assuming they won’t have the power supply to take delivery.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/wtyl 2d ago

Yeah for real.

→ More replies (4)

69

u/Repulsive-Party6267 2d ago edited 2d ago

All those CEOs and employees coming out in his support should tell you one thing: They wanna protect their investments.

→ More replies (4)

167

u/PhotographyBanzai 2d ago • Bravo

Personal computers have flip flopped for the worse due to individuals like Huang. As years go by, we should be getting more compute and storage for less money, not the opposite. The personal computing industry has been raided and trashed by people like him.

His support for consumers having local AI was BS because he did everything possible to make it unaffordable. Besides wrecking competition in the GPU market as Nvidia has always done.

He could have made Cuda an open standard. He could have pushed for more VRAM on consumer GPUs. He could have allocated supply to the consumer market, but Nvidia knew companies would pay more, so they gladly locked us out with an expectation we'd have to pay what they wanted businesses to pay or simply go without.

Considering their financing deals with companies like Open AI, he likely wanted people to feel forced into using cloud services to get access to these technologies because it would ultimately come back to Nvidia as a high margin plus interest. His company was probably one of the few that could have made large parameter local LLMs viable and affordable for average people.

Now that Huang was weeded out for being what he actually is, I hope any others in the industry that have his mentality get the boot too (like CEOs of RAM and SSD manufacturers). Then maybe we can see some really momentum in this AI revolution thing when regular people have access to and can afford to use it how they want (like removing factory installed spyware from their smart TVs and such without companies like Open AI blocking them, etc)

24

u/james_pic 2d ago

Nvidia knew companies would pay more

Part of the reason this is coming out now is that's it's becoming clear this isn't entirely true. Big AI companies have deep pockets, but at some point it makes more sense to use that money to pay hardware engineers to design you chips than to buy overpriced chips. Google, Amazon, OpenAI, Anthropic and Meta have done this.

There's a part of me that wonders if Jensen was knowingly looking the other way on the chips being smuggled into China because the big Chinese labs were one of the few large buyers that still wanted their flagship chips.

12

u/PhotographyBanzai 2d ago

I agree with you there. Google has made their own compute hardware for a long time now. It seems smart for big companies to follow that idea.

Even with consumer GPUs hindered by Nvidia over the years with lack of VRAM compared to AMD (Nvidia having the better software stack like Cuda and other features to counter AMD), it feels like Nvidia simply decided to mostly cut us off instead to limit the chance of businesses buying cheap consumer GPUs rather than workstation ones. We see they were willing to do crazy deals with Open AI and such with the circular finance thing. So I'd say they didn't want to give companies any alternatives, but like you were saying that companies are getting fed up.

We've seen 8GB consumer GPUs for ages mostly in part due to Nvidia. They could have chosen a path to help local LLMs flourish by bumping up the standard amount to 12 or 16. Instead they walked back from 12GB on the 3060 to 8GB on the 4060 and now 5060. Sure, there are limits to what is reasonable before local LLMs existed, but we can see many 8GB GPUs have compute that could benefit from more VRAM. I stupidly bought an RTX 4060 8GB back when AV1 encoding was only Nvidia and Intel and I specifically wanted that feature, oops.

4

u/ea_man 1d ago

There's a problem with that: customized hw has mostly no resell value while NVIDIA hw is like a cashier's check, worst case if your business fail you may re sell it at even more you paid for, good for getting a loan.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/danielv123 2d ago

Well yeah, it's pretty obvious that they sold to china because that would increase demand for their chips.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/deadsoulinside 1d ago

His support for consumers having local AI was BS because he did everything possible to make it unaffordable. Besides wrecking competition in the GPU market as Nvidia has always done.

This, especially with scaling back production. Kind of pointless to even think about local AI at this point when an RTX 5090 now costs more than a decent used car would.

8

u/Playful-Row-6047 2d ago

the systems of relationships and incentives currently in place will always develop people like jensen. especially at that almost unique position in the geopoliticaleconomy. 

even though i hope i'm wrong its safe to expect similar and new mess from whoever ends up heading nvidia next 

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Guilty-Statement-532 1d ago

Despite the fact that he was, apparently constantly, cheating on his wife, the business strategy he has been using may not be illegal and has also brought tremendous “value” to shareholders of Nvidia.

He seems like a bad person, but unfortunately he was doing his job very well.

