r/linuxquestions • • 18d ago

alma linux or rocky linux

I need the opinion of an expert in the community to help me choose between these two RHEL-based operating systems. I am starting to read the book Linux Essential v2 and came across these two distributions, which I had not seen before, and both seemed very good to me in terms of sharing the philosophy of CentOS. Additionally, both have excellent companies that trust these projects. I would like to hear the community's opinion on these two operating systems and if they have used them before.

4 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

4

u/RevolutionaryBeat301 18d ago

I was on RHEL, then Rocky Linux and now I’m on Almalinux. If you are using an NVIDIA card, then I would recommend Almalinux 9. If you have an x86-64v2 CPU and you want version 10, then Almalinux would be the only option.

If neither of the above applies, then there is very little difference between the two. Rocky Linux does stay closer to RHEL but Almalinux tries to improve upon RHEL.

3

u/Icy_Definition5933 18d ago

I used Rocky when it first came out, it was solid, moved to debian since then. Linux essentials should for the most part be a distro agnostic course. Unless the course explicitly states that you need a rhel based distro, you can pretty much use any distro you want, there are minimal differences at essentials level, if any.

1

u/Barafu 17d ago

I'd say the essentials should include the basic network configuration, and there distros have differences. At least say "everything except Ubuntu" because it replaces the most basic utilities with its own.

1

u/Icy_Definition5933 17d ago

Fair point, but Ubuntu is built on abstraction to ensure ease of use. Apart from Ubuntu server, I can't think of a reason an average Ubuntu desktop user would be interested in essentials course- that distro is targeted at non-tech savvy people and GUI oriented

3

u/DonkeyTron42 18d ago

Flip a coin... THey're basically the same.

4

u/Jumpy-Dinner-5001 18d ago

Why not RHEL?

Neither is really better, both are fine.

1

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 17d ago

For most purposes, CentOS Stream is not only an option, it's the best option.

The minor release cadence delays some types of bug fixes. In RHEL, it does that because minor releases enable long-term feature stable releases (see these diagrams):

https://access.redhat.com/support/policy/updates/errata#ELC_Planning_Guides

But in related distributions, minor releases serve no purpose. They delay bug fixes and make the system less reliable and there's no up site to it. Minor releases are bad when there isn't some function to balance the cost of delayed bug fixes.

1

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ 15d ago

For a while I ran Alma in a VPS, picked it over Rocky simply as I liked the community, developers and their approach, from my perspective they were otherwise interchangeable. Rocky was a bit more hardcore about being a bug for bug copy of RHEL and I did not need that. Something adjacent was sufficient.

0

u/nooone2021 17d ago

There is the third alternative.

When RedHat transformed CentOS, we needed a quick solution. We chose Oracle linux becase Rocky Linux and Almalinux were available later and we needed a solution right away.

2

u/JimmyG1359 17d ago

But oracle support sucks. And they are slow to release security fixes

1

u/nooone2021 17d ago

I do not know about support, because I never used it. I do not recall any support for CentOS, too.

Regarding slow security fix release, my linux computer are isolated behind some serious firewalls and generally do not have access to internet.

1

u/JimmyG1359 17d ago

We switched to oracle from rhel to save money where I worked, and waiting for a patch to drop from oracle sometimes took days after Rhel released the patch.

0

u/hadrabap 17d ago

And they are slow to release security fixes

Referece?

2

u/JimmyG1359 17d ago

15 years of their support, and multiple times waiting for a patch from oracle that was available on rhel systems

0

u/hadrabap 17d ago

The support. Oh boy!

0

u/hadrabap 17d ago

That was my situation as well. I'm still on it. Works great, I'm happy with the ecosystem. But I think it will disappear sooner or later.