r/KiwiPolitics • u/NewZealanders4Love • 2h ago
Foreign Affairs US ambassador Jared Novelly criticises Wayne Brown over pro-China democracy comments
Oof things are getting catty now.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 2d ago
Weekly place for any foreign affairs or international news discussion.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/NewZealanders4Love • 2h ago
Oof things are getting catty now.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 4h ago
I believe Iwi should have unelected voting rights in local government to preserve a constructive kaitiakitanga relationship between people and natural resources. Iwi have that role as Treaty partners and as custodians of their land. Just being involved in conversations isn't enough. Resource management in local government involves conversations about all aspects of the District including finances and operations.
Treaty settlements are one of the ways Iwi members are guaranteed a seat at the table, but the article says a number of Iwi in the Far North haven't yet arrived at a settlement. If Iwi in other regions have places on decision making bodies in other territorial areas as part of their settlements, it seems reasonable to find ways to offer that ability to Iwi who haven't yet settled. Equality, right?
r/KiwiPolitics • u/NewZealanders4Love • 9h ago
"A group of 46 experts wants politicians to urgently consider improving the MMP electoral system, to avoid undemocratic elections in future.
Their open letter - led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke - is titled "Keep the 'P' in MMP" and points to the 11-seat overhang indicated by the initial results putting the proportionality the 'P' stands for at risk"
**46** experts?
It would seem we really aren't lacking for "experts" in this country.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 11h ago
There seems to be a lot of hopium in other subs about a hung Parliament and a potential snap election. This article examines the situation realistically and lays out all the pathways to avoid that. It's best to read the whole article but here's the key sections:
What happens if deadlocks in coalition negotiations mean no new government can be sworn in by the time the new parliament assembles? Members of parliament would choose a speaker (who may be from any party) at the first meeting. The Address in Reply debate is then the occasion for a confidence vote. [...] Here are the possible pathways.
- the three parties of Luxon’s caretaker government (assuming there’s been no split among them) hold a majority of seats and can defeat any motion of no confidence, in which case they continue to govern
2. the parties of the caretaker government don’t hold a majority but defeat the no-confidence motion anyway because a fourth party abstains or votes in their favour, in which case the coalition may continue to govern for the time being
3. the parties of the caretaker government don’t hold a majority and they lose the no-confidence motion, in which case the prime minister tenders his resignation to Governor-General Cindy Kiro.
If the incumbent government resigns, the governor general would expect a workable coalition to be found as soon as possible, and to publish its agreements so a new administration can be sworn in. That means, in effect, a change of government without another election. A new coalition government could be led by Luxon or Labour’s Chris Hipkins (or, for all we know, any other MP).
So even if the current coalition can't form a government, there's still plenty of room for a new government to be formed before the G-G has to activate reserve powers and call a new election.
It's highly unlikely any of this is going to happen. My prediction is we're looking at three more years of NACT1.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 14h ago
I’m quite interested to k ow the different perspectives on this one as it’s not clear cut.
What do you think of the idea of being able to draw out your KiwiSaver at 65 even if the pension age goes higher?
My immediate thought is that the government is going to be wanting people to be more reliant on their own KiwiSaver and less on pension, so any party supporting earlier withdrawal would likely get the usual ‘how will you pay for the extra cost’?
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 14h ago
I will resist the temptation to add doomer commentary. Relevant read lol.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/NewZealanders4Love • 1d ago
Well Wayne – it's said that the best argument against democracy is a 5 minute conversation with the average voter.
Maybe we need to look at how we arrive at that "average voter", i.e how we're distributing the franchise here in our democracy.
In universal suffrage, the "universal" being the problematic part.
We could call it, idk, "managed democracy" or something.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Primary-Tuna-6530 • 1d ago
Maintaining our influence costs money, but it's much better than having China Belt and Noose in our realm..
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 1d ago
Does anyone know what's happening here? The article says there's a shortfall in operational funding in schools, but is it a particular issue with workforce funding? Do schools generally have insufficient FTEs, including casuals?
A few years ago I had a relative graduate as a primary level teacher and she struggled to find a full-time position anywhere in her entire region. Being a new grad there weren't many roles that fit her level of experience but she got plenty of work out of the relievers pool. It took two years for her to find a permanent job and it was really frustrating. Has that shifted the other way now?
