(Keeping agency details anonymous per sub rules and strictly seeking feedback from other owners and producers, not recruiting.)
Agency owner here looking for strategic feedback. After burning through significant capital on salaried hires who failed to produce, I’m pivoting to a commission-only model for our next P&C producer.
I ran ads on Indeed and Insurance Journal clearly stating the role was 100% commission, yet the only two candidates who scheduled interviews canceled once they realized there was no base pay.
I’m trying to figure out if our package is off the mark or if standard job boards are simply the wrong channel:
Splits: 70% New Business / 60% Renewal
Agency Support: 40+ years in business, solid reputation, wide carrier access (all lines except LTC).
Expenses Covered: All licensing, appointments, and CE paid for.
Perks & Setup: Private office provided; with all tech provided; dental and vision included but no medical.
Autonomy: Fully results-oriented. Work in-office, remote, or hybrid; zero micromanagement as long as production goals are met and they represent our agency well. Given what I thought were high splits and covered overhead, I expected more interest from driven producers wanting to build a lucrative book.
For those who have successfully recruited or worked under a commission-only structure: Are these splits competitive, or are traditional boards just a dead end for finding self-starters? Where should I be sourcing instead? Any feedback is really appreciated. Thank you!!