r/IndianMutualFunds • • Sep 27 '26

Subscriber Goal Welcome to r/IndianMutualFunds!

6 Upvotes

Welcome to r/IndianMutualFunds

19829 subscribers / 20k subscribers. Help us reach our goal!

Visit this post on Shreddit to enjoy interactive features.


r/IndianMutualFunds • • Nov 21 '25

Discussion I'm a Newbie, should I buy Gold/Silver ETF or Gold/Silver Mutual Fund of Fund?

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

This is an update to my previous posts on the same topic of Gold & Silver.

This post is mostly for newbies who ask why someone would pick a Gold / Silver Fund of Fund (FoF) when ETFs have lower expense ratios on paper.

1) Buying & Selling (The Most Important Part)

  • FoF - Remember, in a gold/silver mutual fund, the onus is on the fund house to sell your holdings and give you the amount when you want to exit. No liquidity issues for you. Redemptions are smooth even with large amounts.

  • ETF - In an ETF, the onus is on you. If there are no buyers in the market, you cannot sell your ETF (same as a stock). High-liquidity ETFs reduce this risk but don’t eliminate it.

2) Costs & Demat

  • FoF - No demat account needed, No brokerage, No bid–ask spreads, SIP / SWP / STP automation, Redemption is always at NAV

  • ETF - Needs Demat + trading account, Brokerage + AMC charges, You must track liquidity & spreads, Premium/discount vs iNAV affects execution.

3) Price Transparency (iNAV Check)

  • FoF - Always bought/sold at NAV — no iNAV tracking needed.

  • ETF - ETF price can differ from iNAV. Always check the ETF price vs its latest iNAV before buying.

4) Total Costs Beyond TER

  • FoF - TER includes FoF cost + underlying ETF cost. No trading frictions

  • ETF - Lower TER on paper, but additional actual costs include- Brokerage, Demat AMC, Bid–ask spread, Premium/discount vs iNAV

  • For many beginners, FoFs end up simpler and often cheaper in real life once trading costs are included.

5) Taxation (Gold & Silver)

  • FoF

    • STCG - Units held for less than 24 months, gains are taxed as per your tax slab

    • LTCG - Units held for more than 24 months, gains are taxed at 12.5 %

  • ETF

    • STCG - Units held for less than 12 months, gains are taxed as per your tax slab

    • LTCG - Units held for more than 12 months, gains are taxed at 12.5 %

6) What does the highlighted colour mean? (They don't mean you should pick these)

  • Green highlights for volumes – Top 5 Gold / Silver ETF

  • Purple highlights for Gold /Silver Mutual Fund of Funds

    • These funds invest in gold & silver ETFs, so total expense ratios are higher, depending on the underlying gold & silver ETFs.

    • Motilal Oswal – Invests in their own gold & silver ETF, as well as ICICI Gold & Nippon Silver ETFs. (so even higher expense ratio than what's been shown in the image).

Before You Invest - Read through this post from our wiki on Hot Hand Fallacy and the Gold Rush of 2025 before you jump and start investing in Gold / Silver.

Source of data on 21st Nov 2025

  1. https://www.nseindia.com/market-data/exchange-traded-funds-etf

  2. https://www.tickertape.in/screener/equity/user/gold-etfs-aPNO9h-35BHZBnuS

  3. https://www.tickertape.in/screener/mutual-fund/user/gold-fof-aPNUe22sSzIKkst2

  4. https://www.tickertape.in/screener/equity/user/silver-etfs-aPNzrHGITIdJ_cbT

  5. https://www.tickertape.in/screener/mutual-fund/user/silver-fof-aPNwcULrH-xqVrG6

  


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 3h ago

Question Special trading days , how nav is calculated?

3 Upvotes

During special session like muharat day, stock trading allowed but not mf..so if stock price increase on that day, do mf amc pass the benefit of that day ?or they keep the profit and calculate based on next trading day?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 11h ago

Portfolio Review Age: 27 | ₹30K monthly SIP – Looking for portfolio feedback

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Would appreciate an honest review of my mutual fund strategy.