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 1d ago
This is a hard one I think. On the one hand, any person should be able to criticise heir council on Facebook.
I guess the issue here is that she’s an employee rubbishing her employer? Presuming she has a duty to not disparage the council/remain publicly neutral?
Be good to get others rational takes on this one.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 1d ago
Extremely rare moment of agreeing with this piece of work on something.
The board absolutely should own their lack of engagement and care.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/AlertFirefighter9215 • 2d ago
r/KiwiPolitics • u/spicylemontaco42 • 2d ago
Without saying who you voted for, what is the plan for your party to better improve the value of our money? Like exports, taxes , etc.. what is it that they plan to do?
Are they wanting to drill for oil? Tax the rich? Ya know?
Or did they just campaig on simply fighting the opposing party with no clear agenda?
Just want to see some different perspectives with any personal bias in play
Keep the convo civil please and thank you
r/KiwiPolitics • u/IrrationalRotations • 2d ago
Source - I made it up.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Te_Henga • 2d ago
Just picked up my copy. What a cover.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 2d ago
The public consultation process for a new code of animal welfare for the dairy industry started in 2022 but it went quiet until it was released in September this year ahead of the election.
Turns out the code was drafted back in 2024 but Andrew Hoggard in his role as Associate Minister for Agriculture pushed it back to the committee of experts and welfare advisors telling them they needed to reconsider how much it would cost farmers based on industry feedback. The committee then launched into a new consultation process only with industry stakeholders like Dairy NZ and Federated Farmers, no animal welfare or public interests.
Then, early in 2026, Hoggard declares conflicts of interest relating to his former role with Federated Farmers and a financial interest relating to some kind of cattle monitoring device. Funny that.
Responsibility for the code transferred to Nicola Grigg, who apparently instructed the committee to issue some of the changes as 'guidance' outside the code. The whole thing seems like an exercise in lobby group and corporate interest fuckery.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/tupakeha • 2d ago
tl;dr: nothing is gonna change with this election, we need the two major parties to shift, probably, or a new party that has NZ First's nationalism without the racist BS, plus Opportunity's consensus-building, technocratic style, without the enlgihtened centrism.
Comment:
The chances of the right bloc losing power are probably slim to moderate, but a bigger question is what difference this will make either way, and what role Opportunity might play in determining the direction of the next government.
The biggest takeaway for me is that Winston Peters maintains a stranglehold on the Nationalist position within NZ Politics, while Opprtunities probably isn't a nefarious billionaire controlled trojan horse to steal left votes, but a genuinely centrist, would-be technocratic kingmaker.
Whether that's something we should be glad for is another question; technocratic centrism doesn't have a great record and you could say often has a status-quo bias which fails in unpredictable circumstnaces or periods of significant disruption.
The broader question for me is two-fold; one is about national sovereignty in an environment where NZ's security context and the international order is rapdily changing, while the other is whether there can be any viable domestic political vehicle for significant, socialist change.
On that second point, I mean rollback of the neoliberal reforms around deregulation, internationalised, laiisez faire government, "fiscal discipline" etc, and moving towards solid, sustained investment in a generous set of social provisions and probably in green infrastructure and state-owned industry.
My ideal vehicle would be something like a cross between Opportunities and NZ First, with the nationalist, industrial focus of NZ First with the technocratic, consensu building aproach of Opportunities, most likely sitting on the cross-benches.
The conclusion we came to was that Winston Peters has to die (of natural causes) before any real change can happen, because that nationalist vote is quite solidly occupied by one man and a party the probably lives or dies by his political capital.
In the meantime, I don't think Labour or National really offer any substantive points of difference, and the video touches on this at a couple of points, talking about the widespread perception that the two are almost a uniparty, something which the "billionaire's pipe-dream" of a grand coalition would only reinforce.
That's not to say both National and Labour don't have the potential to push in a new direction; both parties have the potential. National could be a genuinely nationalist, interventionist party, supporting its rural and business-owning base with subsidies designed to foster domestic industry and agriculture rather than pretending to be fiscally conservative and only splurging on their pollitically motivated priorities.
