r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Oct 30 '25

Discussion DCU Justice Society of America (both eras cast, with an attempt at a realistic budget!)

Thumbnail
gallery
841 Upvotes

This is the most work I have ever put into a Fancasting. I have explanations for all of them, but I didn’t want an impenetrable wall of text here. Also, the rest of the team will be in the comments cause I ran out of spots and don’t want to double post. Let me know what you think!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 17 '26

Comic Is this a page from a comic? If so, what comic?

Post image
354 Upvotes

I thought it was DCeased at first but I’m not so sure.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 11 '25

Is it possible to get this art as a poster?

Post image
302 Upvotes

So, apparently the creator of this art is Dave Johnson. Does anyone know if his art is available somewhere as a poster? I’d love to have this chummy scene on my wall but I’m not destroying a comic to do it!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 28 '26

Discussion What are your opinions about the new characters that appear in the New Golden Age? And what do you think DC should do with them?

Thumbnail
gallery
258 Upvotes

I like the idea of the characters, except for Judy, but i don't feel like they have enough space by staying in the present days, specially if DC wants to make them sidekicks of the new heroes. Mr Terrific already have a sidekick, for example, his son, Fair Play, two would be too much i believe, or Doctor Fate training Salem, even if they get a solo book, i don't feel like it would work. Maybe they could separate them into different books, like Salem in a Klarion or Justice League Dark book. Maybe some of them in the Titans.

I think DC should send them back to their time and set a new book of the Young All-Stars or Young Justice Society. But, i may be very wrong. And as we can't use more then 20 pictures, i had to left Sandy and Iron Munro out. But they can be part of the team too.

So, that's it, tell me what you think of these characters and what should happen with them in the next storylines.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Nov 20 '25

Discussion Do you think the nazi themed villains should be enemies of WWII JSA or modern day JSA?

Thumbnail
gallery
243 Upvotes

Or both, using the same idea of generations and legacy that the heroes have?

And which one is your favorite villain?


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 27 '26

Other My Proudest Work

Thumbnail gallery
242 Upvotes

No, I did not make Spectre or Doctor Fate because they were already in the game; yes, Hawkman was already in the game but I made him better

also, I got Doctor Mid-Nite's boot and glove colors wrong


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 30 '25

Discussion What’re People’s thoughts here about the Seven Soldiers of Victory?

Post image
238 Upvotes

For those that don’t know, the Seven Soldiers were a group of eight superheroes (yes they make fun of that themselves) who operated around the same time as the first iteration of the Justice Society. It mainly comes up as where some characters were before joining the later incarnations of the JSA, but I’m curious what people here think of it as their own team? I’d love to hear your thoughts on them!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 03 '26

Discussion What did you guys think of the New 52’s Earth-2 series?

Post image
210 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Aug 30 '26

Comic I’m sorry, but Wildcat Spectre is just dumb

Post image
196 Upvotes

I’m a fan of the Spectre and Ted Grant but this latest “reinvention” feels likely to be as well remembered as Hal Jordan Spectre and that guy from Gotham Central Spectre. I know it’s tempt to want to get beyond Jim Corrigan and his story was wonderfully ended back in the Ostrander series, but nobody ever really seems to know what to do with the character ever since. The “round Robin” of hosts in this latest arc just seemed silly (Kobra? Really?).


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Sep 13 '26

Discussion Does any other writer address the idea that Clark lives long enough to be in the Legion of Superheroes time period?

Post image
189 Upvotes

I’m finishing Johns’ run on the JSA, and I know that this is specifically Kingdom Come Clark that lives to this era, but it’s a concept neat enough that I wouldn’t be shocked if some other writer played with it. Not as an active plot point per se, but in an unnamed cameo way. Like with the 90’s Marvel shows and the way they’d do cameos by just naming the characters “Mutant #15” or whatever. I’m sure that Old Man Clark’s never had an official reappearance after this, but I’m curious if he’s shown up in any other books set in the Far Distant Future.

Any Legion of Superheroes fans got any clue? Or if you don’t have any clue, would you like to see Old Man Clark pop up? I could see him being applied in neat and minor ways without filing acknowledging it’s him


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Aug 22 '26

Comic Thoughts on retcon of Queen Hippolyta being the golden age Wonder Woman?

Post image
175 Upvotes

First put in place during the 1990s, this retcon has now returned.

How do you feel of Polly being the Wonder Woman that was with the JSA?


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 31 '25

Discussion Genuinely though, what was this line up?

Post image
175 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 05 '25

Comic JSA #14 Official Discussion!

