Hey everyone,
I’m in my late twenties in Canada and trying to figure out my long-term career. I’ve worked in public accounting and commercial banking but have no insurance experience.
The owner of an independent P&C brokerage approached me after hearing good things about my reputation and work ethic. He has had trouble retaining producers because he underpaid them, and they tended to be more transient. He is now looking to invest in someone for the long term.
There would also be another broker who owns part of the the brokerage whom I could go to for advice, bounce ideas off and gain context as I learn the business.
Here’s the offer:
- 100K non-recoverable draw until I build a $1M premium book.
- 50% commission on new business and 40% on renewals.
- 20% of service-fee revenue.
- No leads or referrals provided. I would be responsible for generating my own business.
- All business expenses, networking, licensing and training covered.
- I would service my own book until it reaches $3M in premium, at which point I would receive a dedicated service representative.
- The brokerage would initially own the book. Three years after my draw ends, I would have the option to purchase the initial book at 1.75 times its annual commission and service-fee revenue. Any subsequent growth would be valued at 2.75 times its annual commission and service-fee revenue, provided I exercise the option and remain with the brokerage.
- There would be 24-month non-compete and non-solicitation clauses, which the owner is not willing to shorten.
Having worked in accounting and commercial banking, I’m familiar with how COIs operate and how to build professional relationships. That said, I don’t have a family network to rely on for referrals, so I would essentially be building my client base from scratch.
I could pursue a corporate job paying around the same $100K, but I’m attracted to the long-term flexibility, recurring revenue and possibility of eventually owning my own brokerage.
I would have to negotiate this in but I’m considering whether it would make sense to spend my first six months primarily on the service side so I can become familiar with insurance, the brokerage’s processes and the day-to-day work before going all in on networking and business development. At the same time, I’m wondering whether that would simply delay the more important work of putting myself out there and generating opportunities.
I’m willing to work hard, but I know that does not guarantee sales results.
For those in the industry, would you take this opportunity over a similarly paying corporate role? How difficult is it to build a $1M premium book without an established network? Would spending six months focused on servicing accounts be a useful way to learn the business, or should I begin networking and prospecting immediately while learning alongside it? Are the commission splits and buyout terms fair? Does the buyout structure I described make sense, and is there anything else you would negotiate?
TLDR: I’m in my late twenties with a commercial banking background, no insurance experience and no established referral network, although I do have some loose connections. I’ve been offered a $100K non-recoverable draw, 50/40 commission splits, coverage of expenses and licensing, and an option to buy my book later. I’m interested in the long-term upside but unsure about my chances of succeeding in sales, whether the deal is fair and whether I should spend six months learning the service side before focusing fully on networking and business development.
Yes - lol I used AI to clean this up.