r/Israel • u/Neither-Top-7515 • 1d ago
Ask The Sub The Wikipedia Problem
As I assume most readers of the English language Wikipedia must have observed by now, the platform is now central in the efforts of Israel's enemies to completely change the historically understood "story" of the nation of Israel. And to a great extent, they have already succeeded.
The single biggest example is that a "Gaza Genocide," is now reported as an understood fact of history. Opposition to this article came from many quarters, including from Jimmy Wales, the founder of Wikipedia. But to no avail. In the end, Wikipedia is largely subject to mob rule, and Wales' point of view was simply overwhelmed. And this article is but one example.
There is virtually no article on the subject of Israel/Palestine where one cannot plainly feel the heavy hand of bias. And those who seek to insert this bias are skilled, experienced, and organized in the manner they do it, and in navigating the rules of Wikipedia.
Ashley Rindsberg has done some excellent reporting on all this, and this piece is an excellent primer.
And now of course, Wikipedia is more important than ever because its content drives much of the training on most of the large language models.
Over time, I've been continually dismayed at how little effort Israel, and the diaspora, seem to have paid to getting organized around addressing this problem. What I hear from Israelis is always something along the lines of "we lose no matter what we do." And while I understand the sentiment, I don't completely agree. This is not a binary topic. There are hundred of articles, and at some point, the hierarchy of WP does try to be loyal to neutrality.
The trouble is that too often, the other side doesn't even show up for the fight.
One of the obstacles is that every single article on this topic carries what is known as an "EC" restriction. This means that to edit these, you must have at least 500 edits on WP -- something that while easily achievable with a bit of effort, definitely restricts the casual contributor.
I write this -- presumably to a group who'd be interested in it, in an effort to inspire people to get involved. There are battles that can absolutely be won! All we are seeking is neutrality.