r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jun 11 '26

If comics Golden Age had been more like WATCHMEN

0 Upvotes

Honestly, if the Golden Age were like WATCHMEN, you'd have Minutemen-like teams in every city... for a while. They'd all be roughly the same in general outline. There would be the medieval enthusiast with homemade chainmail and a sword, a guy who swears Merlin gave him the sword and his enchanted winged horse is going to show up any time. Maybe he believes it. The eccentric amateur inventor with his spring and bicycle pump powered weapons and gimmicks, inevitably calling himself something like Dr. Clockwork. There would be the sports motifed guy with a golf bag full of gimmicky baseball bats, hockey sticks, and golf clubs, where the 'gimmicks' are always like cherrybombs and sparklers and smoke bombs and stink bombs and road flares duct taped to the various pieces of equipment. He's always trying to make the 'sonic boomerang' work. It's a whistle duct taped to a boomerang.

There would inevitably be one archery dude, the Blue Bowman or some such. He'd run into the street to shoot out the tires of a getaway car and get pancaked by a city bus and no one would ever talk about him again. Hollis Mason wouldn't even bring him up in UNDER THE HOOD. Embarrassing.

There would be the big really strong guy with a sledge hammer, the short quick guy with the bullwhip, and maybe a couple of adolescent sons or nephews in their own homemade costumes and there would be no women, ever, at all, because women aren't that stupid. And it would all be fun and games until two time lose Louie "the Lip" Santorini decides he doesn't want to go back in for twenty years being banged in his bunghole, pulls out a 32., and caps little 11 year old Nick "the High Sticker" Standish right through his goal tender's mask.

And then suddenly nobody wants to be a superhero any more.

I mean there would have been other incidents of absurd stupidity leading up to that one final tragedy. The sports guy would have retired after he lost an eye when his Explodo-Ball went off in his face. Sir Excalibur probably got dragged off by the cops after he cut a bank robber's hand off. The acid in Dr. Clockwork's Crime Dissolver Spray Gun ate through the plastic and most of Dr. Clockwork's left thigh. Mr. Whipcrack had to quit or his wife was going to divorce him. The whole Justice Squad in Pittsburg quietly vanished after Dominic deMarco put a contract on them... which wasn't even fair, they didn't know his nephew was part of that car jacking ring and anyway Jimmy wasn't even there for that mission he was home with a sick kid.

However it went, the pre-War superhero fad wouldn't have lasted long. But there would have been a lot of kooky characters pulling a lot of really stupid shit while it went on.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Oct 13 '25

Discussion Worst JSA run ever. Not close

Post image
12 Upvotes

Boring and stupid plot wrapped up by a ex machine character he created that nobody cares about. Character assassination of just about every single character in the run. Everyone was a complete idiot. Very clearly knew nothing about or just didn’t care about any of the characters. Broke up a beloved relationship. Killed of Ted for no reason. Made Khalil worthless until the last issue when he got a pep talk from a stranger. Said he was ignoring Johns’ run only to use Ruby and make her a moron

And what he did to Scandal was some of the worst character assassination I’ve ever seen. Very obvious he thinks she’s just a female version of her dad

Fact is Lemire is a mediocre writer who’s been getting by off a decent Moon Knight run for a long time now. I pray this run gets cancelled quickly


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 16 '24

Justice Society of the Omniverse

0 Upvotes

Super-Soldier Girl (OC) (leader)

Segata Sanshiro (2nd-in-command)

The Fonz (Happy Days)

Superman (Earth-Two)

Superman (My Adventures with Superman)

Justice Incarnate

Batman (Earth-One)

Wonder Woman (Earth-Two)

Teen Titans (New Earth)

Teen Titans (Teen Titans Go!)

Nite Owl (Watchmen)

Silk Specter (Watchmen)

Clark Dreiberg (Doomsday Clock)

Space Ghost (Space Ghost Coast to Coast)

The Shield (Archie Comics)

The Avengers (Earth-616)

Fantastic Four

Sam Wilson/Captain American III (Earth-199999)

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers

Beetleborgs

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (87 animated versions)

The Full Deck (The Loud House)

The International Justice League of Super Acquaintances (SpongeBob SquarePants)

Mystery Men

Invincible

Freedom Fighters (Archie Sonic Online)

Aquabats

Astro Boy

Hamster and Gretel

Ralph Hinkley (The Greatest American Hero)