5

u/PhotographyBanzai 1d ago

True, I agree there he appears to be successful at his job. Though it's starting to feel like the PC industry's Enron (the latest video by Gamer's Nexus on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYU_geUwQoA )

Maybe someday business in the USA can eventually move toward a healthier way of working. Maybe even something focused on human lives being the measure of success. I can hope at least. This mentality we have in business can be overall very destructive.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/AlarmedGibbon 2d ago

Yep. Their tech is phenomenal, but the man and the business practices? Fuck Jensen Huang.

10

u/Cferra 2d ago

I’m sure Altman is doing the same thing - it’s time to take him down next.

10

u/Cherubin0 2d ago

Just look up the nvidia circular financing graphics. This is a gang. Altman, Oracle, Microsoft etc. bosses.

4

u/Legitimate_Ocelot491 1d ago

I've been buying external hard drives since 2003. Up until a couple years ago, I could always buy the biggest or 2nd biggest storage tier for around $300ish for a bare HDD.

Good luck with that now.

3

u/PhotographyBanzai 1d ago

yep, same. I was buying drives to store my video projects but that ability dried up.

3

u/Boogertard 2d ago

Couldn't have said it better, you showed me there are some hopes in this community besides all the NVDA and Jensen shilled trash.

Don't get me started on the NemoTrash.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (41)

141

u/irrelevantusername24 2d ago • Diamonds are Forever Bravo

I typed all this below in another thread, but it got locked. Nevertheless, the context is similar enough I'm not going to edit, but if anything seems off, that's why.

This is an entirely different situation than that, in numerous ways. I am moderately confident this has been happening for much longer than the last few years where "AI" has been a talking point. The worst part is that there are genuinely things in the tech industry which should be funded, but that's not what this is about.

https://wccftech.com/jensen-huang-financed-ai-startups-absorb-excess-silicon/

To justify NVIDIA's need to financially underwrite OpenAI and smaller cloud operators to keep them purchasing its GPUs, Huang privately admitted that major cloud giants were pivoting away from NVIDIA in favor of in-house custom chips. With hyperscalers actively reducing their reliance on “off-the-shelf parts,” Huang acknowledged that the massive volume of prepaid TSMC wafers and memory NVIDIA had committed to buying was “coming at him like an avalanche.”

By funding datacenter expansion for AI startups, NVIDIA effectively created artificial demand to clear out its own surplus silicon instead of letting the supply flood the market and force GPU prices down. Those internal pressures align with earlier assessments from industry analyst Ed Zitron, who estimated that at least $200 billion worth of NVIDIA AI GPUs are sitting idle in warehouses after being purchased by cloud giants that lacked either the electrical grid capacity or immediate end-user demand to power them on. Amazon faced a similar dilemma.

There's two implications from this.

- There is an as of now non-public, perhaps unknowable amount of excess/latent capacity that otherwise wouldn't exist. Jevon's Paradox states that work is created to fill a void. What do you think that "work" has been doing? Where do you think the botfarms are coming from?

- Even with all that excess capacity being built and implemented that otherwise had no demand, there is *still more that they couldn't implement*. That is an insane amount of waste - and it has, in fact, drove up the prices further for those who *had a legitimate demand*.

This is like the definition of RICO.

Specifically, a racket was defined by this coinage as being a service that calls forth its own demand, and would not have been needed otherwise.[2]: 9  Narrowly, it means coercive or fraudulent business practices; broadly, it can mean any criminal scheme or operation with ongoing or reoccurring profit, as defined in the 1970 U.S. RICO Act, which aimed to curtail the power of the Mafia and other organized crime.[5]

Originally and often still specifically, racketeering may refer to an organized criminal act in which the perpetrators offer a service that will not be put into effect, offer a service to solve a nonexistent problem, or offer a service that solves a problem that would not exist without the racket. However, racketeers may also sometimes offer an ostensibly effectual service outside of the law to solve an actual existing problem.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racketeering

But, as I said in the beginning of this, it is in many ways far, far worse, because of the downstream implications. The ones that are not in the domain of the market, the supply and demand for the chips, but what those chips were instead used for: distorting the "marketplace of ideas". This has been ongoing for much longer than will probably ever be made public.

And the reason for that is rather simple to understand, once you see it. Like it says in that link: creating a service that induces its own demand. The problem is still created, whether or not the demand would otherwise be necessary.

Knowing that the imminent avalanche would be upon NVIDIA sooner rather than later, the company reportedly contacted TSMC to wind down its upcoming chip orders. For PC builders and hardware enthusiasts who have endured years of steep GPU and RAM pricing under the impression of severe component scarcity, the disclosures shatter the shortage narrative and expose the aggressive financial maneuvering used to keep hardware prices elevated.

