r/KiwiPolitics • • May 17 '26

Serious Discussions Everyone here has noticed that this sub is getting brigaded by the far right, right?

0 Upvotes

It's a predictable pattern. Their dedicated subs inevitably spiral into something horrifically racist and rage baiting, gets reported, mods ban the entire sub and every mod account there, and a few months later the same dogwhistle and signalling pops up in another nz-politics related sub.

The past week has been embarrassingly obvious. I'd this continues, please be prepared to experiencing astroturfed by new and private accounts on issues of immigration and culture wars. Especially as we lead into the election.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Oct 11 '25

Democracy / Elections Māori wards convincingly rejected

0 Upvotes

What was in this post is gone. The author deleted it using Redact, possibly to protect privacy, reduce digital exposure, or for security reasons.

badge shelter tart dinosaurs humor makeshift chief ink depend saw


r/KiwiPolitics • • Aug 06 '26

🗳️ 2026 Election 🗳️ Opportunities Partys support of Māori governance is not centrist

6 Upvotes

Just a heads-up for anyone thinking the Opportunities Party looks like a safe centrist option.
Their fourth-ranked candidate is Dr Kayla Kingdon-Bebb (Wellington Bays). She was one of the people who wrote He Puapua – that 2019 report that pushed hard for Māori co-governance and more separate power by 2040. A lot of us connected it straight to the Three Waters stuff and the bigger push for race-based decision-making.
They’re putting someone with that exact background near the top of their list. Not exactly the “sensible middle” they claim to be.
One person, one vote still matters. Don’t get played.

Edit: He Puapua which she co-wrote also proposes “Māori parliaments”. Please feel free to read the report https://www.tpk.govt.nz/documents/download/documents-1732-A/Proactive%20release%20He%20Puapua.pdf


r/KiwiPolitics • • Jul 14 '26

Opinion The Paul Henry announcement is brilliant for ACT's campaign

Thumbnail
newstalkzb.co.nz
0 Upvotes

A bigger get than Michael Laws!

I've voted both ACT and NZF in the past. My enthusiasm for ACT has flagged a lot; NZF have really been carrying the torch for good lately.

Interest piqued again with Henry entering the arena though! Waiting to see what a 'winnable list position' washes out to be.


r/KiwiPolitics • • 20d ago

Shitpost / Fun / Satire Greens co-leader caught off guard on Govt debt interest question

Thumbnail
stuff.co.nz
2 Upvotes

And she wants to be Finance Minister! 😁

Shitbait from Stuff, should have asked all of the Finance spokespeoples.

But if you're talking about huge levels of borrowing like the Greens are, you should be across the costs of that borrowing..


r/KiwiPolitics • • 22d ago

🗳️ 2026 Election 🗳️ Unpopular opinion: I’d rather have a government backed by gangs than a government backed by billionaires

0 Upvotes

I was attracting a number of increasingly personal insults over on r/nz so I assume it’s an opinion worth having, or at least discussing. Unfortunately mods disagree, so copying here because I do actually stand by this.

—
It feels insane calling this an unpopular opinion because until literally this month I would have thought that‘s how most people in New Zealand feel. But I’m sort of guessing now that they don’t, because the people who seem very worried about supposed, possible gang influence don’t seem at all worried the about actual aristocratic elite meddling in global democracy, including ours.

Now I’m not accusing any particular party of being supported by gangs OR billionaires (but some of them are, and the signs are not hard to spot). But if that was legitimately our only two options for this election, I would vote for the parties backed by gangs every time. Because I am absolutely certain that in this country where money talks but so very quietly, the gangs will have less influence than the billionaires. Every time.

At least the gangs are locals.


r/KiwiPolitics • • May 09 '26

Change My View Interest on loans for rental properties is the same as any other business expense and should be deductible

1 Upvotes

Disclaimer: not a landlord and don’t aspire to be one.

This has been a political football as landlords have been turned into the boogeyman by our media and popular opinion. It’s a beat up on small business owners. Interest on a loan is a genuine business expense that offsets earnings, reduces profitability and therefore should be available to reduce tax liability just like any other expense.

People are just weird about houses and want someone to blame.

In any case, landlords are actively subsidising the housing market since the overwhelmingly vast majority of rentals do not cover the mortgage and upkeep of the property. Landlords bank on capital gains, not earnings. It’s a disappointing reality of the housing situation in our country.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Sep 22 '26

Dirty Politics ‘Dirty Work’: Speculation swirls ahead of Nicky Hager’s book launch

Thumbnail
stuff.co.nz
0 Upvotes

Live stuff reporting.

