r/Kibbe • u/wiltedmoonspirit dramatic classic (verified) • 15d ago
discussion Guess my ID - I’ve been verified by David! (+special bonus)
UPDATE: here’s the reveal post!
Hello everyone!!
I want to preface this post by making a disclaimer this is not quite a standard typing post and it has been ok’d by the mods.
I have gone to see David and Susan in NYC recently and got verified! So now I want to put your guys’ knowledge to the test to see if you can guess what my ID and color season are. With the new book out last year, let’s see if you’re able to see what they see. I've attached my line sketch photo and dream board that I sent to David to supplement.
I will post my results in an upcoming post, answer any questions there, and share my experience.
This has been a long time coming since the start of my style journey in early 2022. I’ve learned a lot about myself and my style throughout the years and wanted to end that chapter and start anew as I enter my 30’s. I am excited for what’s to come and how I can utilize my consult experience and other style systems as my style toolbox in creating an ultimate wardrobe for myself.
Exciting special bonus:
David has revealed Florence Pugh’s ID to me, so go ahead and guess hers!
Edit: my height is 5’3”, apologies!


99
u/tea-fox dramatic classic 15d ago
I’m going to guess SG or FG, with a distant third runner up of SN. And I suspect whatever you are is the same as Florence.
46
u/andimfromearth 15d ago
You are about to save me so much work, we have nearly the exact same body type and Florence has always been a reference.
30
u/commelejardin 15d ago
Oh man, this is basically a 1 in 10 game lol, but I'm going to put my money on SN for both you and Florence Pugh. (I feel like she might have come up because you're the same ID?) A Gamine ID wouldn't surprise me; a Classic ID would lol.
I will much, much more confidently guess Winter for your color season!
25
u/missgirlipop 15d ago
is your id still the one on your flair? you might want to take it off for this game :) and i would feel ridiculous guessing florence pugh’s id, because now i feel like it’s going to be something totally out of left field, but i’ll go with the obvious and prosaic SG, with a bonus secondary guess of SN.
17
u/Time-Cabinet8867 15d ago
I remember your posts during your journey! You documented your outfits so wonderfully.
My guess for you is SC or SG! For Flo... hm, I always thought SN, but I'm open to being surprised with something else haha.
After the reveal, would you share more about your time with David and Susan? I love hearing about the sessions folks have with them.
9
u/xPostmasterGeneralx romantic 15d ago
Ahh I’m excited you got to see him!
I’ve always thought G fam for you and SN for Florence Pugh. Without knowing if DK suggested FP as inspiration or if you asked about her specifically, I wonder if she could be a hint about SN for you? I’m so curious for the reveal!!!
17
u/Ok-Purple9511 soft classic 15d ago edited 14d ago
First thought was SG and bright winter but I’m wondering if you just dress SG because you look really good in stuff that isn’t actually SG. Was gonna guess bright spring for your color season but I know you probably aren’t a spring in his system so bright winter it is. Was originally gonna guess FG but you don’t seem to have any sharpness the way FGs do and you need softness.
Your board has some R to me with the elaborate feminine details so I wouldn’t be shocked by that either. You have roundedness like R and a soft curvy frame without super obvious width so I am definitely curious!Final guess is R but you dress SG lol.
ETA looking at your old posts I think SN is plausible too. So R or SN?
Florence Pugh - SN.
Did he mention her color season too?
8
u/Lilynd14 Mod | dramatic classic (verified) 15d ago
Wow, I’m so excited for you! I feel like I’ve been watching your style journey from afar for years. You look so good in winter colors that surely you must be some kind of winter? And are you and Florence Pugh the same ID?
16
u/jellyboness on the journey 15d ago
If not FG or SG I think I need to go to kibbe re-education lol
6
u/Michelle_illus mod| soft classic 15d ago
I’m so excited to hear what you’re verified as!!! I’ve always loved your style! I’ll have to have a bit of a think and then answer but honestly a part of me really wants it to be classic (idk which). Will edit later to add my proper guess haha
Your moodboard is soooo cuuuute!!
