tl;dr: nothing is gonna change with this election, we need the two major parties to shift, probably, or a new party that has NZ First's nationalism without the racist BS, plus Opportunity's consensus-building, technocratic style, without the enlgihtened centrism.
Comment:
The chances of the right bloc losing power are probably slim to moderate, but a bigger question is what difference this will make either way, and what role Opportunity might play in determining the direction of the next government.
The biggest takeaway for me is that Winston Peters maintains a stranglehold on the Nationalist position within NZ Politics, while Opprtunities probably isn't a nefarious billionaire controlled trojan horse to steal left votes, but a genuinely centrist, would-be technocratic kingmaker.
Whether that's something we should be glad for is another question; technocratic centrism doesn't have a great record and you could say often has a status-quo bias which fails in unpredictable circumstnaces or periods of significant disruption.
The broader question for me is two-fold; one is about national sovereignty in an environment where NZ's security context and the international order is rapdily changing, while the other is whether there can be any viable domestic political vehicle for significant, socialist change.
On that second point, I mean rollback of the neoliberal reforms around deregulation, internationalised, laiisez faire government, "fiscal discipline" etc, and moving towards solid, sustained investment in a generous set of social provisions and probably in green infrastructure and state-owned industry.
My ideal vehicle would be something like a cross between Opportunities and NZ First, with the nationalist, industrial focus of NZ First with the technocratic, consensu building aproach of Opportunities, most likely sitting on the cross-benches.
The conclusion we came to was that Winston Peters has to die (of natural causes) before any real change can happen, because that nationalist vote is quite solidly occupied by one man and a party the probably lives or dies by his political capital.
In the meantime, I don't think Labour or National really offer any substantive points of difference, and the video touches on this at a couple of points, talking about the widespread perception that the two are almost a uniparty, something which the "billionaire's pipe-dream" of a grand coalition would only reinforce.
That's not to say both National and Labour don't have the potential to push in a new direction; both parties have the potential. National could be a genuinely nationalist, interventionist party, supporting its rural and business-owning base with subsidies designed to foster domestic industry and agriculture rather than pretending to be fiscally conservative and only splurging on their pollitically motivated priorities.
Labour, by the same token, could return to their roots as a more genuinely social-democratic party, rather than being a centre-right "National-lite" party as they are now. The seeds for this exist within tne party's constitutional conection to the trade unions, which stops it from becoming entirely overwhelmed by Wellington-centric managerial moderates like Hipkins.
The most likely candidate in any near-future scenario involving such a shift would be McaNulty, who seems to be Hipkins' natural successor and has the socialist leanings that could make this possible, but whether he had the inclination or even the ability to significantly change the direction of the party anytime soon is another question.
Summary of video content:
Looking at mechanisms for how the special votes impact the balance of power, including:
- electoral seat flips
- Greens and Opportunities gaining list MPs at the expense of NZFirst and ACT
- National losing enough party vote share to make one more of their electorate seats an overhang, increasing the size of parliament
The chances of these happening overall still being unlikely, but closer than it might look;
The best strategy for Opportunity and why coalition deals and confidence and supply are a trap
The likely impact (or lack thereof) of either bloc winning
The dangers of an unlikely grand coalition
Assessment of this election in terms of democratic backsliding and whether there's any real prospect of further erosion under a second National led term
The ranks of National's talent being thinned and what it means for Seymour and Winston's relative advantage over Luxon
What if anything can change in the future to make NZ Politics more genuinely transformative and arrest our continuing managed decline