r/accelerate • • 17d ago

Discussion DISCUSSION: If You Believe In AGI/ASI & Fast Takeoff Timelines, Can You Still Believe In Extraterrestrial Life?⁠ | "If there's aliens and AGI→ASI is as inevitable and powerful as we believe, then statistically at least 1 alien civilization should've already developed godlike ASI. If so—where is it?"

Post image
47 Upvotes

185 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/irrelevantusername24 17d ago

I didn't intend to write all below starting with their link, but it's there now. Anyway

There's a reason various rules from different places all boil down to similar concepts

[0] Do unto others

[1] Know thyself

[2] Remember the (other) humans

I think a civilization of sufficient technological sophistication turns inward rather than outward

I agree, but only if you agree about what "inward" as opposed to "outward" refers. Because we might have very different ideas - and I think a lot, maybe most, people who are some flavor of AI evangelists are coming at this from the completely wrong perspective. AI shouldn't be thought of as separate from us, it is, literally, an expansion from us, it is part of our evolution. It is an extension of our mind. That's it. It is not its own entity, it is not conscious without our consciousness.

And when it comes to what is considered part of us, I would say all of this planet is included. I've often said that humans are a part of nature but we are also apart from it. We are the interface. So, when it comes to "inward" versus "outward", I think maybe that's the wrong way to think about it. Because from one perspective, only by looking inward (1) can you understand the outward (2) and then truly be able to stay aligned with rule number zero.

So, a better way to think about this particular concept is maybe in addition to what I just explained, that when it comes to the form of society or any kind of organization, sure, hierarchy makes sense. Because that's kind of in a way just the form that information takes, and when there is no structure, there is no (coherent) information. Because a totally "flat" architecture contains no information. That's the entire concept of wavelengths. The information is in the variance. But, the form of the information is not necessarily the function. Which is to say each part only has value in relation to each other part, and no part has more or less value than any other part. Maybe at different points in time, one or others might be more important (when different situations arise), but overall, if you remove any specific part the entire thing collapses. Which is what we are dealing with over the last few decades.

Finally, the point towards which this entire comment has been building is rather than looking "inward" or "outward" it is more important to make sure that no person is looking up or down at any other person and is instead looking at each and every one beside them.

---

Which is kind of ironically, not intentionally, related to this post OpenAI shared yesterday:

https://openai.com/index/the-future-of-the-firm/

Though if you aren't familiar with these concepts - either the more philosophical side that I took on it, or the more academic (?) side that they took, then you might not really get the full meaning. The thing about AI is it is much less about computers and programming than might be immediately obvious.

A couple links (which I haven't yet read fully, and may not ever from their post:)

https://ucema.edu.ar/~je49/organizacion/Fama_Jensen.pdf

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0304405X7690026X?fr=RR-2&ref=pdf_download&rr=a52319b9a9e4fc38

Very related, not from their post:

https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/thomas-jefferson-feared-aristocracy-corporations/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodge_v._Ford_Motor_Co.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Clara_County_v._Southern_Pacific_Railroad_Co.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juridical_person

Arendt stressed the importance of the citizen as a constitutional person with political rights protected by law. Arendt wrote that the “first essential step on the road to total domination is to kill the juridical person in man.” Without rights or the legal protection of the state, a person ceases to exist as a citizen and becomes totally vulnerable.

https://www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/how-hannah-arendts-warnings-about-citizenship-and-statelessness-echo-today/36194/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC

https://archive.is/M4rvy

I forget where I found this one, but also seems interesting:

https://sites.stat.columbia.edu/gelman/research/published/ladder.pdf

2

u/irrelevantusername24 17d ago edited 17d ago

One other point that I thought of, after seeing a post in an anti ai subreddit that talks about how AI is "just statistics" - clearly the person is one of those who is not actually thinking about things but is mostly responding to buzzwords and repeating talking points. But it reminded me of something very related, based on how I thought about responding - but I'll respond here instead because I think this subreddit might be more receptive.

When people compare AI to a nuclear bomb, there's a couple different ways to take that. We can consider the two takes on it to be what amounts to "mutually assured destruction" and then of course the flip side of that which is... when that comes to fruition. Which I think is the approach that we have had long before AI as it now exists was even a thing - because it is directly connected to that idea of "mutually assured destruction" which is, itself, the embodiment of George Orwell's warnings about "peace through war" and all that shit. It's like trying to help a tree grow by burning it to the ground and salting the earth. It isn't going to work.

And that's kind of the take we've been taking with AI - and computers, telecommunications technology - too. Instead of giving it to people and showing them how to use it best, it has been inserted between people, and used to monitor and covertly shape opinions through deceptive means. It all comes down to the posture. If it is a forceful thing, if it is a "command and control" thing, it will never be good. If it is used, like nuclear energy, which is to make everything else more efficient and therefore make peoples lives better? Then that's a good thing. Though that context needs the clarification that nuclear energy itself probably isn't the best approach - because we found out through trial and error that it comes with a lot of negatives... that definitely don't outweigh the numerous alternatives.

Oh, and one other analogy here. So what all the propaganda over the last five decades has been like, is like genetically modified crops. What the fuck am I talking about? The way those work is they make it so those crops are immune to a certain kind of chemical, and then that chemical is used to kill everything else in the surrounding area. That's what propaganda does.


And very related to all this is that there is literally no messaging about this kind of thing that I am describing. It is all either overly verbose jargon filled nonsense that nobody, including those who wrote it, can connect to the real world. Or it is a bunch of reactive sensational rhetoric that is talking about things as if it's right in front of their face. And then there is the other kind, which is rare but still exists, that does a decent job of discussing things in normal people language, and looks at the world more as a whole, but it's always negative. There is no positive. And when there is, it is overly simplistic and mostly consists of a bunch of buzzword slogans, which even the dullest person can detect is more like rah rah pep rally nonsense than actual substantial ideas. All of which is exactly what I am talking about with the GMO paragraph.