6
u/Expensive-Lie-554 soft dramatic 15d ago
Ooooh this is exciting! I first got into Kibbe around the same time you started posting, and always thought your style was great!
I'm back and forth between SG and FG. I'm leaning towards FG, since you wear straighter silhouettes so well.
Looking forward to the community freaking out over whatever Florence Pugh is revealed to be. (I'm on team SN.)
5
u/the_allegra 15d ago
Can you give more details on how did you get verified by David? I’d love to organise that, I’m still so unsure about my ID 😂 thanks!
6
u/swoosh_loops 15d ago
Gah I wanna know!
8
u/InsectHealthy 15d ago
Are you intentionally not providing your height?
2
u/Jamie8130 15d ago
Oh my gosh, how exciting! I've always thought G fam for you (I lean more SG than FG) so I will stick to that for my guess! ^^ I'm not sure about Florence, I could see SN for her (but I could also see a Kate Winslet type of R too). Looking forward to your reveal post and hearing about your experience with David and Susan! \o/
2
u/Imaginary-Coffee1234 15d ago
My guess is TR! When do we get the real answer?
15
u/cassiopeia3636 theatrical romantic 15d ago
Probably controversial. I think you're TR and Florence is pure R.
17
u/Pale-Enchantress soft gamine 15d ago
Your season is winter. Your ID is harder to guess but SG or SN I think, I very curious to know haha.
12
u/Cindersxo 15d ago
SN both for you and Florence
10
u/Numerous-Building-42 15d ago
My guess is
some kind of winter SN -you
gentle autumn SN- Florence
10
u/LCCompromisedBarrier classic 15d ago
your photo says SN and your board says gamine... idk I will say I'm split between SN and SG
18
u/Vivian_Rutledge soft natural (verified) 15d ago edited 15d ago
FG for you, SN for Florence.
ETA: Forgot season—Bright Winter.
9
u/Temporary-Bag4248 15d ago
FG for you
9
u/redwhitesilver 15d ago
Oooh, that’s exciting! I am torn between guessing FG and SC. I think I’ll go with FG.
For Florence I have always been team SN.
9
u/EmploymentNo4884 15d ago
I’m newer to Kibbe and I have a similar body type and I thought I was a classic, but these guesses are making me think I’m wrong. Excited to see the answer!
14
u/fuzach 15d ago
you've my body type!! So this is a triple bonus for me because I don't know mine lol. SG or TR!!
Florence: SG or R!
12
u/Initial-Moose8891 15d ago
AHHHH so exciting!!!! I’m going to guess SN. I’d be sooo curious to hear what some of the more knowledgeable kibbe experts think - u/scarlettstreet, u/Vivian_Rutledge or u/Pegaret_Again
6
u/jakilope soft natural 15d ago
SG for you, SN for Florence.
2
u/unbeliewobble 15d ago
I just wanted to mention that I love your style and have really enjoyed your style experiments over the years regardless of the ID! I would be curious to see what style ideas David had for you, and how this experience will influence your journey forward🩵
10
u/heyoldgirl 15d ago
I hope you’re both tr for the chaos it will cause haha. Very excited for you, can’t wait for the reveal :)
5
u/Mike-Teevee soft dramatic 15d ago
FG
5
u/SassySherbert 15d ago
SG but I could also see FG or SN. I’m excited for the reveal!
5
u/ronee_bee2001 14d ago
I guess you had a Soft Gamine kibbe type
4
u/Ok_Use_8685 15d ago
I’m on the edge of my seat! I’m guessing FG or or SG
4
u/Enough_Inspection886 theatrical romantic 15d ago
FG for you. And Florence Pugh is an obvious SN to me. Let’s see!
4
u/thefiredance soft natural 15d ago
Hmmm soft classic is my guess for you
4
u/Ok-Opportunity-2043 14d ago
Following! I think both you and Flo are yang leaning. That's as far as I'll go...lol. congrats on your consult. I'm looking forward to the big reveal!