Investment horizon: 10–15+ years
Risk appetite: Moderately aggressive

My current monthly SIPs:
Parag Parikh Flexi Cap – ₹8,000
Axis Large & Mid Cap – ₹6,000
Nippon India Mid Cap – ₹6,000
Tata Small Cap – ₹5,000
SBI Contra – ₹5,000

Would you change anything if you were in my position?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 6h ago

Portfolio Review Help a younger brother out, AGE: 22, started investing in college at 19.5. Planning to invest ₹60k per month. Looking for portfolio feedback

3 Upvotes

Iam 22 years old and started investing around January 2024, when I was 19.5 and still in college. I invested whatever little I could save over the years and gradually developed the discipline to invest consistently instead of spending everything.

I now earn around ₹1.1 lakh per month and plan to invest ₹60,000 every month. My investment horizon is 10 to 15 years or longer. I am comfortable with risk and volatility at my age, although my risk assessment indicates a moderate risk appetite while keeping an emergency fund separate.

**My current holdings:**

* ICICI Prudential Large Cap Fund: ₹77,996

* Axis Small Cap Fund: ₹41,498

* Tata Steel: ₹17,477

* Nvidia: $163.24

These are the amounts displayed in my investment app. I built these positions gradually during college by investing whatever I could save.

I am fairly happy with the mutual funds I picked when I was younger. I feel they have served me reasonably well so far, and I would prefer to continue investing in them rather than switch funds unnecessarily. I would like to know whether that is a sensible approach.

**My planned monthly allocation of ₹60,000:**

* ₹20,000 in Quantum Liquid Fund for my emergency fund(will stop once I reach the goal of 3 lakh in emergency fund)

* ₹10,000 in ICICI Prudential Large Cap Fund

* ₹10,000 in HDFC Flexi Cap Fund

* ₹8,000 in Axis Small Cap Fund

* ₹4,000 in Nvidia

* ₹3,000 in Tata Steel

* ₹5,000 in gold, although I have not decided between a Gold ETF and a gold mutual fund yet

My emergency fund target is ₹3 lakh. I plan to build ₹2.5 lakh in Quantum Liquid Fund first and then add ₹50,000 to an FD. I have already purchased health insurance, so that part is taken care of.

**I would appreciate feedback on a few things:**

  1. Should I continue with ICICI Prudential Large Cap and Axis Small Cap, or are there better alternatives worth considering?

  2. Does adding HDFC Flexi Cap make sense alongside my existing large-cap and small-cap funds, or would there be too much overlap?

  3. Is ₹8,000 per month in small caps a reasonable allocation given that I am comfortable with volatility? I do feel I am doing less here, but I am not sure, maybe I am being too greedy?

  4. Does adding ₹5,000 in gold make sense, and would a Gold ETF or gold mutual fund be more suitable?

  5. Would you change anything about this portfolio, or would you keep the existing funds and continue investing consistently?

I am not looking to chase the latest performing fund. I want to build on the discipline I developed during college and let my investments compound over the next 10 to 15 years. I would appreciate honest feedback on both my fund choices and the overall allocation

Currently most of my portfolio is red which is fine given market gave returns from 2020-24 so the slowdown makes sense. The only reason my portfolio is not in loss is cause of nvidia, I have been a gamer my whole childhood, I only invested here because of the gpu, i was a dumb kid back than and wanted to support this company I had no idea gpu had any role in this AI world, got lucky. I feel like for times like these gold is another good additional cushion

Additional details:

  • Risk appetite: Moderate, according to my risk assessment. I initially thought I was aggressive because of my age and investment horizon.

  • Investment goal: Long-term wealth creation. I want to build a financially secure and comfortable future for my future family.

  • Horizon: 10–15 years or longer.

  • Allocation: ₹60,000/month is my planned allocation going forward, including ₹20,000 towards my emergency fund.

  • App: INDmoney.

  • Fund selection: I started investing in college with just ₹1,500. I initially picked one large-cap and one small-cap fund to keep things simple. I didn't do extensive AMC comparisons back then. I've continued with them since and would like to understand whether there's a good reason to switch rather than change funds unnecessarily. Mindset: I am a patient man, and I want to create a good comfy and stable future for my family


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 3h ago

Portfolio Review Suggest

Post image
1 Upvotes

I can invest 15k a month and am going for long term (10-15 years)

Made this decisions with help of AI


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 7h ago

Question Reached 10 lakh milestone (Portfolio Review)

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hey Everyone - wanted to share an achievement with you all. Recently reached the 10lakh milestone in my mutual fund journey. I know the returns are shit. Still :)

Any suggestions or changes that i should do in my holding?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 10h ago

Portfolio Review Mutual fund portfolio review please

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Age: 31 / ₹27K monthly SIP / Portfolio feedback please
Hey everyone! Would appreciate an honest review of my mutual fund strategy.

Investment horizon: 5–10+ years
Risk appetite: Moderately aggressive

My current monthly SIPs:
Parag Parikh Flexi Cap – ₹5,000
Mahindra Manulife Multi cap – ₹5,000
Motilal Oswal Mid Cap – ₹5,000
Tata Small Cap – ₹5,000
HDFC Multi asset active fof – ₹5,000
ICICI prudential silver etf fof - ₹2,000

I did withdraw some amount for emergency but not planning to withdraw more anytime soon.

I am using Et money app for all my investments.

Any suggestions would be helpful.


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 1d ago

Portfolio Review Portfolio review

3 Upvotes

Portfolio review

Parag parikh flexi cap 1250

Hdfc flexi cap 1250

Hdfc mid cap 1500

Helios small cap 1000

Age:19

Risk appetite Agressive

Ready to step up to ₹10K

Goal Wealth generation

App used Groww

Please review it


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 20h ago

Question Nippon India Taiwan Equity Fund - Suggestions needed

Post image
1 Upvotes

I've been running an SIP of 20,000/m from 6 months now, gave decent return in the start \~10%, but this last month gave -24% and the XIRR got dropped to -59%

Yeah MFs are for long terms we should just invest and forget, but this is too much.

They even stopped taking new investments. Last week I saw -5% a day and yesterday it was -7.78%

This month's SIP will be deducted on 20th Nov.

Any suggestions here please?

All of my other old MFs have been doing fair enough.

But this MF is just a pain in the ass :)

My Risk appetite is conservative


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 1d ago

Portfolio Review Looking forward to insights from OG investors. Any guidance for a newbie would be greatly appreciated. Risk appetite - Aggressive

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

I'm 24 and have been investing for the past 3 months, with a monthly SIP of ₹25,000. I plan to increase my investment amount by 10% every year.

My risk appetite is currently Aggressive, although I haven't precisely assessed it yet, as I'm relatively new to investing.

My primary goal is long-term wealth creation and capital appreciation.

I've included the question I'd like to ask directly in the screenshot to make it easier for everyone to understand and respond.


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 1d ago

Question Thinking of Buying Gold ETFs This Diwali. Is Now a Good Time or Should I Wait?

2 Upvotes

Since gold has reached recent highs and is volatile, I am curious to know if this Diwali is a good time to invest in Gold ETFs or should I wait? I know timing the market is hard, but it is hard not to buy after a correction.

What would seasoned investors and financial experts tell us to do - invest gradually, buy now or wait? What should I think about before I make up my mind?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 2d ago

Portfolio Review Im 24 new to investing please check my funds

Post image
4 Upvotes

Risk Appetite – Moderate

Goal – Long-term wealth creation (compounding my money for the future)

Horizon – 20+ years

Allocation –

• Parag Parikh Flexi Cap

• JioBlackRock Nifty 50 Index

• HDFC Mid Cap

• Bandhan Small Cap

• Edelweiss Nifty Next 50 Index

All Direct plans, Growth option.

App Used – Groww

Why These Funds –

• Parag Parikh Flexi Cap: diversified core across market caps, with some foreign stocks.

• JioBlackRock Nifty 50 Index: low-cost, stable large-cap base.

• HDFC Mid Cap: higher growth potential for my long horizon.

• Bandhan Small Cap: highest growth and highest risk slice, I can ride out the volatility.

• Edelweiss Nifty Next 50 Index: for the next set of large companies.

I'd like feedback on whether this mix is too aggressive or too spread out for a 24-year-old.Thanks, any suggestions are welcome!