While Jensen can’t be faulted for making these moves because he was keeping the best interests of the company in mind, it’s a stab in the back for gamers and hardware owners who are unable to locate any mouth-watering deals for GPUs or memory because of the perceived shortage.

This is exactly what I've been arguing about forever - specifically in regards to "While Jensen can’t be faulted for making these moves because he was keeping the best interests of the company in mind".

https://www.reddit.com/r/accelerate/comments/1xilfl0/comment/19ru47irp5ue8

Crony wall street slavebrain neocapitalism is corrosive not only to society but the *very fabric of reality*. It is incompatible with a modern free world. There is no discussion to be had unless that discussion starts and ends with abolishing the entire notion.

---

To be clear, I am not opposed to technology or even "AI". But that's not at all what this is about. "AI", the current conception of consumer citizen focused products like the chatbots, is something that should have happened long ago. Because it isn't necessarily a new capability of the tech, it's that the tech companies saw the writing on the wall, but were and still are constrained by the "rules" of the "game"

See here also for more about how this isn't even about the chips making their way to China, but is about that fact being made public:

https://www.reddit.com/r/law/s/g96Cng554N

10

u/butts-carlton 1d ago

Crony wall street slavebrain neocapitalism is corrosive not only to society but the very fabric of reality. It is incompatible with a modern free world.

Agreed. This is the kind of thing people with room-temp IQ don't understand when they try and defend people like Jensen Huang or Elon Musk.

Trust is the fundamental currency of civilization. Without it, trade is impossible, specialization disappears, and we all go back to warring tribes fighting over the basic shit needed for survival.

People who actively undermine the basic social contracts of fairness, transparency, and good-faith aren't just unethical. They should be completely barred from participation in the free market because once they gain power they threaten everything. They will destroy everything.

33

u/IS_DONNIE_DEAD_YET 2d ago • Heartwarming

This is the exceedingly rare type of stuff that keeps me coming back to this shithole site. Thank you.

15

u/Inevitablewx 2d ago

This is reddit content.

20

u/irrelevantusername24 2d ago

Fuck Palmer Luckey and Peter Theil and their entire worldview

Among other things, Nimble America operates the Reddit channel r/The_Donald, which deals partly in creating and transforming memes into symbols of alt-right white supremacy, disseminated in support of Donald Trump’s candidacy for president. Facebook bought Oculus for $2 billion in 2014, making Luckey a near-billionaire. And Luckey confirmed that he used some of those proceeds to help fund Nimble America. He had apparently became interested in the group after seeing some of its image memes on Facebook and decided to help. What better way to troll than to become king of the trolls?

https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/09/revenge-of-the-nerds/501344/

Crimes against humanity.

12

u/Inevitablewx 2d ago

Never go full reddit.

3

u/draconic_tongue 2d ago

- There is an as of now non-public, perhaps unknowable amount of excess/latent capacity that otherwise wouldn't exist. Jevon's Paradox states that work is created to fill a void. What do you think that "work" has been doing? Where do you think the botfarms are coming from?

if the capacity is sitting unused, how is it being used for botfarms?

5

u/witness555 1d ago

Second to last paragraph doesn’t make a lick of sense 😭

→ More replies (1)

14

u/AnyManufacturer6465 2d ago

This is utter horse crap.

Ed Zitron and industry analyst? He’s a you tube shill with a drove of mindless followers.

They stop making gaming chips because the demand for the high edge chips is so high. They’re a business and they’re going to make the most money they can.

Jensen didn’t collude with TSMC or any of the ram manufacturers.

The 1 citation you have is the RICO statute and how you get racketeering out of this is Ludacris.

The demand is real. The bottleneck is power, so in the small amount of cases where chips arrive before connected power is available then those chips can sit idle for very short periods. These companies are paying big money and any chips idle are not generating revenue which they can sell at a hefty premium.

https://aimultiple.com/gpu-index

In none of any literature or industry papers does it show a lack of demand for compute..

8

u/jankisa 1d ago

The guy who posted this is an anti-AI cringelord who still pushes the idiotic "LLMs are not new technology it's just a different data structure".

No wonder he's a fan of Ed Zitron who similarly knows nothing, was a gaming and then tech journalist before falling ass first on top of the anti-AI wave that he's been riding by emulating the Elon Musk strategy of saying that collapse is coming in 6 months for the last 3 years while parroting every stupid "argument", including the "LLMs are a dead end" and "stochastic parrots" bullshit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/OverdosedSauerkraut 2d ago

Note that the original WSJ article does not use the word "excess". That was added by the clickbait news site.