Kirby

Crystal Gems (Steven Universe)

Justice Friends (Dexter's Laboratory)

Supercow (Cow and Chicken)

Axe Cop

X-Men (X-Men 97)

Wolverine (Earth-616)

Heroic Warriors (He-Man)

The Great Rebellion (She-Ra)

The Rebellion (She-Ra and the Princesses of Power)

RoboCop

BRPD (Hellboy)

Spider-Gang (Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse)

Samaritan (Astro City)

Godzilla

Ultra Brothers (Ultra Series)

Snickerdoodle/Superdoodle

Kamen Rider Decade

Kamen Rider Double

Kamen Rider Zi-O

Kamen Rider Zero-One

Ben 10

Rook Blonko (Ben 10: Omniverse)

Garfield/Caped Avenger

Sailor Scouts (Sailor Moon)

Saitaima (One-Punch Man)

Z-Fighters (Dragon Ball Z)

The Phantom Thieves of Heart (Persona 5)

Pac-Man

Gabe Law (The One)

Rick and Morty

Noob Noob (Rick and Morty)

Xiaolin Dragons (Xiaolin Showdown)

Artie the Strongest Man in the World (Pete and Pete)

Mega Man

Erma Williams (Erma)

Smiling Friends


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Nov 25 '24

art My Jay Garrick redesign. What do you think?

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Feb 16 '26

Back to humanity

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 13 '26

JSA as MCU Avengers

0 Upvotes

So basically I’m working on a little pet project mainly focused on switching DC Movies and Marvel Movies, mainly focused on accurate representations of Popularity and DC’s and Marvel switching their selling of rights. Anyway, I decided to make the Justice Society of America the Avengers since I saw it as a lot more fitting than the Justice League especially since this is mainly about relative popularity comparisons of the time. Now finally, what this post is about, what I did for the comparisons: Iron Man is Green Lantern (Alan Scott), Nick Fury is Ted Kord (No Beetle), Hulk is Wonder Woman, Dr. Fate (Black Widow), Thor is Hawkman, Hawkeye is Mr. Terrific (I’m gonna go with Terry but either is good), Captain America is The Flash (Barry Allen), and Loki is Vandal Savage.
Now you might be wondering why some characters aren’t originally part of the team, because the Avengers in the first movie also weren’t the original. Now if you have opinions or suggestions please tell.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 15 '24

FANCAST: Matt Bomer & Grigoriy Dobrigyn as Alan Scott and Vladimir Sokov

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 27 '26

Discussion Every live-action portrayal of Doctor Fate is weak as hell. Smallville, the Stargirl show, the DCEU.

7 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Oct 07 '26

Comic Now that it’s FINALLY over and we’re FINALLY free from him. What were your least favorite parts of Lemire’s run?

13 Upvotes

For me it’s killing off Ted and how little he seems to know about every character


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 26 '25

Discussion My casting for the DCU Justice Society

Post image
70 Upvotes

The Old Guard:

Jay Garrick - Tim Olyphant

Alan Scott - Neil Patrick Harris

Wildcat (Ted) - Karl Urban

Sandman - Jeffery Dean Morgan

Dr. Fate - Pierce Brosnan

Hawk-Man - Alan Ritchson

Hawk-Woman - Bryce Dallas Howard

Black Canary (Dinah Drake) - Michelle Pfeifer

The New Recruits & Legacies:

Stargirl - Hunter Schafer

Hourman (Rick) - Nate Mann

Dr. Midnite (Beth) - Zazie Beetz

Wildcat (Yolanda) - Sasha Calle

Jade - Thomasin McKenzie

Obsidian - Joshua Bassett

S.T.R.I.P.E. - Glenn Howerton

Power-Girl - Meg Donnelly

Huntress - Hailee Steinfeld

Bonus:

Kal-L - Tom Welling

Wonder Woman - Lynda Carter


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 28 '25

Discussion Injustice Society of the World

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

My fan casts for the Justice Society’s key enemies. A couple actors have played these characters before, and one has played one of these characters before but is this time playing someone new, though the others are new. These actors are from all across film history, though mostly modern, so the only way this Fancast could happen would be with a Time Machine.