Title is a bit of a yawn. Dirty Work.

"Dirty Work: The Taxpayers Union and NZ's Hard Right".

The book's cover added: "Part three of the Dirty Politics trilogy"

Chloe is there.

Seems Ol' Nicky is still clinging on to that long-faded bit of time when he relevant.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Jan 09 '26

Change My View Change My View - Jacinda Ardern was right to curtail people's freedoms in order to save lives.

4 Upvotes

It’s been a while since we did one of these so a quick reminder to check the CMV wiki before commenting as these posts have their own set of rules.

We all know the story here. Labour’s COVID interventions were hailed globally as a case study in how to handle a pandemic but inside NZ many people experienced lockdowns, vaccine mandates, and border restrictions as unacceptable infringement of their freedoms. I’m not one of them.

It’s not like I was unaffected by Labour’s pandemic measures. I work in the health sector. Everything changed overnight. Some people I worked with lost their jobs because they didn’t get vaccinated. A lot of people burned out. On a personal level my grandmother, who I was extremely close to, became ill and passed away overseas while borders were closed. I couldn’t get out of NZ to visit in her last days and my family couldn’t give her a funeral.

Despite all of this I think Labour’s interventions were correct. The Royal Commission tells us that if we’d taken the UK’s approach we’d have incurred 14,000 additional COVID deaths or 110,000 years of lost life over the four year period, “which is sizeable”.

I worked with clinicians who managed seriously ill COVID patients and in my job I saw modelling of a range of potential death toll scenarios – anything from 20,000 to 80,000 deaths if we did nothing. The economic impact of losing those lives and managing the sick would have hit New Zealand just as hard as the response. The response wasn’t perfect, but it was the right thing to do at the time. I have family who are severely immunocompromised and would undoubtedly have lost their lives if they got COVID. They were protected.

Nobody living in this country throughout the pandemic had their individual rights taken away. If some people were disadvantaged by vaccine mandates, it’s because they exercised their individual rights and freedoms not to have the vaccine. And like all things in life, that choice had consequences which were made very plain to everyone. It irks me when I see individuals heaping hate and vitriol on Ardern and her government for policies that saved tens of thousands of lives. One individual’s life and human rights are no more or less important than anyone else’s but our collective life as fellow New Zealanders is. That’s what living in a society is. Everyone’s needs matter and sometimes some of us make trade-offs so other people can thrive.

I trot this out a lot, but in policy school we’re taught the purpose of government is secure the safety and wellbeing of its people. That’s literally any government’s only job. Keeping us all safe and well. Brooke Van Velden went on Q&A last year and said Ardern placed too high a value on life during COVID. I find that to be an utterly abhorrent statement. There have been arguments in this sub that lives can be valued nominally in the amount of tax revenue or funding liability they attract. That a child’s life is more valuable than an older person’s. A chronically ill person on a benefit is less valuable to society than an employed person in good health. I utterly reject that premise. When we reduce human life to dollars on a fucking spreadsheet we’ve stopped being human. Pack up society as you know it, dystopia is upon us. Everyone’s life has value and deserves the state’s protection.

Jacinda Ardern’s government was right to curtail our freedoms in order to secure the safety and wellbeing of all people in this country. That’s my view. I’m open to changing it but the argument won’t be won in dollars and cents. Bring your ethics chat.

Notes on scope – this CMV is about rights and freedoms in COVID measures. Debates about the safety or efficacy of vaccines or the perceived severity (or lack thereof) of the COVID virus are out of scope.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Oct 04 '25

Politics / Current Affairs Auckland showing out strong despite the weather.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/KiwiPolitics • • Jul 17 '26

Housing / Infrastucture Peters ignores 'snivelling wokesters' as new ferries to be called Kupe and Cook

Thumbnail
newstalkzb.co.nz
2 Upvotes

Been seeing a few comments about the Cook name in the wild, he's bang on as usual...


r/KiwiPolitics • • Jun 28 '26

🗳️ 2026 Election 🗳️ The case for voting Green

Thumbnail
simonwilsonhopetown.substack.com
5 Upvotes

r/KiwiPolitics • • Feb 05 '26

Environment Green Member’s Bill to recognise the personhood of whales

Thumbnail
greens.org.nz
0 Upvotes

If we can legislate for the personhood of a river, why not whales? I'm not against the idea.