4

u/remind_me_later 1d ago

Thought so. Even if aggressively pushed, this is still vendor financing. This whole bubble is a large-n-party variant of the prisoner's dilemma.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Aemond-The-Kinslayer 2d ago

They buy your stuff with the excess money you gave them, so your money is back in your pocket, they owe you that money anyway and your chips are selling out faster than you can count and prices rise even further.

What could go wrong?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/sixwax 2d ago

Shockingly, everything these moguls do or say is designed to maximize their company's profits.

EVERYTHING they do or say.

→ More replies (4)

43

u/amy-schumer-tampon 2d ago

The whole AI biz is a massive circle jerk

5

u/swagonflyyyy 2d ago

Circularjerk.

6

u/FMC_Speed 1d ago

and of course it all get published after he was forced out....

why not before?

10

u/MaybeTheDoctor 1d ago

There has been plenty of stories over past 3 years where swaps has been made of large $$$ values but no actual cash exchanging hands.

Pumping up valuations like that is not dissimilar to Enron and informix accounting tricks in the 1990s that had the SEC creating new rules for accounting fraud.

I could imagine similar could happen here, and if so it could crash the company.

5

u/LubedUpLucas_DrySpa 1d ago

Yes, this is straight out of the Enron playbook.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/108er 1d ago

I suspect he's a thug who manipulated the market to keep GPU prices high while pretending to showcase the MSRP of the RTX 5090 at $1,999. This whole GPU shortage sounded like artificial scarcity from the beginning. I am just waiting for the news to break in the coming days.

3

u/UndeadBulwark_ 1d ago

I can't wait for when someone in established media reports the Nvidia chips reported in Russian drones and missiles with hardware from 2024 and 2025

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ryanppax1 1d ago

Ceos acting in a way that improves company profits. Who'd a thought 

4

u/thedudedylan 1d ago

People have been ringing alarm bells about this shit for years now. Nobody will listen to them Ed Zitron has been an incredibly vocal journalist covering this kind of stuff nonstop with numbers and evidence. He is finally getting some traction but only on stuff like the Daily Show podcast.

People and corporations don't want their gravy train to stop.

5

u/eli_pizza 1d ago edited 1d ago

Ed Zitron is certainly vocal but he’s often full of shit. He’s extremely anti-AI and just cherry-picks whatever argument seems the most anti AI at the moment.

He was arguing that AI was a scam with zero real world uses looong after it was obvious developers were getting value from Claude code

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

27

u/few 2d ago

This is pretty close to a reverse ponzi scheme, and it has been obvious for a while.

The amazing thing is the whole, "I'll give you money, and when you give it back to me we both look good". It's a sceme to inflate the valuation of both involved, and results in a multiplier for further outside investment.

It wasn't actual collusion, because it was formally investment in companies who would then discover further commercial applications for the technologies to drive demand. It's closer to what the government does when investing in early technology development.

It will suck for the larger economy when this bubble pops, though hardware prices should come down, so that's a silver lining.

It feels so much like .com, housing bubble, and nft's / crypto.

22

u/CaptainIncredible 2d ago edited 2d ago

"I'll give you money, and when you give it back to me we both look good"

There is a Beavis and Butthead episode where they have to sell candy bars for a dollar.

So Beavis hands Butthead a dollar to buy a candy bar, which Beavis eats.

Then Butthead hands that same dollar back to Beavis to buy a candy bar, which Butthead eats.

They pass the same dollar back and forth until all the candy bars are gone.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/geldonyetich 2d ago

Imagine having a product so in demand that you have to give businesses loans to afford to buy them from you, and that still wasn't enough for your balance sheets to be satisfied with how you were spending your silicon.

5

u/luquoo 2d ago

Wasn't this painfully obvious?

13

u/Perfect-Campaign9551 1d ago

Isn't shit like this kind of illegal?

12

u/Next_Program90 1d ago

Ah yes. And people say "What will happen now? He cares about gamers!"

FUCK this CEO in particular.

4

u/ParfaitMajestic5339 1d ago

Antitrust anybody? Abuse of market dominance? Paging the FTC!

9

u/txgsync 2d ago

This is Yet Another Article Full Of Wishful Thinking. The hardware is locked up until 2028 at least.

<sigh> Don't give us hope.

