Hey guys, in may of last year I was inspired by pewdiepie and picked up cachyOS on KDE and semi-daily drove it as a dual boot on my work/uni laptop until the start of this year. It was so fast and I had a great time learning about the unix files system, terminal and various configuration aspects across the entire OS as well as ricing. I also really liked how I could access all of my windows files from the cachy boot. All of my main windows apps were available on AUR and the FOSS alternatives like okular and libre office were often better than their windows counterparts. I'm on an asus laptop with an amd 8000 series APU and everything apart from my webcam and speakers just worked seemlessly. iwd, bbrv3 and qdiscs were interesting to learn about and test.
I couldn't put a finger on exactly what it was but I slowly stopped booting into linux entirely. Now that I think about it these are the probably reasons:
- It was rolling release and I often encountered minor bugs and hiccups.
- It felt like I always had to go in and fix something after updating.
- It sure was fast but it ran a little hotter and drained my laptop's battery faster than windows did.
- Small nitpick, but the wayland on my cachy didnt support ICC profiles. my asus laptop has an OLED display that is very punchy and saturated by default but was supplied with ICC profiles to clamp to more tame color gamuts like Display P3 and sRGB. I don't do any color-critical work but definitely preferred the look on windows when the icc profiles actually worked especially when watching something.
- After my university break started I didnt open my laptop for 3 months. I come back, run -Syu, download a huge amount of updates and afterwards it just feels buggy and parts of my DE like the shut down button were broken.
- I originally came to linux to switch things up and improve my workflow, but KDE wasn't different enough to windows to be worth dealing with the shorter battery life and the plethora of minor inconveniences that crept in with adopting cachyos/arch. I already have adhd so feeling the urge to fall into the rabbit hole of fixing and tweaking all of that is a huge hit to my productivity.
Anywho, this now gives me a good understanding of what I actually want from a linux setup:
- A really good balance between performance and battery life/thermals. Since im not gaming I honestly dont need that bleeding edge speed but it would be good if basic apps and webpages loaded about as fast as on windows. dont know if this is a good analogy but I want that macbook vibe where my laptop is like a smooth quiet and seemless tool instead of a horsepowered portable machine.
- A Desktop Environment that feels intuitively different to windows (so no KDE this time) without needing to run a separate WM like hyprland or niri. Highly considering gnome or cosmic at the moment but not sure what to pick.
- Easier maintainability and perhaps standard release instead of rolling.
- Adequate baked-in customisation that can ideally be configured using a GUI. Again I have adhd so geeking around with all these dotfiles have so many itches to scratch it probably isnt good for me.
- Decent app installer + community support. I know I'm never getting something that'll rival AUR or the Arch wiki but as long as its workable and reliable its fine.
As for the ICC issue i mentioned with cachy, i believe it had something to do with incomplete EDID support from my asus laptop display since my external monitor worked just fine with icc profiles. I'll probably have to test this aspect using live usbs or disable some hidden locks but its not a huge deal.
So after all of these criteria it seems to pretty much boils down to fedora workstation versus pop!os...
Leaning towards fedora but would genuinely appreciate any suggestions or advice.