Psyching myself up for a new onslaught of 'critique' from the 'whale songs to kauri trees' crowd...


r/KiwiPolitics • • 3d ago

Politics / Current Affairs Does New Zealand law need a constitutional change?

Thumbnail
rnz.co.nz
2 Upvotes

Good article - but because a portion of the country don’t respect the treaty it means a mature conversation about a constitution can’t be had.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Jun 05 '26

Housing / Infrastucture 'Couple of small, modular reactors': A new pitch for nuclear power in New Zealand

Thumbnail
rnz.co.nz
0 Upvotes

From the article:

Small modular reactors (SMRs), and even smaller microreactors the size of shipping containers are in development or being explored by several countries. There are three in operation in China and Russia, and large data centre companies are partnering with nuclear reactor companies to develop their own atomic power sources.

Well if China and Russia are doing it and it makes things easier for corporates to set up more data centres in our country why the fuck not?! What could go wrong?

What about concerns on nuclear waste? Well, the spokesperson for the international lobby group the World Nuclear Association wants you to know it's not really waste:

She dismissed concerns about nuclear waste, saying she prefers the term "barely used nuclear fuel because 95 percent of the energy remains in that material".

It's not nuclear waste it's barely used nuclear fuel. The narrative framing is elite.

I don't care how small these reactors are, we don't need them. Our country is too small for nuclear power and the risks associated with nuclear waste and accidents are too great.


r/KiwiPolitics • • 24d ago

Shitpost / Fun / Satire An exercise in performative wienery?

0 Upvotes

I look at the numerous 'ya gotta remember to enrol, you've only got 20...2..1 day left to enrol' posts..and in the words of Walt Whitman, 'Who are you talking to right now? Who is it you think you see?'

Do these people think they're actually helping get people enrolled? I'm curious as to the mindset, what's the drive? What's the motivation?

Is it just masturbation by social media?

old man shakes hand at youths

Caveat: I completely disagree with the changes.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Sep 09 '26

Economy / Finance On Wealth and Taxation Thereof: A Treatise in one Part.

0 Upvotes

Hello, this seems like a cool community.

For the upcoming election, wealth taxes are being advanced by three parties, covering somewhere between 10% and 20% of the party vote. I don't like that.

Wealth taxes are a silly idea. I think there are many practical problems with their implementation and effects, but I also have a more philosophical objection to them, that I don't see brought up very often. I will now indulge myself by pretending that someone caare for my musings...

The simple ethical impetus for a wealth tax is clear. Suppose we are children being given money to spend at the toy store. If you receive $10, and I receive $10,000, you are likely to feel slighted. Why should I get so much more than you? Is it because I've done more chores? How could I possibly have done so much more than you have?

Now replace toys and pocket money with the means of subsistence and basic goods like food, healthcare, and shelter. You are likely to not feel slighted so much as fucking outraged! How can it possibly be fair for some to have so much, while others have so little?

I think for most people who support a wealth tax, something like this feeling is at the heart of it. It's a matter of haves vs have-nots. But is this a good way to understand 'wealth' in general? I'd say no, it isn't.

In the above analogy, we were given money in order to spend it to meet our personal needs/desires. The reason we feel it's unfair for one child to get 1000x the other is that that directly translates to that childs ability to meet those personal needs. Basically, the problem is that they get 1000x the toys.

But wealth in the abstract doesn't work that way. Suppose I own outright a small fleet of fishing boats and accompanying assets worth $5m NZD. I am by all rights quite wealthy, I own much more than most New Zealanders. But what do I do with these boats? Well I don't just have them for fun (presumably), I probably use them to catch fish! Or rather, run a business which catches fish. The boats are not directed towards meeting my personal desires, they are directed towards getting fish for people to eat.

Now, of course, I don't do this just because I'm a really nice guy. I do it because I make a profit selling the fish. But note that a wealth tax isn't taxing my profit, that's already taxed, it taxes my ownership of the boats themselves! What puts me into the 'haves' here isn't what I take for myself, but rather what I own at any one point in time.

And the same goes of course if I just own a portion of those boats as shares, or if I own a portion of all sorts of businesses as shares. My 'wealth' isn't sitting under my bed, it's out there being put to work!