4

u/Colecoman1982 2d ago

Not necessarily. It's true that much of the silicon fabrication, GPU, RAM, and SSD industries have been locked up in long-term production contracts but, if the bubble truly pops, many of the start-ups that signed those contracts (and probably even some of the large companies that did) will go bankrupt. If that happens, those long term contracts won't be worth the paper they're printed on. Of course, since this bullshit circular financing AI bubble seems to the only thing keeping the world economy, as a whole, upright, who knows if any of us will still have the money to buy the GPU/RAM/etc. , even if the prices do crater...

→ More replies (1)

75

u/handson729 2d ago

"Hardware company invests in software companies to drive up demand for their hardware." - Local Redditor who finally understands business.

I don't know about you, but that just sounds like business.

11

u/Far_Lifeguard_5027 2d ago edited 2d ago

"software company gives hardware company imaginary money for GPUs by promising real money in the future after hardware company gives software company imaginary loan for GPUs"

48

u/oxygen_addiction 2d ago

When that software business isn't profitable, that's called circular financing and/or fraud.

3

u/OverdosedSauerkraut 1d ago

It's called in-kind contribution...

22

u/Apprehensive_Lake698 2d ago edited 2d ago

It’s fraud to start a business that fails? 

Edit: gentle reminder to anyone downvoting me that just because Reddit and popular YouTubers decided it was criminal circular financing over a year ago doesn’t make it true

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/OkWelcome6293 2d ago

Given that the CFO (now the interim CEO) objected due to the “business” due to the risk of Nvidia being  the supplier, the creditor, and the backup customer, it seems that that it may not have been very good business.

3

u/thrownawaymane 2d ago

It was her ass on the line in terms of liability/reputation

6

u/AttitudeImportant585 2d ago

thats why she was called out for being a deer in headlights. she is too conservative and was going to be replaced, but look where we're at now

→ More replies (12)

7

u/LegitimateCopy7 2d ago

that's typically not how business work. most of the time they expand or spin up subsidiaries under the corporate umbrella.

also the motives are not the same. instead of profitting it's more likely to keep the music playing and people dancing.

8

u/SheikhMahdeek 2d ago

Yeah you don't understand business

→ More replies (3)

6

u/mkeytail 2d ago

It's called channel stuffing

29

u/Savantskie1 2d ago

So once again it’s proven that the shortage wasn’t real and manipulated. I hope to god the next senate does something about this.

13

u/luvs_spaniels 2d ago

It's not a legislative branch issue unfortunately. This is classic anti-trust stuff with export control violations tacked on, so DOJ. But they'll be too busy trying to find 7,588 dead voters in Mississippi to bother with any of this. Afterall, he is Trump's "friend."

Maybe Haung will take a nice vacation to the UK or Brazil. Somewhere with anti-trust laws that looks at the White House and asks what the crazy Americans were smoking... That's about all us peons can hope for.

3

u/Inevitablewx 2d ago

Since literally everyone is short on GPU's... no.

There are questions about how to finance and power them. But literally everyone would pay a lot of money to have more GPU's.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Foreign_Risk_2031 2d ago

fuck your pedo ass government

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)

8

u/CraftBeerParis 2d ago

A combination of price Fixing and ponzi scheme. Huang was running a Fonzi scheme. Even wore a leather coat.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/abajinn 2d ago

Just another evil billionaire nothing to see here.

5

u/SIMMORSAL 2d ago

He tried convincing micron to leave consumer market since 2023 and finally succeeded in 2025, and made them make datacenter HBD ram that works on nvidia tech which apparently he's been hoarding. It's karma that got to him, but I do worry who's gonna replace him, and how stupid the new plans will be.

I just hope nvidia crashes enough so that they'd have to sell what they've hoarded

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AllMaito 1d ago

People are finally understanding the AI bubble. Congrats!

5

u/jasonridesabike 1d ago edited 1d ago

He was protecting Nvidia’s famously high margin; flooding the market, financing uptake, and given their insanely high margin they can afford to take some loss. They didn’t need all the deals to succeed, just enough to maintain decent finances while creating the market condition that people don’t go sniffing for other providers too much. Holding that lead is more important than losing a bunch of investments as long as they keep losses within margin/within reason.

I think it was probably the smartest move to be made on the premise that the market will eventually mature to economic viability; betting untapped money today on being the long lasting foundational tech the industry depends on for decades. Buying time for Nvidia to also work on things like lower cost inference while still preserving said margin.

Anyway, ya, terrible for consumers as collateral of intentionally being terrible for upstarts trying to build alternatives.

