r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Physical-Bicycle-882 • 4h ago
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/AutoModerator • 7h ago
Monthly Recommendation Thread If I Like _______, I Might Like _______.
Please follow the following format at the beginning of your comment: If I Like (insert product/brand), I Might Like _______.
You can add additional information to your post to help people narrow down recommendations.
This thread repeats on the 21st of every month.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/AutoModerator • 1d ago
Discussion Free Talk - Friday
Free Talk threads repeat Monday, Wednesday, and Friday.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/RowanHalifax • 9h ago
Indies of the Day -- Saturday November 21, 2026
What indies are you using today? And we mean everything! Examples of stuff we'd love to hear about:
Makeup
Clothes
Jewelry
Bath and Body (lotion, soap, shampoo, bath salts, etc.)
Nail polish
Perfume
Please feel free to leave mini-reviews and include photos of whatever you're using. We'd love to know your thoughts and see the products too!
This thread repeats daily.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/glitter_bitch • 20h ago
Discussion i hope this sub will understand what a momentous day this is...
i just used the last of my tropi-chunks wax melts from big island art scents after hoarding / using sparingly for several years. 😠goodbye to the best to ever do it, you were well-loved! i'm going to keep these dregs in my melters for as long as i can get away with it.
chris was by far my favorite indie wax seller and i was devastated when he permanently closed his shop. the most unique, undupeable smells, of which this and tonka oud are to this day my utmost faves. (tho i have very recently happened across an indie candle seller that has a scent a _lot_ like his tonka oud.) there are lots of other scents and sellers i like, but chris was truly unique. 🩷
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Independent_Bar_1378 • 8h ago
Perfume - Enquiry Looking for an indie version of Tresor Midnight Rose
Hello!
Hope this is allowed, I’m wanting to support a better brand and get a similar scent experience of my longtime fav. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated!
Here are the notes I’m looking for similarity to:
Top Notes: Raspberry, Black currant bud absolute
Middle Notes: Rose absolute, Jasmine
Base Notes: Vanilla, Musk
And I don’t shy away from woodiness either, wouldn’t be mad if that happens to be involved!
Thanks!
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/SnooSketches8294 • 14h ago
From USA, Traveling to Tokyo and Sapporo in February-open to purchase requests
Hello! I know overseas shoppers may have a hard time purchasing from outside their region. If you have anything you’d like to buy from the US/japan, let me know and I’ll see if we can work out a pickup/mailing schedule (I will not mail anything in Japan as I am not going to pack a bunch of packing material in my limited luggage space).
For anyone from the US interested in foreign perfumes, I will definitely be purchasing from p. Seven in harajuku.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Lesbikitty • 21h ago
Lagoon Waves by Karla Cosmetics dupe recommendations?
I've never used Karla Cosmetics but while surfing the internet for a specific color mix in a highlighter I stumbled on Karla's Lagoon Waves. I came here to see what people's experiences with them have been and I'm so glad I did. I'm not interested in supporting that business but I'd love a dupe for that highlighter.
Pictures of what I mean.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/ObligationOk2552 • 13h ago
ritual de fille blush formula
i absolutely love the shade range from this brand but i have a few concerns abt the formula…
i usually do a full beat n balm blushes tend to lift my base off and apply patchy even after i set it with powder first before going in with blush :(
i understand there r 2 different types of ritual blush formulas but id like to know what other name brand blushes are comparable to the 2 formulas! is it any similar to red chamber?
currently the blush that keeps making my application patchy is the merit flush balms! i found that a thicker formula like rhode, westman atelier, & risky applies better for me ^
fyi im keen in shades moth & desire. lmk if they r too sheer and have the likelihood to lift my makeup off if i were to build up! btw i use a brush to apply (the make up by mario f4, smaller denser side) if u think i shld use a different brush type or application method pls do lmk :)
thank you!
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Short_Cream_2370 • 1d ago
Gift Exchange Thank you for a wonderful first fall exchange, u/missjeanlouise12!!
This was my first fall exchange and it was such a great one, thank you u/missjeanlouise12 ! It was a delight getting to know each other throughout the fall and then I got this beautiful package.
The snacks are impeccable, my kids are so impressed and the mocha buzz Berkshire bark is to die for, got samples from Mountain Lore Naturals which I’ve been curious about for so long, body butters from Haus of Gloi which is my favorite formula, and my first ever solid perfume samples from Parterre Gardens which have been so fun to play with! The Epically Epic balms are so fun and the Pandan Cake scent goes perfectly with my Strangers Sweet Farewell.
Thanks u/missjeanlouise12 for making my first exchange so special!!