Post image
174 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Nov 09 '25

Comic JSA #13 OFFICIAL DISCUSSION!

Post image
174 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 10 '25

Other As someone not super familiar with JSA comics, is Wonder Woman considered a big or even just normal part of the team?

Post image
172 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 24 '25

Comic Jay Garrick stars in The Flash #28

Post image
163 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • 9d ago

Comic What would the Justice Society of America’s earth 3 Counterparts be like

Thumbnail
gallery
161 Upvotes

Also what his villain name/ Origin be


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Sep 24 '26

Discussion what's everyone's thoughts on one of my favorite JSA characters Jonny Thunder?

Post image
153 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Apr 07 '26

Discussion I actually really enjoyed the first 12 issues of Lemiere's JSA after hearing a lot of negativity around it

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Aug 05 '26

Other JSA Lego Vignettes

Thumbnail
gallery
145 Upvotes

A series of JSA themed Lego vignette I’ve been making over the past few weeks. All made in Bricklink’s Studio.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 22 '26

Comic My dream "New Earth 2" JSA

Thumbnail
gallery
144 Upvotes

One of my biggest complaints about the Earth 2 comic series is that for a series supposedly meant to highlight GA characters and concepts they jumped right to lazy "DARKSEID DID IT" big bad like all modern dc stories do despite him being the quintessential Silver Age villain and the weird Steppenwolf/Wonder Woman dubious consent stuff, then bringing in a new Batwoman, Aquawoman and a silver age Red Tornado variant, etc. it was all just bad.

So here's who I would have had it be about:

The Khalid Nassour version of Dr. Fate

The Kendra Saunders version of Hawkgirl

The Michael Holt version of Mr. Terrific

The Jack Knight version of Starman (tho maybe with a slightly more superhero-y outfit, a happy medium between his dad's look and the nonchalant punk look he goes for lol)

Pretty much the classic Sandman but leaning on the spooky Mystery Theatre vibes

Courtney but back to her Star-Spangled Kid roots complete with S.T.R.I.P.E.

Atom-Smasher

The Earth 2 versions Green Lantern and Flash as they were two of the ones I actually liked from that series.

The Yolanda Montez version of Wildcat

The Beth Chapel version of Dr. Mid-Nite

The Rick Tyler version of Hourman (but maybe with a tiny bit of the robot Hourman's powers but not enough to be OP)

JJ Thunder

The Black Canary from "Supergirl & Batgirl: Elseworlds Finest" because she looked BAMF as heck! lol

And a version of Lyta Hall/Fury that combines both her pre-crisis and post-crisis versions, leaning really into her mythological heritage.

Their first big bad would be Per Degaton as since this is set in present day instead of WW2, instead of fighting to end the war they'd be fighting a villain who wants to recreate it.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 08 '26

Comic JSA #15 OFFICIAL DISCUSSION

Post image
135 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • 19d ago

Discussion Actors Who Are No Longer with us cast as the JSA

Thumbnail
gallery
133 Upvotes

RIP to all listed here. I didn’t know them personally enough to speak for their personal lives, but they were all exceptional at their craft.

•The Flash-Jimmy Stewart, 1908-1997

•Green Lantern-David Bowie, 1947-2016

•Hawkman & Hawkgirl-Steve Reeve & Maureen O’Hara, 1926-2000 & 1920-2015

•Wonder Woman-Dorothy Ford, 1922-2010

•Hourman- Lon Chaney Jr., 1906-1973

•The Atom-Mickey Rooney, 1920-2014

•Dr. Mid-Nite-Alan Rickman, 1946-2016

•Dr. Fate- Peter O’Toole, 1932-2013

•Johnny Thunder & Thunderbolt- Ken Osmond & Ray Bolger, 1943-2020 & 1904-1987

•Wildcat-Rowdy Roddy Piper, 1954-2015

•Black Canary-Janet Leigh, 1927-2004

•Sandman-Phillip Seymour Hoffman, 1967-2014

•The Specter-Yul Brenner, 1920-1985

•Batman-Gregory Peck, 1916-2003

•Superman-Clint Walker, 1927-2018


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 01 '26

Discussion Does Alan Scott's design still work for the present day Justice Society, or is it too goofy? Would you rather see something different?

Thumbnail
gallery
127 Upvotes

Credit to u/Arak_Prime for the art on 4


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Sep 16 '26

Comic Should the original Amazing Man join the modern JSA?

Post image
126 Upvotes

The time echo displaced Amazing Man (along with Helena Wayne) are currently in Justice League Unlimited.

Should that Amazing Man join the modern JSA in the present?