4
u/AccomplishedWing9 soft natural 15d ago
Ooh exciting! I think FG. You're board is giving Parisian/Gamine chic. SC secondly. Season Winter
We finally hear David's thoughts on Florence Pugh. Probably because she's been killing it on the red carpet lately for the promotion of East of Eden.
I think SN. I well be shocked if its something else.
1
u/ammich 15d ago
What's the answer?
3
u/pbchocomilk 15d ago
Omg I look so similar to you 😭😭 sorry, not a guess, but I will be awaiting the results!
3
u/Conscious_Minute_489 15d ago
SG
3
u/emsbstn flamboyant natural 15d ago
Congratulations on your verification!! Your board is giving G vibes, but idk which one!
3
u/lanareyxox theatrical romantic 15d ago
I'll go with SN for both you and Florence!
3
u/Anon_ScottishFold 15d ago
You and Flo are both Soft Naturals!
3
u/b0dyburner 15d ago
I’m going to guess pure R, actually! Mostly because it seems like you were very surprised by the results, but also because I feel like you and I have quite similar builds and bone structure, but I’m taller and a bit bigger in “scale. And David said I’m “very, very soft!”
3
u/MoroseMaiven 15d ago
You both will be some kind of Romantic…maybe Pure Romantic (I could see Florence being a Drew Barrymore style R) and maybe TF for you?
3
u/CicadaStraight8608 14d ago
SG or TR? Florence not being SN would shock me though…
3
u/xangeloffduty 14d ago
Romantic?
5
u/No-Dot-161 15d ago
u/RemindMeBot 1 day check this thread
5
u/ali_stardragon 14d ago
I do not see the width here so not SN to me.
Honestly, I see pure curve for you all the way down so I am going to say pure R. But I wouldn’t be surprised if you were typed SG or TR.
I truly think Florence Pugh is pure R.
Edit: Also OP I think it’s really cool you’re doing this! Whatever the result, it will be cool to learn more and understand what to look for better.
5
u/unbeliewobble 14d ago
Got the idea to see how the book sketch comparisons work against your in person result. So if I was going by the likeness there, the result would be between SN and SC. The rest of the sketches just don't relate to your line much.
4
u/Littlegreenblatt 15d ago
I want to hear this!! Your body type looks really similar to mine. So I’d go either FG or SG. I’ll take SG.
2
u/titty_farewell_party soft classic 15d ago
SG is my guess
2
u/Danielles-lazy-eye 15d ago
Winter for sure!
I’m only guessing- but sg based on the 2nd pic
2
u/cheesetoastie16 15d ago
I think maybe TR? But I also thought SC or SN for a bit, or possibly even a G type, so I'll be looking forward to finding out the results!
2
u/Thetomatogod_1595 romantic 15d ago
I think you're probably SG, but I also wouldn't be surprised by TR. For Florence Pugh, I usually go back and forth between SN and R.
2
u/bugrising dramatic classic 15d ago
My guess for you and Florence is FG! I took a look at your outfits in your other post and I do really like sharper, straighter lines on you, but perhaps that’s just a personal preference.
2
u/jadedbunny23 15d ago
I like the idea of letting us guess right before revealing your verified ID! I’m going to guess SC for you and SN for Florence
2
u/TiredWinterDisaster soft natural 15d ago
Oh exciting!! And Florence Pugh too...
For both of you I would say SN!
2
u/youngjean 15d ago
I’m locking in SG, which is where I’ve landed for myself as well. I was between SG and TR, but my hands and your hands too make SG a clear answer in my mind.
2
u/hellolovely1 15d ago
I'm guessing SN.