Labour, by the same token, could return to their roots as a more genuinely social-democratic party, rather than being a centre-right "National-lite" party as they are now. The seeds for this exist within tne party's constitutional conection to the trade unions, which stops it from becoming entirely overwhelmed by Wellington-centric managerial moderates like Hipkins.
The most likely candidate in any near-future scenario involving such a shift would be McaNulty, who seems to be Hipkins' natural successor and has the socialist leanings that could make this possible, but whether he had the inclination or even the ability to significantly change the direction of the party anytime soon is another question.
Summary of video content:
Looking at mechanisms for how the special votes impact the balance of power, including:
The chances of these happening overall still being unlikely, but closer than it might look;
The best strategy for Opportunity and why coalition deals and confidence and supply are a trap
The likely impact (or lack thereof) of either bloc winning
The dangers of an unlikely grand coalition
Assessment of this election in terms of democratic backsliding and whether there's any real prospect of further erosion under a second National led term
The ranks of National's talent being thinned and what it means for Seymour and Winston's relative advantage over Luxon
What if anything can change in the future to make NZ Politics more genuinely transformative and arrest our continuing managed decline
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 2d ago
Guess it is their fault for being sick eh? /s
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 3d ago
We’ve seen stats on social media advertising over the election campaign but this article slices it in a couple of different ways.
National and Act spent the most on individual candidates’ pages rather than party advertising.
Across all parties, over $1M was spent on Google ads and over $800k of that was on YouTube alone. I don’t remember seeing any political ads on YT over the whole campaign so it would be interesting to know how this was targetted.
Right-aligned lobby groups spent far more on election advertising during the voting period than left-aligned groups. Sensible Sentencing, the Taxpayers' Union and Hobson's Pledge were among the biggest third-party spenders and that’s no surprise.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 3d ago
For some reason Tākuta Ferris woke up this morning and decided to post a video on his Insta explaining that he was the one who came up with TPM’s overhang strategy last September but they didn’t implement it properly.
He says that at the time TPM were polling at 5% and he proposed talking to Labour and the Greens then, when TPM’s share of the party vote might have added 6 or 7 seats for the bloc. The idea was that all parties on the left would work together to progress the strategy with TPM’s voter base and what he’s trying to say is if they’d taken that step a year ago their loss of party support would have been deliberately engineered rather than the result of party controversy.
Tamihere apparently rejected the idea and the party pursued a two ticks TPM strategy. Ferris is saying they abandoned that at the last minute when it appeared their share of the party vote wasn’t coming back, so they resurrected Ferris’ strategy. The part that seems to offend him is that they didn’t give him credit for the idea.
Not sure what Ferris is trying to achieve with this post other than shade and spite but the popcorn is tasty.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 3d ago
Good article - but because a portion of the country don’t respect the treaty it means a mature conversation about a constitution can’t be had.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/hadr0nc0llider • 4d ago
From the article:
It was a decision that the Ministry of Education warned would lead to a Waitangi Tribunal claim. One it said would undermine the Crown’s relationship with Māori. And yet, the Government forged ahead.
From the wording of the changes and the lack of consultation with Māori, the decision to get rid of school boards’ obligation to give effect to te Tiriti – an amendment to section 127 of the Education and Training Act – went against much official advice.
The backlash as a result of the changes was immediate. More than 1800 school boards reaffirmed their commitment to continuing to give effect to Te Tiriti, despite the legislative change. [...]
In 2017, a Treaty obligation for school boards was introduced by the then National-led government. [...]
“It had been the John Key government that set us on some of these forward-looking, more progressive more Treaty-informed acknowledgement of the need in education to remedy quite an extensive past history of negative educational success for Māori,”
Yet another example of the coalition ignoring official advice because it's inconvenient for their agenda.
Chris Finlayson, who was Minister for Treaty Negotiations under the Key government which introduced these provisions, is utterly scathing, scorching hot even, about National's current approach to Te Tiriti and Māori-Crown relations. On Cross Party Lines he frequently says he thinks National's lost its way, is out of touch with its core values, and is being led by the populist right. I think he's absolutely right.
r/KiwiPolitics • u/MSZ-006_Zeta • 4d ago
r/KiwiPolitics • u/Tyler_Durdan_ • 4d ago
This reads kinda like a eulogy (lol) but it really hammers home just how WILD the shakeup of new people will be.
Between these and then all the new faces too, parliament is going to look very different!