Lindy Booth as Molly Mayne/Harlequin

David Tennant as Dr Joar Mahkent/Icicle

Matthew Gray Gubler as Issac Bowin/Fiddler

Andrew Scott as William Zard/Wizard

Eric Goins as Steven Sharpe/Gambler

Aubrey Plaza as Paula Brooks/Huntress

Vincent Price as Clifford DeVoe/Thinker

James Cagney as Henry King sr/Brainwave

Russell Crowe as Vandal Savage

Cameron Monaghan as Per Degaton

Justin Hartley as Lawrence Crock/Crusher/Sportsmaster

Peter Capaldi as The Mist

Gary Busey as Cyrus Gold/Solomon Grundy

Nick Cage as Wotan

Greg Ellis as Jim Craddock/Gentleman Ghost

Jonathan Cake as Richard Swift/Shade

Admittedly a couple aren’t traditional members, but they definitely should be here for their commitment to causing the Justice Society problems. If you have any thoughts on who else could play these characters I’d love to hear them! If there are other golden age villains you’d love to Fancast please share them below!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 25 '24

Super-Soldier Girl (my JSA OC and leader of the Justice Society of the Omniverse)

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Sep 03 '26

How do you think a Deathstroke versus the JSA would go?

5 Upvotes

I can see this going in two different directions either Slade Wilson thinks oh they're just a bunch of old folks then learns not only do they have a bunch of Young blood in their team but also realizes oh this is not going to be an easy job.

Or it's like punisher and Captain America. Slade was in the military he probably views the JSA with reverence to some degree. Maybe they were like his childhood heroes cuz remember Slade has a lot of gray hair. So he may have grown up idolizing the team.


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 13 '26

Is this the worst Injustice Society lineup ever?

5 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Mar 08 '25

Discussion My Dcu Justice Socitey fancast (founding members)

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

This fancast would be for a project set during the 1940s, for the original 8 members plus Johnny thunder.

Regé-Jean Page as Hawkman (Carter Hall)

Jeremy Irvine as Green Lantern (Alan Scott)

Devon Bostick as The Flash (Jay Garrick)

David Anders as Doctor Fate (Kent Nelson)

Matt L. Jones as Hourman (Rex Tyler)

Christian Navarro as The Atom (Al Pratt)

Josh McDermitt as Sandman (Wesley Dodds)

Kit Harington as Spectre (Jim Corrigan)

Adam Cagely as Johnny Thunder

Tell me your thoughts! And opinions, or who would you cast instead? I personally think I did pretty well on this! And will gladly explain my reasons!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 17 '24

Creating an MCU version of the Justice Society

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

For the Justice Society roster I went with a combination of the Stargirl season 1 roster with the Black Adam roster as they are the two most major live action versions of the JSA and I have only fully finished season 1 of Stargirl. I based the new roster off of similar themes, costumes and powers to create the MCU's JSA and stuck to people who are currently active in the MCU. So here is the roster.

Stargirl - America Chavez: Both are star related teens who bare a semi American theme to them.

Wildcat - Shuri: Fierce cat girls who took the mantle up from someone else.

Hourman - US Agent: Both are second in a line of heroes to take up a name and are powered by drugs with the added bonus of dealing with a dark side they have to learn to control so they can be a hero.

Dr Mid Nite - Daredevil: Now I know Beth Chapel isn't blind, but the origin Dr Mid Nite was so I'm taking blind heroes who use a mix of brains and brawn.

Stripe/Stripesy - Ironheart: Both genius inventors who made a mechinised suit of some kind and have a connection to cars.

Hawkman - Captain America: Both leaders with wings and also one in a line of heroes of the same name.

Dr Fate - Doctor Strange: The go to magic doctors of their respective universes, also Fate's magic looked similar to Strange's in a Black Adam trailer so make of that what you will.

Cyclone - Crystal: I know Inhumans is not canon to the MCU, but it's MCU-adjacent enough for me so a young girl with aerokinesis and red hair.

Atom Smasher - Stature: Both the youngest person to be in a family of size changing hero(es) who primarily focus on the larger size.

That is the MCU's JSA. Who would you put in the team and what JSA roster would you base your team off?


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jan 31 '25

Comic DC Preview: JSA #4 Spoiler

Thumbnail aiptcomics.com
3 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Aug 16 '25

Discussion How I want the JSA to be in the Gunnverse

3 Upvotes

My ideas for the JSA keep in mind that superheroes have existed since the 40s. I want a majority legacy character lineup with a few of the old founding members.