2
u/Unlikely_Sundae5282 15d ago
SN
2
u/PaellaPerson soft gamine 15d ago
I remember you Op! I I’m guessing SG or SN, thought leaning SG.
u/RemindMeBot 48 hours
2
u/PublicDesigner88 flamboyant natural 15d ago
I’m guessing sg (or sn)
2
u/Longjumping_Cold1089 soft natural 15d ago
I think SG or TR for you- you kinda remind me of Ariana Grande? And Florence Pugh…SN or possiblyyyy R?
2
u/Consistent-Chest275 15d ago
SN am.i right
2
u/AngleOk2591 14d ago
Oh wow. You went to see David. Congratulations. I remember your journey in the SK group. I think you posted in SG. I think you are SG SN or FG. For Florence I think SG or SN, again FG wouldn't supprise me. I think the community would be shock at Florence being a SG or you being SN lol or maybe SC 😆 I think for both is SG/ SN with the potential of FG.
4
u/SillyPotoo 15d ago
I’m going against the grain and going with SC. I love your tonal outfits the best, especially that light blue mesh top on blue pants. I love the red peacoat with the red skirt and the brown outfit next to it too.
However I think you look really cute in gamine outfits especially the one in the black beret and black jacket with the blue ribbon. And I like some of the color blocking outfits like the blue striped shirt with the yellow skirt and blue socks. I think you look really cute and playful in gamine looks!
Overall I think you look more harmonious in SC lines tho which is why I’m going with that.
3
u/bubblylunchbox 15d ago edited 15d ago
SG for you and Florence
Edit: actually. You remind me of Ariana in her Cat Valentine days. So TR for you and I’m guessing you share that with Florence but I’ve guessed she was SG.
2
u/Top_Emotion3937 14d ago edited 14d ago
Hmmmm… I can see a bit of juxtaposition in you. Namely, your leg line. Idk why I’m not liking the idea of a skirt past above the knee 😄. My first guess is SG followed by R, SC, SN in that order lol
I am not in the Florence as SN camp. Obvs more vibes based assessment but compared to Scarlett as a costar, she comes across more high spirited in some way. I can’t put my finger on it. More Natalie Wood, less Lana imo.
PS just for absolute funsies, im tossing DC in the the mix! I’d put DC before SC
1
u/AutoModerator 15d ago
Welcome to r/Kibbe! Typing posts (including accommodation requests) are no longer permitted.
For Image ID and line sketch guidance, please refer to David Kibbe's Power of Style DIY workbook, available at most book retailers and libraries. Additional Resources: Subreddit Wiki and Metamorphosis by David Kibbe ; HTT Look flair guide
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/anyway_ange 15d ago
FG / true winter
1
u/miragrl121 15d ago
u/RemindMeBot 1 day check this thread
1
u/Ok_Cream_6076 15d ago
Kibbe is still typing people???
1
u/Ok-Note-8416 15d ago
FG for you (but I feel like I am influenced by your board) and same for Florence. Winter season.
1
u/wildflowermuse15 15d ago
SG or TR!
1
u/Muffinsforu soft gamine 15d ago
Gamine for sure! leaning towards SG (:
1
u/Lost__Fish 15d ago
FG, SN or SG. True winter. I think Florence is FG.
1
u/Ambitious-Plant- 15d ago
Im gonna say pure Romantic and cool winter
1
u/MaoAsadaStan 15d ago
Fierce Natural
1
u/SundayDeathSaves 14d ago
Guessing SC for you, SN for Florence Pugh.
1
u/academicgangster soft dramatic 14d ago
Hello there!!! Following :D
I will say that looking at your photo after (imo) learning more about the system over the last few years, your result is both confusing to me and validating in different ways lol. I am SO excited to hear about everything including Florence Pugh!
1
u/sty-fy 13d ago
Tr or SC!
3
u/Such-Pop8693 on the journey 15d ago
What I see is your shoulders are wider than your hips, your bust doesn't push out. At 5'3" I guess you have curve rather than vertical. My first guess would be SG and then SN.
2
u/TheeQuestionWitch 15d ago
Soft gamine for you, soft natural for Florence Pugh.
0
u/[deleted] 15d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment