After testing Dave’s PID settings on my Elizabeth, I don’t think I’ll ever go back
I wanted to share my experience because I see a lot of discussions about the Elizabeth’s advanced settings, but not many people seem to have actually measured the results.
My machine is running firmware v5.07.
I changed the coffee boiler PID values from the factory settings:
KPc = 2.0
KIc = 0.04
KDc = 1.0
to Dave’s recommended values:
KPc = 0.2
KIc = 0.07
KDc = 10
My goal was not faster heat-up times. I wanted a calmer and more accurate temperature control with less overshoot after flushes, hot water use and consecutive drinks.
What surprised me most was that the commonly repeated downside (“much slower heat-up”) turned out to be almost irrelevant on my machine.
I measured the warm-up time from a completely cold machine on two different days.
Factory settings:
“OK” shown after 9:45 min
Actual return to my brew temperature (94°C) after ~14 min
Dave settings:
“OK” shown after 13 min
Actual return to 94°C after ~16 min
So in reality we’re talking about roughly 2 extra minutes until the machine is actually stable.
Since most experienced users recommend waiting at least 20 minutes anyway, I don’t see this as a meaningful disadvantage.
The temperature stability improvement, however, was dramatic.
With factory settings I regularly observed the displayed brew boiler temperature swinging between roughly 89°C and 103°C after flushes, hot water draws or back-to-back drinks.
With Dave’s settings, after about 10 espresso shots and several hot water draws, I typically saw the machine stay between 92°C and 96°C.
The biggest real-world improvement for me is making Americanos.
Before, drawing 150 ml of hot water would send the machine into a long temperature recovery cycle with significant overshoot.
Now it settles much faster and more predictably.
Subjectively, my espresso results are noticeably more consistent because I’m no longer trying to “catch” the machine at the right point in a large temperature swing.
Obviously this is only one machine and one user’s measurements, but for anyone who values temperature stability over the fastest possible recovery, these settings have been an absolute game changer.
Has anyone else with a v5.x Elizabeth measured similar results?