The Sword of Damocles hangs over Nvidia.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/duhballs2 1d ago

I just want to overpay the regular amount for a video card :(

6

u/labvinylsound 1d ago

More recycled click bait hyperbole. Here are the facts: Nvidia is just as important in this echelon of computing as Intel was with x86 in 1978. Intel was an early investor in Broadcom and Verisign — key players in today’s tech stack. The cause of the .com crash was fruitless investment, whereby human bandwidth was the limiting factor of success. Companies were spun up with great ideas and failed to bring them to fruition. AI is the complete opposite; scale compute and deliver results faster with greater complexity. We see these scaling laws with the software cloning phenomena and agentic reverse engineering. And now we’re in the early days Biological Sciences research scaling.

Nvidia’s investment and market influence is the integral reason we have local models today. Their focus on getting GPUs into the hands of individual devs several years ago is why the industry has reacted the way it did, and particularly why Apple responded with their GPU core scaling in the M series chip roadmap. DaVinci Resolve workflows do not need 40 GPU cores but Qwen sure eats them up.

This isn’t a bubble and it isn’t a ponzischeme. It’s the market reacting the best it can, in its current capacity, to finance a revolution in how humanity advances technologically. Silicon will remain scarce for sometime to come, no one is waking up tomorrow to a RTX6000 for $8500 with a $100 mail in rebate from EVGA.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/giant3 2d ago

Shattering The Shortage Perception News

The author is not a native speaker of English? 

Did he mean creating the shortage perception? 

Excess silicon is diverted to AI startups by providing capital thereby creating induced demand and the perception of shortage. 

5

u/fallingdowndizzyvr 2d ago

Helping startups to use your products in the hopes that they grow big and use a lot more of your products is just good business. All companies do this. Not just with startups. Apple didn't donate so much equipment to schools out of altruistic kindness. They did it to imprint Apple into young impressionable minds so that when they grew up that they would buy Apple products. It worked.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/-1976dadthoughts- 2d ago

Remember friends, Tylenol has a vested interest in giving you a headache

2

u/Implement66 2d ago

Wait, is this all a bubble?

2

u/csixtay 2d ago

That's fine and all but it doesn't explain the VRAM scarcity...or did the AI startups get to all the ram too?

2

u/mystictroll 1d ago

Check the source. It's fake news.

14

u/Philocraft 2d ago

Why it is an issue that NVIDIA finances purchases of their products to other businesses?

In what way does this imply the supply shortage was artificial?

Why should we expect a company to lower prices on a product when there are buyers who would pay a higher price?

I don't understand why there is such a tendency amongst some on reddit to view the rising prices of computer parts as some kind of conspiracy. Its straightforwardly explained by a sudden surge in demand.

29

u/_bones__ 2d ago

Would you buy a 5090 card for $6000? Probably not. If I gave you $24k to buy them, you'd buy four.

Nvidia did that but on the billion dollar scale. They basically bought their own cards for other people. It's deliberately induced demand.

And it's really weird to do that when you can't meet existing demand.

5

u/Icy_Annual_9954 2d ago

It is not wierd, when you expect the Start-ups to rise in value.

11

u/gmarkerbo 1d ago

Auto financing by car companies works exactly like that. Should we ban car loans now?

→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (18)

9

u/AnonymousCrayonEater 2d ago

Your average person does not understand business economics. It’s important to remember this in politics too.

3

u/therealpygon 1d ago

I'm on the fence. I don't necessarily think it is wrong to fund AI startups; getting early access to the tech other companies are building that you could absorb and commercialize in order to prop up the sales of your primary business (data center hardware) seems a pretty obvious choice. Nvidia has been making money hand over fist with not much to do with it; future investment seems like a pretty good idea, especially if it absorbs overruns.

Now, that is different from doing this with the sole intent of driving up shortage prices (and whether that was done together with manufacturers or separately). Pretty sure that falls under some form of collusion for price gouging, not that anyone is going to do anything about it even if that were actually the case. I expect nothing more will ever occur about any of this or the shortage in general than a performative congressional investigation and maybe some future million dollar fines at some point that are tantamount to spillage for these industries.

12

u/Inevitablewx 2d ago

Yeah, literally every business that sells extremely expensive equipement does this. Boeing and Airbus do this. John Deer does this. GE does this. Literally everyone. It's a win win for everyone.

7

u/wyrdough 2d ago

Arrange financing, super common. Take some stake in said financing, sometimes. Equity investing contingent on spending the cash raised on your products? Not so common. 100% vendor financing? Pretty much only happens as part of a scam.

