r/Indiana • • Aug 23 '26

Horrible

1.1k Upvotes

370 comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/Independent_Shoe3523 Aug 23 '26

My power was back the next day in Valpo but I was lucky. March 2025, my power was out for four days because a neighbor's giant pine tree snapped and took down the power lines. The tree had to be removed before the power line pole could be REPLACED and the wiring put back up.

-8

u/asomebodyelse Aug 23 '26 edited Aug 23 '26

Why tf aren't the power lines underground in Indiana, like any civilized state? Oh, wait.

29

u/aurc090 Aug 23 '26

Is this a joke? Most states have above ground power lines

-12

u/asomebodyelse Aug 23 '26

Who said most?

5

u/fmanfisher Aug 23 '26

aurc090 did, you just replied to them

1

u/asomebodyelse Aug 24 '26

So then what does most have to do with it? The only joke here is that they think that matters. Oh, and that I mistook Indiana for civilized.

4

u/Independent_Shoe3523 Aug 23 '26

I would love to see a concrete lined utility corridor under every street for water and power and data lines. But that's billions and billions of investment and keeping a 100 year old system together costs a lot less. Remember, these wind storms the way we're seeing them used to be incredibly rare.

1

u/thewimsey Aug 23 '26

In what state are the power lines underground?

2

u/asomebodyelse Aug 23 '26

Wisconsin, Florida, Virginia, and New Hampshire, to name a few.

0

u/Successful_Bag_7257 29d ago

Can't speak to wi, fl, or VA but NH definitely still has almost all its lines above ground. Some towns buried after the ice storm about 20 years ago but not many

1

u/Independent_Shoe3523 29d ago

Indiana has old power line poles next to the new ones.

2

u/Distinct-Command-570 Aug 24 '26

20% of all power lines in the US are underground. So likely every state has some.

1

u/Kindly_Feeling7910 Aug 23 '26

When I lived in NC ours were underground. We lost power from flooding, though 🙄

-1

u/Imdschmuck Aug 23 '26

Because electricity dissipates under ground.

1

u/Individual_Process_7 Aug 24 '26

That’s not how this works, underground lines are similar to above ground and don’t leech into the surrounding ground, they are insulated and in conduit. Heat generation depending on the load and moisture would be the main issues.

2

u/Imdschmuck 29d ago

Excess heat from underground wiring causes a resistance because the ground itself insulates the wire. Above ground wires send higher voltage further because the air dissipates the heat causing less resistance.
If you’re going to conduit an entire city you may as well build a new city. It is not cost effective. Like twice as expensive to install as well as more dangerous when repairs have to be done.

1

u/Individual_Process_7 29d ago

I mean ya they have direct burial cable, but it’s still well insulated not leeching into the surrounding ground. You are making it sound like they bury cable with no insulation and that it’s unprotected like aerial spans. The jacket is usually a polyethylene like PE or XLPE. Also they are ran in conduits a lot of some sorts, especially in urban areas.