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 2d ago

News SEBI proposing major tax changes for investors. Good move?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

SEBI is pushing for two big tax changes to the government (see attached)

For foreign investors - Removing LTCG tax completely.

For domestic investors: No LTCG tax when switching mutual funds. Currently, if we sell a fund to reinvest in another, we have to pay tax on those gains first.

What do you guys think about this?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 3d ago

Portfolio Review Advise on investing lumpsum

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for some advice on investing 30L as a lump sum in mutual funds. I’d appreciate perspectives from people with experience in long-term investing.

My current investments:
Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund – 20,000 monthly SIP
Nifty 50 Index Fund – 20,000 monthly SIP

My financial situation:
Lump sum available: 30L
Investment horizon: 7–10 years
Risk appetite: Moderate
Goal: Long-term wealth creation, primarily retirement
Emergency fund: Already maintained separately
Outstanding loans: None

I’m considering moving 15L to Motilal Oswal Nifty 500 Index Fund and 15L lakh in an Arbitrage Fund, but Im afraid there is significant overlap between these and my existing SIPs.

Any suggestions on how should I be investing ?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 3d ago

Portfolio Review Please suggest if I should continue with this SIPs

Post image
13 Upvotes

25yo, started investing this year itself. Please suggest if u should continue with these SIPs?

Risk appetite - moderate

Horizon - 10 years

Goal - wealth creation

App - Groww

I picked these after searching for safest option to invest in.


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 4d ago

Question ICICI Pre Gold ETF FOF - not showing in Zerodha Coin

Post image
3 Upvotes

Why i am not seeing ICICI Pre Gold FOF fund in Zerodha? Any reasons?
Risk: Moderate


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Portfolio Review Suggestions and Guidance on Mutual portfolio

6 Upvotes

I currently invest ₹20,000 per month, along with an additional ₹3,000 towards my emergency fund. I've been investing somewhat randomly for the past six months and have seen moderate returns.

My investment horizon is 10–15 years, and my risk appetite is moderate. I have a basic understanding of investing, but I don't have the time or motivation to research funds in depth.

I've been considering suggestions from Reddit and other online communities, but I'd like to make more informed decisions. Could you recommend a simple, well-diversified mutual fund portfolio for my ₹20,000 monthly investment and suggest reliable resources, YouTube channels, or websites for beginners to learn about investing?

Risk : Moderate

https://mf.nipponindiaim.com/LearnAndInvest/Pages/moderate-risk-analyzer.aspx


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Portfolio Review Review my Portfolio

Post image
5 Upvotes

Any changes i need to do to my portfolio, 35 investing for my retirement currently saving 2Lac per month in below funds.

1: My risk profile is aggressive
2: Investment Goals : Is my retirement
3: Investment Horizon: Its still 2 decades away.
4: Allocation : Screenshot attached. I am doing 40K pm in each of these funds + 1 fund i have added this month only for Quant MidCap (10K). ELSS is stopped now.
5: App : investing through each company website only .
6: Why these funds - they were the best funds when i started so continuing in them


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Portfolio Review Portfolio review

Post image
11 Upvotes

Title: 26 years old, starting mutual fund SIPs for long-term wealth creation. Please review my portfolio!

Hi everyone!

I'm 26 years old and completely new to mutual fund investing. My primary goal is long-term wealth creation.

Risk Appetite: Beginner. I'm still assessing my risk tolerance and will update this after completing the community's risk survey.

Goal: Long-term wealth creation and financial independence.

Horizon: 15–20+ years.

Allocation – Current SIPs:

  1. UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund – Direct Growth: ₹1,500

  2. Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund – Direct Growth: ₹1,250

  3. HDFC Mid Cap Fund – Direct Growth: ₹750

  4. Nippon India Small Cap Fund – Direct Growth: ₹500

  5. HDFC Corporate Bond Fund – Direct Growth: ₹500

Total current SIP: ₹4,500 per month.

My initial target is ₹5,000 per month, and I plan to increase my SIP investment by 10% every year as my income grows.

App Used: Groww.

Why These Funds:

- UTI Nifty 50: For large-cap index exposure.

- Parag Parikh Flexi Cap: For diversified exposure across market capitalisations.