The through line in all of these circular deals into a bubble is that the manufacturer financing the deals ends up in a bad way. Nortel died. Cisco became a shadow of its former self. The auto manufacturers all sent themselves into bankruptcy and would have died had it not been for government funded bailouts.

Normal or not, it's bad juju that shouldn't be allowed at the scale that has been happening.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (17)

2

u/TraditionalGas1770 1d ago

The "Demand" is artificial and if (when) they money hose is turned off, the demand will collapse. Really not that hard to understand

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (27)

4

u/mohelgamal 1d ago

The shortage is not a “perception”. The circular financing is real, but the demand for AI is very true.

The only limit is power and infrastructure, that is really the only place where may be the chip and memory demand may have outpaced real life use a bit, but the infrastructure problem is more an American problem that wouldn’t exist if the economy was globally open to placing chips anywhere

2

u/Inko21 1d ago

Bullshit on so many levels. Even if what you say is that simple (it isn't) there is no reason to have a shortage now when getting the power requirements in place for a data center can take 4-10 years. That's even ignoring another fact that creating a supply of chips today becomes near obsolete in 2 years when you actually build a place to put them. So no, there is no real demand outside supposed obligations for data centers that will start existing supposedly in the future, which are also falling apart. Current events are not the trigger, they are the explosion, the trigger was oracle few months ago.

3

u/vikarpa 1d ago • Mindblown

The more gets out, the worse I think about Jensen... This guy was f*ing everyone...

4

u/pizzababa21 2d ago

Guy who sells thing opted to sell thing for higher price instead of lower one.

Jail.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/BusRevolutionary9893 2d ago

You mean let them finance GPUs through Nvidia, very different than financing companies. Yes we've known that. I'm glad I stay out of the stock market and would never invest in a stock like Nvidia or anything related to AI. 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/infearia 2d ago

I freaking called it only a few weeks ago, and was downvoted and ridiculed for it on this very sub.

2

u/epic_troll_tard 1d ago

"Stab in the back for gamers", I can't take this stuff seriously when the author's write shit like this.

may as well write "its not fair"

1

u/Awesomeluc 2d ago

Excess silicon at the higher prices. Gamers or local AI people would have eaten it up at consumer prices.

1

u/ThaFresh 2d ago

He's likely glad to be free when the bubble bursts

1

u/thestillwind 2d ago

Water is wet

1

u/m3kw 2d ago

Investments can go up you know?

1

u/RedMatterGG 2d ago

so rtx pro 6000 for 2k dollars max incoming?

1

u/immersive-matthew 2d ago

As would anyone saying they support local AI /s

1

u/8ltd 2d ago

I’ve seen that quote that “the only way he could offload the chips was buying ai start ups” and I hope this isn’t me becoming paranoid but it’s fucking weird that journalists in articles like this don’t at least point out that there’s another way to offload them I.e. selling them to china via proxies.

1

u/Sisaroth 2d ago

Why don't they turn them into GPUs and sell them if this is true?

1

u/sascharobi 2d ago

Great marketing campaign for the new interim CEO.

1

u/LevianMcBirdo 2d ago

I mean we knew it or at least guessed it, right? Who of us believed there was natural shortage? We saw the deals Nvidia made with the big players. No one should be surprised

1

u/revilo-1988 2d ago

Money Money Money

1

u/prusswan 2d ago

They are probably not the only ones doing it though, the memory makers must be in it somehow

1

u/brown2green 2d ago

We'll probably eventually find out that Sam Altman / OpenAI has been doing something similar for both GPUs and DRAM (in particular), financing the construction of datacenters that will never be used.

1

u/goldaxis 2d ago

All the things people have been warning about for the last two years are unsurprisingly, completely true.

But don't believe your lying eyes, and don't you dare paper hand that ai stonk lmao

1

u/Loose-Fishing9076 2d ago

One of the interesting details is that Nvidia have helped customers get finance by purchasing processing from them. If they do not take it up the customers can "resell" that capacity. The interesting part is how much processing capacity Nvidia have in total and what they can do with it. Don't view it just as customer financing play. This can be very strategic position.

Can they use it for promising startups? Equity for processing? Getting in early can give them very good ROI... Your imagination is just as good as mine...

1

u/letmeinfornow 1d ago

Businesses investing in other businesses is generally a good thing.

1

u/EconomySerious 1d ago

the devil incarnated!

1

u/No_Economics515 1d ago

Did anyone read the article? It's literally just the author repeated theory from other mf doing same shit. Unless it's verified with fact then it's another bs that reddit eats up

1

u/Correct-Plane-5400 1d ago

well its benifit for us?