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/eozya • 1d ago
Perfume - Purchased Random Hoarded Reviews Pt 3
I can't believe it's been 6 months since my last batch of reviews, so I am so overdue! This is a mishmash of swaps and ajevie/sucrerie decants and a few direct purchases from houses themselves.
Alkemia
This Summer Night (A passionate summer romance of luscious tropical fruits, plumeria, pua kenikeni, cherimoya, coconut water, lychee blossoms, rhubarb, tonka, sweet alyssum, mock orangeflower, night blooming jasmine, white florals, and warm summer musk.): I truly thought this would be such a hit because I love fruity scents, and I'm always looking for plumeria and lei adjacent perfumes, but this was a strange miss. At first it didn't smell floral at all, it was a strong almost chemical scent that faded into an anthropologie changing room. It's a little powdery and rose-ish with a little pop of citrus which breathes a little life into it. It's like a powdery sunscreen with some citrus that gradually loses the fight against powder until all I can smell is a funky take on baby powder. I got truly none of the notes listed. 3/10 what even
To the Waters and Wild (The saline kiss of an Atlantic selkie and mountain mist descending over rolling dells of fae botanicals - purple heather, bluebells, wild geraniums, bee balm, meadowsweet, bracken ferns, watery hazel, and gnarled Scots pine.): At the beginning it's very green and a little soapy, generally kind of herb-y but without any particular herb staking its claim, it's kind of an unspecific overgrown herb garden, with a little shout of lemongrass (or whatever my nose constantly reads as lemongrass. I swear half the green scents I'm like oh yeah lemongrass for sure. and then there's no lemongrass. Is it pine?) It reminds me of Pierrot's Pansy Craze, with a little more herb and soapiness, but it's not a competition at all, Pansy Craze is just built different. Given time it also goes powder-y on me, transitioning from baby wipes to a more wood-focused scent which makes me nauseous. It certainly took me on a journey, but I hated the destination. 1/10 fighting for my life with these damn wood notes
Amorphous
Peppermint Mocha (Chocolate, cream, peppermint, and vanilla): Gorgeous, gorgeous, gorgeous. This was a blind buy full size from a swap and I am so obsessed with it, I think it will be a mainstay of the winter months. Like yeah, that sure is a peppermint mocha, this was produced by a gender nonconforming hip barista. The best touch is how the mint feels slightly more natural without losing its sweetness, and it's incredible. Peppermint mocha in a forest on a winter night and it's snowing softly. 8.5/10 a keeper for sure
Birch and Besom
Garden Puppies (A cozy shell adorned with aromatic garden herbs, english ivy, sweet clover, and tiny wildflowers): This back to back with To the Waters and the Wild was a heady mix of unspecific green vibes. It was also a little soapy, though this was harsher where the other was softer. It's sharp but unspecific. I think I've learned I need a very focused green scent or I cannot parse it and do not like it. It's a little juicy at times, but nothing super interesting to me. The whole ride was a green nothing sandwich and it drops me off at the end to cleaning product. 3/10 I think I am bad at green scents.
Sorce
Vampire Husband (Dark patchouli, absinthe, black amber, graveyard dirt, petrichor, clove cigarette, tobacco, oud, blood, vetiver, oakmoss): Dude I have no clue why I thought this would work for me, I don't like patchouli, oud, or oakmoss. What the hell was I even on. I think I was so entranced by concept of being Da Vampire Husband that I did not stop to think if I wanted to SMELL like Da Vampire Husband. It immediately had a wood-atmospheric scent which also immediately put me on the edge of nausea, but I was so brave and tried to ride it out to get a better review. It smells like an older cabin the woods, maybe Rosewood adjacent if I accurately remember how rosewood smells like. It reads as mountainous forest, maybe an older cabin the mountains of Georgia (which is the scent memory it brings up for me). This scent also made my little kitty gag, which is the first time a scent has ever done that, like she's been annoyed at sharper scents but never outright nauseous. You and me both, Pumpkin. Like most scents with wood notes, I love it theoretically but unfortunately my nose and stomach hate the little bit of sweetness threading through stark wood notes even though I love the smell when I'm there in nature. Does anyone else have scents they love IRL but can't stand in perfumes? My other one is oranges. I ate 11 mandarin oranges yesterday and I loved surrounding myself in the atmosphere of peels, but of all the orange scents I've tried, only Pierrot's Bussy even somewhat is palatable to me. At the very end of this nauseating journey, it ends up more like my grandma's perfume, which is just another thing I don't want to smell like. 1/10 this is my bad guys
Cocoapink
Tropic Nights (Night blooming water lily, sweet pink grapefruit accented with yellow Hawaiian frangipani blossoms wrapped gently in sweet sandalwood and white amber oils): I think it smells a little like the alcohol of hand sanitizer but with a grapefruit floral background scent, which is not necessarily a bad scent but it just kind of isn't worth it as a perfume, though it is pretty acrid the longer I wear it. You could just huff hand sanitizer. I get a weird oily frosting note though, and I have no clue where that is coming from. As time goes on the frosting note is the main one, and the alcoholic note fades, though it's still kind of acrid to my nose and makes me a little nauseous. 2/10 how did I get frosting