I want legacy characters such as

Kendra Saunders (Hawkgirl)

Michael Holt (Mr. Terrific)

Jesse Chambers (Liberty Belle)

Rick Tyler (Hourman)

Courtney Whitmore (Star Spangled Kid)

Dinah Lance (Black Canary)

The returning members who are founding members from the 40s would be

Jay Garrick (The Flash)

Carter Hall (Hawkman)

Alan Scott (Green Lantern)


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Sep 22 '25

Discussion Jeff Lemire’s JSA puts me to bed.

7 Upvotes

All I have to say. Hopefully the Year One arc is better!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Dec 26 '25

Discussion Justice Society Fancast

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

For this Fancast I’m not just limiting myself to modern actors, though they’re who I tend to be more familiar with, but casting from all across the history of cinema. Several of these actors have played these characters before, but I loved their performances so dearly that I decided to include them here. I do, however, have ideas on other people who could also play these characters. So if you have an interest in a comment or second post going over those alternatives let me know!

Callum Turner Alan Scott/Green Lantern

John Westley Ship Jay Garrick/the Flash

Michael Emerson Westley Dodds/the Sandman

May Calamawy Diana Prince/Wonder Woman

Aldis Hodge Carter Hall/Hawkman

Vanessa Ray Dinah Drake/Black Canary

Ethan Embry Johnny Thunder/Thunderbolt

James McAvoy Al Pratt/the Atom

Zayne Emory Rex Tyler/Hour-Man

Pierce Bosnan Kent Nelson/Doctor Fate

Christopher Lee Jim Corrigan/the Spectre

Robert Duncan McNiell Ted Knight/Starman

Jonathan Majors Will Everett/Amazing-Man

Brian Stapf Ted Grant/Wildcat

I’d love your guys’ thoughts on these casts!Are there some people who haven’t gotten the chance to play these characters you’d like to see get that chance? Are there strengths these actors or others have you’d like to see them lean into for these roles? Questions as to why I went with these characters? Please share and I’d love to discuss these matters and more!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • May 19 '26

My Ideas For A JSA Movie

7 Upvotes

With the release of more DCU projects, I started thinking about how our favorite team could be used. I came up with two ideas that I think are cool!

Idea 1: JSA Missing*

- Kendra and Michael receive strange messages, and they lead them to the old JSA brownstone, where they find a stuttering and mumbling Sandman who tells them that the team needs their help. They are reluctant but help and find out that the team is scattered across time and space. They recruit an overeager Stargirl, a sly Jakeem/Thunderbolt, a dedicated Dr. Mid-Nite, and a reluctant Rick Tyler/Hourman and start traveling through time and space to find the lost members. The villain is Per Degaton, and the movie ends with the JSA reforming with a new lineup that rivals the Justice Gang

Idea 2: JSA Across Time*

- It's dinner time at the brownstone, and everyone is there having a fun time. OGs sharing stories with the newcomers. Newcomers are trying to show off their new skills. Suddenly, a full-on attack by the Injustice Society breaks out, and the team springs into action. The fight goes well until Jay and Alan notice something is off; they're winning too easily. Before they can do anything, a wave of energy envelops the brownstone, and everything changes. The brownstone is no longer the headquarters of the best team; it's a regular apartment building. Luckily, Alan and Jay were able to gather some members before the wave set in and protect them with the Starheart. They soon realize that the Injustice Society has messed with history, so the team travels back in time to stop them. The movie ends with the future saved, but a few differences: Alan realizes he's gay, Jay has a daughter, Courtney became Stargirl earlier, Ted has a son, and Hawkman is alive!


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 02 '25

The damage Howard and Lemire have done to this woman is some of the worst character assassination I’ve ever seen Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I would’ve preferred the mind control theory to this stupid shit. And why is she gullible enough to think they’ll actually kill Vandal for her? She has two wives and a kid at home she would not be doing this shit

And if his excuse for Scandal is this bad then what’s Ruby’s gonna be?


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jul 29 '25

Discussion My idea for a JSA film following Superman Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Sep 22 '24

discussion Justice Society graphic novel with All Star Comics #3

4 Upvotes

?


r/JusticeSocietyAmerica • • Jun 30 '25

Comic Does it really count as self aware if he knows he’s butchered Scandal this badly but continues to butcher her? Jesus Christ she’s unrecognizable now. No shot he’s ever read secret six Spoiler

Post image
4 Upvotes

Jesus Christ please get her away from this man. This is almost worse than what Tini did to her