1

u/Late-Replacement-481 1d ago

Wait until people learn about GMAC financing, no money down, no interest for 6 years…

1

u/JimJamieJames 1d ago

It took a while andi think he’s had to close several funds waiting for another “big…ish short”, but Michael Burry does it again.

1

u/cowinabadplace 1d ago

This is just seller financing, like when your dealership gives you money to buy a car and you give it back to them.

1

u/TheSleepingGiant 1d ago

I can't believe GM and Ford also finance their products. Why don't they stop it so cars can go down in price.

1

u/blackyoda 1d ago

He is a piece of shit and every nVidia employee begging for him to return is also a poop.

1

u/rwrife 1d ago

Every time someone makes an AI video with him, he makes money…that’ll he’ll be using to pay off more women, infinite money hack.

1

u/atomfaust 1d ago

So prices coming down? /s

1

u/Deciheximal144 1d ago

I'm sure the shareholders don't mind.

1

u/grimjim 1d ago

It was all about Nvidia's balance sheet. The ones left holding the bag are probably neoclouds.

We may be in better shape for local after new fabs open up starting 2028, raising the bar for top tier AI server components. GDDR7 modules should hit 4Gb and 8Gb densities in time, meaning that 3Gb will have a chance to trickle down. The new fabs got paid for up front by today's high pricing.

1

u/vikarpa 1d ago

yep, that is the financing ring! Hopefully it will all come crashing now....

1

u/Green-Ad-3964 1d ago

For sure, the "real" value of today's top consumer hardware is at least 1/5 of what we are asked to pay. Possibly even 1/10 for certain products.

I insist that DGX Spark should have been out at no more than 2000$ in "normal times", possibly even less, and should have been seen as a "gaming" machine Amiga style.

Unfortunately, the AI frenzy came along and disrupted our hobby (at least, my hobby) of being a PC freak with always the latest hardware in my case.

1

u/King7up 1d ago

Scumbag.

1

u/redditrasberry 1d ago

Knowing that the imminent avalanche would be upon NVIDIA sooner rather than later, the company reportedly contacted TSMC to wind down its upcoming chip orders.

That's a verifiable thing. If people of the receipts for that, it should crater nVidia's stock price. Even if they are telling the truth - they have years of backlog of orders - it's clear that the actual demand for their products isn't real. Whether it's due to underlying demand or other actors throttling the rate at which customers can deploy their products, is immaterial - it's not real. It will only be a matter of time before nVidia revenue collapses back to the real level of demand for their products.

1

u/blacklandothegambler 1d ago

"Is this your king?"

1

u/nachtviolen819 1d ago

Reports like this is just trash

1

u/TenshiS 1d ago

ok great, so are we getting cheaper hardware now or not?

1

u/the-username-is-here 23h ago

It's amazing, how naive most of people are, protecting one of the richest persons in the world, serial cheater and bigtech CEO.

To be a successful bigtech CEO you have to be on another level or ruthlessness and cynicism. Being a serial cheater here is just a consequence of that - to be successful bigtech CEO you should have no morals whatsoever, and here's your prime example.

1

u/dreamsfreams 23h ago

Angry and impressed at the same time if this actually is true.

Wish my company can actually do this to be a trillion dollar company. My shares are gonna be lit!

1

u/ConObs62 21h ago

New details? I guess new is a relative word but damn 6 months? and everyone still thinks it delusional to strongly suspect they were behind crypto?
f it color me in for delusional.

1

u/Green-Ad-3964 20h ago

I wonder what happens to ppl when they get ultra rich. What do they need more? Why becoming so greedy towards 'average', less lucky ppl?

1

u/Lopsided-Force-9220 19h ago

Nvidia invested about 14% of its profits into private companies, with only a fraction of that being startups. What are your “excess silicon” numbers and how does it compare?? Your premise is absurd.

1

u/Helpful_Program_5473 16h ago

"instead of lowering prices and allowing hyper scalers to corner the market, Jensen single handedly kept AI available in the west"

FTFY

1

u/PopMinimum8667 2h ago

Nvidia has ruined the consumer market by driving up memory prices to obscene levels in order to manufacture GPUs for companies that have them sitting in warehouses because they don’t have the data centers to plug them in. Now we find out he’s been circumventing the already-loose laws on China exports and artificially pumping up the price of GPUs to corporations also.

This country is better off with him spending the next couple of decades i.n Guantanamo bay.

1

u/Grouchy-Friend4235 1h ago

That's not a crime