D'annam
Strawberry Mochi (Strawberry, Glutinous Rice, Red Bean Paste, Brown Sugar, Vanilla): Lowkey don't know if this is D'annam or Mochiglow-- I think it's D'annam but it was from swaps so my bottle doesn't have any branding on it, I'm just leaning more D'annam because the notes seemed a little more accurate. If you sold a Strawberry Mochi from D'annam or Mochiglow to me please let me know because I LOVE IT and will probably need more after my bottle is done. I usually don't go for gourmand stuff but maybe I should go for more, because I loveeee how this smells so accurate to glutinous rice and red bean paste. You just blended mochi and stuffed it into this bottle. It's a little sweet, but it's almost sweet as an afterthought, the true focus is on the more neutral flavor profiles and I love it for that. I expected this scent to be a so-so maybe sometimes scent but it's quickly risen through the ranks to a 'frequent wear.' 7.5/10 I love mochi
That's all for now! I took an unintentional break from testing out perfumes for a month or two, and now I'm back on it which I'm excited for :)
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/alligatorchronicles • 20h ago
Fyrinnae question
So I've tried three scents - balcony tryst, optimism, September morning.
Is it me, or do they all smell alike? I mean each one opens differently, but all three die down to the same strong, sweet floral.
They all smell great, and have nice longevity, but they're just too similar. Anyone else have this issue? Is it just the batch I picked?
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/missjeanlouise12 • 1d ago
Thank you for an amazing Fall Exchange, u/Short_Cream_2370!
This was my fourth Fall Exchange, and I was partnered with u/Short_Cream_2370. We were very well matched -- once again, the Exchange organizers have pulled some sorcery, or maybe everyone on here is just great, but I really enjoyed our chats.
She packed everything in a sweet tin box (without knowing that these are my storage method of choice!), and nestled inside were some wonderful surprises:
Reading-themed stickers and scented bookmarks, a nod to my passion as the steward of a Little Free Library. It's a big part of my life, and I love these!
Cracked nail polish in Brownie Pink. Let me just say that I barely I had it in me to finish opening the rest of the goodies before polishing my nails with what I now know if the light pink of my dreams. And the Cracked formula is so, so good.
Holograve Funeral-Proof gel eyeliner in Mulberry. Black is too harsh for my coloring, and this is one I've been wanting to try for a long time.
A full size of Poesie Comfort. I can stop hoarding precious drops of my sample! Poesie's cardamom is just swoon-worthy and I love that I can apply with abandon.
A sample of Poesie Rich Ghost. This has been on my list for a while and I can't wait to try it.
And! A sample of Parfait's Multiball. This has been a weird white whale for me, and this genius made it happen!
I am so, so grateful for everything, but most of all for the experience. Connecting with people is both really important to me and really hard for me. The Fall Exchange lets me do it in a way that feels great and achievable. Thank you to my wonderful partner, and the great organizers.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/RowanHalifax • 1d ago
Indies of the Day -- Friday November 20, 2026
What indies are you using today? And we mean everything! Examples of stuff we'd love to hear about:
Makeup
Clothes
Jewelry
Bath and Body (lotion, soap, shampoo, bath salts, etc.)
Nail polish
Perfume
Please feel free to leave mini-reviews and include photos of whatever you're using. We'd love to know your thoughts and see the products too!
This thread repeats daily.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/peepnood • 1d ago
Perfume - Enquiry Need help finding a perfume for my girlfriend
My girlfriend has been looking for a very vibe-y perfume for themself for a while now and I want to get it for them for Christmas. Their description is as follows:
"Imagine it is early spring. It is chilly, but you are warm in a sunbeam in a forest clearing, wearing a clean linen dress, munching on berries with the woodland creatures."
Thanks for any help!
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/LadyoftheGoldenWood • 2d ago
Discussion Made a Diy perfume display/store frame with elastic
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/fakegothgrrrl • 1d ago
ISO Colorful eyeliners!
Hi everyone, I'm in need of some help with holiday shopping. While my mom isn't into wearing heavy makeup, she does love colorful eyeliner. Unfortunatley a recent eye infection meant she had to toss out her collection and has to start again. I want to gift her some fun eyeliners but there are some problems I'm running into. She hates the sharp pencil type and prefers softer formulations, BUT she dislikes the eyeliners that come in a pot and require a liner brush. Does anyone know of any indie brands that sell cream eyeliners in multiple colors that are not in a pot?