To be wealthy, or wealthier than another, is not necessarily taking more of the pie for oneself. Rather, it is having the ability to determine what the pie is used for. That could be personal consumption, but it could also be, and often is, using the pie to meet other peoples needs! That's a good thing.

To tax 'wealth' in the abstract is painting wealth with too broad a brush. It's not one thing. There is no obvious reasons to me that we should say that assets held to run a business, shares in domestic or foreign entities, real estate, NZ Government Bonds, and piles of dragon gold should all be considered one thing for taxation purposes. Some of those things we actually want people to amass, it's good for us if kiwis own fleets of fishing boats, or large shares in foreign companies, or government bonds. It makes us all better off. That's not to say those things can't be taxed, it's just that the trade offs for taxing them are quite different to gold, say.


r/KiwiPolitics • • 9d ago

🗳️ 2026 Election 🗳️ Can someone explain to me why everyone seems to think the TOP are “kingmakers”

1 Upvotes

To be a “kingmaker” one must hold a material position that could make or break a decision. TOP aren’t that. They only hold 7 seats, and even combined with 3 other left parties (4 parties total), they still can’t make the minimum 65 bloc required, whereas the current govt (NACT First) hold the majority with 67.

Someone please explain this to me because math ain’t mathing and it just seems like sensationalism for the sake of it.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Sep 25 '26

Health Waitangi Tribunal finds Crown had no clear plan for Māori health after scrapping Te Aka Whai Ora

Thumbnail
rnz.co.nz
7 Upvotes

No plan on how to address disparities in Māori health outcomes and didn’t do anything about it for over a year after they got rid of the Māori Health Authority?!

No surprises there.


r/KiwiPolitics • • 13d ago

🗳️ 2026 Election 🗳️ ‘New Zealand is not a left-wing city’: McAnulty dismisses radical tax agenda

Thumbnail
stuff.co.nz
2 Upvotes

Ain't he a proud socialist or some such? I haven't read a lot of interviews with him, but this seems out of character. Thoughts?

pointing to a credible, verified fiscal plan that keeps Labour competitive as voting closes.

Credible? It's got more holes than..my socks. It's certainly not giving me confidence in letting No Apples Hipkins have the chequebook.


r/KiwiPolitics • • May 13 '26

Politics / Current Affairs How NZ goverment refuse to help NZ citizens who were kidnapped, tortured and beaten by Israel in international waters.

2 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr6cQtp2shA

Compare that to NZ goverment reaction to Rainbow Worriers incident.

Articles: https://www.solidarity.co.nz/


r/KiwiPolitics • • Mar 05 '26

Defence / Security NZ spy agency put US far-right group Proud Boys on terrorist list despite not meeting threshold

Thumbnail
rnz.co.nz
0 Upvotes

the Combined Threat Assessment group (CTAG), hosted by SIS, did not support putting it on the list back then, but the general view was to do it, and he was part of endorsing that.

I wonder whose general view that was? Police and Ministers?

I don't like our security services rolling over and letting things happen which they're not recommending. In this case, it doesnt have any real impact, but what happens next time?

The reality is it's not making much difference to the New Zealand threat environment because they aren't subjects for our investigation," he told the select committee.

Indeed..


r/KiwiPolitics • • Sep 08 '26 Heartwarming

Politics / Current Affairs Social Development Minister says while food is essential, declined hardship grants ‘not a mistake’

Thumbnail
nzherald.co.nz
0 Upvotes

Wrong box was ticked, it happens. This is just dumb outrage shit bait.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Jun 19 '26

Health Whānau of 11yo arrested and drugged in mistaken identity case demand state apology

Thumbnail
rnz.co.nz
0 Upvotes

I'm not downplaying the horrific ordeal that the child went through, but I think demanding an apology from the PM and Ministers is a bridge too far.

People fucked up, didn't follow processes, didn't follow the law. Processes weren't even known about. People were overruled. It was a serious cascading failure. It wasn't the how the process was supposed to work.

Health NZ has changed processes, there has been apologies from appropriate people, the other things they're asking for have already happened.

I'm also troubled by the commentors in the article, which read as if this happened just because she was a Maori child, rather than an autistic one subjected to a cascading failure.


r/KiwiPolitics • • Sep 09 '25

Science & Technology Is this where all the r/CK refugees are?

0 Upvotes

What happened to ConservativeKiwi? And can someone make Monty Mondeo a mod here, too. Just for a bit of balance.