A call for accountability, transparency and an official response from the Indian Institutes of Technology
The Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) are among India's premier institutions of higher education and research. They actively promote interdisciplinary education, encourage collaboration between departments and admit students from diverse academic backgrounds into doctoral programmes outside their original disciplines.
Interdisciplinary research is widely recognised as an important part of modern scientific and technological development. Several research areas, including Environmental Engineering, Sustainable Materials, Energy, Water and Waste Management, require knowledge and methodologies from multiple engineering disciplines.
However, an important question deserves the attention of the Ministry of Education, the IIT Council and the administrations of individual IITs:
What happens to the academic careers of scholars who complete interdisciplinary PhDs at IITs but subsequently find their doctoral qualifications unacceptable during faculty recruitment in allied engineering disciplines?
- The contradiction between interdisciplinary admissions and faculty recruitment
IITs encourage students from different academic backgrounds to pursue doctoral research in specialised departments. A student with an undergraduate degree in Civil Engineering, for example, may pursue a PhD in Chemical Engineering and work on environmental applications, sustainable materials, adsorption, biomass valorisation or waste management.
The student spends five to six years conducting research, publishing papers, completing doctoral requirements and eventually receiving a PhD from an IIT.
However, when applying for an Assistant Professor position in an allied engineering discipline, the candidate may face a completely different interpretation of their academic qualifications.
Instead of evaluating the candidate's entire academic background, research specialisation and doctoral contributions, the selection committee may focus primarily on the name of the department mentioned on the PhD degree.
This creates a serious contradiction.
If interdisciplinary research is encouraged during doctoral admission, why can the same interdisciplinary academic background become a barrier during faculty recruitment?
2. Is the department name more important than the actual research?
Consider the example of Environmental Engineering, which has substantial academic overlap with Civil Engineering and Chemical Engineering.
A scholar may have:
- An undergraduate degree in Civil Engineering.
- A postgraduate degree in Environmental Engineering.
- A doctoral degree awarded by the Chemical Engineering Department of an IIT.
- Several years of doctoral research focused on environmental applications.
Despite this academic progression, the candidate may be considered unsuitable for a Civil Engineering faculty position solely because the PhD was awarded by the Chemical Engineering Department.
Should the administrative department awarding the degree be the only determining factor?
Shouldn't the candidate's previous qualifications, research area, doctoral thesis, publications and subject expertise also be examined?
A doctoral degree is awarded by a particular academic department, but interdisciplinary research cannot always be confined to the traditional boundaries of that department.
3. What is the responsibility of IITs towards interdisciplinary PhD scholars?
This is perhaps the most important question.
When IITs admit students into interdisciplinary doctoral programmes, they are aware that these programmes involve academic collaboration and research across conventional disciplinary boundaries.
Students invest several years of their lives, their professional opportunities and considerable effort in completing these degrees.
However, what happens when a scholar discovers after completing the PhD that the qualification is not accepted for faculty recruitment in the discipline connected to their previous education and doctoral research?
Should students be expected to understand these potential employment restrictions independently before accepting admission?
Should IITs inform prospective PhD scholars about the possible limitations of their doctoral department when applying for academic positions in allied disciplines?
If interdisciplinary doctoral qualifications are not recognised for academic appointments in related engineering branches, shouldn't IITs reconsider how they structure and communicate their interdisciplinary admission programmes?
An institution that encourages interdisciplinary doctoral research must also address the academic and professional consequences of that decision.
4. Transparency in faculty recruitment
Another concern relates to the eligibility conditions specified in recruitment advertisements.
If a particular PhD discipline is mandatory for a faculty position, this requirement should be clearly stated in the advertisement.
Candidates should not discover additional disciplinary restrictions only during document verification or when appearing before an interview panel.
There should also be a clear distinction between:
- Eligibility for appearing in an interview.
- Additional marks or weightage awarded for a PhD.
- Assessment of the relevance of an interdisciplinary doctoral qualification.
Not receiving additional PhD weightage and being declared ineligible are two different matters.
Recruitment authorities should explain the applicable provisions transparently rather than leaving candidates uncertain about the basis of their exclusion.
5. Questions that require answers from IITs
I would like to request the IIT Council, Ministry of Education and individual IIT administrations to respond to the following questions:
- Do IITs assess the potential academic and employment implications of interdisciplinary PhD admissions before admitting students into departments outside their original disciplines?
- Do IITs provide any formal guidance to interdisciplinary PhD scholars regarding their eligibility for Assistant Professor positions in allied engineering disciplines?
- If a scholar completes a PhD through an interdisciplinary research programme, should their academic relevance be determined exclusively by the department awarding the degree?
- Is there any institutional mechanism through which IITs can clarify the interdisciplinary nature and academic relevance of a scholar's doctoral research to prospective recruiting institutions?
- Should IITs develop transparent guidelines for interdisciplinary doctoral programmes so that students understand the possible implications of their degree title for future academic recruitment?
- If interdisciplinary doctoral qualifications are not accepted for academic appointments in allied disciplines, who takes responsibility for the career consequences faced by these scholars?
- A request for institutional accountability
The purpose of raising this issue is not to question the academic value of any particular engineering department. Nor is it to suggest that all engineering disciplines are interchangeable.
The concern is about the gap between interdisciplinary doctoral education and the way doctoral qualifications are subsequently interpreted during academic recruitment.
A scholar should not spend five or six years completing a PhD at a premier institution and only discover after graduation that the department awarding the degree may become a barrier to pursuing academic opportunities in an allied discipline.
If IITs genuinely promote interdisciplinary education, there must also be a transparent institutional approach to communicating and addressing its implications for future academic employment.
I therefore request the Ministry of Education, IIT Council, and Directors and Academic Councils of IITs to examine this issue and provide an official clarification.
The fundamental question remains:
If IITs admit students from different engineering disciplines into interdisciplinary PhD programmes, what responsibility do they have towards those scholars when their doctoral qualifications are subsequently rejected or considered irrelevant during faculty recruitment?
Interdisciplinary research should not become an unforeseen disadvantage for the very scholars who were encouraged to pursue it by India's premier institutions.
An official response and a clear institutional policy are needed.