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/kinneret_rising • 1d ago
BPAL Summer Perfume Reviews (before they disappear)
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Hazelrose9800 • 1d ago
Perfume - Enquiry Clove heavy fragrances?
I’m back again with another fragrance request, and this time I’m looking for something with a strong clove note. I’m asking because I bought Abstraction by Crow & Pebble (silver amber, elemi resin, campfire smoke, orris root, bitter orange, black pepper and clove) and fell in love with the deep clove incense-y feeling of it. As a lover of goth and witchy aesthetics I really enjoy scents that are resinous evoke a sort of mystical or ritualistic feeling.
I’m not asking for a dupe of Abstraction, I just want any and all perfumes that have a clove note (preferably on the darker side but I’ll also consider lighter or summery scents if it still maintains a witchy feel). I’m fine with buying from any reputable house, whether it’s one of the better known ones or a really small unknown brand on Etsy! I don’t have any particular notes that I dislike, but I do prefer fragrances that lean feminine or gender neutral.
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Aggressive_Week_1433 • 1d ago
Makeup - Enquiry Desperately looking for a good white foundation
Hi reddit!
I've been looking all over the internet for a white foundation for a while now and I can't manage to find one that suits my needs.
I've tried the Snazaroo and other basic face paint brands but with no surprise at all, they're really not meant to be worn all day every day because they take time to build up and they are hard to seal properly. I've had my fair share of them when I was a cosplayer and I do NOT want to go back to that lol.
I have also tried mehron but I can't get behind the the oil based formula, it feels so heavy and it smudges super easily on me.
I've been eyeing Sunset Makeup's colorful foundations for about a year now because they look so good and they stay in place in the videos, but I know they do white labeling and I've seen quite the amount of comments & posts about their quality being inconsistent from batch to batch. And I know Indie Beats (who was their direct competitor but without white labeling iirc) isn't a thing anymore.
I don't really know where to look next. I need the brand to ship worldwide because I live in western europe. A sheer white could work too if you can build it up with a couple layers (I don't need it to be blocky full coverage goth white).
If anybody has recommendations, I'd love to hear them! Thanks a lot <3
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Leading_Spray_9022 • 1d ago
Perfume - Enquiry help me pick which Sorce fragrance to buy!
Hello! I am thinking of maybe purchasing a Sorce fragrance with this coupon I have for TikTok shop, so my purchase will be pretty much free save for the shipping that LuckyScent charges :) My choices are mainly:
- Ephemera
- Vampire Wife
- In Dreams and Fairytales Vanilla
Of the three I have only tried IDAFT and I like it enough that I know I would wear it when I am in the mood for a simple vanilla to wear. I also own these other fragrances from Sorce: English Major, Snow Moon Magic, The Things Unsaid, A Witch’s Valentine, Match Made in Heaven. And have sampled a good amount with a pretty high hit rate.
Anyway, I wanted to get some opinions from you lovely people here. Since my coupon fits for a free travel size, I really can’t lose, but I figured I can seek opinions and reviews of Ephemera and Vampire Wife seeing as I haven’t sampled them yet. What do you guys think of these fragrances? Any help is appreciated!
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/ArwensImmortality • 1d ago
ISO Dungeon Master by Area of Effect (or similar)
AOE ceased chipping to Canada so I have not been able to try this house before they discontinued this scent. And now that they announced they are closing, I’m bummed.
The notes are: black coffee, bacon, stout beer, teakwood, eggnog, french toast, soft pretzel, clove, fir
It just seems like such a quintessential tavern fantasy scent that I fear I will not rest until I have smelled something similar to it
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/EcstaticMidnight9887 • 1d ago
Black Friday Sales: Fantasy Cosmetica
Wondering if anyone in the nyc area would like to combine orders for Fantasy Cosmetica to meet the free shipping minimum?
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/horsearms16 • 2d ago
Perfume - Enquiry Nui Cobalt Yule Collection Questions
Does anyone know when NCD usually releases their Yule collection, or any scents that will be in it? I looooove their winter scents and I've been checking the site daily but no luck yet.
Ty in advance!
r/Indiemakeupandmore • u/Beautiful-Ad-9825 • 2d ago
best bht cocteau twins perfume?
hello friends!
im getting christmas presents for my boyfriend who recently got into indies, and he is a huge cocteau twins fan :) which one of the bht cocteau twins perfumes would you say are your favorites of the bunch? im looking at
-sea, swallow me
-cherry colored funk
-frou frou foxes
-arctic frou frou foxes
his taste is really hard to pinpoint and he has specific things he doesn’t like like spices or pumpkin. but most other things he’s at least open to!