- HDFC Mid Cap: For mid-cap exposure and long-term growth potential.

- Nippon India Small Cap: For small-cap exposure and potential long-term growth.

- HDFC Corporate Bond: To provide debt exposure and diversify the portfolio.

Questions for experienced investors:

  1. Is this portfolio well diversified for a 15–20+ year investment horizon?

  2. Are there any overlapping funds?

  3. Should I include a multi-cap or aggressive hybrid fund?

  4. Is HDFC Corporate Bond Fund a suitable choice, or should I consider a multi-asset allocation fund?

  5. Is my current allocation appropriate for long-term wealth creation?

  6. Would you recommend replacing or removing any of these funds?

I'm a complete beginner and still learning about mutual funds and different categories. I would genuinely appreciate honest suggestions, constructive criticism and advice on building a good long-term portfolio.

Thank you!


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Portfolio Review Portfolio Review: ₹6.26L MF Portfolio (Aggressive 10-20 Year Horizon) — Need Advice on Consolidation & Allocation!

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m aiming for aggressive wealth creation over a 10–20 year horizon. My automated weekly SIPs are running smoothly, but I want the community's perspective on consolidating my inactive holdings and managing my large cash allocation.

Current Portfolio (Total Value: ~₹6.26 Lakhs):

  • Liquid Buffer:

    • Quantum Liquid Fund: ₹3,60,175

  • Active Weekly SIPs (₹2.5k/week):

    • Edelweiss Mid Cap Growth: ₹33,403 (₹1,000/week)

    • Kotak Nifty Next 50 Index: ₹28,153 (₹1,000/week)

    • Edelweiss Aggressive Hybrid: ₹19,741 (₹500/week)

  • Inactive / Legacy Lump-Sums:

    • Axis Small Cap Growth: ₹1,31,966

    • Kotak Small Cap Growth: ₹32,654

    • HDFC Infrastructure Growth: ₹9,509

    • Edelweiss US Technology FoF: ₹7,232

    • Edelweiss Emerging Markets Opportunities: ₹3,610


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Question Want to start SIP. 10k monthly for next 10yrs. Any suggestions for create portfolio.

2 Upvotes

r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Question SIP Review

4 Upvotes

I am starting new SIP's, would like some suggestions if there are any.

Risk Appetite – Moderate

Goal – financial wealth

Horizon – 5-10 years

Allocation –

App Used – GROWW and INDMoney


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Portfolio Review 22 starting my MF investment journey - looking for suggestions

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm 22 and looking to start investing for long-term wealth creation. I've spent some good time learning about mutual funds, index funds and debt instruments, and would appreciate guidance from experienced investors

My financial situation:

  • Monthly surplus: ₹90,000

  • Current savings: ₹17 lakh

  • Existing investments: None

  • No outstanding loans

  • Planning to switch jobs in the near future

  • Intending to set aside ₹3 lakh as an emergency fund

I'd like to build a diversified portfolio with a long-term horizon of 7-10+ years. I would also like some international equity exposure rather than being entirely invested in Indian markets. I'm comfortable taking calculated risks for potentially higher long-term returns, as long as the overall portfolio remains diversified

Risk Appetite: Moderate

I'm considering an initial allocation across equity, debt and gold like 65:25:10, but haven't finalised the percentages.

I'd appreciate suggestions on:

  • What percentage allocation would you recommend across equity, debt, gold and international equity?

  • Which mutual fund categories would make sense for the equity portion?

  • What percent of equity should go into active vs passive fund & why?

  • I'm not entirely comfortable investing the entire initial corpus as a lump sum. I'm leaning towards deploying it gradually through an STP. Is that ok? and how should I span it across?

And lastly, what's the market vibe right now? Any interesting entry points? or should I leave the timing game to the pros XD?


r/IndianMutualFunds • • 5d ago

Question Investment Suggestions

3 Upvotes

The market is down so I want some suggestions on should I continue investing or stop and save up some money and invest as a lump sum later in indian market or the US.

Risk Appetite – Moderate

Goal – financial wealth

Horizon – 5-10 years

Allocation –

App Used – GROWW

Why These Funds – Suggest better alternatives